Joshlin Smith case: WMACA calls for additional arrests
The case has become a chilling symbol of the ongoing crisis of child trafficking in South Africa.
Joshlin Smith vanished and was reportedly sold for R20 000. The court found that Smith, along with two co-accused, conspired in the sale of the child.
ALSO READ: You have a legal obligation to report child abuse – State Advocate
While WMACA expresses satisfaction with the outcome of the trial, they firmly believe that more individuals were involved who have yet to face justice.
'There was a middleman, and there was a client. Someone wanted something from this child, and we still don't know who they are,' WMACA said. 'There are people who were nearby, who saw or heard things. Too many loose ends remain.'
WMACA is calling on those convicted to come forward with the full truth now. With nothing left to lose, they urge the guilty to reveal the identities of any additional accomplices.
One of the most disturbing aspects of the case, according to WMACA, is the involvement of Joshlin's mother.
'How does a mother even begin a conversation about selling her child? And how does that conversation lead to a buyer, whether for the entire child or body parts? It's diabolical.'
ALSO READ: Bertha Gxowa creates awareness on child abuse
Despite the absence of Joshlin's body, WMACA holds the convicted trio fully responsible for her disappearance, whether she is ultimately found alive or dead.
'Nothing less than a life sentence would have been acceptable,' the organisation stated.
WMACA acknowledges and praises Judge Erasmus for delivering a sentence that sends a strong message.
The organisation mourns that it took such a tragic and horrific case to bring attention to the horrors of child trafficking.
'Justice was served in court, but for Joshlin and countless other children who disappear without a trace, we may never know the full truth. We only wish that a little girl had not met such a gruesome fate for the world to take notice.'
At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The South African
3 hours ago
- The South African
Woman attempts suicide as loan shark increases interest to 400%
A woman attempted suicide in KwaZulu-Natal, Phoenix on Monday, 11 August 2025, after a loan shark unexpectedly increased the interest rate. Initially, the interest rate was 50%; however, the loan shark increased it to 400%. They demanded R100 000 in payback for a R20 000 loan. According to Reaction Unit South Africa (RUSA), the woman's family mentioned that the loan shark changed the interest rate to 400% after seeing that the debt was almost settled. After the woman resisted paying the high interest, the loan shark threatened to send a group of men to repossess her car if the money was not paid. Feeling scared, the woman borrowed smaller amounts of money to pay the loan shark as he continued making demands. The woman called family members and informed them that she intended to jump off a bridge because she had become overwhelmed with debt. She then requested her family to take care of her child. RUSA Spokesperson Prem Balram said that they informed the family about the next steps they need to take to get help for the woman. A suspect was arrested in Verulam, KZN on Tuesday, 12 August 2025, after attacking a family with a knife. The 36-year-old male suspect entered a property on Aslaam Road in Riyadh with intentions to rob the residence. Two family members were having tea in their yard when they suddenly noticed the suspect approaching them. 'The 78-year-old woman and her male domestic worker fled into the house, followed by the suspect. The robber produced a knife and attempted to steal the metal payer statue, but was confronted by a 54-year-old male who exited the bedroom. He stabbed the victim on his hand and fled empty-handed,' said RUSA. The suspect was later caught on Russom Street. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
Eyewitness News
3 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
Joshlin Smith trial: Lourencia Lombaard, 2 co-accused apply for leave to appeal conviction, sentences
CAPE TOWN – A mother and two others convicted of selling her daughter are applying for leave to appeal their convictions and sentences. Kelly Smith, her boyfriend, Jacquen Appollis and his friend Steveno van Rhyn were handed life sentences for human trafficking in May. This is after the court accepted the State's version, that then six-year-old Joshlin Smith was sold to a sangoma in Saldanha Bay in February last year. ALSO READ: Joshlin Smith: Former accused-turned-State witness Lourencia Lombaard returned to the dock The girl is still missing. The matter was adjourned for the day and continues in the Western Cape High Court on Wednesday. Meanwhile, former accused-turned-State witness, Lourencia Lombaard, was also in court to hear the argument around whether she should be granted indemnity. Lombaard had testified to witnessing Smith sell the child for R20,000 in February 2024. The National Prosecuting Authority's Eric Ntabazalila explained: 'We can confirm that arguments began this morning in the application for leave to appeal involving the accused in the Joshlin Smith matter, as well as the Section 204 witness issue involving Ms Lourencia Lombaard. The case has been postponed to tomorrow morning [Wednesday] and judgement is expected to be delivered tomorrow morning on both matters."
