Businesses appeal for change to defamation laws
retail
and
hospitality
sectors have urged Minister for Justice
Jim O'Callaghan
to tackle 'vexatious defamation litigation being entertained' in the courts, saying they do not feel legally protected.
'The civil law system is actively conspiring to extort money from them in vexatious, unmeritorious litigation,' a letter to the Minister from
Neil McDonnell
, chief executive of the
Irish Small and Medium Enterprises Association
(Isme) said.
The correspondence, obtained under freedom-of-information legislation, followed a recent meeting between Mr McDonnell and Mr O'Callaghan during which current defamation reform was discussed.
The sector is specifically concerned about false claims against staff, including alleged shoplifting accusations.
READ MORE
Isme believes spurious defamation proceedings brought against small businesses are an issue comparable to fake personal injury claims, and often requiring less effort.
[
'They laugh at us': Dublin retailers voice fury at €10,000-plus payouts for defamation over shoplifting
Opens in new window
]
Isme has estimated the cost of defamation actions to small businesses to fall between €30 million and €50 million annually, based on data from a single security firm. It believes there are also many undocumented payouts.
As with other stakeholders, including the media, the business lobby hopes to affect change during the passage of current legislation that would improve its position in legal disputes.
Legal reform has long been called for and the programme for government committed to restoring the Defamation Bill and to 'make passing the legislation a priority'.
The association is seeking various changes, including the introduction of a 'harm test' and other gatekeeper mechanisms that would restrict or temper such claims. Citing official data, Isme noted that defamation cases in Ireland currently outnumber those of the UK which has a similar legal system.
'When Ireland has the same number of defamation cases as a jurisdiction with a population 12 times greater, there is an undeniable systemic problem,' the letter stated.
Mr McDonnell said the argument of a person's 'access to justice' was moot among those in hospitality and retail 'when those sectors identify both the criminal system as failing to protect them and the civil law system as actively conspiring to extort money from them in vexatious, unmeritorious litigation'.
Speaking to The Irish Times, Mr McDonnell said there were two types of theft in retail – actual theft and feigned theft where a person will attempt to look suspicious in order to attract an accusation.
'It's more attractive [than fraudulent personal injury] in many ways and the reason why is it's far faster,' Mr McDonnell said of the claims process.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Post
21 hours ago
- Irish Post
New hopes in identifying Sophie Toscan du Plantier's killer
GARDAÍ investigating the 1996 murder of French filmmaker Sophie Toscan du Plantier are awaiting new forensic analysis that could, for the first time, point definitively to her killer. The Garda Serious Crime Review Team has been working with Forensic Science Ireland (FSI) and US-based specialists M Vac Systems to re-test key exhibits from the near 30-year-old case. The M-Vac process, first developed in the early 1990s to detect bacteria, has since been adapted for use in criminal investigations. It sprays a sterile solution onto a surface while simultaneously vacuuming it back up, dislodging and collecting DNA material that may be trapped in rough or porous textures — surfaces where standard swabbing often fails. This summer, the technique was applied to items central to the murder scene, including a rock and a concrete block believed to have been used in the killing, as well as Ms Toscan du Plantier's clothing and footwear. Investigators hope that any viable DNA will allow comparisons with samples taken from suspects and other persons of interest during the original inquiry. Ms Toscan du Plantier, 39, was found dead outside her holiday home near Schull, Co Cork, on 23 December 1996. She had been beaten to death. Ian Bailey, an English journalist living locally, was twice arrested but never charged, and consistently denied involvement in the crimes. He died last year. A 2001 review by the Director of Public Prosecutions found no forensic evidence linking Bailey to the crime scene. The Irish Times reports that the gardaí say that all the exhibits have remained in Ireland during the review, despite reports suggesting they had been sent abroad for testing. They have declined to comment on whether the M-Vac process has produced a complete DNA profile, saying it is too early to draw conclusions, according to The Irish Times. The technology has been credited with solving long-unsolved murders in the United States, including cases from the 1970s and 1990s, where DNA was successfully recovered from items such as rocks and fabrics decades after the crimes. Death in West Cork ON DECEMBER 20, 1996, Sophie Toscan du Plantier embarked on a solo trip to her holiday home near Schull in West Cork. Three days later her beaten body was found outside her holiday. After several weeks of investigations without tangible results or leads, and despite no forensic or reliable witness evidence, Manchester-born Ian Bailey, a former journalist, came under suspicion. Bailey, who died in January 2204 of a suspected heart attack, always expressed his innocence, denying any knowledge of the crime. He never stood trial in Ireland. The Director of Public Prosecutions (in Ireland) ruled that insufficient evidence exists to convict. But a French court found him guilty of murder and in his absence — he refused to leave Ireland — sentenced him to 25 years in prison. What is the M-Vac system? THE M-Vac system is a specialist DNA collection tool developed in the early 1990s to detect bacterial contamination in the food industry. It has since been adapted for forensic use, particularly in cases where evidence may be embedded in rough or porous surfaces. The device works by spraying a sterile solution onto the surface while simultaneously vacuuming it back up. This action creates turbulence — loosening microscopic traces of biological material such as skin cells, blood, or saliva — which are then captured in the fluid. The collected solution is filtered and concentrated for DNA analysis. Because it can draw material from deep within textured surfaces, the M-Vac has been used successfully in historic and complex investigations where traditional swabbing techniques produced little or no result. Cases in the United States have seen the technology recover DNA from rocks, fabrics, and other difficult materials decades after crimes were committed. See More: Ian Bailey, Sophie Toscan Du Plantier, West Cork
