Auckland driveway death: Elizabeth Smith pleads guilty to manslaughter of Dean Fifield
Smith returned to the address at about 11pm on June 13, 2024, 'with the intention of recovering property', according to the agreed summary of facts for the case. She brought with her two associates to assist with the task.
Auckland accountant Elizabeth Lynn Smith appears in the High Court at Auckland, charged with the June 2024 murder of Dean Fifield in Massey. The charge was later downgraded to manslaughter. Photo / Michael Craig
Things quickly escalated.
Fifield came out of the house to confront the group, and the associates pulled out of the driveway and onto the road.
'Mr Fifield followed their vehicle on foot and angered by the situation began punching the associate's stationary vehicle with his closed fist, causing damage to the windscreen,' documents state.
Smith, in her own car, a Mazda Axela, then drove out of the driveway and directly into Fifield.
'Ms Smith's vehicle struck Mr Fifield, which propelled him onto the bonnet initially before he fell under the front of Ms Smith's vehicle,' the agreed summary continues. 'Ms Smith continued driving a short distance with Mr Fifield wedged underneath her vehicle.
'Mr Fifield was trapped under the vehicle when it came to a stop on Moire Road.'
Fifield was pronounced dead at the scene, after emergency responders took measures to lift the car.
Auckland resident Dean Fifield was fatally struck by a car in Massey in June 2024. Elizabeth Lynn Smith was charged with murder but instead pleaded guilty today to manslaughter. Photo / Supplied
Fifield previously described himself online as an avid amateur athlete with a background and passion for nutrition and food science.
'I believe you are what you eat, which reflects on happiness and wellbeing in our communities, providing the well-being to be and perform to everyone's best,' he wrote on his LinkedIn profile. 'Developing tasty consumer demanding healthy products which bump off the junk food products is one of my next big goals.'
In online tributes after his death, friends described him as 'a lovely chap' and 'a force to be reckoned with'.
'A big heart, you couldn´t help but want to help anyone that you passed paths with,' one person wrote.
Smith's murder trial had been set to begin in September. She will instead be sentenced next month.
Justice Mathew Downs accepted the guilty plea today, ordering her to remain in custody until sentencing.
Craig Kapitan is an Auckland-based journalist covering courts and justice. He joined the Herald in 2021 and has reported on courts since 2002 in three newsrooms in the US and New Zealand.
Sign up to The Daily H, a free newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Almost 5500 complaints of shoplifting weren't investigated
crime police 32 minutes ago Almost 5500 complaints of shoplifting weren't investigated while a controversial police directive was in place earlier this year. Police executive director of service victims and resolutions Rachael Bambery spoke to Ingrid Hipkiss.
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Retail NZ says members will be 'devastated' by theft incidents not being investigated
Retail New Zealand chief executive Carolyn Young. Photo: Supplied Retail New Zealand says its members will be devastated that while police were directed not to investigate reports of shoplifting below $500, retailers reported almost 5500 incidents of shoplifting that fell into that category. As a result, they were never investigated. The shoplifting complaints were made between March and May this year while the police directive was in place not to investigate reports of shoplifting valued at below $500. Other crimes police were directed not to investigate included general thefts of below $200, petrol drive offs, $150, online fraud and scams of under $1000 and other fraud, $500. But after RNZ reported the directive it was walked back by Police Commissioner Richard Chambers who launched a review to establish how many reports of retail crime were filed away under the controversial directive. That figure has been revealed by RNZ as 5454. Retail New Zealand chief executive Carolyn Young said shop owners were disappointed at the number. "I'm sure they're absolutely devastated that the impact that's happened in their store has not had any follow up and we know from our research that our members have told us that 40 percent of retail crime is not reported and one of the reasons they give is 'cos they think nothing will happen. "So if there was 5400-odd incidents in that two month period, add another 40 percent on and you're probably at the right level of what was occurring. "It just reiterates how big a crime issue is when you say that's the level below $500." She said it was a systemic problem with a devastating impact on the retail system. Young said while it was disappointing when retail crime was not followed up, Retail NZ understood it came down to resourcing. "Whilst we are always really disappointed that the police are unable to follow up on every incident that occurs, we know that one of the principle problems that we've got is resourcing and we just need more police." Young said shoplifting was often repeated by the same offenders and when police didn't investigate the cumulative harm was greater. "One of the things that we know is there is a lot of small level offending. You think about drive-offs at the petrol station - invariably that's under $500 but someone offends five or six times, it's a significant amount of money." "And when you have people that are offending in a supermarket or an apparel store three or four times a week the cumulative factor of that adds up and so the dollar value is not the material piece. "It's actually what harm is that individual doing and how often are they offending and how can we stop that individual person." She said the Police Commissioner had acted swiftly and made a commitment to combating retail crime and Retail NZ was working closely with the police on it. Retail Crime Ministerial Advisory Group chairperson Sunny Kaushal called the number of uninvestigated shoplifting complaints "a shocking figure". "That's why it was so important that Commissioner Chambers responded so quickly to our call for it to be reversed at the earliest opportunity." He said the directive was clearly having an impact on investigations. "Shoplifting is costing New Zealand $1.4 billion a year, and the bill is being paid by every hard working Kiwi through increased prices at the till. "Shoplifting of any value is not okay. Offenders need to know that police will investigate any and all cases reported to them." He also said the Police Commissioner planned to make retail crime a key priority for police. "Retailers are now seeing the benefit of this change in priority, especially in areas that now have a dedicated retail crime team. "I encourage police to scale these efforts so that every area across the country can benefit from the great work of those teams." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Vehicles stolen after NZTA breaches privacy of 1000 owners
Photo: RNZ / Dom Thomas A privacy breach exposed the details of nearly 1000 people in a Transport Agency database over the course of 12 months. The agency said the breach was suspected to have resulted in at least 13 vehicles being targeted for theft. It admitted the problem to RNZ after one of the people affected contacted RNZ. The agency said the problem involved the agency's Motochek system, which allowed registered users to electronically access information held on the Motor Vehicle Register. "NZTA became aware of the breach in May 2025, via a customer complaint and through police as a part of an ongoing investigation. We determined that the unauthorised access resulted from the Motocheck account of an ex-employee of Auckland Auto Collections Ltd being used to access people's names and addresses from the MVR," it said in a statement. "To date we have determined that names and addresses of 951 people were accessed improperly over the 12 months to May 2025, and that at least 13 of these vehicles are suspected to have been targeted for theft." The agency said it was contacting potentially affected people to advise them of the breach, update them on actions being taken to address the situation, and to provide support and advice to address their concerns. "We have sincerely apologised to those affected for the inconvenience and distress caused by the breach," it said. NZTA said it was also assisting police with their investigations of the breach and vehicles which might have been targeted for theft. It had also notified the Office of the Privacy Commissioner. NZTA said it had systems and processes to protect peoples' privacy, including the terms and conditions which authorised users were expected to meet if they accessed the register. "Work is underway to improve the protection of personal information within our registers, with a priority to address risks of harm. This work will involve improvements across policy, contractual, operational and digital aspects of register access," it said. A person affected by the breach was told in a message from NZTA that their full name and address were accessed last year. "We have been unable to confirm the reason why your name and address was accessed. If you feel that your personal safety is at risk, we encourage you to contact NZ Police directly," the message said. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
