Attorney for defendant in fatal OVI crash files motion to suppress blood evidence
In a motion filed Tuesday in Mahoning County Common Pleas Court on behalf of Walter Bolt, 65, of Struthers, attorney Rhys Cartwright-Jones said blood drawn from Bolt after the March 3 crash should be excluded from trial because it was not collected according to state law.
Cartwright-Jones also said the affidavit to get a warrant for the blood draw was not sufficient.
Bolt has been in the Mahoning County jail on $250,000 bond since his arrest after a grand jury indicted him on two counts of aggravated vehicular homicide, a second-degree felony; aggravated vehicular assault, a third-degree felony; and operating a motor vehicle while under the influence of alcohol, a first-degree misdemeanor.
He is accused of driving drunk on March 3 and causing a head-on crash that killed Angela Brown, 44, and her son, Jason Daff, 15, at state Route 170 and Unity Road in Springfield Township.
Another son of Brown's was injured in the crash and is presently recovering.
Bolt pleaded not guilty to the charges at his arraignment May 19. Court records list a July 9 pretrial hearing and July 14 trial before Judge R. Scott Krichbaum.
Troopers say his blood-alcohol content was .215, over the legal limit of 0.08. At a bond hearing last week before Judge R. Scott Krichbaum, Assistant Prosecutor Steve Maszczak said troopers and police also found several beer cans scattered throughout Bolt's car in the wake of the crash.
In his motion Tuesday, however, Cartwright-Jones said the affidavit written by state troopers from the Canfield Barracks of the Ohio State Highway Patrol requesting a blood draw did not say if those beer cans were open and did not provide a link between the cans and their suspicions that Bolt was drunk.
Although accident reports said Bolt appeared confused after the crash, Cartwright-Jones wrote in his motion that it would be reasonable for someone to appear confused following a head-on collision.
'The warrant application relied heavily on the presence of beer cans and a generalized claim of impairment without confirming the condition of the containers or establishing a clear nexus between any alleged alcohol abuse and the crash,' Cartwright-Jones wrote.
Cartwright-Jones also wrote that the way Bolt's blood was drawn goes against state law because medical records fail to identify who took the blood when Bolt was being treated at St. Elizabeth Health Center or the qualifications of the person who drew the blood.
Also, the state has failed to provide a 'chain of custody' for how the blood got to the state crime lab, or a documented chain of people who had the blood from the time it was taken until the time it got to the lab.
'Really, no one can say how the blood got to the state lab, let alone who took it, let alone whether anyone took the sample in an Administrative Code-compliant way,' Cartwright-Jones wrote.
Prosecutors have yet to file a response.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
All eyes are on upcoming special election
U.S. Rep. Elise Stefanik, R-Schuylerville, has taken an interest in the upcoming special election for the state Assembly seat that will be vacant when Assemblyman Billy Jones, D-Chateauguay, resigns at the end of the month. 'Mark my word. Republicans will run and win the NY Assembly special election in the North Country. Voters will flip this seat,' Stefanik posted on Facebook on July 31, two days after Jones announced his pending resignation. 'Wishful thinking,' countered Lynne Boecher of Queensbury, a National Democratic Committee member, in a telephone interview Thursday. 'The majority of the voters in those counties have overwhelmingly supported Billy Jones. I'm sure that they will continue with an independent-minded voting pattern.' Jones is resigning to become vice president of strategic initiatives and workforce development for Clinton County Community College. It is generally expected that the special election will be held in conjunction with the Nov. 4 general election, in order to avoid the expense of a separate local election. Once Jones' resignation is official at the end of August, the governor must call a special election within 90 days. There will be no primary. Party chairs in the three counties will select respective nominees based on a weighted voting system. The concentrated race is expected to be spirited. 'You're looking at six weeks — maybe,' said Essex County Democratic Chairwoman Margaret Bartley. 