Does the £17k Volkswagen ID 1 really represent progress?
There's a lot to like about the Volkswagen ID 1. In an age when cars are forever growing bigger, here's a proper city car that's right-sized and looks great.
A mainstream car brand committing to the A-segment is something to celebrate.
But there's one big concern: with a promised range of 'at least' 155 miles, it's possible the ID 1 will go on sale in 2027 with basically the same range as offered by later versions of its spiritual predecessor, the e-Up. That doesn't feel like progress.
To be fair, the ID 1 promises to be larger, more practical, more powerful and around £3000 cheaper than a new e-Up would have set you back in 2023 (and the e-Up benefitted from a government grant). Those are hard-won gains, and they haven't been easy. Still, it's a stark illustration of how making affordable electric cars is a huge challenge.
EV batteries are slowly – glacially – getting cheaper, but they remain by far the most expensive part of a new EV.
Volkswagen was determined to hit its €20,000 (£17,000) target for the ID 1, and the best way to do that is to right-size the battery for its intended urban use case.
Trouble is, that requires buyers to accept a potentially unpalatable compromise. A range of 155 miles might be fine for the everyday, but what about those occasional weekend trips away?
History suggests buyers are unlikely to compromise with their main or only car.
It's concerning that, like the Renault Zoe, Nissan Leaf and e-Up in the early days of mass-market EVs a decade or so back, the likes of the ID 1 and Dacia Spring could find most success as budget second cars – a daily runaround that allows you to keep your bigger, posher car for the weekend.
Which is great, but that means instead of widening access to electric mobility, the new wave of cheap EV is really providing further benefit to more affluent buyers who can afford two cars. Single-car owners on a budget who don't want to compromise will stick with petrol.
None of that is Volkswagen's fault: it can produce cheaper EVs, but it can't control who buys them. And in an age when so many rivals have given up on smaller, more affordable cars, credit to it for persisting in a category that is no longer a huge profit driver. It's absolutely doing the right thing.
But this is a reminder that there's a long way to go to making truly usable everyday EVs that are genuinely affordable – and that, at present, even the drive towards affordable EVs risks benefitting those who are better off.
]]>
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Trump wants more American pick-ups in Tokyo and London. That may be a hard sell
By David Dolan, Maki Shiraki and Marie Mannes TOKYO/STOCKHOLM, August 7 (Reuters) -Donald Trump is right that Japan and Europe buy few American-made cars - but it has little to do with trade barriers. From Tokyo to London, many consumers see Detroit's offerings as simply too big and too gas-guzzling. That view has made Chevrolets and Cadillacs a hard sell, and a rare sight, in cities full of slimmer cars from the Toyota Corolla to Honda Civic, Volkswagen Golf and Renault Clio. Trump often complains about what he sees as a refusal to accept U.S. cars while the Japanese and Europeans sell millions of automobiles a year into the United States. In recent trade deals, both markets agreed to drop or ease safety tests on American vehicle imports. Europe will lower levies on U.S. cars. But it may take more than a change of rules and lower tariffs to convince Japanese and European consumers, who contend with narrow roads and painfully tight parking, to buy big American-made Ford F-150 trucks and Cadillac Escalade SUVs. "American cars are designed for wide roads and freeway driving, so handling them on narrow Japanese streets can be tricky. It takes a bit of technique," said Yumihito Yasue, president of Johnan Jeep Petit in Tokyo, which imports and services vintage cars from the United States. His customers tend to be enthusiasts in their 50s and 60s who grew up seeing American cars on TV and in movies. On a recent weekday, he was servicing two Chevrolets, a lustrous brown 1971 Nova and a low-slung 1986 El Camino, both with their steering wheels on the left. In Japan, steering is on the right. Yasue inherited his love of American cars from his father, who started the business four decades ago and would travel to California to scout for cars. Yasue took over after his father died nine years ago, and sells about 20 vehicles a year. "What makes American cars special is the design. Compared to Japanese or German cars, the body shape is more beautiful. Especially the lines, like the rear lines and the fenders," he said. Some 3.7 million new cars were sold in Japan last year, with a third of those mini or "kei" cars - tiny, fuel efficient vehicles not produced by American automakers. Overall, foreign cars accounted for 6% of new car sales, data from the Japanese Automobile Manufacturers Association showed. Of those, around 570 Chevys, 450 Cadillacs and 120 Dodges were sold, data from the Japan Automobile Importers Association showed. Ford pulled out of Japan almost a decade ago. Tesla makes cars sleeker than some of Detroit's and is becoming more popular. The data does not give a breakdown for the EV maker. 