Criticism of JMPD's focus on revenue generation through fines
Image: Simphiwe Mbokazi / Independent Newspapers
The SA Municipal Workers' Union (Samwu) has accused the Johannesburg Metropolitan Police Department (JMPD) of focusing more on generating revenue than enforcing traffic laws and dealing with road infringements.
Samwu's reaction follows the DA's allegations that JMPD officers informed the party that they are under pressure to each collect at least R7,000 in traffic fines daily.
DA City of Johannesburg councillor and former member of the mayoral committee for public safety, Michael Sun, said to incentivise compliance with the set targets, officers were being provided with overtime payments, which effectively transformed law enforcement into a commission-based revenue scheme.
'This pushes JMPD officers to aggressively pursue fines instead of focusing on their duties, such as by-law enforcement, traffic management, and crime prevention,' he said.
According to Sun, the revelations were disturbing and coincide with the common sight in Johannesburg, where the JMPD is increasingly engaging in indiscriminate and excessive roadblocks, particularly at high-traffic intersections, not to ensure road safety or enforce the law but to maximise fine collection.
'Many of these operations are non-compliant with the National Road Traffic Act and the SA Police Service standing orders. By reclassifying illegal roadblocks as 'roadside checks', JMPD evades crucial legal requirements, including proper authorisation by a senior officer, clear signage and adequate warning to motorists, among others,' he explained.
Samwu Johannesburg deputy regional chairperson Lebogang Ndawo said this was unfortunately the direction of the JMPD, which is either disguised as a performance management system where officers are told to issue a minimum of 10 tickets or is done when private companies are involved.
He said the private companies get a share of every speeding violation that is captured, or through payments made at roadblocks, in which they get a percentage.
'Now what is happening is that because these companies are profit-oriented, for example, they will look into setting up speed camera traps in revenue-generating zones rather than dangerous zones or those with high accident rates,' Ndawo said.
Like Sun, he added that this led to the setting up of speed cameras not being mainly focused on deterring drivers, but to try and trap them so that there is more money made as a result.
'Roadblocks are primarily focused on payment of fines, other than to perform law enforcement, crime prevention, and traffic law enforcement, but instead it's just focused on payment of traffic fines,' he said.
He said this was a result of a department suffering from political interference and managers who have forgotten its vision and mission.
Samwu called for reforms and for the municipality to put service over profit as well as safety over quotas, according to Ndawo.
'That is the only way JMPD must function, JMPD must continue to protect and serve the residents of Johannesburg and not be converted into a profit-making company,' he urged.
The JMPD has denied the existence of the targets or any quota system.
Spokesperson Xolani Fihla: 'The JMPD has been made aware of the allegations made by the DA. We would like to emphasise that our enforcement operations are conducted with the primary goal of maintaining safety and order on the city's roads.'
He said that while officers are expected to issue citations when motorists violate traffic laws, doing so serves as a necessary corrective measure to address lawlessness, curb unsafe behaviour, and promote a culture of responsibility among all road users.
Fihla continued: 'It is important to clarify that while issuing citations is an expected part of an officer's duty to enforce traffic regulations, there is no quota system that they are expected to follow.'
He said the JMPD's focus is on ensuring compliance with traffic laws to prevent accidents and protect the lives of all road users not on generating a specific number of fines.
'The performance of our officers is measured by their overall effectiveness in creating a safer environment for the community, and one of the ways is to issue citations, not by a predetermined target for fines. The integrity of our operations is paramount, and all actions are taken in strict accordance with the law,' said Fihla.
