Businesses appeal for change to defamation laws
The
retail
and
hospitality
sectors have urged Minister for Justice
Jim O'Callaghan
to tackle 'vexatious defamation litigation being entertained' in the courts, saying they do not feel legally protected.
'The civil law system is actively conspiring to extort money from them in vexatious, unmeritorious litigation,' a letter to the Minister from
Neil McDonnell
, chief executive of the
Irish Small and Medium Enterprises Association
(Isme) said.
The correspondence, obtained under freedom-of-information legislation, followed a recent meeting between Mr McDonnell and Mr O'Callaghan during which current defamation reform was discussed.
The sector is specifically concerned about false claims against staff, including alleged shoplifting accusations.
READ MORE
Isme believes spurious defamation proceedings brought against small businesses are an issue comparable to fake personal injury claims, and often requiring less effort.
[
'They laugh at us': Dublin retailers voice fury at €10,000-plus payouts for defamation over shoplifting
Opens in new window
]
Isme has estimated the cost of defamation actions to small businesses to fall between €30 million and €50 million annually, based on data from a single security firm. It believes there are also many undocumented payouts.
As with other stakeholders, including the media, the business lobby hopes to affect change during the passage of current legislation that would improve its position in legal disputes.
Legal reform has long been called for and the programme for government committed to restoring the Defamation Bill and to 'make passing the legislation a priority'.
The association is seeking various changes, including the introduction of a 'harm test' and other gatekeeper mechanisms that would restrict or temper such claims. Citing official data, Isme noted that defamation cases in Ireland currently outnumber those of the UK which has a similar legal system.
'When Ireland has the same number of defamation cases as a jurisdiction with a population 12 times greater, there is an undeniable systemic problem,' the letter stated.
Mr McDonnell said the argument of a person's 'access to justice' was moot among those in hospitality and retail 'when those sectors identify both the criminal system as failing to protect them and the civil law system as actively conspiring to extort money from them in vexatious, unmeritorious litigation'.
Speaking to The Irish Times, Mr McDonnell said there were two types of theft in retail – actual theft and feigned theft where a person will attempt to look suspicious in order to attract an accusation.
'It's more attractive [than fraudulent personal injury] in many ways and the reason why is it's far faster,' Mr McDonnell said of the claims process.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
3 days ago
- Sunday World
Fed-up former gardaí reveal number one reason for leaving the force
Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan confirmed the feedback came from 39 voluntary exit interviews The woman attempted to bite a number of gardaí during the incident on Park Street. Fed-up former gardai have revealed in exit interviews their number one reason for leaving the force - they can't manage family life while pursuing a career as a cop. The revelation was made by the Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan as he released data from ex-members as to why they resigned. The two other issues have emerged: commuting and the distance between home and their assigned Garda station. The Minister confirmed the feedback came from 39 voluntary exit interviews carried out in 2024 and 60 by the end of April this year with former Garda and Garda staff members leaving. The woman attempted to bite a number of gardaí during the incident on Park Street. News in 90 Seconds - May 31st Mr O'Callaghan said, 'In 2024, 39 voluntary exit interviews were conducted among sworn Garda and Garda staff. As this is a very small sample, it is difficult to draw any firm conclusions . 'But among the issues cited by people who participated was that they found it difficult to maintain their career as a Garda while also managing their family life. "Commuting and the distance between home and the station was also a concern. 'In 2025 an exit survey was introduced to further extend the sample reached. Up to the end of April there were 60 responses. 'This survey will increase the capacity of the organisation to collate, analyse and act upon the data gathered from colleagues who have chosen to resign. 'These are still small samples but the objective is that over time it will help develop better understanding of these issues and in turn allow further adjustments where possible. 'I am aware for example that Garda management seek to locate new recruits within a reasonable commuting distance of their homes but this is not always possible to achieve in every case.' The Minister was responding to a Dail question from the Sinn Fein TD Matt Carthy. Mr O'Callaghan claimed the current rate of Garda resignations between 1-2 per cent is very low. He said this turnover rate is far below the UK level of 10 per cent, and the rest of the public sector in Ireland which is 10-20 per cent. The Minister also said resignations within the police in the United States, Canada and New Zealand are much higher than in Ireland. More than 280 gardaí have left the force within five years of joining since 2020 - 214 were male and 73 were female.