The Citizen
4 hours ago
- The Citizen
Bail appeal dismissed for alleged Durban drug dealer accused of bribing survivor
The suspect fatally wounded his former employee and injured another, who survived the shooting. An Durban alleged drug dealer has suffered another setback after his appeal challenging the denial of his release on bail was dismissed. Shirwin Nowtham will remain in custody until his trial begins after his application for leave to appeal was rejected by the KwaZulu-Natal (KZN) High Court. Nowtham was charged with murder and attempted murder in connection with a shooting that took place a year ago. Durban drug dealer 'shoots' his employees It is alleged that on 29 August 2024, Nowtham fatally shot his former employee and wounded another, who survived being shot with a shotgun. The survivor and the deceased had previously worked for Nowtham selling drugs. On the day of the shooting, Nowtham and a man named Stephen arrived in a grey VW Polo and picked them up for another job. At some point, the two victims were forced out of the vehicle, and Nowtham allegedly opened fire on them. ALSO READ: Crime Intelligence CFO, co-accused granted bail in burglary cover-up Nowtham was arrested on 14 September. He was refused bail by the Verulam Magistrate's Court on 4 October. Rather than appealing that ruling immediately, Nowtham later renewed his bail application, citing new evidence. In his application, the accused referred to his son's ongoing illness, his own hypertension, and the survivor's retraction of the claim that he was the shooter. Survivior's statements The survivor had initially made a statement three days before Nowtham's arrest and then a second one on 18 November. In the second statement made to a police officer, the victim confirmed Nowtham had shot him and also claimed that the suspect bribed him during a prison phone call to change his testimony, paying him R5 000 and promised an additional R20 000 to drop the charges. Despite this, the survivor maintained that he did not want to withdraw the charges. On 25 November, attorney Mondli Mthethwa filed an affidavit stating that the survivor, accompanied by two men, approached him wanting to declare that Nowtham was not the shooter. READ MORE: 'Why were alarm bells not sounded sooner?' – Jayden-Lee Meek's mother denied bail The survivor explained that he had first approached the police but was told they did not want to take his statement. The victim then gave a further statement to another attorney, Ivy Mukweka, in January this year in which he claimed that Stephen, not Nowtham, was responsible for the shooting. Nowtham contended that these developments weakened the prosecution's case and amounted to new facts warranting his release on bail. The bail application was, however, denied on 14 March, leading Nowtham to appeal to the high court. High Court judgment In his ruling, Judge Robin Mossop acknowleged that there is 'substantial uncertainty' about the survivor's definitive version of events. He highlighted the state's argument that other evidence, which Nowtham had not focused on, pointed to his involvement. One such fact was that the deceased did not die immediately, and reportedly told a security guard that Nowtham was the shooter. 'That dying declaration was heard by a security guard who, alerted by the sound of the shooting, proceeded to the scene where he found the injured survivor and the dying deceased,' Mossop said. READ MORE: Likely to destroy evidence: Accused's bail bid rejected in Ditebogo Phalane murder case The judge also referenced evidence linking Nowtham with the crime through the grey Polo. 'The security guard apparently stated that he had observed a grey Polo motor vehicle with CY registration plates leaving the scene. 'Immediately after the shootings, the motor vehicle was returned to the dealer who had sold it to the appellant, and it was apparently swapped for another motor vehicle. Why this strange turn of events occurred was not explained by the appellant.' Mossop further pointed out that telephone tower evidence placed Nowtham's phone near the shooting location. He said the Verulam Magistrate's Court gave a 'reasoned judgment' on the bail application based on the new facts. 'Extremely strange' According to Mossop, the only potentially new fact was the sequence of affidavits from the survivor. 'Objectively speaking, the circumstances under which the affidavits that purported to exonerate the appellant came into existence are extremely strange. 'The survivor described himself in the affidavit drafted for him by Ms Mukweka as being an adult unemployed and unmarried male,' the judgment reads. 'In addition, he was apparently a person who had to be given a handout to purchase groceries, yet he was prepared to consult with two different private attorneys to prepare two statements. 'Why did he consult private attorneys? Where did he get the money to do this from? 'Why did he simply not report what he wished to say to the investigating officer and thereby avoid the cost that he must indubitably have incurred consulting with private attorneys? 'I do not accept, as allegedly stated by the survivor and as previously mentioned, that the Saps refused to take his statement. The answers to these questions are not immediately obvious,' Mossop continued. Nowtham's appeal was consequently dismissed as evidence showed his ability to interfere with state witnesses. NOW READ: Cop and prosecutor get bail in R1.6 million extortion case
