‘Tháinig ár lá': Lawyers agree €100,000 damages award is undeniable win for Gerry Adams and republicanism generally
Gerry Adams
is in the 'medium range' for awards for defamation.
Very moderate defamations, Mr Justice Alexander Owens had told the jury, should get awards of up to €50,000, medium range defamations €50,000 to €125,000, serious defamations €125,000 to €200,000, and 'truly exceptional' defamations, €200,000 to €300,000.
Given that Adams was alleged to have given the go-ahead for a man to be murdered, the award could be seen as a low one, two experienced lawyers, speaking off the record, observed in the wake of the verdict.
Nevertheless, it is an undeniable win for Adams and republicanism generally. 'Tháinig ár lá' [our day has come], muttered one legal figure as the court was emptying, referring to the republican catchphrase 'Tiocfaidh ár lá'.
READ MORE
The jury found the
BBC
Northern Ireland programme, Spotlight, defamed Adams in 2016 when it quoted an anonymous man saying Adams would have given the go-ahead for the 2006 murder of self-confessed republican informer, Denis Donaldson, and that Donaldson was killed by the
IRA
. The programme included a statement from Adams refuting the allegation.
In the witness box Adams pointed out that the IRA issued a statement in 2005 saying it had 'formally ordered an end to the armed campaign' and that all members were told to restrict themselves to 'exclusively peaceful' activities.
The Spotlight allegation, he said, meant that the IRA statement was all 'a cod'. As someone who had worked hard to bring about peace, this had damaged his name in the 'broad republican family'.
The jury found that the BBC was not entitled to a defence that the defamatory material was published in good faith or constituted fair and reasonable journalism.
The cost of the lengthy High Court trial, to be borne by the BBC, is likely to exceed €3 million.
The decision by Adams to take proceedings before a jury in Dublin rather than in Belfast was one of the many interesting features of the case. (It was open to Adams to take proceedings on both sides of the border). It is too late now for proceedings in Northern Ireland.
The programme had just 15,800 views on terrestrial TV in this jurisdiction, which may be a factor in the size of the award. The jury was told only to compensate damage to reputation in this jurisdiction.
Adams, in the witness box, accepted that politicians, journalists and others have repeatedly alleged he was a senior figure in the IRA and associated with overseeing many of its most heinous crimes.
His evidence was that he joined
Sinn Féin
as a young man and not the IRA. 'It wasn't a path I took, that was a decision by me, not to join the IRA, to join Sinn Féin,' he told the jury.
The BBC were arguing he had 'no reputation, that my reputation is useless,' he complained. Spotlight believed it could 'say whatever they like about me, and I can have no redress'.
The lawyers who spoke to The Irish Times were critical of the Spotlight programme.
Just because a person had a sullied reputation should not mean anything can be said about them. Under US law wild allegations can be published there about public figures without fear of being sued if the person's reaction to the allegation is also published, one observed. 'That's unfair.'
Mr Justice Owens, who made many observations during the five-week trial, at one stage remarked that reputations change and instanced that Ireland had a civil war after which the reputations of the participants changed over time. Adams, presumably, would have welcomed the analogy.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
29 minutes ago
- Irish Times
EU-US trade deal: Any future US tariffs on pharma exports to be limited to 15%, EU insists
The European Union is confident that any future US tariffs on its exports of pharmaceutical products would be limited to a 15 per cent rate, under the terms of the recent agreement, senior officials have said. The final terms of the deal were worked out during a meeting between European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen and US president Donald Trump at his Turnberry golf resort in Scotland on Sunday. The deal will lock in tariffs of 15 per cent on most EU imports to the US , but prevent the prospect of an economically devastating trade war. The US has been preparing to levy tariffs on the EU pharma industry, which Mr Trump previously threatened could be at cripplingly high rates of up to 200 per cent. READ MORE The industry has escaped any tariffs to date, but the Trump administration has been planning to hit the sector with specific levies. Ms von der Leyen, who negotiated the final part of the deal with Mr Trump, said the agreement would cap any future pharma tariffs at a blanket 15 per cent rate. The two sides agreed that no tariffs would be charged on imports of aircraft, certain chemicals and some agri-food goods, though the finer details of what agricultural products will benefit from these exemptions are still to be worked out. Challenge for Ireland Minister for Enterprise Peter Burke said there is 'no doubt' Ireland is in a challenging position in relation to tariffs but that the agreement does bring 'some clarity'. Minister for Enterprise Peter Burke. Photograph: Conor Ó Mearáin / Collins Photo Agency Speaking on RTÉ Radio 1's Morning Ireland on Monday, Mr Burke said the EU was four days away from 30 per cent tariffs, which would have been 'significant', while the Government is awaiting more details to emerge. Mr Burke said there would be a number of 'carve-outs' for particular sectors such as aviation, agri-foods and spirits. He said the Government was concerned about the 'stacking mechanism', which refers to the cumulative effect of multiple tariffs applied to the same imported product. 