RTÉ News
4 days ago
- RTÉ News
Data protection watchdog moves to new Dublin headquarters
The Data Protection Commission (DPC) has moved to new headquarters in Dublin. The building project was commenced by the Office of Public Works in May 2023, and has brought together all of the DPC's Dublin-based staff into one office. The DPC said its new headquarters provides staff with a greatly improved, modern and collaborative work environment that will support the work it does both in Ireland and across the EU. Since the introduction of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in May 2018, the DPC has imposed fines of more than €4 billion on big tech firms. Just €20 million of that has been paid, as most of the rulings are under appeal. In May 2023, the DPC imposed a record fine of €1.2bn on Meta for breaches relating to the transfer of personal data from the EU to the US. Earlier this month, the DPC fined video-sharing platform TikTok €530 million over the transfer of the personal data of European users to China. The DPC's new headquarters was officially opened today at an event attended by the Taoiseach Micheál Martin and Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan. "As the DPC continues to play a leading role in European data protection, this new home will help us meet that responsibility with confidence and ambition," said Data Protection Commissioner Dr Des Hogan. His fellow Commissioner Dale Sunderland added that the new building is a reflection of how far the DPC has grown and developed as an organisation. "A decade ago, we were fewer than 50 people. Now, we're 275 strong and continuing to grow," Mr Sunderland said.
Dublin Live
5 days ago
- Dublin Live
Dublin Rape Crisis Centre receive 'hugely concerning' record number of calls
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info Calls to the Dublin Rape Crisis Centre reached a record high last year, the organisation has revealed. The almost 23,000 contacts made to the centre's helpline in 2024 represented the highest in the DRCC's 46-year history. The figures were contained in the organisation's annual report published on Thursday. Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan, who will launch the report in Dublin on Thursday morning, said the figures were 'hugely concerning'. He said: 'Sexual violence is a crime that has historically been under-reported and this is something I am committed to addressing, and something that is changing as complainants become more confident in our justice system. 'Many of the figures and statistics in this latest report from Dublin Rape Crisis Centre are hugely concerning but I am encouraged that a significant percentage of those who seek support from DRCC also report to An Garda Siochana.' Mr O'Callaghan commended the 'excellent work and unwavering commitment' of the centre. Chief executive of DRCC Rachel Morrogh said contacts with the helpline broke the 20,000 mark for the first time in 2024, reaching a total of 22,700. She said: 'In fact, engagement with the National Helpline increased by over 20% from 2023, bringing the number of contacts to almost 23,000. There are likely a number of drivers behind the increased demand for our 24-hour listening service, including that survivors feel increasingly confident about where to find non-judgmental support, but also the reality that sexual violence is still an insidious and common occurrence in modern Ireland. 'Although we are encouraged by the marked rise in the number of survivors contacting us, we know that this is a fraction of the thousands of people living with trauma who have not yet sought support. Our message to them today is that they are not invisible to us, that they deserve support, and that when they feel ready to talk, we are ready to listen.' Ms Morrogh said the sharpest increase in activity across the organisation's frontline supports was reported by its therapy service. She said: 'Dublin Rape Crisis Centre's counsellors held almost 6,000 counselling sessions with survivors, an increase of 57% compared to 2023. 'Specialised counselling unlocks healing for many survivors of sexual violence and we are proud to have supported 637 women and men last year. The number of therapy clients increased by 28%, or 140 people. While many people choose not to make a report to An Garda Siochana about what happened to them, Dublin Rape Crisis Centre therapy clients do so at much higher rates than the national average. "The Central Statistics Office has reported that tiny numbers of people who have experienced sexual violence in their lifetime have reported it to the Gardai. There are many reasons for this, ranging from a fear of not being believed or thinking they are in some way to blame or that what happened was not serious enough. Amongst our new therapy clients last year however, the reporting rate was 27%. 'We are honoured to support our clients through the justice system, which can be a very difficult process for many. Every time there is a conviction and sentence for a sexual offence, we know it is felt as a victory for those who will never have their day in court or have the validation and catharsis of a guilty verdict.' The 24-hour National Rape Crisis Helpline is available on 1800 778888 Join our Dublin Live breaking news service on WhatsApp. Click this link to receive your daily dose of Dublin Live content. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. For all the latest news from Dublin and surrounding areas visit our homepage.
