Housing minister meets Raac campaigners in Dundee as key theme emerges
Paul McLennan sat down with Yvette and Wayne Hoskins on Monday afternoon to discuss a range of concerns, including communication issues between residents and Dundee City Council.
Speaking to The Courier afterwards, Mr McLennan said: 'I met with the council earlier on today as well and asked them some questions about their approach.
'And I've spoken to Wayne and Yvette in more detail.
'There's some things that we've taken away, one of them is about communication both for council tenants and for private residents.'
The housing minister believes local authorities should be taking the lead on informing residents about Raac-related issues and said learnings could be made.
'I think the key thing is communication between council and the Raac community – whether it's either residents or council tenants,' said Mr McLennan.
'The situation in Aberdeen is different to Dundee and is different to other parts, so the lead on this should be local authorities.
'One of the other things we talked about today was learning from other local authorities.
'In terms of Aberdeen, its communication has been different from Dundee, it's been different from North Lanarkshire and other parts of Scotland.
'So we look at best practice as well in terms of communication.'
When asked outright if Dundee City Council had to improve on their communication, Mr McLennan said: 'I think they're just different approaches.
'It's an unsettling time for residents and council tenants and I think one of the key things is knowing what they need to know.'
Earlier this week, Raac residents in Menzieshill were furious after being told to expect a repair bill by council for work on their flats which began without consultation.
Mortgages and insurance concerns were the other key messages raised by the campaigners.
The housing minister said the Scottish Government were continuing to ask Westminster to set up a UK Raac fund.
However, he admitted that currently the UK Government was saying no.
Mr McLennan pointed to Raac now being found in Wales and other previous instances where it was found in England.
'We believe it's a UK Raac issue and we've asked the UK Government to set up a Raac fund.
'They've said no at this stage, but we've went back to them.'
The Courier is asking people to sign a petition to help homeowners gain a voice at Westminster.
Dundee Raac campaign chairman, Wayne Hoskins, said it had been a good meeting with the minister.
He told The Courier: 'We want answers for homeowners and tenants.
'We want answers on mortgages, we can't get mortgages on our property.
'How do we restore these to market value? We're losing £30k-40k on these properties.'
The housing minister said he would return to Dundee for a public meeting on the issue.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
SNP fails to hit flagship pledge as SQA results revealed
As 147,000 pupils received their exam results earlier today, it emerged the attainment gap has actually grown since Mr Swinney took over as First Minister Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) NATS ministers have failed to meet their flagship pledge to wipe out the poverty-related 'attainment gap' in the final report card before the 2026 Holyrood election. Nicola Sturgeon pledged in 2015 to eliminate the difference in achievement between rich and poor kids and in 2016 she and John Swinney - who was then Education Secretary - said this would be done 'substantially' in a decade. Sign up for the Politics newsletter Sign up 2 The SNP government has failed to reach its pledge to eradicate the poverty-related attainment gap Credit: PA 2 School pupils across Scotland received their exam results today Credit: Getty But as 147,000 pupils received their exam results earlier today, it emerged the attainment gap has actually grown since Mr Swinney took over as First Minister. In 2017 the gap was 15.7 percentage points at National 5, 15.8 at Higher and 11.5 at Advanced Higher. It is now 16.6 at National 5, 17.1 at Higher and 12.8 at Advanced Higher. But sparking criticism from opposition parties, the Scottish Government hailed a 0.1 percentage point improvement on last year - a figure which was rounded up by officials - as evidence of progress. Scottish Labour education spokeswoman Pam Duncan-Glancy said: 'This once again proves that any promises made by the SNP are simply not worth the paper they are written on. 'The SNP has gone from promising to close the attainment gap entirely to congratulating itself for the most incremental progress.' Scottish Tory education spokesman Miles Briggs said: 'These results have been achieved against a backdrop of another challenging year in our schools with violence soaring out of control and teachers often feeling like they do not have enough say over the school curriculum. 