'So that's pretty crazy if you're a candidate.' Prior to Jones' election in 2016, the local Assembly District had been consistently represented by Republicans at least since the early 1980s. In the balance of power, a Republican win would have virtually no significance in the Assembly, where Democrats outnumber Republicans 103-47. A GOP win could add momentum in Stefanik's likely run for governor in 2026. If Stefanik takes an active public role in the local Assembly special election, it also could offer a glimpse of how popular she remains in the area. In recent weeks, Stefanik has repeatedly said her priority, for now, is on boosting candidates in this year's local and county elections, and state legislative special elections. She has said she will announce a decision on the governor's race after the November general election. Late Thursday afternoon, Stefanik announced via a news release she was endorsing Malone Mayor Andrea Dumas for the 115th Assembly District seat. As of press time Thursday night, there were no candidates besides Michael Cashman who officially announced they were running for the seat. In June, Stefanik established Save New York, a state political action committee to support Republican candidates in local, county and state races. In June and the first nine days of July, its initial weeks of operation, the PAC raised $260,214, with contributions ranging from a few cents to $5,000 each, coming from 34 states and the District of Columbia, according to a semi-annual finance report filed July 15 with the state Board of Elections. Democrats have a slight enrollment advantage in the 115th District, with 34.1% of active enrollment, as of Feb. 20, the most recent statistics available from the state Board of Elections. There are 1,152 more active enrolled Democrats than Republicans. Republicans comprise 32.8% of active enrollment and independents 26.1%, with the rest enrolled in other political parties. Jones first won election to an open seat in 2016, receiving 52.7% of the vote. In his only other contested election, he received 64.9% of the vote in 2022. He ran unopposed for reelection in 2018, 2020 and 2024. Jones, a former corrections officer, drew heavily from correctional officers, which more commonly vote Republican, said former U. S. Rep. Bill Owens, D-Plattsburgh. Republicans are prepared to tie the Democratic candidate with Gov. Kathy Hochul, who remains controversial in the region after a wild cat correctional officer's strike earlier this year. 'I am confident this race will come down to the people of the North Country being given a choice between someone who shares their values or a rubber stamp for the worst Governor in America,' said Vince Casale, a Republican strategist from Cooperstown. Owens said tariffs and the drop in Canadian tourism may be prominent in the race. 'I think because you can tie it to the local economy that's something you can do, as long as you keep it in the local context,' he said. Jones has generally been considered a moderate, as was Republican Janet Duprey of Clinton County, his predecessor for a decade. Owens said he would not be surprised if state political parties play an active role in the race. 'It's fairly certain that the state parties will play in the game if the candidates are considered viable,' he said. 'I'm expecting they will get in the game.'
CBS News
2 days ago
- CBS News
Man shot and killed after standoff at Mercer County hotel, police say
A man was shot and killed after a standoff at a hotel in Mercer County on Thursday, Pennsylvania State Police said. Police said they went to the Park Inn by Radisson off Route 18 in Shenango Township on Thursday afternoon to serve a warrant to 45-year-old Tyrell Askerneese of Farrell, CBS affiliate WKBN reported. Troopers said Askerneese was armed and refused to surrender peacefully. The Mercer County Crisis Intervention Response Team was called to help and took over the scene after troopers tried multiple tactics over several hours but couldn't get Askerneese to surrender, the TV station said. The standoff ended about three hours later when Askerneese was shot and killed, WKBN reported. A woman staying at the hotel told the TV station that she wasn't allowed to leave until the incident was over. Pennsylvania State Police are investigating the shooting. No other information was immediately available. It was the second police shooting that troopers responded to on Thursday. Across the state in northeastern Pennsylvania, two troopers were shot and the suspect was killed after what Commissioner Col. Christopher Paris called an "ambush." Police said 61-year-old Carmine Faino shot and killed his neighbor, 57-year-old Lori Wasko, outside her home in Thompson Township, Susquehanna County, before police responded. Investigators said police shot and killed Faino, who was armed with a rifle and refused to comply. The two troopers shot, Joseph Perechinsky and William Jenkins, were flown to hospitals and are in stable condition. Paris said he had met with both and they were in good spirits.
