Image of man lying outside South African hospital fuels anti-migrant narratives
Operation Dudula is a movement that promotes the deportation of undocumented migrants (archived here).
The X post, with over 2,000 likes, features a photo of a man lying on the ground outside a metal gate, with a young woman standing above him.
Image
Screenshot of the false post, published on August 2, 2025
Comments to the X post were mixed, with some replies asking why the man hadn't gone to a private hospital and others criticising the poster for using an old photo to spread propaganda.
Image
Screenshot of some of the replies to the X post, taken on August 7, 2025
Similar claims have circulated on Facebook and YouTube.
However, the image shows an incident earlier in the year, unrelated to the ongoing disputes about foreigners in South Africa.
January reports
A reverse image search of the photo led to Afrikaans online articles from January 2025 by regional radio station OFM and the paywalled newspaper Netwerk24 (archived here).
According to the news reports and the original Facebook post describing the incident, the photo was taken when the post's author, Vuyo Majuba, 'came across a deeply disturbing scene' at MUCPP Mangaung Community Health Centre in Bloemfontein, Free State province (archived here).
'An elderly, sick man was lying outside the clinic gates with his children by his side, visibly helpless,' read the post published on January 2, 2025.
The post added that the gates were locked, and security told him the clinic only assists 'women giving birth'.
At the time, the Free State Department of Health responded to the backlash from concerned citizens (archived here).
'Last night, Thursday, 02 January 2025, it transpired that a patient was taken to MUCPP after 21:00 and their pictures were spread on social media when they could not get help because the clinic is closed at that time for casualty services,' said the provincial government.
The health department added: 'The ambulance services were contacted to check the situation but did not find this person because they had been taken to Pelonomi Hospital'.
The provincial health spokesperson told AFP Fact Check on August 6, 2025, that they are aware that the 'picture has suddenly resurfaced as an apparent new issue'.
'We can confirm that this is used for misinformation purposes," Mondli Mvambi wrote in a WhatsApp message.
Mvambi also confirmed that the man was reportedly South African, not Zimbabwean.
'We checked MUCPP that night to see what had transpired after our EMS had been sent to MUCPP, only to be told that this South African patient had been taken by car to Pelonomi," he said.
The health department could not locate the patient after that night: 'We checked Pelonomi and there was never any confirmation of a patient with such a description.'
Healthcare dispute
In recent years, groups including Operation Dudula as well as March and March have been blocking undocumented foreigners from accessing public healthcare in South Africa's Gauteng and KwaZulu-Natal provinces (archived here and here).
The groups advocate for the deportation of undocumented foreigners from South Africa, claiming they are straining the country's resources.
The South African Human Rights Commission condemned these actions as unconstitutional (archived here), and the Socio-Economic Rights Institute (SERI) launched a case in the Gauteng High Court in 2024. The case was heard in June, but the court reserved judgment, meaning that a written decision will be handed down at a later date (archived here).
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
AFP
2 days ago
- AFP
Image of man lying outside South African hospital fuels anti-migrant narratives
'A Zimbabwean man dies after he was dragged out of hospital by South African Dudula gangsters, here in the photo his wife stands confused and shocked all because of bad governance in Zimbabwe (sic),' reads an X post published on August 2, 2025. Operation Dudula is a movement that promotes the deportation of undocumented migrants (archived here). The X post, with over 2,000 likes, features a photo of a man lying on the ground outside a metal gate, with a young woman standing above him. Image Screenshot of the false post, published on August 2, 2025 Comments to the X post were mixed, with some replies asking why the man hadn't gone to a private hospital and others criticising the poster for using an old photo to spread propaganda. Image Screenshot of some of the replies to the X post, taken on August 7, 2025 Similar claims have circulated on Facebook and YouTube. However, the image shows an incident earlier in the year, unrelated to the ongoing disputes about foreigners in South Africa. January reports A reverse image search of the photo led to Afrikaans online articles from January 2025 by regional radio station OFM and the paywalled newspaper Netwerk24 (archived here). According to the news reports and the original Facebook post describing the incident, the photo was taken when the post's author, Vuyo Majuba, 'came across a deeply disturbing scene' at MUCPP Mangaung Community Health Centre in Bloemfontein, Free State province (archived here). 