logo
£35bn! Chagos surrender deal 'will cost Britain ten times more than what the Prime Minister claimed'

£35bn! Chagos surrender deal 'will cost Britain ten times more than what the Prime Minister claimed'

Daily Mail​16 hours ago
The Chagos deal will cost ten times what Labour said it would – according to the Government's own figures, it was reported last night.
Official documents are said to show the UK will pay some £35billion to hand the islands over to Mauritius – compared to the £3.4billion previously stated by Sir Keir Starmer.
Dame Priti Patel, the Shadow Foreign Secretary, accused the Government of 'tricking' the public after the figures, seen by the Telegraph, were released under Freedom of Information laws.
She told the newspaper: 'Instead of owning up to the costs, Labour have used an accountancy trick to claim the amount was only a mere £3.4billion.
'We've all known it's a terrible deal with huge costs to hard-pressed British taxpayers. But for months, ministers in public and Parliament have sought to cover up the true amounts.'
Dame Priti is expected to demand a correction and apology over the 'cover-up' from the Prime Minister when MPs return from their summer break on September 1.
She said the cost was almost double the entire annual policing budget or could pay for ten brand new aircraft carriers, 70 hospitals or a 5 per cent income tax cut.
The deal for the British Indian Ocean Territory was branded a 'surrender' by the Conservatives, who have warned against giving up the islands which are also home to a US military base.
Under the terms of the controversial agreement, the UK will cede sovereignty of the islands by the end of this year and then lease back the Diego Garcia base.
Sir Keir previously claimed that this will cost £3.4billion over 99 years, but the Tories always argued it would be more like £30billion.
The Prime Minister told Parliament that estimates it would cost between £9billion and £18billion were 'absolutely wide of the mark' and suggested they were too high.
However, the official document, which was produced by the Government Actuary's Department, shows the cost of the deal was first estimated at £34.7billion.
The document shows civil servants were first instructed to lower the cost on paper to £10billion, to account for an estimated annual inflation rate of 2.3 per cent over 99 years, the Telegraph reported.
Foreign Office sources told the paper that ministers had used a 'standard' calculation for long-term government spending and denied accusations that it was part of a 'cover-up'.
MPs have previously requested the document in Parliament, but ministers have refused to release it.
A Government spokesman said: 'The Diego Garcia military base is essential to the security of the UK and our key allies, and to keeping British people safe. The average cost is £101million per year, and the net present value of payments is £3.4billion – this is less than 0.2 per cent of the annual defence budget.
'The deal is supported by our closest allies, including the US, Canada, Australia and Nato.
'The costs compare favourably with other international base agreements, and the UK-US base on Diego Garcia is larger, in a more strategic location and has unparalleled operational freedom.'
Last night a government source said the £35billion figure was 'inaccurate and misleading'.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Nicola Sturgeon's memoir Frankly goes on sale ahead of publication date
Nicola Sturgeon's memoir Frankly goes on sale ahead of publication date

The Independent

time9 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Nicola Sturgeon's memoir Frankly goes on sale ahead of publication date

Nicola Sturgeon's memoir, titled Frankly, has gone on sale in some branches of Waterstones – even though its publication date is listed as being later this week. The former first minister's autobiography was on shelves in at least two Glasgow branches of the retailer on Monday. Ms Sturgeon started working on the book in 2023, when publisher Pan Macmillan picked up the UK rights in a hotly-contested auction. She has previously said the book will be open and candid about her 'mistakes and heartbreaks' as well as her 'triumphs'. Ahead of the book's release, excerpts saw Ms Sturgeon describe self-doubt as her 'secret superpower'. She also said the police investigation in which both she and her husband were arrested was like 'mental torture'. The publication date for Frankly is Thursday August 14, but Waterstones said no sales embargo was in place. A statement from Waterstones said: 'The publication date does not necessarily equal an on-sale date unless the publisher puts an embargo in place. 'In the case of Nicola Sturgeon's memoir no sales embargo has been arranged, which means the book can go on sale as soon as it arrives in shops.'

