Hong Kong's security chief attacks Guardian newspaper over Jimmy Lai claim
Hong Kong's security minister has hit out at a British news outlet for 'smearing remarks' made in an article about the top court's rejection of an appeal by former media boss Jimmy Lai Chee-ying over the hiring of a foreign lawyer.
Advertisement
Secretary for Security Chris Tang Ping-keung on Sunday wrote to The Guardian to defend the Court of Final Appeal's recent rejection of Lai's appeal over an earlier decision to stop his preferred British lawyer, King's Counsel Timothy Owen, from representing him.
Headlined 'The obscure Jimmy Lai ruling that exposed the erosion of Hong Kong's rule of law', the article published on March 22 discussed the implications of the court's decision by quoting several legal experts, including former United Kingdom supreme court judge Jonathan Sumption and ex-chairman of the Hong Kong Bar Association Paul Harris.
They said the rule of law in Hong Kong was 'profoundly compromised' and the fact the decisions made by the national security committee could not be legally challenged 'effectively gives the committee the powers of a police state'.
Lai won approval for Owen to represent him in 2022, and the government lost its appeals to block the move.
Advertisement
Chief Executive John Lee Ka-chiu then sought an interpretation of the national security law by the country's top legislative body, which later gave the city's leader and the national security committee the final say on the matter, with the decisions of the latter not open to judicial review.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
HKFP
9 hours ago
- HKFP
Hong Kong justice minister downplays departure of foreign judges, says numbers ‘not main point'
Hong Kong's justice chief has downplayed the departure of foreign judges in recent years, saying it is not about their numbers but whether the judges have 'a good international reputation.' Secretary for Justice Paul Lam told Cable News in an interview published on Monday that the city's foreign judges system was still effective. 'There are new [foreign] appointed judges who are willing to join. Would you say [the system] is useless?' Lam said in Cantonese. 'If they think they wouldn't make any contribution if they were to come here, [I] believe they would not come to Hong Kong to help,' he added. The top official's comments follow a recent exodus of foreign judges from the city's top court. The most recent departure was former Australian justice Robert French, who resigned in April and said the role of foreign judges in the court had become 'arguably cosmetic.' In June, a New Zealand judge, William Young, joined the city's Court of Final Appeal (CFA). There are currently six overseas judges in the top court, compared with 15 at its peak. Lam told Cable News that the number of foreign judges was 'not the main point.' 'It's about what type of people come, and whether they have a good international reputation,' he said. The justice minister also dismissed Hong Kong's fall in the global rule of law index. 'Regarding human rights and freedoms, I believe that their ranking of Hong Kong… does not reflect the actual situation. This might be an issue of external perception,' he said, adding that Western countries often did not have a 'comprehensive' judgement of Hong Kong. Top court exodus Since the CFA's establishment in 1997, it has sporadically extended invitations to judges from other common law jurisdictions to join its panel. This practice has been regarded as a testament to the international community's trust in the city's judicial system. Last year, however, the apex court lost five judges. Anthony Murray Gleeson from Australia did not renew his term when it ended in February 2024, citing old age; UK judges Jonathan Sumption and Lawrence Collins quit in June 2024 before their terms ended; while Canada's Beverley McLachlin and the UK's Nicholas Phillips did not extend their terms. Sumption wrote an opinion piece for the Financial Times just days after his resignation, saying Hong Kong was 'slowly becoming a totalitarian state.' Judges operate in an 'almost impossible political environment created by China,' he said. Before the recent string of departures, two British judges in 2022, Robert Reed and Patrick Hodge, quit the CFA, citing the erosion of political freedoms.
HKFP
3 days ago
- HKFP
Lingnan University student sues school over disqualification from top council election
A student at Hong Kong's Lingnan University is challenging in court the school's decision to disqualify him from a top council election last year. Isaac Lai, vice-chair of the Lingnan University Students' Union, appeared at the High Court on Friday to dispute the public university's decision to bar him from running in the top governing council election last November. At that time, the university accused Lai of 'promoting himself by non-official means' and disqualified him from the election one day before the vote, according to local media reports. Lai filed the lawsuit in March, asking the court to overturn the university's decision after his internal complaint to the university council was rejected. Lingnan University registrar Margaret Cheung and the university council were listed as the respondents in Lai's challenge. Lawyers for Lai told the court on Friday that he only used his personal Instagram account to share his election platform, Sing Tao reported. That account was private and not openly accessible, they said. They also argued that the university's election rules did not explicitly restrict candidates from promoting themselves through official means, and that Lai's disqualification was unlawful. But lawyers representing the university argued that the rule restricting election promotion to official channels could ensure a 'fair election.' Lai knew the rule but deliberately posted QR codes linking to his Instagram account on campus, hence breaking election rules, the university's lawyers said. Judge Russell Coleman will hand down his judgment on or before July 31.
RTHK
3 days ago
- RTHK
Xi sends condolences to Modi and Charles over crash
Xi sends condolences to Modi and Charles over crash Narendra Modi visits the sole crash survivor Vishwash Kumar Ramesh at a hospital in Ahmedabad. Photo: AFP Relatives try and console each other at a mortuary in Ahmedabad. Photo: AFP President Xi Jinping on Friday extended condolences to Indian President Droupadi Murmu and Prime Minister Narendra Modi over the heavy casualties caused by the crash of an Air India flight. He also sent a message of condolences to Britain's King Charles III over the heavy British death toll. Xi's condolences came as rescue teams with sniffer dogs combed the crash site of the London-bound passenger jet that ploughed into a residential area of India's Ahmedabad city on Thursday, killing at least 265 people on board and on the ground. The airline said there were 169 Indian passengers, 53 British, seven Portuguese and a Canadian on board the flight bound for London's Gatwick airport, as well as 12 crew members. Only one person aboard the Air India Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner – carrying 242 passengers and crew – miraculously survived the fiery crash, which left the tailpiece of the aircraft jutting out of the second floor of a hostel for medical staff from a nearby hospital. The nose and front wheel landed on a canteen building where students were having lunch, witnesses said. Deputy Commissioner of Police Kanan Desai said 265 bodies had so far been counted – suggesting at least 24 people died on the ground – but the toll may rise as more body parts are recovered. Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who on Friday visited the devastated neighbourhood where Air India flight 171 went down, earlier described the crash as "heartbreaking beyond words". In an unrelated development, an Air India flight from Phuket to New Delhi received an onboard bomb threat on Friday and made an emergency landing on the island, airport authorities said. All 156 passengers on flight AI 379 had been escorted from the plane, in line with emergency plans, an Airports of Thailand official said. The aircraft took off from Phuket airport bound for the Indian capital at 9.30am but made a wide loop around the Andaman Sea and landed back on the southern Thai island, according to flight tracker Flightradar24. (Xinhua/AFP/Reuters)
