The Surprising Way Police Finally Caught the Long Island Serial Killer
Gone Girls: The Long Island Serial Killer goes over the details of a case that has haunted New York for over a decade. The docuseries, directed and produced by Liz Garbus, follows the Gilgo Beach serial killings and examines the perspective of the victims and loved ones as it unravels the murders of Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman, Amber Lynn Costello, and Maureen Brainard-Barnes.
But the Netflix docuseries doesn't just do that, it also delivers a very detailed account of how law enforcement finally managed to zero in on Rex Heuermann, a local architect, and eventually charged him with the murders of seven women.
More from StyleCaster
The Life List Movie Changed a Key Detail From the Book-Here's if Alex Ends Up With the Same Character
Where the Long Island Serial Killer Is Now & If He's Still in Jail For Allegedly Murdering 7 Women
Related: All the evidence pointing to the real Zodiac killer
An exhaustive investigation finally led to the arrest of Rex Heuermann, who has been charged not just with the murder of the so-called 'Gilgo Four,' the first four victims whose remains were discovered along a stretch of Ocean Parkway in Suffolk County in 2010, but three other women as well.
The investigation that led to Heuermann's arrest was led by the Suffolk County Police Department and District Attorney's Office alongside the FBI and New York State Police.
One of the key factors that led to his arrest was Heuermann's Chevrolet Avalanche. The car led authorities to his residence in Massapequa Park and his office in Midtown Manhattan, both of which were identified as zones of interest in the investigation. Heuermann was also caught by police adding minutes to a burner phone, which matched the movements of burner phones used during the crimes. Crucially, though, his DNA matched hair found on the victims. How did the police figure that out? Well, the DNA was lifted from a discarded pizza crust, so yes, this is how he finally got caught. All of it put together was enough for an arrest.
Heuermann's arrest is anything but the end of the story, though. With multiple victims attributed to the suspect, authorities are now looking back at multiple other cases, looking for possible connections. Gone Girls director Liz Garbus was very aware of the reality of dealing with an ever-changing case even as she was trying to deliver a finished cut of the documentary.
'After we completed and turned in our cuts to Netflix, there was another victim added to [Heuermann's] docket. Will there be more between now and the time that we air? It's possible. Will there be more between now and the time that we go to trial, if they go to trial? It's probable,' she told Tudum about the documentary.
Gone Girls: The Long Island Serial Killer also examines allegations of corruption that may have hindered real progress on the case for years. 'I think Suffolk County under police chief Jimmy Burke and DA Tom Spota was run like a crime syndicate…. This is a cautionary tale about how to stop that kind of thing before these kinds of people get in positions of power,' Garbus also said.
'I think audiences should believe in the power of their voices when they see injustice,' Garbus added. 'These family members were never going to give up. They knew there was a need to shake the establishment to get attention for this case.'
Best of StyleCaster
The 26 Best Romantic Comedies to Watch if You Want to Know What Love Feels Like
These 'Bachelor' Secrets & Rules Prove What Happens Behind the Scenes Is So Much Juicier
BTS's 7 Members Were Discovered in the Most Unconventional Ways
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
7 Netflix crime dramas so addictive, you'll want to binge them more than once
If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, BGR may receive an affiliate commission. Streamers like Netflix have a way of turning crime dramas into compulsive viewing, with stories that pull us deep into the dark side of human nature and show what happens when people decide the rules don't apply to them. It's not just the thrill of a heist or the tension of a cover-up that make them so perversely fascinating; it's watching ambition, desperation, and ego collide in slow motion, usually with a body count. It's the way power and avarice can build up and dash an empire. These kinds of stories, when you think about it, offer the entertainment of pure escapism and a front-row seat to chaos. Which, by the way, is more or less what MobLand star Tom Hardy told me when I recently interviewed him about his Paramount+ series, and I asked him why we're so drawn to stories like these: Today's Top Deals Best deals: Tech, laptops, TVs, and more sales Best Ring Video Doorbell deals Memorial Day security camera deals: Reolink's unbeatable sale has prices from $29.98 'It's sort of wish fulfillment and escapism, isn't it? Watching people doing things that are beyond me doing. And I think there's something of the comic book within them as well, in many aspects. And, there's a parody in a lot of it, too — because, in real life, gangsterin' is pretty horrible and heinous, serious stuff. I think it's just an escape. And there's freedom in it as well … like saying, 'No, I'll do what I want whenever I want.' We like to see whether they get away with it.' -Tom Hardy, in an April 2025 interview with BGR That mix of danger and hedonism is what makes these stories so hard to resist. And so, with that in mind, I've rounded up seven Netflix crime dramas that are so addictive, bingeing them just once won't be enough. Believe me, because I've burned through all of these at least twice. Guy Ritchie's signature swagger gets the perfect delivery vehicle in the form of this Netflix original that