UK taxpayers on hook as failed Cumbria coalmine investors sue government
UK taxpayers on hook as failed Cumbria coalmine investors sue government

The Guardian

time10 minutes ago

  • The Guardian

UK taxpayers on hook as failed Cumbria coalmine investors sue government

The UK government is being sued in a secretive 'corporate court' after a proposal for a new coalmine in Cumbria was quashed by the high court. If successful, UK taxpayers would have to fund a substantial compensation payment to the mine's investors. It is the first such case to be filed against the UK government by a fossil fuel company as a result of climate policy. The case uses investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) rules agreed in a 1975 trade agreement between the UK and Singapore, where the major investor in the coalmine is incorporated. The details of the claim have not been made public, but ISDS courts allow foreign investors to sue states when their activities are affected by government policies, such as green regulations. ISDS courts were described as 'unjust, undemocratic and dysfunctional' in a recent UN report. Experts have repeatedly warned that their use threatens efforts by countries to cut carbon emissions and fight the climate crisis. More than $100bn in public money has been awarded to corporations through ISDS courts. Fossil fuel companies have benefited most, receiving $80bn since 1998. The controversial proposed coalmine in Cumbria was blocked by the high court in September. The judge ruled it had been unlawful for the then Conservative government to accept a claim that the mine would be 'net zero' when granting planning permission. Labour ministers have since withdrawn government support for the mine. Cleodie Rickard, the trade campaign manager at the NGO Global Justice Now, said: 'We've been calling on the government to scrap ISDS in its trade deals for years, to stop exactly this eventuality: fossil fuel companies suing us over necessary climate action.' She added: 'These corporate courts mean that when governments or courts make the right decision, like halting the Cumbria coalmine, foreign corporations have the power to threaten the government in highly secretive processes. If they win, they get to pass their losses from obsolete projects on to the taxpayer.' The case has been filed by Woodhouse Investment Pte Ltd, a Singaporean company, and West Cumbria Mining (Holdings) Limited. Woodhouse Investment holds 80% of West Cumbria Mining and is itself owned by a firm in the Cayman Islands. The companies are being represented by the barrister and Conservative MP Geoffrey Cox and the law firm Withers. Sign up to Down to Earth The planet's most important stories. Get all the week's environment news - the good, the bad and the essential after newsletter promotion The most used ISDS agreement is the Energy Charter Treaty, which was initially intended to protect foreign investment in the former countries of the Soviet Union. The UK withdrew from the ECT in February 2024, saying it 'could penalise us for our world-leading efforts to deliver net zero'. A 'sunset clause' means investors may still use the ECT for up to 20 years. The government is also reported to want ISDS terms in a trade deal being negotiated with India. The oil company Exxon Mobil is using the ECT to sue the Dutch government for its decision to phase out gas exploration in Groningen, while the UK oil business Rockhopper was awarded $190m in a case it brought against the Italian government, though that has since been annulled. Chris Rowley, of the Cumbria-based charity South Lakes Action on Climate Change, said: 'We are very disappointed to see this attempt by West Cumbria Mining to sue the UK taxpayer after their proposed coalmine was refused an extraction licence and its planning application was quashed. We hope that the UK government will oppose this claim as strongly as they can.' West Cumbria Mining, Cox, Withers and the Department for Business and Trade have been contacted for comment.

Sheffield Council announces six-month recruitment freeze
Sheffield Council announces six-month recruitment freeze

BBC News

time10 minutes ago

  • BBC News

Sheffield Council announces six-month recruitment freeze

Sheffield Council is to freeze recruitment for six months as it grapples with a budget gap of more than £ authority said it would stop external and non-essential internal recruitment from 1 September to save £ non-essential spending - including travel, training and projects - would be tightly restricted and there would be a "prudent review" of reserves. Funding already earmarked could potentially be re-allocated, it Zahira Naz, chairman of the finance committee, said: "We are facing the same tough choices as councils across the country, but we are taking clear, co-ordinated action now to tackle these challenges." A council report said there had been "a persistent budget overspend that we need to tackle".Officers are aware that the findings from an equal pay review looking at 2,000 different job roles will be published next council has previously said it was confident any equal pay claims would not be on a scale serious enough to bankrupt the council, but similar pay reviews at other councils nationwide have led to multimillion-pound backdated pay-outs. 'Rigorous review' The recruitment freeze would contain immediate staffing costs and give the council time to reassess its workforce in the longer term, the budget report would need to deliver services with a lower budget "encouraging creative solutions and potential realignment of roles where appropriate".The council said its budget had been reduced over a number of years with continued pressures in adult social care, children's services and homelessness, driven by rising demand and ongoing cost adult social care, there would be a "radical review" of non-essential and discretionary spending to reduce special educational needs and disabilities, senior managers were having daily meetings "to drive down" the number of students transported by taxis from home to school, which currently stands at more than 1, would be a "rigorous review" of who is eligible for transport, routes and post-16 travel policy, the authority of disabled children can get direct payments so they have more control and flexibility over services, but there would be "detailed analysis to identify cost-saving opportunities".The report said: "Measures include scrutinising high-cost care packages and assessing the feasibility of in-house residential facilities to ensure value for money." Listen to highlights from South Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store