MacTaggart Lecture: James Harding calls for BBC to be protected in changing media landscape
In his keynote MacTaggart Lecture, Harding said the perception of a "political presence looming over the BBC" is a problem and that the broadcaster needs to be "beyond the reach of politicians".Several staff were asked to step back from their duties after the live streaming of Bob Vylan's Glastonbury set, where the punk duo led chants of "death, death to the IDF [Israel Defence Forces]" and made other derogatory comments.Nandy's subsequent call for accountability at the top of the corporation for the decision not to pull the live stream of the performance was subsequently interpreted as calling for Davie's resignation.In his speech, Harding criticised "political interference", or the perception of it, in relation to the BBC, saying it was something "we've got too accustomed to"."The culture secretary's office insists she did not explicitly ask Samir Shah, the BBC chair, to deliver up the director general's resignation... but people inside the BBC were left in no doubt that was the message," Harding said."Whatever your view of the hate speech vs freedom of speech issues, an overbearing government minister doesn't help anyone," he said. "The hiring and firing of [the director general] should not be the job of a politician."A DCMS spokesperson said: "The BBC has itself acknowledged a number of serious failings in recent months, including the broadcasting of the Bob Vylan set at Glastonbury. It is entirely right that the culture secretary raised these issues with the BBC leadership on behalf of licence fee payers."The government remains committed to the very important principle that the BBC is operationally and editorially independent. We are focused on securing a sustainable future for the BBC and helping strengthen public trust in the Corporation as part of the upcoming Charter Review."
Read about previous MacTaggart Lectures:2018: Michaela Coel reveals she was sexually assaulted2019: Dorothy Byrne says media have right to call politicians 'liars'2020: David Olusoga: 'TV industry left me crushed'2021: TV has 'utterly failed' disabled people, writer Jack Thorne says2022: Maitlis says BBC rebuke over Cummings remarks made no sense2023: Louis Theroux: Anxious TV bosses should stop playing it safe2024: James Graham calls for more working-class people in TV
The BBC has been criticised for a number of high-profile scandals in recent months, such as breaching its own editorial guidelines on accuracy in relation to a documentary about Gaza.Elsewhere, Match of the Day host Gary Lineker left the BBC after sharing an Instagram reel about Zionism that featured an illustration of a rat, considered an antisemitic slur.Harding said the BBC was "not institutionally antisemitic", and that it was "untrue and unhelpful to say it is", adding that it was "much better to correct the mistakes and address the judgement calls that have been wrong".He acknowledged the BBC had "made mistakes... and it can be much too slow to correct them".Referring to a debate early in the conflict about the BBC's use of language, Harding said he thought it the BBC was "wrong not to use the word 'terrorist' for the attacks of October 7th; journalists shouldn't censor words, but use them accurately". Harding did not comment on the events surrounding Lineker's resignation, but did say he felt football pundits generally "should be able to have views as a citizen, as well as a job as a BBC broadcaster".
Harding also used his speech to argue the BBC has a crucial role to play in defending truth in an age of artificial intelligence (AI) and declining trust in traditional media."A shared understanding of what's true is disappearing before our eyes," he said."More people are paranoid, prone to conspiracy theories. Large numbers of people are giving up on the idea of facts."He continued: "Politics and technology are doing untold damage to trust in the world. "On the one hand, politicians are trying to control or cancel the media, particularly news. On the other, AI is beginning to lay waste to the economics of information, while also remaking the job of storytellers."In an age where "we're more divided, more certain we're right", Harding argued, the BBC should be protected and championed as the "most important source of information in this country".He said the corporation was "the best defence of truth and trust against the lies of dictators and demagogues".