feels like a cross between Succession and a blood-soaked pub brawl. Set in the same universe as his 2019 film, the series follows a reluctant heir to a cannabis empire trying to keep the family business from going up in smoke. It's fast-talking, sharply dressed, and full of double-crosses, with loads of dry wit and a rotating cast of psychopaths who'll charm your socks off. With The Gentlemen, Netflix in my humble opinion has found its most effortlessly cool new crime franchise. This Swedish thriller is a pulse-pounding ride through the dark intersection of ambition and greed. A tech entrepreneur chasing startup dreams gets entangled in Stockholm's criminal underworld, and suddenly lines start blurring. Snabba Cash isn't just gritty; it's icy and ruthless, with the tension of a fuse that never stops sizzling. Paced like a thriller, it also makes you care deeply about characters whose choices grow more questionable by the minute. Ricky Gervais raved on X about the series: 'Just finished Season 2 of Snabba Cash. Blown away. One of the best series of all time. The writing, acting, direction, casting, editing, soundtrack, design and titles are all perfect. The Wire meets Wall Street. Stunning.' Based on the best-selling Danish crime novels, Dept. Q is a slow-burn procedural that follows a disgraced detective and his partner as they reopen long-forgotten cold cases — and also stumble into secrets that powerful people want to keep buried. The cases are haunting, the atmosphere is bleak, and the character work here is as sharp as a coroner's scalpel. And while the show leans into familiar, Slow Horses-style grumpy detective territory, I can't stress this point enough: Dept. Q is one of the best new Netflix shows of 2025. Oh, and it comes from the writer of The Queen's Gambit, in case you need another reason to watch. Jason Bateman as a criminal mastermind? Um, yes please. What starts off in Ozark as a simple money-laundering job quickly spirals into a bloody feud with cartels, corrupt politicos, and local crime families. Bateman plays against type as genius accountant Marty Byrde, while Laura Linney's Wendy evolves into his cold-blooded Lady Macbeth of a wife. What makes Ozark so good isn't just the danger; it's the slow transformation of Marty from a mild-mannered numbers guy into a master manipulator. Like Walter White, he's calm under pressure and scarily good at rationalizing his descent. But Marty doesn't break bad so much as calculate his way there. Watching him balance family life with criminality is like watching someone juggle knives while blindfolded. This Italian gem is a bit under the radar as far as Netflix crime dramas go, but Suburra is absolutely a must-watch for fans of international thrillers. Set in the underbelly of Rome (the name itself refers to a poor slum in ancient Rome), this series puts politicians, priests, and street gangs on a violent collision course. It's got the operatic intensity of Max's Gomorrah (which, cards on the table, just so happens to be my favorite crime drama of all time) but with more political intrigue and style that's just a little bit sharper, whereas Gomorrah is much rougher and much more primal. And when you're done, don't forget to check out the follow-up show with a similar title that's also available on Netflix: Suburræterna. This next beloved Netflix crime drama is basically a walking quote book. In creator Steven Knight's Peaky Blinders, Cillian Murphy leads a Birmingham crime gang with icy calm and steely charisma, in a show that fuses post-World War I ennui with rock 'n' roll swagger. What started off as a BBC period drama became a global phenomenon, thanks to Knight's superb writing, family drama, and style so slick it should be illegal. Whether you're watching for the gangster power plays or the killer suits, Peaky Blinders delivers. What's more: Netflix has also a feature film in the works that will serve as a one-off extension of the six-episode series. This final Netflix crime classic is more about psychological warfare. Produced by David Fincher, Mindhunter is all about the early days of the FBI's criminal profiling unit. Instead of car chases and shootouts, viewers are treated to chilling interviews with serial killers. It's methodical, cerebral, and utterly terrifying. Mindhunter digs into what makes monsters tick, and what it costs to stare them in the eye. Starring Jonathan Groff and Holt McCallany, the series is so good that if you ask a group of Netflix subscribers which cancelled series they'd most want to see brought back — this one would end up on most people's lists, no question about it. Don't Miss: Today's deals: Nintendo Switch games, $5 smart plugs, $150 Vizio soundbar, $100 Beats Pill speaker, more More Top Deals Amazon gift card deals, offers & coupons 2025: Get $2,000+ free See the
Yahoo
11 hours ago
- Yahoo
The OceanGate Victims' Eerie Last Words Speak Volumes of Their Mindset Before the Vessel's Tragic Implosion
