Mary Poppins is the most complained about film of 2024 over controversial slur
In rather surprising news, given the Disney family film's release in 1964, it still managed to attract ire and comment 60 years later.
The popular musical starring screen legends Dame Julie Andrews as Mary and Dick Van Dyke as chimney sweep Bert respectively, has long been a childhood favourite and rated U (Universal) by the the British Board of Film Classification.
Decades later, it was followed up by 2018 sequel Mary Poppins Returns, starring Emily Blunt, Lin-Manuel Miranda, Ben Whishaw and Emily Mortimer – as well as a delightful cameo return from Van Dyke.
However, last year the organisation adjusted the rating of the original Mary Poppins, reclassifying it as a PG (Parental Guidance) and moving one step away from the suggestion that it was suitable for all audiences.
It is this decision which sparked backlash, with the BBFC revealing in its annual report that of the 224 complaints it received in 2024, 56 of them were about Mary Poppins' reclassification.
The BBFC had adjusted the movie's rating due to the use of the term 'Hottentots', which it classified as discriminatory language.
Admiral Boom, portrayed by Reginald Owen, uses the word twice throughout the film, which was a Dutch racially loaded term, originally used in the 17th century by white Europeans to describe the Khoikhoi, a nomadic indigenous population of South Africa.
Thought to be one of the oldest people in the world, the Khoikhoi were driven off their land by white colonial expansion.
As the Dutch took over land for farms, the Khoikhoi were dispossessed, killed, or enslaved. Those who chose to remain ended up as farm labourers for the invading settlers.
At one stage, Admiral Boom dangles from the roof in a boat and asks if one of the Banks children is off to 'fight' them.
Later in the film, he also uses the term to describe the chimney sweeps, with their faces blackened by soot, and says they're being 'attacked' by them.
The BBFC report, which also shared that Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace is now a PG, also revealed that the complaints were requesting the classification remain unchanged because, although offensive, it is now considered outdated and the same term has also appeared in
other films.
However, the report argued: 'The two uses of the discriminatory term 'hottentots' are neither criticised nor condemned, increasing the risk that very young viewers might repeat it without realising the potential for offence.'
It added: 'Regular research tells us that a key concern for parents is the potential for children to be exposed to discriminatory language or behaviour which they may find distressing or repeat without realising the potential offence.'
Others hit back at the decision when Mary Poppins' new classification became public knowledge in February 2024, calling it 'plain ridiculous' and 'strange'.
Defending its decision at the time, a BBFC spokesperson told Metro: 'While Mary Poppins has a historical context, the use of discriminatory language is not condemned, and ultimately exceeds our guidelines for acceptable language at U. We therefore classified the film PG for discriminatory language.
'For context, we only review (and potentially reclassify) previously classified content when it's been formally resubmitted to us.'
Elsewhere, James Cameron's sci-fi thriller The Abyss received the second largest number of complaints, at 17, following a rumour that a new 4K cinema release had been cancelled owing to concerns over a scene in which a live rat is submerged in liquid. More Trending
The BBFC clarified that it had had concerns when the film was originally submitted in 1989 that the scene constituted the 'cruel infliction of terror' on an animal and therefore contravened the Cinematograph Films (Animals) Act 1937.
It confirmed the organisation's stance had not changed and that the scene had been re-edited in all versions of the film classified by the BBFC since then.
Other films' ratings which drew formal complaints included that of Dune: Part Two due to its knife fight between Timothée Chalamet and Austin Butler's characters, and Saltburn, with people arguing its 'depiction of sexual obsession was too disturbing for [a rating of] 15′.
Got a story?
If you've got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the Metro.co.uk entertainment team by emailing us celebtips@metro.co.uk, calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we'd love to hear from you.