The BBC's royal charter will be up for renewal in 2027, and it has not yet been decided whether the licence fee will be replaced by a new funding system.Harding reflected: "We're at the beginning of a new information age, if we want it to be truly creative, innovative and competitive globally, we can't short-change the BBC again."We need, surely, to be thinking about a mix of funding that gets closer to doubling its resources," Harding said. "Because obviously, given the cost of living, that's not going to happen just through the licence fee."Over five years, nearly two-and-half million households have dropped out of paying the licence fee, so this needs fixing. It's expensive and unfair on those who pay. If we believe in the universality of the BBC, we need to return to the principle in some form or other that every household pays."Harding also suggested news and current affairs programmes could be opened up to independent producers in an effort to make the BBC more of a "people's platform" and allow more varied thinking while maintaining standards of truth and accuracy.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
13 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
Love Is Blind UK couple's 'epic' love story not shown on TV and how it nearly fell apart
Some of the relationship journeys are never shown A Love Is Blind UK couple have shared their "epic" love story that was not shown on TV, and how it very nearly all fell apart. Love Is Blind UK has returned for a second season, with five newly engaged couples navigating their lives together after an extensive dating period on their pods. The latest batch of episodes (August 20) have seen the couples move on to the next phase of their journey. But of course, not every love story has been shown on screens. Stars Amy and James found their way to one another, despite not being seen on screens. Primary school teacher Amy, from Wales had been single for two years after her last relationship broke down when she suggested they started a family. Despite living in Dubai for the last few years, now back on home soil, she was ready to find her life partner. Similarly, real estate manager James had been married before and has two daughters. The 33-year-old used to divide his time between the UK and Thailand where his mum is from. According to Netflix's Tudum, Amy initially said yes to another proposal but a twist of fate soon found her back to James. She said: "I'm a big believer in the universe, everything unfolds exactly how it's meant to unfold." It has been revealed that during their dating period, Amy and James had actually found a lot in common, including the fact she recently returned from a trip to Thailand, where James had been living. However, despite getting on in the pods, they were also forming other relationships. Amy admitted: "That day we missed was key because by day three, I had a strong bond with somebody else." Amy had started to build a connection with Ross M, whilst James was dating both Holly and Laurie. However, James admitted they were both "playing it safe" as he told Tudum: "In hindsight, I should've laid it on a bit thicker with Amy, but I didn't want to propose and then have her say no." When it came to making a decision, Amy was left "crying", unable to decide, until she said yes when Ross M had proposed. However, it was James who could not bring himself to propose to another woman. After their first night out together, Amy and Ross soon called their relationship off, but a few days later she found herself chatting to James on Instagram. At the time, she was in Spain, and so James drove six hours to the airport to pick her up upon her UK return. He added: "It was pretty epic." They made their relationship official around two weeks later before James declared his love, and they have gone from strength to strength since, even meeting James' children. The two have now spent the last three months living together in Malta. Amy added: "Love Is Blind sets a foundation where you have to be vulnerable and emotional because there's nothing else you can offer. "Communication has been a strong point in our relationship, and I think that has genuinely come from starting in the pods."
BBC News
13 minutes ago
- BBC News
Bear Grylls helps people rebuild relationships in new series Wild Reckoning
BBC Daytime and BBC Cymru Wales have co-commissioned Wild Reckoning, a new 16-part series from Wrexham-based Tŷ'r Ddraig, part of Banijay UK's Workerbee Group, fronted by Bear Grylls for BBC One and iPlayer. The series will see Bear Grylls and a team of experts help people to resolve deep personal rifts in the Welsh wilderness. Bear, alongside his team of mediators, psychologists and survival mentors, will guide participants through intense emotional journeys — combining conflict resolution with the raw, revealing power of nature. Expect to see feuding families and broken friendships to neighbour disputes and long-standing workplace grudges, this series will tackle some everyday problems and challenges faced by anyone and everyone. From his island home off the North Wales coast, Bear will strip contributors of their everyday comforts and set them on a transformative adventure in the Welsh wilderness. Here, through carefully constructed physical and psychological challenges, they'll be forced to confront their issues and work together to rebuild their fractured relationships. Bear Grylls says: 'I've spent a lifetime learning from the wild and above all I believe in its power to heal. Away from the noise and distractions of daily life, we're giving people the chance to reflect, reconnect, and rebuild. But nothing comes for free. The price is often