'WE DON'T BUY FORD F-150S' In Europe, smaller locally-made U.S. cars have done well: models like the best-selling Ford Puma and the older Fiesta. But over the past two decades, Ford and General Motors have pivoted towards larger pickups and SUVs, vehicles less suited to Europe's narrow streets and compact-car culture. Ford, a big player in Europe from the early 1900s, has seen sales in the region fall sharply, from 1.26 million vehicles in 2005 to just 426,000 in 2024, according to data from the European Automobile Manufacturers' Association (ACEA). Its market share dropped from 8.3% to 3.3%. "We don't buy Ford F-150s, that's not what our roads are scaled for, it's not what our customers want," Andy Palmer, former CEO of Aston Martin, told Reuters. GM exited Europe in 2017, selling Opel after pulling back Chevrolet, but returned with its Cadillac Lyriq last year. It sold a mere 1,514 of the U.S.-made SUV, according to auto data firm Jato. A GM spokesperson said Cadillac was growing its all-electric lineup in Europe, and the vehicles had been well-received in the markets where they were launched. A Ford spokesperson said the firm exported "passion products" to Europe like the Bronco and Mustang, alongside locally-made models tailored for the market. Clive Sutton, a British car dealer in London who sells luxury American models, said his buyers were drawn to the rarity of vehicles like the giant Cadillac Escalade. But he admitted it was a challenge. "There are people that want that car because of its exclusivity and its perceived status," Sutton said. "But it's not the most easy car to find a parking space for, certainly in central London." COMPETITIVE MARKET Trump has also put pressure on South Korea to open its market to American cars and said duty-free access was part of the trade deal the two countries agreed last week. There, imported vehicles account for less than one-fifth of the car market and U.S. models for only 16% of the imported car segment, which is dominated by German rivals, according to data from the Korea Automobile Importers & Distributors Association. German manufacturers have also carved out a strong presence in Japan's luxury market. Mercedes-Benz sold more than 53,000 vehicles last year, making it the most popular foreign brand, followed by BMW at more than 35,000. Japanese automakers say Europeans have been successful because they committed the time and resources to the market. Detroit carmakers, meanwhile, are often associated with left-hand drive cars, which are more challenging to drive on the left-hand side of the road. But some U.S. manufacturers are changing. GM has offered the Corvette only in right-hand drive since the eighth generation version went on sale in 2021. That may be one reason why some 80% of buyers are new customers, a GM spokesperson said. The Corvette is the only model Chevy offers in Japan, and it has sold fewer than 1,000 of them a year for the last decade. GM this year announced plans for a line-up of right-hand-drive Cadillac EVs and deliveries of the Lyriq started in July. 'WOW, A FOREIGN CAR' Jeep, which sells right-hand drive models, has been the most popular American brand for more than a decade, the importer data showed. It sold just shy of 10,000 vehicles last year in Japan. Yukimi Nitta used to drive a "kei" car but she was drawn to the Jeep Wrangler's appearance, which she described as "friendly" and "outdoorsy". The 42-year-old hair salon owner is now on her second Jeep - a limited-edition beige model - and hopes to switch again to another limited-edition colour. Parking is tight but manageable, she said, and two of her friends have since bought Wranglers. "People often say, 'Wow, a foreign car!' But once you drive it, it feels totally normal. I wish more people would try it," she said. While the Wrangler does burn through fuel quickly, the resale value is good, making it possible to switch out colours, something owners do, Nitta said. A spokesperson for Jeep owner Stellantis said it actively promoted owner events. In July, it announced a collaboration with the "Jurassic World" movie series featuring a limited-edition pink Wrangler, the spokesperson said. Big American cars and trucks might find it hard to follow in Jeep's tracks. Daniel Cadwell, an American living in Tokyo, exports used Japanese camper vans and wagons to the United States. He said he was struck by the size of American cars whenever he went home. "They are just excessively big," said Cadwell, who runs Javan Imports in Portland with his U.S.-based business partner. "I think it is highly challenging for a car of that sort to be seen as attractive in Japan." Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Motor 1
an hour ago
- Motor 1
Volkswagen Is Killing the Touareg After 24 Years
