New York Times issues clarification over viral photo of Gaza boy
The New York Times has issued a clarification over a viral photograph published by multiple outlets that has become controversial as critics seized on the health condition of the child pictured.
After running the photo on its front page with the headline 'Young, old and sick starve to death in Gaza', the publication confirmed in a statement issued Tuesday that the one-year-old at the centre of the image had been diagnosed with a pre-existing health condition.
In the photograph, which shocked the world last week, 18-month-old Muhammad Zakariya Ayyoub al-Matouq is being cradled by his mother as he faces away from the camera and his spine visibly protrudes from his back.
Muhammad Zakariya Ayyoub al-Matouq is being cradled by his mother in the photograph. Picture: Ahmed Jihad Ibrahim Al-arini/Anadolu/Getty
In a post on X, The New York Times said it had added an Editors' Note to its story after learning the boy 'also had pre-existing health problems' post publication.
'We recently ran a story about Gaza's most vulnerable civilians, including Mohammed Zakaria al-Mutawaq, who is 18 months old and suffers from severe malnutrition,' the accompanying statement read.
'We have since learned new information, including from the hospital that treated him and his medical records, and have updated our story to add context about his pre-existing health problems.'
The newspaper, which is the first to release a clarification, said the additional information 'gives readers a greater understanding of his situation'.
The clarification came after David Collier, a British London-based independent journalist who lived in Israel for 19 years, shared a series of posts on social media 'exposing the truth' behind the viral image.
He claimed a medical report issued in Gaza in May 2025 shows the toddler was born with a serious genetic disorder, suffers from cerebral palsy and has been diagnosed with hypoxaemia – a medical conditional characterised by low oxygen in the blood.
He said other images showed the boy with his three-year-old brother and noted 'both mother and brother are healthy and fed'.
The World Health Organization has recorded 74 malnutrition-related deaths in the Gaza Strip this year, with 63 occurring in July alone.
The deaths include 24 children under five, a child over five, and 38 adults.
Images of Muhammad Zakariya Ayyoub al-Matouq were shared by multiple media outlets last week. Picture: Ahmed Jihad Ibrahim Al-arini/Anadolu/Getty
The photograph was taken in July. Picture: Ahmed Jihad Ibrahim Al-arini/Anadolu/Getty
The photographer, Ahmad al-Arini, told the BBC he took the photo in a bare tent which 'resembled a tomb'.
'I took this photo because I wanted to show the rest of the world the extreme hunger that babies and children are suffering from in the Gaza Strip,' he said.
The image, captured in July, was distributed by Turkish state news service, Anadolu Agency and Getty Images.
Mr Collier claimed a medical report issued in Gaza in May 2025 shows the toddler suffers from cerebral palsy and hypoxaemia. Picture: Ahmed Jihad Ibrahim Al-arini/Anadolu/Getty
Picture: Ahmed Jihad Ibrahim Al-arini/Anadolu/Getty
'Distress': Albanese addresses photo
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese spoke of his emotional response to the distressing picture during question on Monday.
'My question is for the Prime Minister. I have been swamped by electorate people writing to me of their horror of the atrocities occurring in Gaza,'' independent MP Sophie Scamps said.
'France will soon join 147 nations in recognising Palestine as a state and a step towards As we witness the mass starvation and the killing of so many civilians and children in Gaza, when will Australia be prepared to recognise Palestine as a state?'
In response, Mr Albanese, who was not asked directly about the photograph, said he too shared 'the distress that people around the world would feel when they look at young Mohammed, 1 year old'.
'He is not a threat to the state of Israel nor is he someone who can be seen to be a fighter for Hamas,'' he said.
Anthony Albanese spoke of the toddler during Question Time at Parliament House in Canberra. Picture: NewsWire/Martin Ollman
'He's a young child who deserves to be treated appropriately.
'And the position of the Australian government is very clear. That every innocent life matters.
'Every Israeli and every Palestinian. This conflict has stolen far too many innocent lives, tens of thousands of civilians are dead, children are starving.'
In parliament, Mr Albanese said Australia was calling upon Israel to comply immediately with its obligations under international law.
'We have also unequivocally condemned Hamas and said it can play no role whatsoever in the future state of Palestine and hostages must be released immediately,'' he said.
'I make three points about recognition. The first is that my government is committed to a two-state solution. Israel and Palestine.
'That has been a bipartisan position for a long period of time. Australia played a role in the creation of the state of Israel in 1948 and it's something we should be proud of.
'But what was envisaged was two states, not one.'
