Asim Munir is the first Punjabi general to attack India. It's sociologically important
The Punjabi advantage becomes that much more accentuated given that Gen Munir has a number of other firsts to his credit, and not all military. They add to his status in an Army dominated by his linguistic kin.
Given Pakistan's military engagement with India during the recently conducted Operation Sindoor, Gen Munir has also become the first Pakistani COAS to have taken his country into conflict with all of its neighbours. GHQ Rawalpindi had earlier launched ground and aerial operations against Afghanistan and Iran. Attacks on India complete the circle. This is an extraordinary undertaking for someone who is just about halfway through his tenure. Gen Munir clearly came with an agenda and is making the most of his opportunity, uncaring about the larger consequences that are likely to come Pakistan's way, and its neighbours' way.
General Asim Munir is the first Punjabi Army Chief to lead Pakistan into a conflict with India, but there's more to it. For an overwhelmingly Punjab-dominated Army in a largely Punjabi-speaking country, his command carries an extra gravitas, especially given the historical animosity with India. As does the fact that a large number of Punjabis in Pakistan are migrants from India, with memories of lands lost, estates vanished, lives uprooted, and haloed lifestyles recounted through misty mythologies of memory. Gen Asim Munir is also likely the first Punjabi-speaking Syed to head the Pakistan Army, sociologically deeply significant.
Also read: What is Asim Munir thinking?
Munir's many firsts
Gen Munir attended a Rawalpindi seminary, possibly making him the first COAS to be madrasa educated. The number of firsts continued to grow as he progressed professionally, but all that after he got a commission from the Officers Training School (OTS) at Mangala in 1986, while Gen Zia ul Haq was still leading the country. He has won the coveted Sword of Honour and is the first COAS to have done so at OTS. Gen Munir was commissioned in 23 Frontier Force Regiment, which he subsequently commanded. During his posting to Saudi Arabia as a Lieutenant Colonel, he memorised the Quran. Which earned him the prefix of Hafiz. He is the first Pakistan Army Chief to have managed that achievement.
It was clearly a sign of things to come, particularly for a higher-born Syed whose family was uprooted from Jalandhar in 1947. He served in Pakistan's Siachen Brigade as a Lt Col. He eventually worked his way up to GOC Force Command Northern Areas, deployed against India across Siachen and Kargil as well. The sight of India dominating the heights in Siachen and the Kargil sector Line of Control must have brutally revived those refugee memories from Jalandhar.
Gen Munir moved down from the heights to occupy the office of Director General Military Intelligence and then Director General Inter-Services Intelligence. He is the first COAS to have occupied both appointments. Certainly, no one else has deeper insight into political, social and other permanent policies as practised by GHQ Rawalpindi. For a Saudi-qualified Hafiz, with a head full of memories, inherited from those who travelled across a hastily carved Punjab border, Gen Munir had the shortest tenure as DG-ISI. He reportedly fell out of favour with Imran Khan when he told the PM that his to-be wife had her hand in the till.
Khan's days as PM were numbered; he was being watched by GHQ Rawalpindi. Dodgy elections and dodgier political manipulation meant that once blue-eyed Khan was out and the coalition Sharif government was in. The coalition gave an extension of service to Gen Asim Munir to make him Chief of Army Staff, and then amended the Pakistan Army Act to give him a five-year tenure. He's the first Army Chief to have been legislatively accorded a doubled tenure. He will remain in office till November 2027, giving him plenty of time to see his vision implemented.
Also read: Pahalgam massacre has blown Pakistan's cover. Asim Munir turned the clock back
Guided by memory
Even as he wears military awards bestowed by Bahrain and Turkey, Gen Asim Munir clearly has a regional agenda. An agenda that has been shaped by Pakistan's politico-military history, and also the sectarian memories carried over the years by its leadership. And none more obvious than General Hafiz Syed Asim Munir Ahmad Shah, Chief of Army Staff, Pakistan. In his case, these memories, accumulated over centuries as the waters of Sutlej and Beas seasonally tore into valuable arable land, even as migrants from Afghanistan continued to flow into the Doaba, occupying dwindling agricultural lands. And all the while, Hindus and Sikhs seemed to grow bolder, in a distinctly Muslim pluralistic district of Jalandhar, from where such memories of resentment travelled into newly born Pakistan, stopping first in Toba Tek Singh and then settling in Rawalpindi.