[email protected]
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
an hour ago
- Daily Maverick
Minister Macpherson to address media as exposé of IDT officials' bribery bid reverberates across SA
Minister of Public Works Dean Macpherson is expected to respond to the details of an explosive exposé by Daily Maverick of an attempted bribery of one of its investigative journalists by the suspended Independent Development Trust CEO and her spokesperson. ANC secretary-general Fikile Mbalula has called for suspended Independent Development Trust (IDT) CEO Tebogo Malaka and her spokesperson Phasha Makgolane to face the law 'if they are implicated in bribery'. Meanwhile, Minister of Public Works Dean Macpherson is expected to address the media on Thursday following an explosive exposé by Daily Maverick of an attempted bribery of one of its investigative journalists by the two IDT officials. On Tuesday, Daily Maverick carried video footage and recordings of this blatant attempt to bribe its journalist, Pieter-Louis Myburgh. Suspended IDT CEO Malaka and spokesperson Makgolane attempted to pay Daily Maverick investigative journalist Pieter-Louis Myburgh R60,000 in cash over the weekend to suppress an investigation into Malaka's personal dealings and questionable IDT contracts. The IDT, a very important, if lesser known, government body, spends upwards of R4-billion each year on social infrastructure projects, such as building schools and clinics, and falls under the Ministry of Public Works. Macpherson last week released a forensic report into a R836-million oxygen tender awarded to a ghost company that was first exposed by Daily Maverick. The report recommended that Malaka be suspended. Malaka was placed on precautionary suspension on Friday. Now Macpherson's remarks at Wednesday's briefing are expected to set the tone for the government's broader response. The attempted bribe, which took place during a meeting in Stellenbosch, was captured on camera. Myburgh photographed the cash, delivered in a white Dior shopping bag, and recorded video and audio of the exchange. Makgolane also sweetened the offer with promises of R100,000 in monthly payments and influence over IDT tenders. In a statement on the briefing, his department confirmed that Macpherson would respond directly to the 'serious allegations by Daily Maverick that Malaka sought to bribe journalist Pieter-Louis Myburgh'. Posting to social platform X yesterday morning, Macpherson said he planned to consult with the IDT board later in the day. The statement also warned that the matter appeared to be part of 'what is now likely a paid-for public campaign aimed at discrediting [Macpherson's] efforts to bring stability and good governance to the entity'. It suggests deeper political and institutional tensions may be at play, especially as Macpherson has been spearheading reform efforts at the IDT. On 22 January, the EFF accused Macpherson of 'brazen and corrupt interference' in IDT affairs, citing an incident where he allegedly instructed staff to process a questionable payment to a construction company. The party claimed that Macpherson had unfairly targeted Malaka and used the PSA oxygen plant tender as a pretext for political interference. EFF secretary-general Marshall Dlamini opened a criminal case of corruption against the minister on 22 January 2025. IDT promises full response While remaining tight-lipped on the details, IDT spokesperson Lerato Modisana said the IDT acknowledged the seriousness of the allegations. The IDT board convened on Wednesday, 6 August, to 'deliberate comprehensively on these matters'. However, Modisana said the IDT was not at this stage in a position to respond to specific media enquiries. The organisation pledged to uphold 'transparency, accountability and good governance' and promised that 'a detailed response will be provided in due course, once the board has fully considered all the relevant facts and implications'. What everyone wants to know Daily Maverick's exposé has garnered significant attention from other media, including radio broadcasts. Readers applauded Myburgh's efforts, while some wondered at the sheer audacity of the brazen bribery attempt. Reader Eddie Maulson summed it up: 'One is gobsmacked at the lack of thought that went into this outrageous attempt at bribery, not to mention the effrontery that these individuals show in their lamentable assumption that they could bribe a man of PLM's integrity in such a crass manner.' A history of red flags Malaka was already under scrutiny, having been placed on precautionary suspension days before the footage emerged on 1 August 2025, following the release of a PwC forensic report into the R836-million PSA oxygen plant project. That report, spurred by Daily Maverick investigations in October 2024, recommended disciplinary action for Malaka, citing her failure to prevent or address serious violations in the project's procurement. The IDT has long struggled with governance and accountability, facing repeated criticism over failed projects and procurement lapses, eroding public confidence in the agency's leadership. DM
Daily Maverick
3 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Cape Town's taxi sector commits to new chapter that ‘cannot be written in blood'
Extortion, disputes over routes, and the infiltration by criminal syndicates using the taxi industry to launder money pose serious threats to an industry that generates billions of rands. The minibus taxi sector in Cape Town has long been marred by issues of violence, extortion and illegality as operators vie for a slice of the industry, estimated to be worth R5-billion to R7-billion in the Western Cape. Taxi violence started in the region during the 1990s, with taxi operators targeting the Golden Arrow Bus Service. Since then, the bodies have continued to pile up. On Monday, 4 August, South African National Taxi Council (Santaco) Western Cape chairperson Mandla Hermanus stated: 'We need to write a new chapter and it cannot be written in blood.' He was speaking at Santaco's Peace Summit in Cape Town, which brought together stakeholders to address the challenges undermining the taxi industry. One message that came through strongly from taxi operators and owners, religious leaders, the City of Cape Town and the Western Cape mobility MEC, Isaac Sileku, was that the killings, extortion and assassinations must end. Conflict resolution At the heart of violence — and the impact it has on commuters who rely on the services — are disputes over routes. Dr Siyabulela Fobosi, a senior researcher at the University of Fort Hare, believes that the violence can be curbed through the introduction of route-based conflict management mechanisms. Fobosi told Daily Maverick: 'Where these problems are happening, the routes are identified to say, 'Look, let's implement this conflict management there, that mechanism will be made up of a multitude of stakeholders. 