Miami Beach strengthens Israeli ties but defers O Cinema vote
Why it matters: The City Commission's moves show how intent it is to demonstrate its loyalty to Israel after a scrapped proposal to evict O Cinema drew national attention.
Driving the news: Commissioners directed the city to maximize investments in Israeli bonds and work on attracting Israeli and Jewish-owned businesses to Miami Beach.
The commission deferred a resolution encouraging O Cinema to screen films that show a "fair and balanced" viewpoint of the war in Gaza.
Friction point: During a tense meeting Wednesday, more than a dozen residents spoke up against the package of Israeli-related proposals.
At one point, Mayor Steven Meiner directed police to escort an audience member out of the commission chambers.
Later, he interrupted a speaker during the allotted two-minute comment period and refused to give the resident additional time.
What they're saying: Miami Beach resident Alex Mayka said the city has "real problems" to deal with, like flooding and housing scarcity, and shouldn't spend time focusing on supporting an "apartheid nation."
"These resolutions don't help people who actually live here."
He criticized the city targeting O Cinema, the South Beach theater with a lease on city-owned property.
"This city government has absolutely no place in telling artists what kind of stories they can or can't tell."
The other side: Meiner, a strong ally of Israel, responded to almost every anti-Israel comment during time reserved for public speakers, labeling some remarks as "hate speech" and antisemitism.
"I give the respect to the people who speak, but I'm gonna counter hate speech when it comes this way," Meiner said.
Commissioner Joseph Magazine, who sponsored the resolution attracting Israeli businesses, said it was "sickening" that someone could oppose recruiting Jewish business owners.
Magazine called Miami Beach a safe haven for the city's "Israeli and Jewish brothers and sisters."
"Part of being a safe haven is speaking proudly about an initiative like this."
Catch up quick: Meiner previously proposed evicting O Cinema and withdrawing its grant funding after it screened "No Other Land," the Oscar-winning documentary about the Israeli demolition of Palestinian homes in the occupied West Bank prior to the war.
Meiner called the film a "one-sided propaganda attack" on the Jewish people.
O Cinema and the ACLU of Florida argued Meiner's effort amounted to government overreach and violated the theater's First Amendment rights.
Meiner later withdrew his eviction proposal after opposition from the Commission and public.
A second Meiner proposal, which wasn't heard Wednesday, criticizes "No Other Land" as an "incomplete portrayal" of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and encourages O Cinema to "prioritize films that present the suffering and moral position of the Jewish people and the state of Israel."
The intrigue: It's unclear why Meiner never brought the item for a vote.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
2 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Israel-Hamas war roils Somerville mayoral race
Get The Gavel A weekly SCOTUS explainer newsletter by columnist Kimberly Atkins Stohr. Enter Email Sign Up Alain Jehlen Advertisement Somerville Outrage against Israel makes Jews a target Shira Schoenberg is right but too lenient in her op-ed 'Could Somerville mayoral hopeful Willie Burnley fairly represent Zionist constituents?' Willie Burnley Jr. can't represent Somerville Zionists. He can't represent Jews; and in being bad for Jews, he's bad for Americans. Oct. 7, 2023, gave license to target Jews in ways that, if aimed at other minorities, would spark outrage. Once such actions are normalized against Jews, they become normalized against any group the mob targets. Jew hate was primed to erupt. Advertisement No other minority faces such mob punishment. Not the Chinese for Communist Party terror against Tibetans, Uyghurs, or Hong Kong; Arabs for horrors in Iraq or Syria; or Muslims for jihadist massacres in Africa. Only Jews. In doing so, radicals target all Americans who hold to the proposition that all are created equal and, out of many, one. In siding with them, Burnley and others don't just endanger Jews; they also threaten those principles and Americans who live by them. Steve Spear Brookline Still waiting to hear a certain condemnation from Burnley Shira Schoenberg's otherwise excellent op-ed about Willie Burnley Jr.'s campaign for mayor of Somerville noted that Burnley has been compared with New York mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani. The comparison is faulty and unfair. Mamdani Burnley has failed to make any such statements, to my knowledge. In fact, on Aug. 7, I saw him at a 'Somerville for Palestine' rally and press conference in front of City Hall, where I politely asked him, 'How would you characterize what Hamas did on Oct. 7, 2023?' He looked at me and then, instead of answering, simply walked away. Ken Brociner Somerville Divestment would make Somerville more welcoming, not less As a Jewish resident of Massachusetts who has donated to Zohran Mamdani and canvassed for Willie Burnley Jr., I felt misrepresented when I read the phrase 'Both are raising fears among many Jewish, Zionist constituents' in Shira Schoenberg's Aug. 11 op-ed. This narrative implies that Jewish and Zionist are two