Volkswagen hasn't sold the Touareg in the United States since 2017. The automaker replaced it with the more mainstream and affordable Atlas , which remains VW's top SUV in America. The company has sold the Touareg elsewhere since then, but a new report alleges Volkswagen will discontinue production in 2026, 24 years after the model's launch. The allegation comes from 'insiders' who spoke with Autocar . According to the publication, Volkswagen does not have a direct successor planned for the Touareg, alleging the company will instead focus on building a portfolio of affordable models for cost-conscious consumers. Motor1 reached out to Volkswagen to confirm the report. We'll update the story if we hear back. Touareg production began in 2002 for the 2003 model year, the result of a collaboration between VW, Porsche , and Audi that also spawned the Cayenne and Q7 . Volkswagen designed the Touareg, along with the Phaeton at the time, to be a premium product that elevated the brand into the luxury space. The Phaeton didn't last long in the American market, but the Touareg stuck around until the mid-2010s, albeit with dwindling sales. Volkswagen isn't abandoning buyers in Europe who want something big. The company introduced the Tayron last October, which is available in two- and three-row configurations and is related to the Tiguan on sale in America. The Touareg's demise, if true, is the end of the era for the brand. The SUV was a bold product that featured a range of powertrains, including a V-10 diesel that even Americans got to enjoy. But all that appears to be just history for the brand as the SUV allegedly fades into the sunset. Here's More From Volkswagen: The Volkswagen Golf GTI Isn't Going Anywhere: 'Definitely Into the 2030s' Volkswagen's EV Sales Are Booming. Its Cheapest Cars Aren't Even Out Yet Get the best news, reviews, columns, and more delivered straight to your inbox, daily. back Sign up For more information, read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use . Source: Autocar Share this Story Facebook X LinkedIn Flipboard Reddit WhatsApp E-Mail Got a tip for us? Email: tips@ Join the conversation ( )
NBC News
5 hours ago
- NBC News
McDonald's sees U.S. sales rebound, but concerns about low-income consumers linger
McDonald's on Wednesday reported quarterly earnings and revenue that topped analysts' expectations as buzzy promotions helped its U.S. restaurants rebound. Despite the chain's improved performance this quarter, executives are still worried about the economic health of the low-income consumer. McDonald's is working with its U.S. franchisees on ways to make its core menu items more affordable, beyond the $5 meal deal it rolled out last summer and the newer Daily Double burger promotion. 'Reengaging the low-income consumer is critical, as they typically visit our restaurants more frequently than middle- and high-income consumers,' CEO Chris Kempczinski told analysts on the company's earnings conference call. 'This bifurcated consumer base is why we remain cautious about the overall near-term health of the U.S. consumer.' Executives said they anticipate that McDonald's results will be stronger in the second half of the year, particularly as the chain faces easier comparisons in the fourth quarter to the fallout from last year's E. coil outbreak. Shares of the company rose more than 2% in morning trading. Here's what the company reported compared with what Wall Street was expecting, based on a survey of analysts by LSEG: Earnings per share: $3.19 adjusted vs. $3.15 expected Revenue: $6.84 billion vs. $6.7 billion expected The fast-food giant reported second-quarter net income of $2.25 billion, or $3.14 per share, up from $2.02 billion, or $2.80 per share, a year earlier. Excluding restructuring charges and other items, McDonald's earned $3.19 per share. Revenue rose 5% to $6.84 billion. Kempczinski in the company's earnings release credited the chain's value, marketing and new menu items for the 6% increase in system sales during the quarter. Same-store sales, a metric that only tracks the performance of restaurants that have been open at least a year, increased 3.8%, the chain's biggest jump in nearly two years. McDonald's U.S. restaurants saw same-store sales growth of 2.5%, reversing two straight quarters of domestic declines. Kempczinski said the burger chain outperformed its rivals by both same-store sales and comparable traffic. 'Certainly, overall [quick-service restaurant] traffic in the U.S. remained challenging, as visits across the industry by low-income consumers once again declined by double digits versus the prior year period,' he said on the call. This quarter, the burger chain's U.S. sales received a boost from a tie-in meal with the 'Minecraft' movie and the launch of the McCrispy Chicken Strips. Shortly after the quarter ended, Snack Wraps returned to menus for the first time in nine years; executives said that early results are 'encouraging,' and franchisees have voted to maintain the $2.99 promotional price through the end of the year. Outside the U.S., demand for its Big Macs and french fries was even stronger. 'I would just note, also on our international side, it's not as competitive a market as it is in the U.S.,' Kempczinski said. 'I think it's a little bit easier for us to stand out and represent good value in international.' The chain's international developmental licensed markets division, which includes Japan and China, reported same-store sales growth of 5.6%. Its international operated markets segment saw same-store sales growth of 4%, thanks to gains in countries like the United Kingdom, Australia and Canada. Executives said McDonald's value and affordability scores from consumers have improved in key markets.
