logo
Millions spent, jobs lost as Tourism Equity Fund scandal exposed

Millions spent, jobs lost as Tourism Equity Fund scandal exposed

IOL News12-07-2025
The meeting, led by Minister Patricia de Lille, exposed a web of implementation challenges, transparency failures, and accountability concerns that have plagued the fund since its inception.
Image: Ayanda Ndamane/Independent Media
IN a tense and revealing session recently, the Select Committee on Economic Development and Trade convened to hear testimony from the Department of Tourism regarding the beleaguered Tourism Equity Fund (TEF).
The meeting, led by Minister Patricia de Lille, exposed a web of implementation challenges, transparency failures, and accountability concerns that have plagued the fund since its inception.
The TEF, launched in 2021 with the aim of driving transformation and inclusive growth in South Africa's tourism sector, has been mired in legal battles, administrative delays, and allegations of mismanagement. A court challenge brought by AfriForum and Solidarity initially halted the fund, which was only revived after an out-of-court settlement in mid-2023.
Despite this, the fund's rollout has continued to face serious hurdles — most notably, the refusal of the Small Enterprise Finance Agency (Sefa), now known as Sedfa, to release critical beneficiary information to the Department of Tourism.
De Lille opened the meeting by acknowledging the complexity of the situation: 'We appreciate the opportunity to present on the TEF, and we request the Committee's support in helping us move the process forward.'
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
She explained how her predecessor had initially set the fund's black economic empowerment threshold at 51%, exceeding the legislated 30% requirement under the Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment (B-BBEE) codes. This decision was challenged in court by AfriForum and Solidarity, and the government lost the case on jurisdictional grounds.
Following her appointment in 2023, de Lille engaged directly with the litigants and brokered a settlement to unblock the R2.1 billion fund. She described the decision-making process in candid terms: 'I made a deliberate decision to set aside political pride to serve the interests of the sector and the country… I proposed a settlement in the spirit of recovery and collaboration, given the urgency of economic reconstruction following the pandemic.'
The revised framework, approved by Cabinet in August 2023, allocates 80% of funding to existing SMMEs and 20% to new entrants, a policy shift that drew sharp criticism from several committee members.
The Department outlined how Sefa, appointed as the implementing agent for the TEF, had failed to meet expectations: 'Due to ongoing challenges with Sefa's performance, the Department informed them in early 2025 of our decision to terminate the agreement,' De Lille said.
Despite terminating the service-level agreement, the Department is still awaiting a full close-out report from Sefa. More troublingly, Sefa has refused to disclose details of beneficiaries, citing the Protection of Personal Information Act (Popia). 'They refuse to disclose the names of applicants who benefited from the TEF,' the Minister said. 'We disagree with their position and have sought legal opinion confirming that the Department is entitled to receive this information.'
Legal advice obtained by the Department supports this view, reinforcing that Parliament, as an oversight body, also has a right to access such data. The legal opinion, circulated during the meeting, recommended including confidentiality clauses in future agreements to ensure Popia compliance while maintaining transparency. 'Parliament must be able to exercise its oversight function,' said Mmaditonki Setwaba, the deputy director-general of Tourism Sector Support Services.
Committee members raised urgent questions about the cost per job created through the TEF. The DA's Nicolaas Pienaar expressed alarm: 'Based on the figures presented, nearly R1 million has been spent per job created. In my view, R1m should result in at least four jobs.'
His sentiment was echoed by the FF+'s Hendrik van den Berg, who pointed to staggering disparities: 'In the Northern Cape, two jobs were created at a cost of R4.4m each. In the North West, ten jobs came at a cost of over R8m per job.'