'The issues are then identified. The conflict is identified in its early stages. The people are advised to practise mediation before it escalates into something that kills people.' He said the issue of route duplication must be addressed urgently, as licences are often issued without proper adherence to the law. 'We end up with too many operators on a single route. While competition is expected, it should be fair, not as cut-throat and hostile as it currently is.' Mobility MEC Sileku said his department had a five-year strategic plan to compel taxi owners and associations to register with municipalities, which would help prevent route invasions. He said there was a focus on establishing stakeholder engagement forums. The taxi industry has often been at odds with the City of Cape Town and Western Cape government, particularly over issues such as by-laws. Governments across South Africa have attempted to register and formalise the taxi industry, with Fobosi writing, 'Post-apartheid governments have failed to formalise or regulate the sector effectively, leaving it trapped in a liminal space: too essential to ignore, too unruly to reform.' Fobosi added, however, that formalising the industry was possible. A template Speakers at the Peace Summit pointed to a recent example of how conflict between operators was resolved through dialogue. In June, an agreement was reached between the Cape Amalgamated Taxi Association and the Cape Organisation for the Democratic Taxi Association to resolve route disputes and operational challenges on the Mfuleni-Somerset and Khayelitsha-Somerset West routes. Seven people were killed and five others injured in the conflict, but through dialogue, the associations resolved their disputes and came to a mutually beneficial agreement. Sileku said this agreement was a testament to what is possible when collective leadership and dialogue are prioritised and people, rather than taxi owners, are put first. Speaking about the Peace Summit, he said, 'This summit is long overdue. We have always dealt with taxi violence as it occurred. So now we have decided to sit down. Let's talk about it.' He highlighted how taxi violence affected commuters: 'A mother waits by the roadside for transport that never comes. A child loses a day of learning because a route is closed. A father does not return home because of a conflict he never chose. A community is left afraid. A family is left grieving. 'When mobility stops, life stops; there is no work, no school and no growth. That's why this summit is so important. A moment where we move from crisis to collaboration, from confrontation to partnership, from fear to a future we can all believe in.' He called on the taxi industry to rise above conflict and fear, and reiterated that the Western Cape government was not there to control or to dictate, but rather to build with the taxi industry. Tackling criminality Security strategist and former Interpol ambassador Andy Mashaile stressed the importance of protecting the taxi industry from infiltration by cartels, syndicates and criminal elements. 'Those are the people who are involved in money laundering, racketeering … those with the money of cash-in-transit heists.' 'Because those individuals want to clean their money, they will, for example, say: 'Here is your gift of R10-million; go and buy yourself some taxis.' That money that came in filthy has now been cleaned because the source of the money cannot now be identified,' said Mashaile. He added that with such vast sums of money involved, the industry was bound to attract organised crime. He called for the implementation of an integrity pact that all taxi associations must sign, which would trigger lifestyle audits on owners. Santaco's Hermanus proposed introducing a cashless system to help the industry deal with extortion. 'There is also the infiltration of the minibus industry by criminal elements, the issue of extortion by gangsters, and also instances of criminal elements within the industry itself extorting members from their own associations. This leads to violence. 'This is why we are discussing a cashless system, because we believe that if we remove cash from the taxi ranks, we will be able to deal with the issue where committee members or executives of associations want to take money from the association and use it for their own ends while eliminating anyone who tries to stop them from doing so,' he said. Hermanus emphasised the importance of vetting minibus taxi operators and drivers. The government, he said, already had those mechanisms in place. 'It is simply a matter of working with us to ensure criminal elements are eliminated,' he said. 'The only thing to do is to deregister that driver from our system — when the registration and vetting kicks you out, then you automatically become deregistered… If you have a criminal record, it is important to look at how long ago it occurred. Rehabilitation will play a critical role.' DM
Eyewitness News
4 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
Tshwane metro says awaiting investigation into 44 dismissed SAMWU workers
JOHANNESBURG - The Tshwane metro says it will only be able to give clarity on the fate of 44 dismissed employees once investigations into allegations against them have been completed. This comes after the South African Municipal Workers' Union (SAMWU) marched to the city's headquarters on Wednesday, calling for the city to honour an agreement of 3.5% salary increases. This in addition to the immediate reinstatement of the dismissed employees. According to the union, the group was unfairly let go in 2021 by the then Democratic Alliance-led administration under former mayor Cilliers Brink. The dismissals in question were effected after a salary increase dispute when the city failed to honor an agreement reached with the union at the time. The agreement was that workers would receive a 3.5% increase in 2021 and a 5.4% boost in 2023.