courage to face the scary, and the humility to walk side by side respectfully with others. Wild Reckoning is a rare opportunity to help those in emotional conflict to face their differences with courage, and hopefully come through stronger, together. I'm proud to host it in North Wales, a place that truly means so much to me.' Ben Smith, Creative Director for Tŷ'r Ddraig, adds: 'This is an ambitious new format played out across the spectacular scenery of North Wales. We can't wait to bring some of the remarkable stories and people we've been talking with to screen on the BBC. It is our greatest hope that we can help to heal rifts and help the people who have come forward. We're also delighted to have Bear and our team of amazing experts lead this project.' Alex McLeod Commissioning Editor for BBC Daytime comments: 'This is a bold and emotionally charged series that uses the raw power of nature to help people confront what's really at stake in their relationships. In stepping away from the constant noise of our fast-paced, digital lives, participants are given the rare chance to reflect, reconnect and reset. With Bear Grylls and his expert team guiding them through intense physical and emotional challenges, the series offers a unique and powerful route to reconciliation. It's about real people, real issues – and the transformative power of the wild.' Julian Carey, Commissioning Editor for BBC Cymru Wales, says: "We are incredibly excited to be working with Bear and his team on such an important new series, one that showcases the dramatic and awe-inspiring Welsh landscape to such positive effect. Seeing Bear in his own "back-yard" working to affect change in people's lives, while also passing on skills and insights that can help all of us, feels very timely and refreshing - and we can't wait for audiences to see it." Wild Reckoning has been co-commissioned for BBC One, BBC One Wales and iPlayer by Rob Unsworth, Head of BBC Daytime and Early Peak Commissioning and Nick Andrews, Head of Commissioning at BBC Cymru Wales, Alex McLeod is BBC Daytime's Commissioning Editor and Julian Carey is the Commissioning Editor for BBC Cymru Wales. The series is a Co-Production between Tŷ'r Ddraig and Natural Studios Productions Limited for the BBC. The executive producers are Ben Smith and Ben Mitchell. HD3 Follow for more
Spectator
16 minutes ago
- Spectator
We need to purge the Ministry of Defence
On Afghanistan, you'll recall, a massive data breach of vast dimensions and bitter consequences has already been revealed, after years of secrecy and lies. The state has forked out billions to transport tens of thousands of entirely unvetted people into Britain, where they and their descendants will reside at public expense. And, to top it off, there was an immense cover-up, the fabricating of official numbers and a super-injunction to muzzle the press. The only part of the whole debacle that the regime executed with any ability was the deceit and the cover-up. It is better at hiding the truth from the public than it is at doing anything else. You might have thought it could not get worse. But the British state — and our Ministry of Defence — will always sink to the occasion. There are always new and innovative ways of failing to deliver. Today, the BBC reports on a freedom of information request it made which turned up 49 data breaches (of which only four were previously known) by the unit handling relocation applications from Afghans. Each one means official incapability, a growing bill in litigation and implied responsibility. The lawyers who represent the Afghans who have had their information carelessly handled or exposed by the British state are full of demands. Some of those are highly practical: we need to know where the gangrene is; the state cannot continue its paranoid mania for deceit and secrecy. It must be honest about its failures if we are to have any hope of stopping more in the future. But of course, they also have other concerns: money, this mostly means. They will want compensation and they'll want a lot of it. And why not? The state has failed these people. Who knows, yet, how bad those failures are? You can, it turns out, put a price on peace of mind – and that price is to be extracted in the form of years of litigation, extracted from the readers of this magazine in taxation, in interest paid on government borrowing, paid for by their children, by their grandchildren, paid forever. Now here's the scary part. This is only the beginning. These stories, reported by the BBC, are only the ones the regime is now permitting us to know about. There will be more horrors that we haven't heard yet — that will only be fed to us in drips, or leaked unexpectedly by people whose movements and motives cannot be predicted. There will be awful stories the regime will fight viciously to keep from you for the rest of time. Be prepared for years of lawsuits, and years of payouts, years of your money being spent on these errors. Almost everyone I speak to in the defence and security world now has an unrecoverable opinion of the Ministry of Defence. It can't build drones; it can't protect its own people from cyber attacks; it can't procure anything. Its failures are endemic and flagrant. As one analyst of the Ukraine war, surveying the breathtakingly useless Watchkeeper drone programme that is now being wound up, said recently, everyone in the MoD should probably be fired. The department should be completely purged and rebuilt from scratch with a less disastrous institutional culture and a wholly new collection of better people. It is completely incompetent at all of its functions. It must not survive to keep on failing.