Gen Munir was born in 1968 in Rawalpindi, when the state and the army remained oblivious to the alarming downturn of events in East Pakistan. Pakistan was preening, given the perceived stalemate of the 1965 war with India, its romance with Washington once again on the upswing as the US wooed China. Syed Sarwar Munir, a principal of a technical school, saw his son Asim arrive in an uprooted Punjabi-speaking household, which, fueled by memory, easily found identifiable enemies to the east and west, Afghan, Hindu and Sikh.
Jalandhar has given Pakistan another Chief of Army Staff, Gen Zia ul-Haq, the progenitor of politico-military jihad across both the Afghan and Indian borders. And like his fellow Doabi successor two generations later, Gen Zia also had a devout mosque going father.
Gen Zia was born in Jalandhar and opted for the Pakistan Army after the Partition of India, whereas Gen Munir carries his origins only in memory form, not on his birth certificate.
But the power of these memories are so intense that Gen Munir doesn't hesitate while telling Pakistani university students, 'When it comes to the safety and security of every single Pakistani, the whole of Afghanistan can be damned.' Afghanistan was the only country that opposed Pakistan's admission to the United Nations after independence, he said, adding that the problem is that 'our people do not read history'.
History, as Gen Munir's example shows, creates its own vault of memories. He has repeatedly enunciated the storehouse of his inherited memories, sparing none, in the east or west.
In the same carefully orchestrated interaction with students from public and private universities in Pakistan, Gen Munir revisited the idea of Pakistan based on the two-nation theory. Reminding them, 'If we want to adopt Western civilisation, then why did we get rid of Hindu civilisation?' he said.
These statements providing a clear insight into his frame of mind were made in public platforms more than a year before he said those gratin, oft-repeated sectarian remarks, which preceded the ghastly Pahalgam attack of 22 April 2025.
With half his tenure still to come, much can be expected from Gen Munir. Unlike some of his predecessors who rejected warlike words and even invited Indian journalists to Pakistan military formations, Gen Munir has been hawkish on the neighbourhood, and brutally dismissive about the calibre of politicians.
Given Pakistan's political processes and precedents, anything is possible between the government that selected him as Army Chief and his ambitions. For now, Gen Munir remains unfazed as he chases down his memories. He's clearly carrying plenty of baggage, so the ceasefire may well be a pause, unless enforced politically.
Manvendra Singh is a BJP leader, Editor-in-Chief of Defence & Security Alert and Chairman, Soldier Welfare Advisory Committee, Rajasthan. He is writing a book on the IPKF. He tweets @ManvendraJasol. Views are personal.