Setwaba responded that while some projects were capital-intensive, particularly in the accommodation and travel sectors, the Department was aware of the need for better value-for-money outcomes. 'We are learning from the rollout and working on enhanced pre-investment support and streamlined compliance processes,' she said.
The lack of detailed breakdowns on the nature of these jobs — whether part-time, seasonal, or permanent — further deepened scepticism among members.
The PA's Bino Farmer questioned the regional distribution of funds and the effectiveness of outreach campaigns in rural areas: 'How many applications came from the Western Cape? How many were rejected and why? If the fund is meant to drive transformation, why allocate 80% to existing businesses when new entrants are the ones most in need?'
He highlighted the case of Lamberts Bay, where tourism remains racially exclusive and ownership opportunities for black entrepreneurs are limited. 'Communities like mine want to know how people are informed about such funding opportunities. Tourism is spoken about in terms of job creation, but not ownership.'
The ANC's Patrick Mabilo lamented the minimal investment in his province despite its rich natural and cultural assets: 'Only one project received funding in the Northern Cape, valued at R8.8 million. Given the scenic richness of the province, including Unesco sites, why hasn't there been more meaningful participation?'
He called for clarity on outreach efforts and asked whether the Department could quantify results in rural townships.
The chairperson, Sonja Boshoff, from the DA, acknowledged the severity of the situation: 'This is not just about administration, it affects the lives of ordinary South Africans. We cannot allow SEFA to hold the Department or Parliament to ransom.'
The Committee resolved to summon Sefa before Parliament, even if it required convening outside normal hours. It also agreed to send a letter to the Minister of Small Business Development, Stella Ndabeni-Abrahams, requesting her urgent engagement with Sefa ahead of their scheduled meeting the following week. 'We expect feedback from her then so that we can determine how best to support the Department going forward,' said the chairperson.
The ANC's Mpho Modise supported the idea of a joint session involving both Ministers and Sefa: 'All relevant stakeholders need to be in the same room so we can ask direct questions and get comprehensive answers.'
The Minister welcomed the suggestion: 'I welcome the Committee's oversight and support any parliamentary investigation into the administration and outcomes of the Fund.'
De Lille did not shy away from the legal and reputational risks involved: 'As the accounting authority, I am fully aware of the possibility of personal liability. But I remain committed to preserving my integrity and resolving this matter as quickly as possible.'
Director-general Victor Vele confirmed that no fruitless or wasteful expenditure had yet been recorded, though he admitted that the full financial picture would only emerge once SEFA released its complete records. 'From the perspective of an accounting officer, there is currently no record of fruitless or wasteful expenditure associated with the Fund,' he said.
Meanwhile, the Department has identified the Public Investment Corporation (PIC) as the new implementing agent, aligning with the TEF's objective of promoting transformation in the tourism sector. 'We are working on a formal handover process to a new implementing agency, which will be announced following legal and operational finalisation,' said Setwaba.
The TEF was conceived as a vehicle for economic transformation and inclusion. Yet five years after its launch, it stands as a cautionary tale of poor governance, legal entanglements, and institutional dysfunction.
With Sefa refusing to share basic information, the Department hamstrung by outdated contracts, and Parliament demanding accountability, the TEF has become emblematic of the broader crisis in public administration.
Unless swift and decisive action is taken — including full disclosure of beneficiaries, independent auditing, and reform of implementation frameworks — the TEF may well go down as another failed attempt at redress in post-apartheid South Africa.
For now, all eyes are on the upcoming joint meeting between the Departments of Tourism and Small Business Development, and on whether SEFA will finally answer the call for transparency. Get the real story on the go: Follow the Sunday Independent on WhatsApp.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