Miami Herald
2 days ago
- Miami Herald
Atlanta man accused of scheming with Jackson exec to bilk millions faces conspiracy charge
A businessman accused of playing a key supporting role in an elaborate scheme to bilk millions of dollars from the fundraising arm of Jackson Health System faces a conspiracy charge on Tuesday in Miami federal court. Yergan Jones, who heads an audio visual company in Atlanta, is the latest person to be charged in the alleged conspiracy with Charmaine Gatlin, the former chief operating officer of Jackson Health Foundation, which raises money for Miami-Dade County's public hospital system. Authorities say Gatlin, 52, and Jones, 62, falsified invoices to make it look like Jones' business, American Sound Design, provided about $2 million in purported services for fundraising events that were paid for by Jackson Health Foundation. Jones and his company kept half of the Foundation's payments and kicked back the other $1 million to Gatlin — money that the former Weston resident spent on Louis Vuitton and Gucci handbags and other luxury goods, court records show. Jones' defense attorney, Hector Flores, declined to comment. The fact that Jones has been charged by an information and not a grand jury indictment indicates that he's cooperating with federal prosecutors and eventually plans to plead guilty to the single conspiracy charge, which carries up to five years in prison. Gatlin's defense lawyer, David Howard, also declined to comment. Gatlin pleaded not guilty to multiple conspiracy and fraud charges in June in Miami federal court. But sources familiar with her case say she's planning to change her plea to guilty in a deal with prosecutors in the U.S. Attorney's Office. Prosecutors say Jones, Gatlin and others schemed to 'unlawfully enrich themselves' by submitting 'false and fraudulent invoices' to the Jackson Health Foundation 'for goods and services that were not provided to the Foundation, did not benefit the Foundation, and benefitted themselves instead of the Foundation.' In one exchange, Gatlin contacted Jones from her personal email on Jan. 8, 2024, telling him to increase his bill for audiovisual equipment at Jackson's 'Holiday Parties' to $58,477, according to the information charging Jones. A week later, Gatlin wired that same amount to the bank account of Jones' company, ASD, the information says. That same day, Jones wired a kickback of about $25,000 to Gatilin's personal bank account — then, a few days later, Jones made a $20,000 payment on his American Express card using the Jackson funds. 'To conceal the kickbacks,' the information says, they 'created false invoices making it appear as though Gatlin did 'event management' for ASD events' at Jackson Health System or the Foundation. Atlanta Connection Before Jackson Health System officials learned of the alleged scheme, Gatlin was making about $300,000 as the Foundation's chief operating officer and was well on her way to becoming its top executive. But in late October, she was put on paid administrative leave while an internal investigation 'related to potential misconduct' got underway. In early November, she was 'terminated for cause' by the Foundation's chairman. Her termination letter, obtained by the Miami Herald, did not elaborate. Jackson officials alerted the FBI and federal prosecutors. In May, Gatlin, a Foundation executive over the past decade, was arrested on charges of fleecing $3.6 million from her former employer, fabricating fake invoices from vendors including Jones and receiving kickbacks from them. Her alleged defrauding of the Jackson Health Foundation, however, extended well beyond Miami, according to an indictment. It stretched all the way to Atlanta, where an unnamed 'audiovisual company' and a 'co-conspirator' suspected of collaborating with Gatlin submitted $2 million in 'false and fraudulent' invoices to the Foundation for purported services that were instead provided to a civic organization in Georgia's capital, the indictment says. While the indictment doesn't identify the company or the co-conspirator, the Herald learned last month from multiple sources that Gatlin allegedly schemed with Jones, the CEO of American Sound Design in Atlanta. Public records obtained by the Herald show Jones' company submitted dozens of invoices to the Jackson Health Foundation that Gatlin approved between 2019 and 2024. The indictment alleges the company's invoices were for 'audiovisual services that did not occur' at Jackson Health System or the Foundation. Instead, the Herald confirmed those services were provided by Jones' company to the civic organization in Atlanta, which is 100 Black Men of America, with chapters nationwide including South Florida. 