Originally published as New York Times issues 'new information' about viral Gaza photo
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Herald Sun
18 hours ago
- Herald Sun
Isaac Torpy: Ballarat athlete loses foot to rare cancer
Don't miss out on the headlines from Ballarat. Followed categories will be added to My News. In the space of just six weeks, a friendly and outgoing Ballarat sportsman and student has gone from having a sore foot to braving a life-altering amputation. Isaac Torpy, 20, is recovering in good spirits after a six-hour surgery on Tuesday to remove his right foot following a sudden diagnosis of a rare and aggressive cancer: what started as a persistent pain playing football turned out to be a 7cm synovial sarcoma. The enthusiastic footballer, basketball player, water skier, and commerce student now has up to four months of chemotherapy to endure before returning to life as he knew it before, including his final three units of study at uni. The treatment, meant to knock out any microscopic spread of the foot tumour, will persist through Isaac's 21st birthday. Isaac's dad Chris Torpy said the extremely uncommon form of cancer appeared to be 'just really, really bad luck'. 'It doesn't appear to be hereditary or genetic like other cancers,' he said. 'We've gone from, 'He's just got a bit of a sore foot that hurts occasionally when he knocks it' to 'It could be something bad' to 'Yep, it is something bad, and it has to get amputated'.' Isaac made good use of his foot in the lead-up to his surgery: last Friday, he – as a Demons supporter – got to kick a footy around with Melbourne AFL players. And on Saturday, he played his 150th football match and first senior game for Lake Wendouree, managing to kick a goal himself. Throughout it all, Isaac has been supported by a strong group of school and footy mates, as well as his younger siblings Noah and Olivia. More broadly, a GoFundMe has attracted more than $58,000 in just four days to help cover treatment, travel, and any home modifications, psychological support, and prosthetics needed in the wake of the 'devastating' diagnosis. 'We've been pretty overwhelmed by the community support from people we know and people we don't even know,' Chris said. 'That's been quite amazing. 'Our aim and our hope is that at the end of the this year he can go back to life as normal.' He thanked the healthcare workers involved with Isaac's case.
Herald Sun
2 days ago
- Herald Sun
Cudgewa kindergarten teacher Collette Carkeek faces cancer battle
Don't miss out on the headlines from Albury Wodonga. Followed categories will be added to My News. An Upper Murray kinder teacher and mum of two is fighting to stick around and watch her sons grow up after received a double cancer diagnosis. What started as a sore back turned into the 'toughest fight of her life' when 39-year-old Collette Carkeek received the diagnosis of Non-Hodgkin's lymphoma and stage four metastatic colorectal cancer. Ms Carkeek is fighting the cancers, but faces a long hard road ahead. Her body responded badly to chemotherapy, with her bone marrow depleting to dangerous levels after just one round of treatment, forcing her to undergo an expensive immunotherapy treatment that was not covered by Medicare. It will leave the family at least $75,000 out of pocket. Growing up in the Cudgewa area and working locally in childcare for years, Ms Carkeek is a beloved member of the community. When she was forced to stop playing netball with the Cudgewa Football Netball Club, where her sons also play footy, the tight-knit Upper Murray community jumped into action to support the family in their time of need. In just 48 hours, the many people whose lives Ms Carkeek had touched raised almost $45,000 towards her cancer treatment in a GoFundMe set up by her sister Stacey. 'Colette has spent her life caring for others — working in childcare, teaching at kinder, and giving back to her community. Now, it's our turn to care for her,' she said. Mr Middleton said the support from the community had been 'overwhelming', and the donations would mean Ms Carkeek could receive the treatment she needed to fight off two cancers and keep cheering on her sons at footy for years to come.
The Age
3 days ago
- The Age
Australia helps develop world-first vaccine against devastating virus
In a sign of how seriously governments treat the risk of foot-and-mouth, scores of cattle carcasses were buried on a research farm this year in Victoria as part of preparations for a potential outbreak. The cows died of toxic weed poisoning, not disease, but the trial is testing how best to compost and decontaminate dead cows should foot-and-mouth strike. An mRNA vaccine could roll out within weeks of an outbreak, potentially saving herds from large-scale culling. The vaccines also provide something called DIVA capacity (differentiating infected from vaccinated animals), which allows responders to test which animals were vaccinated and which were naturally infected, helping to more precisely define the scale of an outbreak. 'That may be something that speeds up a return to international trade after an incursion,' Laurence said. Foot-and-mouth disease has been eradicated from Australia for more than a century. America is also free from the disease, although some have raised concerns infected meat could be imported into the US from risky countries, processed and then sent to Australia. Loading 'I'm not convinced that the potential for importing beef from the US exposes us more to risk, but the fact is that we've now got foot-and-mouth, and lumpy skin disease, on our doorstep in Indonesia. So the risk of an incursion has actually gone up,' Laurence said. The vaccines use stands of 'messenger RNA' or mRNA that code for small viral proteins. When the mRNA is introduced to the body, muscle cells make the protein, which triggers the production of antibodies ready to attack the actual virus upon infection. The mRNA breaks down naturally in the body. 'It's simply an instruction set that we send to the body to ask the immune system to prepare a defence for a particular disease,' Peter McGrath from Tiba Biotech, the US-based company that developed the vaccine, said. 'So it's actually the simplest and safest way to make a vaccine of any technology currently available.' The vaccines last for a year in the fridge, or a month at room temperature, unlike early COVID-19 mRNA vaccines which had to be stored at sub-zero temperatures. In a trial of nine vaccinated cows exposed to the virus in Germany, none contracted the disease or shed the virus. 'That's never been achieved anywhere in the world before,' said Dr Peter Kirkland, from the Elizabeth Macarthur Agricultural Institute, which helped test and develop the vaccine. The vaccine could be made and distributed very quickly with the right setup, Kirkland, a NSW Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development scientist, said. 'You could actually roll out this vaccine potentially within a week of an outbreak starting.' The UNSW RNA Institute is working on the capability to manufacture the vaccine, he said. The Sydney institute is part of a newly announced $17.6 million RNA Research and Training Network, which aims to boost the RNA workforce in NSW. Loading Moderna's new taxpayer-funded mRNA factory in Melbourne rejected the NSW government's request to make the new vaccine, which still requires registration from the Australian Pesticides and Veterinary Medicines Authority. 'Developing local capacity to produce vaccines against emergency animal diseases is a critical priority for the NSW Government, Australia's livestock industries and our economy,' Agriculture Minister Tara Moriarty said.