'An elderly, sick man was lying outside the clinic gates with his children by his side, visibly helpless,' read the post published on January 2, 2025. The post added that the gates were locked, and security told him the clinic only assists 'women giving birth'. At the time, the Free State Department of Health responded to the backlash from concerned citizens (archived here). 'Last night, Thursday, 02 January 2025, it transpired that a patient was taken to MUCPP after 21:00 and their pictures were spread on social media when they could not get help because the clinic is closed at that time for casualty services,' said the provincial government. The health department added: 'The ambulance services were contacted to check the situation but did not find this person because they had been taken to Pelonomi Hospital'. The provincial health spokesperson told AFP Fact Check on August 6, 2025, that they are aware that the 'picture has suddenly resurfaced as an apparent new issue'. 'We can confirm that this is used for misinformation purposes," Mondli Mvambi wrote in a WhatsApp message. Mvambi also confirmed that the man was reportedly South African, not Zimbabwean. 'We checked MUCPP that night to see what had transpired after our EMS had been sent to MUCPP, only to be told that this South African patient had been taken by car to Pelonomi," he said. The health department could not locate the patient after that night: 'We checked Pelonomi and there was never any confirmation of a patient with such a description.' Healthcare dispute In recent years, groups including Operation Dudula as well as March and March have been blocking undocumented foreigners from accessing public healthcare in South Africa's Gauteng and KwaZulu-Natal provinces (archived here and here). The groups advocate for the deportation of undocumented foreigners from South Africa, claiming they are straining the country's resources. The South African Human Rights Commission condemned these actions as unconstitutional (archived here), and the Socio-Economic Rights Institute (SERI) launched a case in the Gauteng High Court in 2024. The case was heard in June, but the court reserved judgment, meaning that a written decision will be handed down at a later date (archived here).
AFP
2 days ago
- AFP
Social media posts misleadingly describe lenacapavir as a vaccine
'UPDATE: WHO has approved Kenya to roll out the Lenacapavir injectable HIV vaccine. You will rush for this more than the one for Corona,' reads an English and Swahili Facebook post published on July 15, 2025. Image Screenshot of the misleading Facebook post, taken on August 1, 2025 Similar claims were published here and here on Facebook. HIV breakthrough HIV is a virus that attacks the body's immune system by targeting white blood cells. These cells are essential in helping the body fight against infections and diseases (archived here). It is transmitted through contact with bodily fluids such as blood and semen from an infected person, and if left untreated, HIV can advance to AIDS (Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome), the most severe stage of infection. At the end of 2024, the World Health Organization (WHO) estimated that 40.8 million people were living with HIV globally, with 65 percent of them in the WHO African Region. Administered as a twice-yearly injection and developed by Gilead Sciences, LEN represents a major advancement in the fight against HIV and was approved by the US Food and Drug Administration on July 1, 2025 (archived here and here). Image Drugmaker Gilead manufactures lenacapavir (GETTY IMAGES NORTH AMERICA / JUSTIN SULLIVAN) During the 13th International AIDS Society Conference (IAS 2025) on HIV Science in Kigali, Rwanda, this July, the WHO also endorsed the drug, issuing guidelines recommending it as an additional pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) option for people at high risk of HIV infection (archived here). PrEP is medication taken by individuals who do not have HIV but are at risk of contracting it. In case of infection, these treatments help the body stop the virus from replicating (archived here). Kenya was selected as one of the nine early adopter countries for the rollout of LEN, scheduled for January 2026. According to the country's health ministry, each dose is expected to cost 6,000 Kenyan shillings (about $46) (archived here and here). However, social media posts describing LEN as a vaccine are misleading. Not a vaccine According to its manufacturer, Gilead Sciences, LEN, marketed under the brand names Sunlenca and Yeztugo, is approved for two uses: as a treatment for adults who are resistant to other HIV treatments -- combined with other ARVs -- and as a PrEP option to reduce the risk of sexually acquired HIV (archived here and here). ARVs are used