(Edited by Theres Sudeep)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
27 minutes ago
- Business Standard
Best of BS Opinion: Playing by instinct when the board is barely visible
It starts like a harmless game. Ludo on the floor, dice in hand, but the lights go out. You keep playing anyway, guessing your way forward, mistaking red for green, rolling sixes that don't save you, and sliding into traps you never saw coming. That's what global decision-making looks like currently: leaders and investors tossing dice in the dark, banking on instinct, memory, or bravado. No rulebook, no clarity. Just blind moves on a colourful board smeared by shadows. Let's dive in. Take Donald Trump's latest signal. He's willing to extend the July 9 trade deadline. But as our first editorial points out, that's not clarity, it's a dim torch in a fogged-up tent. Only the UK has reached a finalised deal. The US-China 'provisional' pact is laced with tariffs. Even the OECD's dim outlook shows that even with extended time on the clock, the players barely know where they're headed. Other nations, watching from the sidelines, now fear a post-deal spike in tariffs. The board's reset, but the fog remains. Meanwhile, silver is streaking ahead like a lucky pawn. With prices up 25 per cent this year after a 21 per cent jump in 2024, and Indian silver ETF assets surging 125 per cent, precious metals are gleaming in the dark. But as our second editorial cautions, even the brightest path can be a trap. The gold-silver ratio has crossed 90, far above its historic average, suggesting silver may be overvalued. Diversification, not dazzlement, is the safer move. T T Ram Mohan sees a more systemic risk hiding off the board. While everyone watches central banks, the real danger may be creeping through the Non-Bank Financial Institutions with hedge funds and private credit pools swelling with risk. US banks' exposure to these entities has tripled since 2010, and while post-2008 regulations offer some buffer, recent rollbacks of Basel III norms threaten to snap those threads. In a different arena of chaos, Ajay Kumar traces how information wars now run on stories, not stats. Operation Sindoor proves that falsehoods told with emotion sprint ahead of truth wrapped in spreadsheets. Misinformation thrives in echo chambers, while official fact-checkers, constrained by dull 'true/false' binaries, fall behind. In a game where the loudest lie wins, truth must learn to shout back in verse, not bullet points. And Neha Kirpal brings us a review of R.D. Karve: The Champion of Individual Liberty by Anant Deshmukh, a story of someone who rolled the dice when no one else dared. Karve was a sexologist, reformer, and rebel who talked about birth control and autonomy in 1920s India. His nudity-laced magazine Samaj Swasthya fought shame with science, facing bans and trials. Karve was ridiculed, but never silenced. Stay tuned!
New Indian Express
an hour ago
- New Indian Express
700 structures damaged in Pakistan shelling in Uri, Karnah
SRINAGAR: The local administration has proposed construction of 5,200 underground bunkers in Uri and Karnah sectors in north Kashmir for safety of border residents, living under the threat of cross-border mortar and artillery fire by Pakistan. As per officials, construction will begin immediately after government approval. These two regions bore the brunt of Pakistan shelling during and in the aftermath of Operation Sindoor last month. Over 700 houses and structures suffered damage. Over 60 structures, including people's homes, were razed, while four schools were partially damaged. An official said the local administration has proposed to the J&K government to establish 4,000 underground bunkers in Uri region. 'We have proposed 3,500 individual bunkers, which can accommodate 10-120 people and 500 community bunkers that can accommodate 30-40 persons at a time,' the official said. In Karnah Valley of Kupwara district, administration has proposed setting up over 1,600 bunkers for border residents in 47 villages. 'We convened panchayats and held interaction with the locals. We discussed the number of bunkers required. Based on their feedback, we have suggested construction of about 1,200 bunkers (including 1,050 individual bunkers and 151 community bunkers) in Karnah for border residents,' the official said.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
No one's forgotten Pakistan sheltered Osama: India after US' Pakistan praise
Representative image NEW DELHI: As American authorities laud Pakistan's counterterrorism efforts, India said Thursday that no one has forgotten that Pakistan gave shelter to Osama Bin laden and its role in the Mumbai attacks. Government also reminded the US that the man who helped locate Osama Bin Laden is still in a Pakistan jail. "The record of what Pakistan actually is, is very clear. We all know the Pahalagam attack is only the most recent example of cross-border terrorism. I would remind you that only recently the conspirator of 26/11 Tahawwur Rana was extradited from the US," said MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal. Rana had helped key conspirator David Headley plot the Mumbai attacks (26/11) in 2008 and was recently extradited by the US to India. "Obviously, none of us have forgotten that Pakistan gave shelter to Osama Bin Laden. It is significant that the person - Dr Shakil Afridi - who helped locate Osama bin Laden is still imprisoned by the Pakistani military," he added. The official was responding to questions about US Central Command (CENTCOM) commander General Michael Kurilla remark that Pakistan was a "phenomenal partner in the world of counterterrorism". Kurilla also said the United States has to have a relationship with Pakistan and with India, and noted that it cannot be a "binary switch" where Washington cannot have ties with Islamabad if it has relations with New Delhi.
