The British Medical Association has just shown its contempt for science
But if the doctors' union is disastrously out of touch on strikes, it turns out that it's even more remote from public opinion on the contentious trans issue. The Cass Review recommended an almost complete ban on puberty blockers for children. Well, the man who led the BMA's opposition to the Report, Tom Dolphin, has now been made chairman of the BMA's council, its governing body.
The appointment followed what looks like a coup by the 69 member board which ousted the previous incumbent, Professor Philip Banfield. Dr Dolphin tabled an emergency motion last July that led to the union rejecting the Cass report. It announced it would be publishing its own review instead. But alas, nothing has so far appeared.
Let's remember that Hilary Cass, the author of the report, found that 'there is no good evidence' that puberty blockers for young people are safe to use and that 'it is unusual for us to give a potentially life-changing treatment to young people and not know what happens to them in adulthood'.
And it seems that in fact many doctors agreed. When the BMA council bypassed debate to reject the Cass review after it ran out of time to discuss the motion at the annual meeting, there were four attempts by members to have an open debate on the review. More than 1,500 doctors, the majority of them BMA members, signed a 'Not in Our Name' open letter to the BMA council, criticising the 'very undemocratic' decision to reject Lady Cass's findings.
But rather than respond to members' concerns, the BMA council has now elected Tom Dolphin to lead the organisation. It's not out to please, is it? Dr Dolphin's view on this issue can be judged by his position three years ago, when he posted photos of himself getting ready for a Trans Pride march, saying: 'About to set off to let London know that trans rights are human rights!'
Mind you, he didn't focus on this when he accepted his new position, observing that the last three years 'has been a period of huge change for the BMA which has seen doctors realise the power that they have as trade union members to change their working lives … for the better. The fight to restore doctors' pay and pensions continues.' More militancy then.
You have to ask: are doctors really best led by a man who takes such a radical approach to giving life-altering drugs to children confused about their gender? I'd say it's proof that the BMA isn't an organisation that patients or the Government can take seriously.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
21 minutes ago
- The Sun
Two killed including school cook, 62, after eating poisonous guacamole as 2 children recover in hospital
TWO people have died and two children are recovering in hospital after several people were poisoned by a toxic batch of guacamole. The fatally contaminated avocado dip was served up to unsuspecting customers at a food festival before they showed signs of botulism. 4 4 4 School cook Valeria Sollai, 62, is said to have eaten the guacamole and then was rushed to hospital. But she died on Monday after spending weeks on life support. Roberta Pitzalis, 38, also ate the same batch of guacamole at the festival in Sardinia - before dying on August 8. An autopsy confirmed Roberta died from a combination of botulism poisoning and pneumonia. Several others required hospital treatment following the horrifying ordeal at the Fiesta Latina festival. The food event took place in Monserrato, in Cagliari, between July 22-24. One boy and one girl, aged 11 and 14 respectively, remain in hospital and are reported to have eaten from the same batch of guacamole. A post-mortem for Valeria is set to take place. She showed signs of recovery before suffering a relapse and tragically dying. Her cousin Gianni Milia said: "It's absurd that someone goes out for a relaxing evening, goes to a party, eats a sandwich and ends up in the hospital. Woman, 45, becomes second person to die after eating 'toxic broccoli' as 17 others poisoned as veg recalled across Italy "She was with her sisters, they all ate the same sandwich, but only she fell ill." She added: "They were celebrating their older sister's discharge from the hospital. A party turned into a tragedy." Describing Valeria, Monserrato mayor Tomaso Locci said: 'She gave so much for our children. "The news saddens us deeply. We will be present at the funeral as a community, as we were for Roberta Pitzalis, the other victim. "This is a loss that affects us all.' Valeria is survived by her husband, Angelo Aru, and her son Alessandro, a police officer in Campania. In a Facebook post last month, Alessandro spoke about an unnamed patient with 'worsening neurological conditions'. He also made a heartbreaking appeal for people to be more careful with street food. He said: "I strongly advise against eating any food sold at street stalls over the next few weeks." The poisoned 14-year-old girl is being treated at Monserrato Policlinico hospital. Meanwhile, the 11-year-old has been flown to Rome's Gemelli Policlinico and is said to be in a serious condition. What Is