South Africa's growing consumer debt: Economists warn of dangerous borrowing trends
South Africa's growing consumer debt: Economists warn of dangerous borrowing trends

IOL News

time9 hours ago

  • IOL News

South Africa's growing consumer debt: Economists warn of dangerous borrowing trends

Economists have warned that rising consumer borrowing for essentials like groceries and fuel poses serious risks to household stability. Image: Ayanda Ndamane / Independent Newspapers Economists have warned that South Africans are falling into unsustainable debt by using credit to purchase basic necessities such as groceries, fuel, and electricity. They say this shift is financially dangerous and structurally damaging to household stability. This follows a warning from the National Financial Ombud Scheme South Africa (NFO), which flagged a sharp rise in consumer credit defaults. TransUnion's Q1 2025 Industry Insights Report shows that 41.3% of non-bank personal loan accounts are now more than three months in arrears, the highest serious delinquency rate recorded in over three years. Retail instalment account defaults stand at 27.1%, clothing accounts at 25.9%, and revolving credit at 14.9%. According to the report, uptake of these products is also increasing, with retail instalment credit up 16%, clothing credit up 7.6%, and revolving credit up 5.4%. The NFO says this simultaneous rise in borrowing and missed payments reflects mounting financial strain on households. 'These figures are not just statistics. They reflect the reality of households using credit to survive rather than to grow,' said Kwanda Vabaza, Manager of Adjudication at the NFO's Banking and Credit Division. 'When nearly half of all non-bank loan holders are behind on their payments, the system is under significant strain.' Independent economist Professor Bonke Dumisa cautioned that consumers should avoid credit for daily expenses. 'Ordinary consumers must avoid purchasing groceries or other regular household goods on credit,' he said. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading He added that consumers should try to avoid having their credit liabilities above 25% of their total disposable income. Professor Waldo Krugell, an economist at North-West University, noted that while the full scale of the problem is difficult to determine from credit bureau data alone, the pressure on consumers is evident. 'Though consumers have been spending on food, restaurants, clothing, and footwear, there is also something of a cost-of-living crisis. The inflation rate has come down, but price levels are high and salaries have been slow to catch up. In the end, many people spend on credit, essentially living above their means.' Krugell added that the situation is likely to affect broader economic performance. 'At some stage, households will have to apply some unpleasant austerity, and consumer spending as a driver of the economy will take a knock.' While financial institutions remain stable, Krugell said profitability and share prices could decline if consumer defaults rise. He also flagged low levels of financial literacy as a key concern. 'Current regulations and checks are quite good, but there is a big deficit in consumer financial literacy. Most of us know too little about managing our finances well.' The NFO has also raised concerns about reckless lending and urged consumers to lodge complaints with it if they were granted unaffordable loans. THE MERCURY

Blow for state over BEE requirement for estate agents
Blow for state over BEE requirement for estate agents

The Citizen

time10 hours ago

  • The Citizen

Blow for state over BEE requirement for estate agents

Ministers will no longer oppose the matter brought before court by Sakeliga. Lobby group Sakeliga has struck an arguably decisive blow in its legal challenge to moves by the Property Practitioners Regulatory Authority (PPRA) to no longer issue fidelity fund certificates to non-Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) compliant businesses. It announced on Tuesday that Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition Parks Tau 'has withdrawn his opposition' to its case. This ministry is responsible for driving government's BEE agenda through legislation, codes, policies and sector charters. Sakeliga originally filed papers in the North Gauteng High Court against the PPRA and the ministers of human settlements; water and sanitation; and trade, industry and competition. It made these papers public in January. The Minister of Human Settlements, Water and Sanitation (Thembi Simelane, since December 2024) had already indicated that the department would abide by the decision of the court, effectively not opposing the matter. The PPRA falls under the ambit of this department. ALSO READ: Real estate agents warned of licensing risks over BEE compliance Sakeliga brought the papers following decisions by the PPRA last year to deny operating licences, in the form of fidelity fund certificates (FFCs), to property businesses that did not meet the regulator's stipulated minimum BEE score. It argues that this was a 'brazen effort to put people out of business unless they comply' and that the case is needed to 'resist further overreach'. The first formal warning from the PPRA came in March 2024, when it warned practitioners in the property sector that failure to comply with BEE legislation 'may result in the inability to obtain or renew' a FFC. Property practitioners, including estate agents, need these certificates to operate. This followed a webinar in March, during which the PPRA's legal manager and acting transformation manager, Deli Nkambule, made it clear that the regulator 'will not issue an FFC unless a compliant BEE certificate accompanies the application. The accepted level of compliance is 40 points or more (BEE level 8). You will not be issued a BEE certificate if you score below 40 (making your BEE certificate non-compliant).' After sustained pushback from the sector, the PPRA quietly made an about-turn in August, with its chair sending a letter to estate agent industry grouping Real Estate Business Owners of South Africa (Rebosa) stating that the PPRA had sought legal advice and would no longer be requiring level 8 broad-based black economic empowerment (B-BBEE) certificates with new FFC applications. Sakeliga described this at the time as a 'tactical retreat'. ALSO READ: State sued over estate agent BEE plan It argues that the mandatory requirement for a 'valid' B-BBEE certificate for the issuing of an FFC 'serves no legitimate government purpose'. It says, 'there is no relationship between fulfilling the requirements for a fidelity fund certificate and having a B-BBEE certificate.' Currently there are around 40 000 FFCs issued, mostly to estate agents operating in the country. It highlights that the 'certificate requirement extends even to those thousands of businesses that do not participate in BEE (due to falling below certain turnover thresholds), bizarrely requiring them to fork out in the region of R10 000 every year just to buy and submit a 'valid' yet 'non-compliant' B-BBEE certificate.' Through the case, it is also seeking to roll back the expanded definition of property practitioner, which it says was 'unnecessarily expanded by the PPRA' to 12 new categories. Sakeliga says this includes developers, property administrators, landlords, homeowners' associations, auctioneers, bond originators and even property marketing companies, which 'improperly expands the reach of the PPRA over thousands of businesses and hundreds of billions of rand in turnover'. Achieving both outcomes would be seen as a success by the group. It is finalising its replying affidavit and, after filing it, will await a date for the matter to be heard. This article was republished from Moneyweb. Read the original here.