'Frankly, no amount of spin from them can avoid the fact that Nicola Sturgeon's promises in relation to the attainment gap lie in tatters.' Overall, the the rate of pupils achieving between an A and a C at National 5 increased from 77.2 per cent to 78.4 per cent year on year, while Higher jumped from 74.9 per cent to 75.9 per cent. The proportion of pupils getting A grades was 30.8 per cent compared to 30.3 per cent in 2024 for Highers, and 39.2 per cent compared to 38.0 per cent in 2024 for National 5s. SNP and Scottish Government chiefs today insisted 'the poverty-related attainment gap has continued to narrow at all three key qualification levels, underlining the SNP's sustained focus on closing the gap'. Moment cops 'pelted with eggs & stones' as hundreds of protesters gather in Scots street But the Scottish Qualifications Authority confirmed the narrowing of the attainment gap at Higher was less than 0.1 percentage point as 'an impact of rounding'. Education Secretary Jenny Gilruth said the failure to eliminate the gap wasn't her fault and blamed Covid and the UK Government. She said: 'We have to be mindful that this is the pandemic generation and these children and young people's experience of school during lockdown saw their education disrupted at points, and I think that has impacted on what have seen in recent years in attainment. A RECORD number of young Scots have secured places at university - but a poverty-related target is still being missed. Statistics released by admission body Ucas show 17,350 17 and 18-year-olds will be admitted this year, compared to 16,650 last year. The number of those from the most deprived backgrounds is also at its highest, at 2,060. But the gap in the proportion of those accepted from the most deprived areas compared with the most affluent remains wide - with 16 per cent from the fifth of areas described as the most deprived being accepted compared to 43.6 per cent from the least-deprived communities. And the total number of applicants from Scotland who secured a place at university this year actually fell compared to the figure for 2024, from 31,970 to 31,850, as a result of a decline in mature student applications. Dr Jo Saxton, chief executive of Ucas, said: 'I'm delighted to see record numbers of young people in Scotland accept a place at university or college via Ucas this year.' The Scottish Government's 2030 target us for pupils from the most deprived backgrounds to make up 20 per cent of university entrants. Lib Dem MSP WIllian Rennie said: 'The university access figures show that the closing of the poverty related attainment gap has all but stalled in Scotland. 'It's difficult to see how the target will be reached by the end of the decade. Universities have been working incredibly hard on this target but ultimately this is a reflection of the SNP government's inability to close the gap in schools.' Some 3,660 students are set to come from abroad - an increase from 3,480 from last year. 'We are also seeing the impact of austerity in Scotland's schools which is harming some of Scotland's most vulnerable young people and their families.' In 2016, the Scottish Government made the pledge for the next decade and said it was 'the yardstick by which the people of Scotland can measure our success'.
The National
2 hours ago
- The National
East Lothian Council to pay almost £50,000 to lease its own offices
East Lothian Council has agreed a 10-year lease of offices in the Fisherrow Centre, Musselburgh, at an annual cost of £47, 560, to house staff from the town's Brunton Hall, which is facing demolition. Control of the community centre was handed to the Fisherrow Trust last year after the local authority agreed a 99-year lease of the whole building with the charity. Now, a report to elected members has revealed that they have signed a deal to use some of its offices for their own staff. READ MORE: Peer urged UK ministers to crack down on Palestine Action at request of US arms firm The report says the move is part of work to relocate staff working in the Brunton, which saw its main theatre close over two years ago after the discovery of reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete (Raac) in its roof panels. The results of a public consultation on the future of the building is expected to go before councillors later this month, with demolition one of the options being considered. The report to members said the council's justice social work team currently work in the hall and need to move to alternative accommodation which meets the needs of the department in terms of size and location. It said: 'Space within the Fisherrow Centre located on South Street in Musselburgh has been identified as suitable space for the needs of justice social work. 'Fisherrow Community Centre is owned by the council and leased to Fisherrow Trust on a 99-year lease. Fisherrow Trust has agreed to relocate current tenants occupying an area of the building, and to lease it to the council, allowing the council to carry out appropriate fit out works to provide an operational office specification, which can only be accessed by justice social work via secure entry doors.' The agreement involves leasing 4014 square feet of office space for ten years with a review in five years' time.