It? Botulism is a rare but serious illness caused by a toxin produced by the bacterium Clostridium botulinum. It affects the nervous system, leading to muscle paralysis and breathing difficulties. How is it contracted? The illness usually comes from eating food contaminated with the toxin. This often happens due to improper food processing, such as inadequate canning. Symptoms to watch for: Muscle weakness Difficulty breathing Double vision Difficulty swallowing How serious is it? Botulism can be life-threatening. In severe cases, it can cause death, with around 10 per cent of cases being fatal if not treated promptly. Treatment: If you think you are suffering from botulism poisoning, medical attention is crucial. Treatment typically involves antitoxins and supportive care, including breathing assistance if necessary. Prevention: Ensure proper food processing and handling. Avoid consuming home-canned foods if you're unsure about their safety. It comes amid mounting concern over food safety in Italy following similar events across the country. Another deadly botulism outbreak was reported in the southern region of Calabria earlier this month. It also comes after two people in Italy died after eating a toxic veggie and sausage sandwich in Italy. More than a dozen people were hospitalised after eating the poisoned sandwiches from a food truck near the town of Diamante in Calabria. Tamara D'Acunto, 45, died shortly after eating the panini made with turnip greens - a vegetable similar to broccoli - last week. Luigi Di Sarno, 52, also died after taking a fatal bite from a sandwich bought from the same vendor. In total, 17 other people have so far been hospitalised with food poisoning within 24 to 48 hours of eating the sandwiches. They all showed signs of botulism - which is caused by a toxin that attacks the body's nerves. The illness can lead to muscle paralysis, breathing difficulties and death. It is typically caused by canned, preserved and fermented foods.
Daily Mail
21 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Expert reveals common kitchen spices that can kill most viruses and cure colds
An herbal practitioner has shared the plants that he claims are more effective than prescribed medicines. Herbalist Simon Mills appeared on The Diary of a CEO with host Steven Bartlett recently, where he listed his go-to herbal medicines. The author insisted that there are a few common kitchen spices that can combat everything from a common cold to cardiovascular problems. He credited ginger, chili, turmeric, cinnamon and garlic as the household ingredients that can kill most viruses. He also detailed the natural remedy that he claims can cure a cold, involving only ginger and cinnamon. Ginger root is said to contain several healing properties, including antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, anti-nausea, raising body temperature. To effectively use it to combat a cold, Mills said to grate about a 'thumb's size' of the plant into a mug. He then combines it with a stick of cinnamon, which contains healing properties such as digestive support, respiratory relief, menstrual symptoms in women, as well as helping to ease other pain. 'You either grate that if you have a spice mill or you take a teaspoon of already dried spice,' he explained. From there, Mills said he adds hot water, letting it sit for a few minutes before straining it into a separate mug. 'You can feel it warning straight away,' he said. He explained that when you ingest ginger or other similar 'hot plants,' it can help clear out sinuses since ginger contributes to hyperemia - a reflex response to open the blood vessels. Mills said this in turn causes the cells producing mucus to loosen up and can even bring up phlegm from the lungs. 'There's a natural escalator that the body uses to get stuff out of the lungs that [get]s stimulated,' he shared. Mills also said he uses spices like ginger, cinnamon, and turmeric as his 'main go-to' to help fend off cardiovascular problem. In addition, he explained that if you cut turmeric in half, you get curcumin - which acts as an anti-inflammatory. The herb enthusiast also spoke of the benefits of garlic, explaining that when eating raw, the vegetable is a 'very powerful prebiotic' and can help the gut flora. '[I] encourage people not to ask the doc for an antibiotic and use some of these at-home, easy, and free treatments instead,' he said. Although much of the research into herbs and spices as medicine is still in an early stage – and often uses concentrated extracts or large doses you wouldn't get from a normal meal – there are signs that everyday amounts could give your long-term health a boost. The FDA considers herbal supplements as foods, not medicines, so they are not subject to the same testing, manufacturing, and labeling standards and regulations as medicines. According to John Hopkins Medicine, herbal supplements can interact with conventional medicines and may have strong effects. Doctors advise people not to self-diagnose or self-prescribe, and to talk with your healthcare provider before taking herbal supplements.