MORE: Iconic star, 99, sparks concern after dropping out of event due to illness
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
2 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Inside the real-life town that Disneyland Paris built – with Italian-copycat homes and no rubbish on the streets
Plus, the Center Parcs village in the town that is undergoing an expansion PARK UP Inside the real-life town that Disneyland Paris built – with Italian-copycat homes and no rubbish on the streets Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) LOVE Disneyland Paris so much you could live there? That's not actually impossible… Because the much-loved European theme park has built its own town called Val D'Europe - which is only a six-minute drive from the theme park. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 8 The second half of Disneyland Paris' town is now being developed Credit: Disney 8 The town which is called Val d'Europe will eventually home up to 80,000 people Credit: Getty 8 There is lots to do in the town itself including two shopping centres Credit: Alamy Just like any normal town, there are thousands of homes, offices, restaurants, schools, supermarkets and even a hospital. Essentially, it has everything you'd ever need... just with a world-class theme park on the doorstep. It all started back in 1987, when Disney started to build Euro Disney, which is now known as Disneyland Paris. Working with the French Government, the park was sold the surrounding land and it soon began to build its own town for people to live in. Today, more than 50,000 people have set up home in the town, with houses selling from €250,000 (£215,521) to €465,000 (£400,869). Many of the houses and buildings town were inspired by both Regent's Park in London and Tuscany in Italy, according to The Times. Frank Hetherton, one of Disney's leading architects, admitted: "We did borrow from there. It's an authentic style." As the town rose from the ground, Disney had grand ambitions for it, like a job for every resident. They're big on cleanliness to, with visitors claiming they never see any Ideals rubbish or graffiti on the streets. And locals are overwhelmingly satisfied with the town, scoring 90 percent on happiness with their surroundings in previous surveys among residents. Disney Music Festival If you are a Disney mega fan, you definitely won't want to miss exploring the town as it is home to many Disney-themed locations. Elsewhere in Val d'Europe you can explore a large shopping centre with lots of French brands but household favourites too like H&M. Just nine-minutes walking from the shopping centre is one of the many hotels in the town - the Relais Spa Val d'Europe. Inside guests can enjoy a serene spa, with an indoor pool, hot tub, sauna and steam room, and stay costs from £135 per night. Or you could opt to stay at the Grand Magic Hotel, which is sat next to a park overlooking a pond. The fantasy-themed hotel even has it's own character named Monsieur Maurice who looks after all the hotel has to offer including flamboyant interiors, a Grand Hall and immersive animations. Back into the town, there is also La Vallée Village, which is home to different outlet stores offering designer items at discounted prices. The destination is owned by the same company as Bicester Village found in Oxford, UK and at La Vallée visitors will find similar brands, as well as more local designers. 8 The first half of the town has already been completed with shops, hotels and other amenities Credit: Disney 8 It also has some historic spots including Château de Chessy Credit: Alamy For a little history hunting, you can head to Château de Chessy, where you will find a pretty castle in the middle of an expansive park with a lake. And if you are looking or a bite to eat, you won't be short of options. You could head to the classic french spot, Le Diplomate Cafe and Bar, which has a range of cocktails, organic wine and champagne. Dishes include grilled aubergine and beef tartare. Alternatively, head to Wonderwoods Restauran, which features a fun interior that looks more like an enchanted woodland. The immersive restaurant features fairy creatures, mushrooms and woodland paths. You could experience snails or opt for a classic truffle pasta, or even treat yourself to afternoon tea. 8 The second half of the development will add 1,800 hotel rooms by 2040 Credit: Disney The entire town is split into six communes, each with different places, attractions and spots to eat worth exploring including multiple green spaces and bicycle paths. For those living there, it has been designed so that everything they could ever need is within a 10-15minute walk. And across the entire development there are no high rises, as it was designed to be a very liveable community that wasn't overdeveloped. That isn't the end either, as over the next 15 years Val d'Europe will double in size. By 2040, there will be even more shops, restaurant and 1,800 more hotel rooms. And by then, 80,000 people are expected to live there thanks to over 6,000 new homes, 1,880 new residences and more office spaces. Philippe Descrouet, mayor of Serris and president of Val d'Europe Agglomeration told Envie de Villes: "We are only halfway through the development of this new city. "The first part of the story, written over the past 35 years, has been a success. 8 Throughout Val d'Europe, there is a 'neo-traditional' design Credit: Disney "The second part will bring us to 100,000 inhabitants and the development of 350,000m² of office space as well as 300,000m² of additional activities." Nearby, Center Parcs' Villages Nature site is also undergoing development which is expected to be completed by 2037. Visitors will be able to enjoy 170 new holiday homes, making there a total of 1,100 at the site. Closer to 2037, there will also be 1,500 more places to stay in the park, leading to 3,000 in total by 2037. Eventually, the village will have new restaurants, shops and leisure activities too. A Sun reporter also recently went behind the scenes of Disneyland Paris' huge park expansion – with a new Frozen land and first ever Lion King ride. Plus, the ground-breaking new Disneyland Paris show that makes you feel like you're inside a Disney movie.