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Britain urged to let hero Afghans bring their families to UK after major data leak put thousands at risk
The government has been urged to let hero Afghans granted sanctuary in Britain bring their loved ones to the UK after a major data breach put the lives of up to 100,000 people at risk from the Taliban. More than 50 refugee charities and lawyers have written to Yvette Cooper, urging her to make it easier for Afghans who were allowed to relocate to the UK due to British links to bring family members – many of whom are at risk of reprisals – with them. The pleas come after revelations of a 'catastrophic' data leak at the Ministry of Defence in February 2022, which involved the details of thousands of Afghans who said they were in danger from the Taliban and had applied for sanctuary in Britain being shared online. The dataset, inadvertently sent out by a member of the armed forces, included the personal details of applicants to the MoD's Arap resettlement scheme, which allows Afghans who supported British troops to seek sanctuary in the UK. The leak was covered up by a superinjunction, which was lifted in July after The Independent challenged the draconian legal order at the High Court. Ms Cooper has now been told the government 'has no time to waste' if it 'wants to prevent the worst possible consequences of the data leak becoming a dire reality'. Charity workers and solicitors, including from Asylum Aid and modern slavery charity Kalayaan, told Ms Cooper: 'The UK government has a moral responsibility to the Afghan people who continue to suffer, including now as a result of the data leak and have no choice but to seek safety elsewhere. 'The 2022 data breach directly exposed Afghans still in the country to a risk of reprisals they were not even aware of, and the High Court, in lifting the superinjunction, recognised that its imposition may have increased the risks these people face.' The letter continued: 'Poor decision-making could yet again have exposed Afghans to serious harm, with many of these people having clear UK family ties'. They added: 'It is essential that those who were resettled under Arap and ACRS are able to live in safety and are given a fair opportunity to reunite with their families.' Unlike asylum routes, Afghans using Arap cannot sponsor family members to come to the UK under refugee reunion rules. The same applies to those relocated under ACRS, designed to help those who supported British values, such as journalists or women's rights activists. However, some may be able to make a separate immigration application. But charities and rights groups say these family routes are very restrictive and can often involve 'extremely costly application fees and require copious, specific documentation'. Decision-makers often refuse these applications from Afghan families, leading to lengthy appeals. Lib Dem MP Wendy Chamberlain, chair of the all-parliamentary group for Afghan women, said: 'There is already anecdotal evidence of reprisals on family members by the Taliban - the Home Office has no time to waste if the government wants to prevent the worst possible consequences of the data leak becoming a dire reality. 'The Home Office desperately needs to take a pragmatic and compassionate approach to allowing Afghans resettled in the UK to be reunited safely with their families. It is clear that these schemes have been seriously mis-handled, culminating in the recent exposure of the 2022 data leak.' In one recent case highlighted by The Independent, a security guard who worked for the British embassy in Kabul for almost two decades has been unable to bring his two eldest sons to the UK. Hamidullah Fahim and his wife Zaghona were brought to Britain with two young children in December 2023, but he couldn't bring his two eldest sons, who are now in their 20s. He said that his family is struggling with being separated, saying: 'We want to do whatever we can to be reunited with them and to let the Home Office know of the injustice that has been carried out in our case'. Isaac Shaffer, at Refugee Legal Support, said it was 'critical' that the government sped up decision-making on Arap cases in light of the data breach. He explained that most of the people he was helping 'have waited over a year for a final decision on their Arap application and have remained in hiding throughout; in constant fear, and in extraordinarily precarious circumstances', adding: 'Knowledge of this data breach has only exacerbated this fear and uncertainty'. James Tullett, CEO at charity Ramfel, who helped co-ordinate the letter, said: 'The government has acknowledged that the people they have resettled need protection and yet this offer of support comes with the heavy price of separation from family. 'Allowing Afghan families to reunite won't solve all the problems associated with the data leak, but it will make a monumental difference for the affected families'.