identities that overlap, which couldn't be further from the truth and dangerously casts the Jewish community as universally supportive of Israel's actions. Advertisement Mamdani, rather than being a bogeyman in the Jewish community, is the leading candidate within it with a To hold that it is antisemitic to say that Somerville should not be investing in companies involved in war crimes is as ridiculous as saying that the divestment movement over South African apartheid in the 1980s promoted hatred against white people. Making Somerville a welcoming place doesn't mean avoiding these questions so as not to offend anyone; it means upholding our values of equality and human rights by divesting from entities involved with human rights violations and Israel's racist policies. Sam Levine Lexington At least the candidate is transparent Somerville mayoral candidate Willie Burnley Jr. has dealt with voters fairly by making his views about Israel clear. Voters can take these views into account. All politicians should be so transparent. Felicia Nimue Ackerman Providence
4 hours ago
Jules Witcover, reporter best known for 'Politics Today' column, dies at 98
WASHINGTON -- Jules Witcover, who cowrote one of the nation's leading political columns for nearly three decades, died Saturday at the age of 98, his daughter Amy Witcover-Sandford said. Witcover's widely syndicated daily column, written jointly for 24 years with the late Jack Germond, gave him an outlet to register strong opinions, leaving little doubt which politicians he admired or despised. 'Politics Today' began at The Washington Star and then moved to The Baltimore Sun, and he continued writing it solo for another five years at The Sun after his partner retired in 2001. Witcover also covered the political beat for the Newhouse News Service, The Los Angeles Times and The Washington Post, in books and in several magazines, including The New Republic, Saturday Review and The Nation. Through his long career, Witcover had a remarkable front seat to history, some of it tragic. He watched Robert F. Kennedy steady first lady Jackie at President John F. Kennedy's grave in 1963. Five years later, in 1968, he pushed his way through a crowded hotel kitchen in Los Angeles after hearing shots and saw Robert F. Kennedy bleeding on the floor. He would later write of RFK's brief presidential campaign in the book '85 Days.' Witcover described himself and the curmudgeonly Germond as 'friendly rivals laboring for obscure newspaper chains' who enjoyed long, booze-soaked dinners on the campaign trail, a culture that was chronicled in Timothy Crouse's classic account of reporters covering the 1972 presidential election, 'Boys on the Bus.' When Witcover and Germond began co-writing their column in 1977, 'we often played the good cop/bad cop routine, each of us able to blame the other guy when a column one of us wrote caused a politician to complain. But sometimes, too, one of us would take the bullet for the other when it unjustly came our way. That was the nature of playing duet pianos in the house of ill repute called political writing,' Witcover wrote in The Sun after Germond's death in 2013. At its peak, the syndicated column ran five times a week and appeared in about 140 newspapers. In his final years as a columnist, Witcover relentlessly hammered President George W. Bush over the Iraq war, calling it 'the most wrong-headed foreign policy in my lifetime and the most dangerous.' But he did not blame that view for The Sun's dropping his column. Editorially, the newspaper also opposed the war, although less vigorously. 'The war was a colossal mistake from the start and has disintegrated into a calamity, damaging not only the people of Iraq but the international reputation of this country, not to mention the terrible cost in American lives and treasure,' he wrote for the Poynter Institute's blog. Witcover was born in Union City, New Jersey, to a Jewish father and Catholic mother. He was raised Catholic and showed an early interest in writing. He wrote in his memoirs that he and a cousin produced a one-page family newspaper on Thanksgiving that they sold for a nickel. A classmate on his high school basketball team persuaded him to apply to Columbia, which he attended for a semester before joining the Navy. He then re-enrolled in the college after the war ended and obtained a master's degree at Columbia's graduate school of journalism. Years later, he told a reporter that he thought his ship had come in when a newspaper in the Boston area offered him a starting job covering the Boston Braves in spring training. Before he could get started the team decided to move its franchise to Milwaukee and the opportunity died. By 1962, 11 years after graduation, he had become a senior correspondent and the chief political writer for the Newhouse News Service. Witcover lived in Washington with his second wife, Marion Elizabeth Rodgers, a biographer of the journalist H.L. Mencken. His first marriage, of nearly four decades, to Marian Laverty, ended in divorce. "Jules was the hardest working newsman I ever knew," said Walter Mears, who as the chief political writer for The Associated Press traveled extensively with Witcover. "On the road, you could hear him banging the typewriter before dawn, working on one of his books. He never stopped writing columns and political histories long after most of us had retired."