'On at least one occasion, Jones provided services to [100 Black Men of America], but Jones and Gatlin made it appear on the invoice as though the services were being provided to the Foundation,' says the information charging Jones, which didn't include details of the charges. In a statement, the 100 Black Men of America said it was not aware of Gatlin's alleged kickback scheme with Jones and his audiovisual company, including billing the Jackson Health Foundation for services that his firm instead provided to the Atlanta organization. Jones provided those services to the youth mentoring group for its annual conferences between 2019 and 2024 under a different audiovisual company, American Electronic Entertainment, 100 Black Men of America confirmed. In fact, 100 Black Men of America said it directly paid Jones' company more than $500,000 for his work, but the organization did not provide details of the payments. '100 Black Men of America, Inc. has no knowledge of Ms. Gatlin's alleged receipt of cash payments or fraudulent invoices being submitted by Ms. Gatlin or any other vendors in the indictment involving Jackson Health Foundation,' the organization said in the statement provided to the Herald, adding that 'Gatlin has never been paid by the 100 BMOA as a 'go-between' to then pay vendors for services provided to 100 BMOA.' Gatlin had worked for 100 Black Men of America from 2009 to 2014 before Jackson's Foundation hired her a decade ago. During her tenure at Jackson, she continued to work with the Atlanta organization as an unpaid volunteer. After the Foundation dismissed Gatlin last November, 100 Black Men of America hired her in January as a contractor for its annual conference in 2025 —but fired her in May when the organization said it learned about her indictment. 'We are fully cooperating with law enforcement and will continue to do so until this matter is concluded,' the organization said. Follow the Money Gatlin, a University of Florida graduate with a bachelor's degree in French, was arrested on May 21 in a town near Savannah where she now lives. The indictment, filed by Assistant U.S. Attorney Elizabeth Young, charged her with a single count of conspiring with other individuals to commit wire fraud, 26 counts of wire fraud and five counts of money laundering. If convicted, the charges carry sentences that could send her to prison for years. Gatlin is accused of authorizing Jackson Health Foundation funds to pay not only Jones' audiovisual company in Atlanta but also a store that sold designer goods and an event planning company in South Florida that created videos, a website and other services for a family member's softball team in Broward County, the indictment says. She's also accused of using the Foundation's money to buy school supplies that were delivered to a church in Riceboro, Georgia, where she lives with her husband. After her arrest, Gatlin was granted a $30,000 bond. Court records show that one of the conditions of her bond was not to contact four contractors, including Jones, who 'were paid' by the Jackson Health Foundation based on 'purported invoices for goods and services approved by' Gatlin, according to the indictment. By far, Gatlin's dealings with Jones dominated her alleged criminal activity, the Herald has learned from sources and court records. Financial documents obtained by the Herald show that Jones' company, American Sound Design, submitted about 40 invoices to the Foundation that Gatlin approved between 2019 and 2024 for services that his firm says were provided to the Jackson Health Foundation. But Jones is better known as the president of AEE Productions, which on its website claims to have done business for major corporations, such as Coca-Cola, Delta Airlines and Walmart, along with NASCAR and 100 Black Men of America. The Jackson Health Foundation was also one of its clients, according to a testimonial by Gatlin. 'Working with AEE Productions is always an exciting time for me. They listen to my ideas and help me create 'the wow' that I am looking for during each event,' reads an online testimonial by Gatlin on AEE Productions' website. 'I have been working with Yergan and his team for over 15 years and each event is better than the last one. Financial records obtained by the Herald show the Jackson Health Foundation received millions of dollars worth of invoices ranging from $5,900 to $81,500 each from Jones' company. American Sound Design claimed in those bills that it provided lighting, sound, staging and production management services for events at Jackson Health System or the Foundation, the invoices show. But the Gatlin indictment says that Jones' company, though not identified by name, never provided any of these services. It's unclear from the indictment how many of these events hosted by the Foundation even took place.