The Titan's story isn't over yet. Netflix's newest investigation documentary Titan: The OceanGate Disaster gives insight to the years and moments leading up to the tragic day where 5 people died on the way to see the wreckage of the Titanic. Netflix's documentary explores the means OceanGate used to skirt through regulations with the Titan submersible and Stockton Rush's obsession to become the next big billionaire. In the film, former OceanGate bookkeeper Bonnie Carl says that Rush 'wanted to be a Jeff Bezos or an Elon Musk. He referred to those guys as big swinging dicks, and he loved that term.' More from StyleCaster Tylenol Murders Suspect James Lewis' Eerie Last Interview Before His Death Included Him Answering 'All the Hard Questions' Are Colt & Kelsey Still Together From Sneaky Links? Where They Are Now After Their Love Triangle With AngeliqueHowever, that journey came at the expense of five lives. Rush, British aviation billionaire Hamish Harding, Pakistani businessman Shahzada Dawood and his 19-year-old son Suleman, and Titanic expert Paul-Henri Nargeolet were all killed in the Titan's implosion on June 18, 2023. According to the US Coast Guard, the Titan's last message to the boat Polar Prince that they were 'dropped two wts,' referring to their weights. After that message, there were no updates from the submersible. Forty minutes after the submersible dived down, the Polar Prince experienced trouble receiving transmissions from the Titan. 'I need better comms from you,' to which the Titan answered 'yes' and said they 'lost system oand [sic] chat settings,' at around 10:15 a.m. Paul-Henri Nargeolet, was believed to be the messenger. The ship later asked, 'status? do you see polar prince on your display?' The Titan wrote back 'yes' and 'all good here.' Tym Catterson, who was OceanGate's contract safety diver and submersible pilot, recounted seeing the victims right before the implosion in a BBC documentary. 'Suleman was close to the last to going in and when he came up I grabbed him by the back of his flotation device and pulled him to make sure he isn't going to go sliding off into the water,' he said. 'I helped him get in I helped him get into the sub and then I said 'have a good dive'.' Rush's wife, Wendy, who was on the support ship, heard a boom. That boom was likely the implosion. The project's development started in 2016 but had major red flags throughout the years. Experts believed that the carbon fiber wasn't up to safety regulations and end caps, made of titanium, were affixed to the hull with glue. There were clear warning signs when the carbon fiber kept popping during subsequent trips. 'I still question it every day: How could he not see this was dangerous?' former Oceangate employee Bonnie Carl says about Rush's ego. 'In my opinion, he clearly wanted fame. Stockton had his mind set. He was going to do this no matter what.' Best of StyleCaster The 26 Best Romantic Comedies to Watch if You Want to Know What Love Feels Like These 'Bachelor' Secrets & Rules Prove What Happens Behind the Scenes Is So Much Juicier BTS's 7 Members Were Discovered in the Most Unconventional Ways
New York Post
13 hours ago
- New York Post
Rex Heuermann has shown ‘no remorse' since his arrest: Pal
Rex Heuermann has been in jail for almost two years, during which he has shown no remorse for his seven alleged victims, The Post has learned. The one-time architect, 61, stands accused of murdering sex workers between 1993 and 2011 and dumping their bodies along Ocean Parkway in Long Island. His friend who visited him in jail, David Jimenez, 63, says he wouldn't give him details about the alleged crimes, but also showed no emotion for anyone beside himself. 7 Rex Heuermann is a 'momma's boy' and had a strange relationship with his mother, according to sources. Rex Heuermann Consultants & Associates 7 Heuermann and his second wife, Asa Ellerup, who lived in the house where he had grown up after they married in 1995. Peacock 'I personally think he disconnects one [personality] from the other and has no remorse. 'I think he's got a split personality. I literally said to him, 'I'm looking at you eye-to-eye and I know you. And this is like, there's somebody else sitting next to me that committed these crimes,' Jimenez said. 'And it's like a dark side of you, psychopathic, Machiavellian. It's sadistic'.' Heuermann – who has pleaded not guilty to all charges against him – still has to stand trial and his wife, Asa Ellerup, maintains he is not a serial killer. 7 The Massapequa, NY, home where Heuermann lived was almost exactly the same inside as it had been when he grew up, according to his friend David Jimenez. Peacock 7 Ellerup outside the home after her husband's arrest in 2023. Police have not said if they believe Heuermann allegedly killled any of his victims inside the home, which is known to have a basement 'gun room'. Kevin C. Downs for NY Post 7 'The Gilgo Beach Killer: House of Secrets' is avilable to stream on Peacock now. Peacock However, Jimenez — who also works in architecture — feels his ex-pal is resigned to his fate. 'He knows intellectually he's lost all his life, everything. I remember him calling me and saying from the correctional facility, 'Are you interested in taking my building code books, my historic ones? So, he realizes he's never going to use them again.' Jimenez also feels Heuermann won't admit to anything because he wants to watch the trial unfold and all the gory details to be poured over once again in open court. 7 David Jimenez has known Heuermann since 2006, but said he had no inkling he was involved in any of the heinous crimes he now stands accused of. Courtesy of David Jimenez 7 Heuermann's seven alleged victims: (Top row L-R) Maureen Brainard-Barnes, Megan Waterman, Melissa Barthelemy, and Amber Lynn Costello. (Bottom row L-R) Sandra Costilla, Jessica Taylor, Valerie Mack. Suffolk County Police Department 'I think [the trial] is the last time he feels in any kind of control over anything. Why not just either admit it and ask for help, or admit it and ask for forgiveness? 'Even though you can never bring back those lives and you've destroyed, why go through trial? Because he's going to put the family through this and expose all these ugly things.' Jimenez also recognizes that, like all high-profile killers, hulking 6' 4' Heuermann is going to have a target on his back as far as other inmates are concerned due to the nature of his alleged crimes, if he is sent to prison. '[He] will be a target in prison. Maybe not right away, but over the years, he's going to be a target and somebody will want to take his life.'