'All of those areas have been called out for separate carve-outs, so we have to see what that will look like and what will that amount to on paper, and that's where the devil is going to be in the detail,' he said. However, businesses are more cautious about the deal. Lobby group Ibec said it represents a 'substantial burden' for many industries, and the most exposed sectors will require Brexit-style supports. 'Our message to the Government, as it was with the 10 per cent tariff, is that the most exposed sectors will require support similar to the interventions provided as a response to Brexit,' he said. Irish whiskey industry The EU and the US sides are to continue negotiations on the finer points of detail, including possible tariff exemptions for several sectors. It is understood spirits are one area on that front where the commission feel they are making progress, which would be welcome news to the Irish whiskey industry, a big exporter to the US. Eoin Ó Catháin, director of the Irish Whiskey Association, told The Irish Times he hopes the deal can 'provide the framework' for a return to zero-for-zero trade in spirits. 'The EU and US government agreed to this zero-for-zero arrangement in 1997, and since then our shared sector has experienced huge growth in value to the benefit of economies and communities on both sides of the Atlantic,' he said. Jameson whiskey: sells over 1 million cases annually across the Atlantic. Photograph: Aidan Crawley/Bloomberg 'It is therefore logical to return to this. As it currently stands, Irish whiskey and drinks producers face a 10 per cent tariff when exporting to the USA – our biggest market. 'This, combined with a weakened dollar, has placed significant pressure on our distillers, and some have unfortunately had to close their doors. A return to zero-to-zero would be a major help to these exporters.' He added he was hopeful 'a mutually beneficial arrangement and the removal of tariffs can be secured'. Dairy Industry Ireland director Conor Mulvihill said confirmation exports will now be subject to a single 15 percent tariff rate with no additional stacked duties was 'particularly important' for Irish dairy products such as butter. 'While the simplification of the new tariff structure, as set out in the deal, will make it easier for the sector to manage, we remain concerned about the broader implications of any tariff border on the island of Ireland,' he said. Conor Mulvihill 'The dairy industry operates on an all island basis, with integrated supply chains and cross-border trade in raw milk, ingredients, and finished products. 'Any divergence in tariff treatment between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland could introduce complexity, cost, and uncertainty for processors and farmers alike.' Deloitte Ireland chief economist Kate English said the EU 'was wise to pick their battles and to choose certainty'. 'Remember, this 15 per cent is not on top of existing custom duties – a good example we saw this weekend was Kerrygold butter, which is already subject to a 16 per cent custom duty, so will see little difference from yesterday's decision.' Daniel Mulhall, who served as Ireland's ambassador to the United States from 2017 until 2022, posted on X that the deal 'does not look like a great outcome for the EU'. Irish Ambassador to the US Daniel Mulhall speaking at the 2019 Conference In response to his post, former taoiseach Leo Varadkar said the deal will mean 'fewer EU exports to the US and higher prices for Americans'. He added: 'The only thing it's better than is no deal at all and that's only if it sticks.' Paul Sweetman, chief executive of the American Chamber of Commerce Ireland, said a 15 per cent tariff level is 'not an optimum trade environment' and will be a 'significant burden' to businesses already managing a 10 per cent tariff. 'However, the agreement does bring a new stability and allows business decisions to be made with greater certainty,' he added. Meanwhile, European governments and companies reacted with both relief and concern to the trade deal, acknowledging what was seen as an unbalanced deal but one that avoided a deeper trade war. France prime minister François Bayrou said Europe had submitted to the US on a 'dark day' for the union. 'It is a dark day when an alliance of free peoples, gathered to affirm their values and defend their interests, resolves to submission,' Mr Bayrou posted on X. German chancellor Friedrich Merz rapidly hailed the deal, saying it avoided 'needless escalation in transatlantic trade relations'. German exporters were less enthusiastic. The powerful BDI federation of industrial groups said the accord would have 'considerable negative repercussions', while the country's VCI chemical trade association said the accord left rates 'too high'. Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni also expressed support for the agreement, calling it 'sustainable.' Market reaction European shares advanced to a four-month high on Monday, led by gains in pharma and semiconductor stocks. The pan-European Stoxx 600 index rose 0.7 per cent. Most regional bourses were also in the green, with Germany's blue-chip Dax rising 0.6 per cent and France's Cac 40 gaining 0.8 per cent. UK's FTSE 100 added 0.1 per cent. Euro area government bond yields edged down on Monday, while investors assessed their bets on European Central Bank monetary easing. Markets saw an additional 25-basis-point rate cut as likely, but pushed back the timing, assigning a 65 per cent probability for the move by December and an 85 per cent chance by March 2026.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Man who sent Springsteen concert videos has conviction for breaching order removed