Corruption and collapse: How Services Seta blew R163-million and broke SA's skills promise
Corruption and collapse: How Services Seta blew R163-million and broke SA's skills promise

Daily Maverick

timea day ago

  • Daily Maverick

Corruption and collapse: How Services Seta blew R163-million and broke SA's skills promise

From fake companies winning multimillion-rand contracts to whistleblower warnings ignored, this exposé reveals how corruption flourished unchecked at South Africa's Sector Education and Training Authorities (Setas). As pressure mounts for reform, the question remains: will new leadership break the cycle of corruption? Long before axed higher education minister Nobuhle Nkabane took office, the Sector Education and Training Authority (Seta) was already under a cloud of corruption and governance failures. Tasked with managing training levies and skills development in the services sector, the Services Seta has been dogged since 2018 by allegations of tender irregularities and financial mismanagement, exposed through investigations by watchdog group Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse (Outa). How the Services Seta missed every red flag At the heart of the Services Seta scandal lies a R163-million contract for biometric units meant to track learner attendance and manage stipend payments. Shockingly, the tender ran for just four days — far short of the Treasury's 21-day requirement — and bids were evaluated a week before the closing date. The contract went to Grayson Reed — a shell company with no track record, no South African Revenue Service (SARS) declarations, and no real capacity to deliver. Investigators later revealed that the name itself was bogus. Despite glaring red flags, the Seta's bid committees waved the deal through. Outa says this blunder cost taxpayers more than R163-million. Outa's investigation also uncovered serious financial irregularities in the execution of the contract. Grayson Reed submitted travel and accommodation claims exceeding R2.1-million, many lacking proper supporting documents. Some invoices were allegedly fraudulent, while others billed for expenses incurred by unrelated parties. Suspiciously high fuel and Uber claims suggested daily double-charging, with duplicated invoices slipping through. Despite the red flags, senior Services Seta officials — including Project Accounting head Mpho Teffo and CFO Tsheola Matsebe — authorised the payments, raising alarm bells over the Seta's internal controls. The contract's pricing was equally alarming — items like exam pads and USB sticks were inflated by up to 8,000%. Learners reported delayed stipends, faulty biometric devices, and underpayments. Strangely, records showed Grayson Reed paid its supplier more than it charged the Seta — raising red flags around possible kickbacks or financial mismanagement. Despite Outa's repeated calls for cancellation and investigation, the Services Seta only terminated the contract six months early, in 2019, with no funds recovered and no criminal charges laid. More contracts and more questions The Grayson Reed saga was not a one-off. In June 2023, Outa uncovered yet another case of suspect spending at the Services Seta — a R36-million contract handed to Five Star Communications and Projects for branding materials. A branded tender box costing R302,000 — marked up by over 8,000% — was among 29 inflated invoices paid to Five Star without question, all approved by then-CEO Andile Nongogo and branding head Duduzile Mwelase. Outa has since laid criminal charges with SAPS against the pair and two Five Star directors, citing fraud, corruption and breaches of the Public Finance Management Act. The Werksmans report: confirming the suspicions Under intense pressure from Outa and Parliament, the Services Seta commissioned Werksmans Attorneys in early 2023 to investigate procurement irregularities across multiple contracts. Werksmans' findings confirmed