Times
2 hours ago
- Times
Mounjaro UK price rise will trigger obesity relapse, say experts
The upcoming Mounjaro price hike could cause people to pile weight back on and 'cycle in and out of obesity', experts have warned. The weight-loss jab, which is bought privately by 1.5 million people in the UK, will more than double in price next month — forcing patients off the drug if they can no longer afford it. Its manufacturer, Eli Lilly, is increasing the list price for the maximum 15mg dose from £122 to £330 for a monthly pen, while the 5mg dose is rising from £92 to £180. Pharmacies have warned that patients are in 'immense distress', with demand soaring as they stock up on Mounjaro before the price increase takes effect on September 1. Professor Tim Spector, a nutrition expert at King's College London, warned that the sudden increase in price had exposed the flaws of relying on weight-loss jabs to lose weight. He said: 'The price rise of the GLP-1 drugs comes at a tricky time for the million-plus Britons that have started taking the drugs. Any losses in weight they will have achieved will be reversed in just a few weeks, as their appetite kicks back in. 'People are being prompted to use these private networks of GLP-1 drugs without any real supervision, and, crucially, without any nutritional support.' Spector, co-founder of the Zoe nutrition app, said that people who were taking weight-loss jabs should instead have been 're-educated about food and good eating habits long term'. He added: 'It's a huge wasted opportunity that's going to get worse as the price for the consumer goes up, and therefore people are unlikely to stay on this long term. We're just going to be back to good old short-term diets, which will cycle people in and out of obesity.' The price hike is taking place after President Trump demanded that pharmaceutical firms lower prices for American patients and stop other countries 'freeloading' off US firms. Pharmacies said they were experiencing record demand and were helping people to switch from Mounjaro to Wegovy, a similar GLP-1 drug known as Ozempic when used for diabetes, as it is cheaper, although not thought to be as effective. • Jon Yeomans: Mounjaro is a taste of the battle to come over drug prices James O'Loan, the chief executive of the online pharmacy Chemist4U, said: 'The distressing news that prices are set to rise by up to 170 per cent with just two weeks' notice, in response to another aggressive initiative from Trump, is very troubling. It's caused immense distress to hundreds of thousands of UK patients on a weight loss journey, who worry all their hard-earned progress could be snatched away from them.' Asda Online Doctor said: 'Following the announcement of steep price increases by the manufacturer Eli Lilly starting in September, we have seen an instant 350 per cent increase in demand. We are making all efforts to enable our existing patients to continue treatment and are actively prioritising them. 'However, this will be a difficult situation for many of our patients with affordability being a key aspect in the access and/or continuation of these services. Therefore we deeply regret this decision from Eli Lilly to increase prices, which will affect many patients. We remain committed to providing an excellent service to our patients at a fair price.' • Mounjaro transformed me — but it had a huge effect on my family's life Dr Leyla Hannbeck, chief executive of the Independent Pharmacies Association, representing thousands of community pharmacies, said: 'Our members up and down the country have been dealing with worried patients, many of whom are enquiring about stocking up before the price increase hits. 'There is a very real danger that the higher prices will see patients desperate for cheaper products turn to the, often unregulated, online market.' Sandeep Dhami, a superintendent pharmacist at MW Phillips Chemists in the West Midlands, added: 'Patients on their weight-loss journeys are coming into pharmacies like mine angry and upset at the news of the price hike. Those on the highest doses, who will face the highest price hike are particularly concerned.'