A man who broke a safety order by sending a woman videos of a Bruce Springsteen concert has had his conviction removed on appeal. Judge Christopher Callan said that he was sure Springsteen 'would not be too happy' to see his music being used in this way and that the man's actions were not in line with the singer's message as a performing artist. The man, who cannot be named for legal reasons, pleaded guilty in the District Court to the breach of a safety order contrary to section 33 (1) of the Domestic Violence Act 2018. He received a one-month suspended sentence in March 2025 and later lodged an appeal against the severity of that term. READ MORE Gda Rachel O'Mahony told the District Court Appeals Court that on June 20th, 2024, the injured party reported to gardaí that the man had breached a safety order on three occasions. She said that on dates between February 2nd, 2024, and June 20th, 2024, the man sent the injured party text messages to her mobile phone. Gda O'Mahony said that these messages included videos taken at a Bruce Springsteen concert in Croke Park and a YouTube link. Gda O'Mahony said the woman said this communication put her in fear. She also presented a victim-impact statement to the judge that was not read aloud in court. Defence counsel for the man, Seosaimhín Ní Chathasaigh BL, said her client co-operated fully with the gardaí and did not dispute the charges. She said he has sincere remorse for the hurt caused by his actions and this is not a pattern of behaviour that will continue in the future. Ms Ní Chathasaigh confirmed to the judge that the safety order has already been extended to last until 2030 with consent from her client. She said her client is not seeking to avoid accountability but having a conviction would have life-altering effects in regards to his employment or possible travel. Judge Callan said the victim-impact statement was very clear about the extent of the fear that the injured party experienced. He said the videos were 'intending to give a certain message' to the injured party, which was explained in her victim-impact statement. Judge Callan decided to remove the man's criminal conviction on the condition he pays a donation of €1,000 to Women's Aid, noting the safety order remains in place until 2030.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Small Irish businesses say tariffs will hurt US consumers most
Many smaller Irish exporters have mixed feelings about the trade agreement between the European Union and the United States. Last week, they understood there was still an outside chance that discussions could go off the rails with the possibility of a trade war. At the same time, they are less than impressed with the outline deal being presented in the media. Sarah Furno, of Cashel Blue, greeted the news from Scotland yesterday with a 'degree of relief' and the sense that the Tipperary cheese company can now make more definite plans for the US market. Sarah and Sergio Furno of Cashel Blue cheesemakers 'Uncertainty is impossible and disabling especially in a prolonged manner,' she says. 'Overall we feel it could have been worse. It's a relatively even playing field for imports and there is enough light to keep doors open. READ MORE 'Of course it will hurt the average American most'. Ms Furno said the 30 per cent rate threatened by US President Donald Trump would have pushed Cashel products off US shelves. Leo Cummins, of Hazelbrook Confectionery in Co Kildare, decided earlier this year to shun the US market due to the uncertainty. On hearing the news of the agreement, he said he was even more convinced that ignoring the US market in the short term was 'the right thing to do'. 'Obviously one has a concern that the deal as it stands looks quite lopsided in favour of the US,' he says. Leo Cummins of Hazelbrook Confectionary in Newbridge, Co. Kildare. Photograph Nick Bradshaw 'I personally think that American candy sales will decline in Ireland, the UK and Europe over the next three years as consumer sentiment towards America becomes more negative. 'Whilst it appears that there will be no tariffs on US candy imports into Europe, American candy manufacturers will have to pay extra for their cocoa and other ingredients that are not produced in America and that will push their costs higher and hence their prices to European customers.' Mr Cummins says more expensive US confectionery will open doors for Hazelbrook in the UK and Europe as importers there will look to find cheaper alternatives. Whiskey manufacturers were particularly concerned at the possibility of trade talks failing. Brendan Carty, of Killowen Distillery in Co Down, will now have to contend with two different trade deals – the EU deal at 15 per cent and the UK one at 10 per cent. As Irish whiskey is bottled and bonded on both sides of the Border, it presents new headaches for the likes of Killowen. 'If a distillery sells 50 per cent distilled in Killowen and 50 per cent distilled in the Republic, I suppose our tariffs will be complicated and will fall between the two,' says Mr Carty. 'That's the nature of navigating a global market. It's always changing and very complex. It's the consumers who will take the hurt in the end. 'It's always a navigation exercise working things out with overseas partners, part and parcel of the business, so we won't get too upset about it'. The Irish Whiskey Association still hasn't ruled out the chance that the agreement could yet see the return of 'zero-for-zero' trade in spirits. Director Eoin Ó Catháin says the 10 per cent rate currently being applied, along with a weakened US dollar, has forced some operators to shut their doors. 'We are hopeful that, as we learn more about this deal and discussions on its implementation continue, a mutually beneficial arrangement and the removal of tariffs can be secured,' he says. The overriding sentiment from many exporters is that the deal represents an unwanted regression. With no upsides for Irish businesses – other than avoiding even worse terms – it is the new price of doing business with the US.