whistleblowers' worst fears — exposing deep rot in the Services Seta's procurement processes. Contracts were pushed through in as little as five days, with payments made before verifying delivery. In one shocking case, a contract ballooned from R6.6-million to R89-million with no valid explanation. Even committee setups were flawed — some decisions appeared to rest on just one improperly appointed member. Adding to the turmoil, the Auditor-General issued a qualified opinion on the 2023/24 financials, citing poor record-keeping, material misstatements and glaring control failures. Irregular expenditure topped R193-million for the year — pushing the total to a staggering R1.26-billion. Impunity persists Daily Maverick spoke to Wayne Duvenage, the CEO of Outa, who said that while Outa had exposed multiple irregularities, particularly concerning tender manipulation and contract awards, in many cases the incumbents had remained in their positions. 'We try to get the boards to recognise misconduct or maladministration. If they don't act, it becomes very difficult for us to effect any meaningful change,' he said. The 2023/24 annual report shows that disciplinary cases over irregular spending remain unresolved. Daily Maverick contacted the Services Seta for comment on 9 July, but the organisation did not respond to queries on the status of these cases. In hearings in October 2024, committee members condemned the Services Seta's leadership for ignoring the Werksmans report and failing to hold anyone accountable, warning that this impunity eroded public trust and fuelled corruption. Outa laid criminal complaints against Nongogo with SAPS in June 2023 over corrupt practices involving overpriced contracts awarded by the Services Seta. Nongogo was implicated alongside other officials for approving exorbitant payments and fraudulent activities. Nongogo was later appointed as NSFAS CEO in 2024. Do Seta boards dodge the old playbook? On the issue of Seta board appointments, Duvenage said that the former minister should have come up with a different approach. 'The chairperson and board members are in powerful positions, and they must be strong people appointed to exercise effective oversight. The minister knows, and we've told her, that these Setas have corrupt networks that infiltrate and use executive positions to control tender flows,' he said. 'We need skilled, credible board members with the moral courage to stand up to corruption,' said Duvenage. 'The public are not fools — we won't just accept anyone in these positions.' In June, Nkabane told Parliament that her selection of 21 Seta chairpersons was guided by an advisory panel including advocate Terry Motau SC and several senior officials. But that claim is now unravelling — Motau says he was never formally involved, and others named have also denied participating in the final decisions. Their denials cast serious doubt on the accuracy of the minister's version of events. The way forward Reflecting on South Africa's investment in skills development, estimated at R21-billion annually, Duvenage said the returns had been inadequate. He reiterated that a systemic overhaul was urgently needed. 'There must be a summit, bringing together government, business, service providers, evaluators, civil society and citizens to map out a new way forward,' he said. Duvenage called for an industry-led approach, with businesses identifying skills needs instead of the government dictating priorities. He warned that credible business leaders were stepping back due to political interference, saying: 'The system has collapsed. It's not working.' South Africa's Setas stand at a crossroads, their promise of skills development overshadowed by corruption and mismanagement. Without urgent reform and accountability, public trust will continue to erode, and the country's workforce will ultimately bear the consequences. DM

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store