The Sun
2 hours ago
- The Sun
Inside the real-life town that Disneyland Paris built – with Italian-copycat homes and no rubbish on the streets
LOVE Disneyland Paris so much you could live there? That's not actually impossible… Because the much-loved European theme park has built its own town called Val D'Europe - which is only a six-minute drive from the theme park. 8 8 8 Just like any normal town, there are thousands of homes, offices, restaurants, schools, supermarkets and even a hospital. Essentially, it has everything you'd ever need... just with a world-class theme park on the doorstep. It all started back in 1987, when Disney started to build Euro Disney, which is now known as Disneyland Paris. Working with the French Government, the park was sold the surrounding land and it soon began to build its own town for people to live in. Today, more than 50,000 people have set up home in the town, with houses selling from €250,000 (£215,521) to €465,000 (£400,869). Many of the houses and buildings town were inspired by both Regent's Park in London and Tuscany in Italy, according to The Times. Frank Hetherton, one of Disney's leading architects, admitted: "We did borrow from there. It's an authentic style." As the town rose from the ground, Disney had grand ambitions for it, like a job for every resident. They're big on cleanliness to, with visitors claiming they never see any Ideals rubbish or graffiti on the streets. And locals are overwhelmingly satisfied with the town, scoring 90 percent on happiness with their surroundings in previous surveys among residents. If you are a Disney mega fan, you definitely won't want to miss exploring the town as it is home to many Disney-themed locations. Elsewhere in Val d'Europe you can explore a large shopping centre with lots of French brands but household favourites too like H&M. Just nine-minutes walking from the shopping centre is one of the many hotels in the town - the Relais Spa Val d'Europe. Inside guests can enjoy a serene spa, with an indoor pool, hot tub, sauna and steam room, and stay costs from £135 per night. Or you could opt to stay at the Grand Magic Hotel, which is sat next to a park overlooking a pond. The fantasy-themed hotel even has it's own character named Monsieur Maurice who looks after all the hotel has to offer including flamboyant interiors, a Grand Hall and immersive animations. Back into the town, there is also La Vallée Village, which is home to different outlet stores offering designer items at discounted prices. The destination is owned by the same company as Bicester Village found in Oxford, UK and at La Vallée visitors will find similar brands, as well as more local designers. 8 8 For a little history hunting, you can head to Château de Chessy, where you will find a pretty castle in the middle of an expansive park with a lake. And if you are looking or a bite to eat, you won't be short of options. You could head to the classic french spot, Le Diplomate Cafe and Bar, which has a range of cocktails, organic wine and champagne. Dishes include grilled aubergine and beef tartare. Alternatively, head to Wonderwoods Restauran, which features a fun interior that looks more like an enchanted woodland. The immersive restaurant features fairy creatures, mushrooms and woodland paths. You could experience snails or opt for a classic truffle pasta, or even treat yourself to afternoon tea. 8 The entire town is split into six communes, each with different places, attractions and spots to eat worth exploring including multiple green spaces and bicycle paths. For those living there, it has been designed so that everything they could ever need is within a 10-15minute walk. And across the entire development there are no high rises, as it was designed to be a very liveable community that wasn't overdeveloped. That isn't the end either, as over the next 15 years Val d'Europe will double in size. By 2040, there will be even more shops, restaurant and 1,800 more hotel rooms. And by then, 80,000 people are expected to live there thanks to over 6,000 new homes, 1,880 new residences and more office spaces. Philippe Descrouet, mayor of Serris and president of Val d'Europe Agglomeration told Envie de Villes:"We are only halfway through the development of this new city. "The first part of the story, written over the past 35 years, has been a success. 8 "The second part will bring us to 100,000 inhabitants and the development of 350,000m² of office space as well as 300,000m² of additional activities." Nearby, Center Parcs ' Villages Nature site is also undergoing development which is expected to be completed by 2037. Visitors will be able to enjoy 170 new holiday homes, making there a total of 1,100 at the site. Closer to 2037, there will also be 1,500 more places to stay in the park, leading to 3,000 in total by 2037. Eventually, the village will have new restaurants, shops and leisure activities too. A Sun reporter also recently went behind the scenes of Disneyland Paris' huge park expansion – with a new Frozen land and first ever Lion King ride. Plus, the ground-breaking new Disneyland Paris show that makes you feel like you're inside a Disney movie. 8
Scotsman
5 hours ago
- Scotsman
Bebe Cave: Christbride
Bebe Cave: Christbride | Bebe Cave The actor and comedian waxes lyrical about her love of medieval aesthetics and her fascination with visionary female Christian mystics, a passion which informs her new Fringe show Christbride. Sign up to our Arts and Culture newsletter, get the latest news and reviews from our specialist arts writers Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... I first became bewitched by the romantic ideals of medieval girlhood as a teenager, when I watched The Princess Bride. Or was it when I was a little girl entranced by Aurora and her magical colour-changing dress in Sleeping Beauty? In fact, it might just have been when I advertised a particularly fetching pastel pink princess corset top with long trailing sleeves on Instagram. My sources may be shallow, but my desire runs deep. Oh, to be a young maiden, blushing and blooming, living in a turreted tower at the top of an old stone castle, sighing constantly, weaving tapestries at a spinning wheel by day and dancing at banquets by night. No responsibilities apart from being beautiful and god-fearing and breedable. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad A time when we didn't have to wade through thirsty Instagram DMs from men who think it's the height of romance to describe you as 'quite fit'. No, men back then in the good old days would joust to prove their honour to you! And ride on a valiant steed in a shining suit of armour for weeks, through rainstorms, fighting off dragons, just to catch a glimpse of you on the balcony, their lust satisfied by a simple kiss on your lily-white hand. These scenes conjured in the dark recesses of my brain make me want to throw my phone into a lake, and grow my hair so long it flows past my waist and tangles in the straps of my backpack. Except I can't throw my phone in a lake because that would be mental - all my stuff's on there! And my hair doesn't grow past my shoulders anymore, I should never have started highlighting my hair at 21. And my boyfriend isn't a knight, he's a stand-up comedian with a podcast. Not ideal! My perception of the medieval age, like many other delusional young women, is a rose-tinted and inaccurate one. It stems from misremembered snippets of childhood Disney films, a vague longing to sit somewhere with stained glass windows, and Taylor swift running into the middle of a field to kiss that comically handsome man with an open shirt in the 2008 music video for Love Story. Okay, so my current hyperfixation is anachronistic and potentially unfeminist - sue me! But it's not just me buddy. Why is there a cultural obsession happening at the moment, both online and in the real world, with the middle ages? Every day my algorithm presents me with montages of medieval inspired folk music, literature, television and pop culture. A filtered version of the medieval revival movement first popularised in the 1960s (think prog rock and colourful tights). It's like my own personal magic mirror, an aspirational reflection of the persona I'm trying to create. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Chappell Roan cosplayed as a punky Joan of Arc at the VMAs, and runs around in a hennin (historical term for pointy princess hat) every chance she gets. The internet is chockablock full with medieval moodboards set to Golden Brown by The Stranglers, fashion trends are leaning towards the ethereal and whimsical, and everyone and their mum is reading some variant of erotic romantasy novel that involves being bedded by an elf king. My one-woman comedy show combines all of these interests of mine, but also attempts to pose a question: what would it have been like for a medieval girl who didn't want to follow the path of traditional romance? Christbride is the story of a teenage girl, Batilda Bigbum, who has aspirations of becoming a beloved patron saint, and escapes to live in a community of mystical nuns. At a time when marriage and motherhood were basically all that was expected of a young girl, to seek out a life of devotion, to become a mystic claiming you were on a conversational basis with God, was a hyper-independent and risky path to take. Very main-character energy. Jesus Christ might just be the perfect husband, he definitely doesn't leave his dirty socks on the floor (I've been told). Chappell Roan at the 2024 VMAs. | Getty Images for MTV I have been fascinated by the stories and lives of many medieval female Christian mystics like Margery Kempe, Catherine of Siena, and Julian of Norwich, all of whom broke convention, carved out autonomous lives for themselves, and lived fearlessly as visionaries. They were determined to seek out answers from the unknown, even if it cost them normal lives, steadfast in the belief of their ecstatic visions. I wish I believed in myself that much. Maybe that's why I've written this show. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Though their world looked very different to the one we live in now, their spirit echoes through the centuries between us. They had the souls of storytellers, and I wanted to let their inspirational lives inspire me to make some live comedy. Visionary women passing on the baton. My own revelation! I hope they would be proud/not offended. Something about their choice to lead lives of harsh asceticism, and never compromise their own fantastical inner worlds, makes me think they would have thrived at the Edinburgh Fringe. Options were very limited for women back then, and I certainly feel lucky I have access to antibiotics and Netflix, but maybe my mystical daydreams have been stemming from a bit of jealousy. Maybe this medieval cultural interest comes as a response to our overstimulation. We have too many options, and screens, and debit cards and so we romanticise a simpler way of life. The grass is always greener! I love the vibrancy, whimsy and fantasy of the mid-century medieval revival culture, my current playlist is simply dripping in paisley and velvet (Gaudete by Steeleye Span may be the best song in the world?). The mood was one of storytelling and artistic flourish. It was grounded in reality and social issues but also had an element of the fantastical, with a lot of imagery around fairytales. I think the renewed interest partly stems from a sense of perceived innocence in this type of media: the music is played with real, often wooden instruments and sung with raw voices unaltered by studio equipment and synthesisers, the clothes are often handmade and embroidered, everyone's hair flows freely and life seems merry. It is very much based on authenticity and most importantly, connection. To the real world, to romance, to nature. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad It's basically the polar opposite to the life young people live now, a world dictated by fast fashion, social media and overconsumption. Perhaps we are craving this aesthetic that reminds us of childhood storybooks, and the safety that comes from those memories. I don't think we want to live the actual historical past, I think we just want to revisit our past lives. So come see my show this Fringe for a dose of nostalgic whimsical escapism.