to treat HIV. They do not cure the virus but are a lifelong treatment that works by suppressing the infection to prevent it from progressing to AIDS (archived here). Kenya's director general for health, Dr. Patrick Amoth, told AFP Fact Check: 'Lenacapavir is not a vaccine. It is an antiretroviral medicine that prevents HIV infection.' This is different from how a vaccine affects the body. Vaccines train the immune system to recognise and fight specific pathogens before a person is infected. They do so by imitating an infection to trigger the body's natural defences. This helps the body identify the pathogen so it can respond quickly if exposed to it in the future, preventing disease (archived here). In contrast, ARVs like LEN are used to treat those already living with HIV or to prevent infection in the case of PrEP. These drugs work by blocking the virus at different stages of its lifecycle, and when taken consistently, they help control the infection and prevent transmission to others (archived here). 'Vaccines work by stimulating the body to produce antibodies against a disease,' Amoth said. 'Lenacapavir is a capsid inhibitor, blocking HIV from replicating by interfering with viral assembly and release, hence allowing the body to prevent new infections.' The capsid is the protein shell of an infectious virus that encases its genetic material. Capsids help viruses such as HIV survive. Drugs that are capsid inhibitors, like LEN, disrupt viral replication and protect the host from infection (archived here and here). Dr Andrew Mulwa, head of Kenya's National AIDS & STI Control Program (NASCOP), reiterated that LEN is not a vaccine. 'Lenacapavir, just like Cabotegravir, is an antiretroviral drug,' Mulwa told AFP Fact Check. Cabotegravir, marketed as Apretude and Cabenuva, was the first long-acting injectable PrEP that was approved by the FDA in 2021. It is administered as two initial injections four weeks apart, followed by an injection every two months (archived here). During his opening remarks at the IAS 2025 conference, WHO Director-General Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said: 'While an HIV vaccine remains elusive, lenacapavir is the next best thing: a long-acting antiretroviral shown in trials to prevent almost all HIV infections among those at risk' (archived here). AFP Fact Check has debunked other HIV-related claims here.
AFP
3 days ago
- AFP
Post falsely claims images show Nigerian children hospitalised after eating local dish
'BREAKING NEWS!!! 3 children hospitalised, after Eating Yariba Ewedu and Amala. Investigation Ongoing (sic),' reads the caption of an X post published on August 2, 2025. 'Yariba' is an ethnic slur against Yorubas. 'Ewedu' is a green soup made from jute leaves, while 'amala' is a soft, stretchy Nigerian dough made from yam flour. A popular dish in Nigeria combines amala and ewedu with stew. Image Screenshot showing the false post, taken on August 5, 2025 Attached to the post are two images showing three children who appear to be unhappy with the food in front of them. Shared more than 500 times, the claim was published by an account called 'Mike Ejeagha'. AFP Fact Check's review of the account shows it regularly shares ethnic slurs targeting ethnicities in Nigeria, especially the Yoruba people. Ethnic slander and tribalistic rhetoric have become increasingly common on X among Nigerian users of Igbo and Yoruba descent, especially in the aftermath of the 2023 presidential election (archived here). The contest saw Labour Party's Peter Obi, an Igbo from the southeast, face off against Bola Tinubu, a Yoruba from the southwest — a dynamic that fed ethnic tensions online. Supporters of both candidates often published divisive posts, many laced with slurs and stereotypes targeting each other's communities. However, the pictures in the claim do not show children who were hospitalised after eating the local dish. Fabricated claim AFP Fact Check found no recent news reports of food poisoning involving three children in Nigeria. We used Google Lens to conduct reverse image searches on the pictures in the X post. The earliest result led to a YouTube Short uploaded on August 1, 2025 (archived here). In the full three-minute video, published by a YouTube account belonging to a user named Adejoke Adekoya, three children are seen being served a local delicacy by someone they refer to as 'Mom'. In the video, we hear a woman interacting with the three children while dishing out okro soup with amala into bowls. A review of the YouTube account shows the woman in the video shares scenes from her family's life. In an Instagram chat message, Adekoya told AFP Fact Check that the claim is false. 'Kindly disregard the post shared by the individual. He purposely used the post to promote his disgusting tribalistic agenda because nothing of the sort happened,' she said. 'My kids ate the food, and they were all ok with it after tasting it. And I've already reached out to him to take it down.'