New York Post
6 hours ago
- New York Post
Jules Witcover, reporter best known for ‘Politics Today' column, dies at 98
WASHINGTON — Jules Witcover, who cowrote one of the nation's leading political columns for nearly three decades, died Saturday at the age of 98, his daughter Amy Witcover-Sandford said. Witcover's widely syndicated daily column, written jointly for 24 years with the late Jack Germond, gave him an outlet to register strong opinions, leaving little doubt which politicians he admired or despised. 'Politics Today' began at The Washington Star and then moved to The Baltimore Sun, and he continued writing it solo for another five years at The Sun after his partner retired in 2001. Witcover also covered the political beat for the Newhouse News Service, The Los Angeles Times and The Washington Post, in books and in several magazines, including The New Republic, Saturday Review and The Nation. Political columnist Jules Witcover has passed away at the age of 98. AP Through his long career, Witcover had a remarkable front seat to history, some of it tragic. He watched Robert F. Kennedy steady first lady Jackie at President John F. Kennedy's grave in 1963. Five years later, in 1968, he pushed his way through a crowded hotel kitchen in Los Angeles after hearing shots and saw Robert F. Kennedy bleeding on the floor. He would later write of RFK's brief presidential campaign in the book '85 Days.' Witcover described himself and the curmudgeonly Germond as 'friendly rivals laboring for obscure newspaper chains' who enjoyed long, booze-soaked dinners on the campaign trail, a culture that was chronicled in Timothy Crouse's classic account of reporters covering the 1972 presidential election, 'Boys on the Bus.' When Witcover and Germond began co-writing their column in 1977, 'we often played the good cop/bad cop routine, each of us able to blame the other guy when a column one of us wrote caused a politician to complain. But sometimes, too, one of us would take the bullet for the other when it unjustly came our way. That was the nature of playing duet pianos in the house of ill repute called political writing,' Witcover wrote in The Sun after Germond's death in 2013. At its peak, the syndicated column ran five times a week and appeared in about 140 newspapers. In his final years as a columnist, Witcover relentlessly hammered President George W. Bush over the Iraq war, calling it 'the most wrong-headed foreign policy in my lifetime and the most dangerous.' But he did not blame that view for The Sun's dropping his column. Editorially, the newspaper also opposed the war, although less vigorously. Witcover co-wrote the 'Politics Today' column for 24 years. AP 'The war was a colossal mistake from the start and has disintegrated into a calamity, damaging not only the people of Iraq but the international reputation of this country, not to mention the terrible cost in American lives and treasure,' he wrote for the Poynter Institute's blog. Witcover was born in Union City, New Jersey, to a Jewish father and Catholic mother. He was raised Catholic and showed an early interest in writing. He wrote in his memoirs that he and a cousin produced a one-page family newspaper on Thanksgiving that they sold for a nickel. A classmate on his high school basketball team persuaded him to apply to Columbia, which he attended for a semester before joining the Navy. He then re-enrolled in the college after the war ended and obtained a master's degree at Columbia's graduate school of journalism. Years later, he told a reporter that he thought his ship had come in when a newspaper in the Boston area offered him a starting job covering the Boston Braves in spring training. Before he could get started the team decided to move its franchise to Milwaukee and the opportunity died. By 1962, 11 years after graduation, he had become a senior correspondent and the chief political writer for the Newhouse News Service. Witcover lived in Washington with his second wife, Marion Elizabeth Rodgers, a biographer of the journalist H.L. Mencken. His first marriage, of nearly four decades, to Marian Laverty, ended in divorce. 'Jules was the hardest working newsman I ever knew,' said Walter Mears, who as the chief political writer for The Associated Press traveled extensively with Witcover. 'On the road, you could hear him banging the typewriter before dawn, working on one of his books. He never stopped writing columns and political histories long after most of us had retired.'