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Downing Street warns against funding Palestine Action after Sally Rooney cash pledge
Normal People author Sally Rooney risks committing a terrorist offence if she funds banned organisation Palestine Action, Downing Street has warned. The award-winning author said she would donate her earnings from her books and BBC adaptations to support the group, which was recently proscribed as a terrorist organisation in the UK. [ Sally Rooney: I support Palestine Action. If this makes me a 'supporter of terror' under UK law, so be it ] Downing Street said 'support for a proscribed organisation is an offence under the Terrorism Act' and said no one should be backing the group. The Co Mayo native said that if backing Palestine Action 'makes me a 'supporter of terror' under UK law, so be it'. READ MORE Writing in The Irish Times at the weekend, Ms Rooney said she would use the proceeds of her work and her public platform to continue her support for Palestine Action and 'direct action against genocide in whatever way I can'. Palestine Action was recently proscribed under terrorism legislation in the UK, but not under Irish law. Ms Rooney lives in the west of Ireland. The BBC has broadcast adaptations of Ms Rooney's novels Normal People and Conversations With Friends in recent years. But she has never been on the broadcaster's staff. The PA news agency understands the corporation is not working with her on any upcoming projects. Dr Jilan Wahba Abdalmajid, the ambassador of the state of Palestine in Ireland, said on Monday: 'Sally Rooney is using her voice to call out international law and human rights violations in Palestine. 'I hope these calls result in practical actions that will stop the horrors we're witnessing carried out by Israel in Palestine; to stop the genocide and forced displacement and end the Israeli occupation.' In Westminster British prime minister Keir Starmer's official spokesman would not specifically address the author's comments, but said: 'There is a difference between showing support for a proscribed organisation, which is an offence under the Terrorism Act, and legitimate protest in support of a cause.' Asked what message Downing Street would give to people considering giving money to the group, the spokesman said: 'Support for a proscribed organisation is an offence under the Terrorism Act and obviously the police will, as they have set out, they will obviously implement the law within the law as you'd expect.' The spokesman said Palestine Action was proscribed 'based on security advice following serious attacks the group has committed, following an assessment made by the [UK's] Joint Terrorism Analysis Centre'. In a statement, a BBC spokesperson said: 'Matters relating to proscribed organisations are for the relevant authorities.'
Irish Daily Mirror
a day ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Tony Holohan drops out of presidential race to shield family from 'abuse'
Former Chief Medical Officer Tony Holohan has said he will not be seeking a nomination to run in the presidential election later this year, citing a desire to protect his family from 'personal abuse'. Dr Holohan had recently indicated that he was considering a run for the Áras after his supporters used polling company Amárach Research to explore his viability as a candidate. Participants in a survey were asked to rank their preferred choice for president out of five names listed. Some 15 per cent of respondents said Dr Holohan would be their first choice, according to the poll published in The Irish Times. In response, Dr Holohan said the results are "encouraging" and that if he decided to put himself forward he is confident he can put a campaign "in place quickly". Dr Tony Holohan (Image: PA Archive/PA Images) However, the former chief medical officer has now said he will not be throwing his hat in the ring in the race for the Áras due to the 'distress, criticism or abuse' it could subject his family to. In a statement to The Irish Times, Dr Holohan said that having spent a considerable amount time weighing up whether to pursue a bid for the Irish presidency, he has decided he would not contest the election. "While a number of different factors have influenced my decision, my overriding consideration has been my wish to protect my family from the kind of personal abuse which is becoming increasingly normalised in Irish politics generally and in presidential elections in particular," he said. "I understand the very tough nature of modern politics and, while I am more than capable of defending my reputation and the decisions which I have taken over a long career during challenging times in public service, my family is not. "I cannot now expose them to further distress, criticism or abuse at a time when we are all still rebuilding our lives." Meanwhile, Fine Gael TD Heather Humphreys is emerging as the frontrunner to be the party's nominee in the presidential election. Fine Gael TD Heather Humphreys speaking outside Largy College in Clones, Co. Monaghan. Two teenage girls who attended the school were killed and three people are in hospital after a road traffic collision on the N54 Clones to Smithborough road at Legnakelly at around 6.45pm on Monday. Issue date: Tuesday August 1, 2023. Last week it was announced that the party's candidate Mairead McGuinness – who had been signalled as a favourite to win – had to drop out on health grounds. Ms Humphreys, emerged as the favourite to replace former MEP, after she revealed that she is "giving a run very serious consideration". "I'm using my time to speak to the people I trust and the people who know me best, both inside and outside politics, before I make a final decision,' she said in a statement to the Sunday Independent. However, MEP Sean Kelly has also expressed interest in contesting. Speaking in Brussels in June, the former GAA President said he was considering it- but later decided not to put his name in the hat. But after Ms McGuinness withdrew, the MEP said he was again weighing up his options. Fine Gael's executive council will meet on Monday night to discuss the next steps after the former EU Commissioner withdrew. Independent candidate Catherine Connolly is currently the only confirmed candidate for the Áras race. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
