Commentary: As Singapore builds up, can it hold on to its memories?
It's not surprising. In land-scarce Singapore, housing is one of the most talked about and debated topics.
But tucked away in the 47-point media release and stack of annexes was a concept for several so-called 'identity corridors' that were first introduced in URA's Long-Term Plan Review in 2022.
What are identity corridors? And how can they help foster Singapore's national and urban identity?
CITIES REPRESENT SOCIAL IDENTITY
In their 2013 book The Spirit of Cities: Why the Identity of a City Matters in a Global Age, political scientists Daniel A Bell and Avner de-Shalit argue that every city expresses a set of distinctive values or ethos.
In that book, Singapore is strongly associated with the ethos of nation-building. This too, is hardly surprising.
Singapore's position as a thriving and liveable global city today is very much an outcome of our nation-building efforts. The outcome of these efforts is clear. The IMD World Competitiveness Index 2025 ranks us as the second most competitive economy in the world.
But this progress comes with big changes. As Singapore's economy grew rapidly, so too did the changes in its urban landscape. The kampungs that dotted our island made way for high-rise public housing with cleaner and more modern living conditions. The old National Library building, much-beloved by students and readers of that era, gave way for the Fort Canning Tunnel.
In some instances, brand new spaces were created to cater to our socio-economic needs. For instance, the Marina Bay district was developed as an extension of the Central Business District (CBD), which had become increasingly crowded as global banks and corporations flocked to Singapore during its rapid growth as a financial hub through the 1990s and 2000s.
This is not unique to Singapore. In many cities, rapid economic development can result in equally rapid changes in the urban landscape. These can have implications for a city's social fabric.
For instance, Google's entry into Zurich has given rise to extensive gentrification and a spike in housing costs and consequent public unhappiness and protests. Protesters blamed large banks and companies for driving up housing costs and accessibility.
In land-constrained cities, heritage sites and buildings can be particularly vulnerable in the face of rapid economic and urban transformation. A 2024 report by the World Monuments Fund identified rapid urbanisation and overtourism as top threats to heritage conservation.
At the same time, cities cannot survive without economic growth. The first cities of the world had emerged due to the confluence of economic and human activity within their boundaries. Cities today continue to thrive as key nodes in global trade and finance.
Even as Singapore continues to grow as a major economic and financial hub, it will need to preserve aspects of the city that reflect citizens' memories, identity and aspirations.
PRESERVING SINGAPORE'S ZEITGEIST
In response to a question that was posed to me during the launch of the 2025 draft master plan, I had mentioned that '(w)e want to plan for our future climate needs, our socio-economic needs; but at the same time, we want to preserve some of the spaces that sort of define the zeitgeist of Singapore'.
Like Bell and de-Shalit, I too feel that Singapore's identity is very much defined by our nation-building efforts. It is therefore important that we conserve some of the spaces that have played key roles in our nation-building story. The NatSteel building that was recently proposed for conservation is a good example of this.
However, Singapore's national identity is much more than our nation-building journey, important as that may be. It comprises a rich tapestry of cultural practices and lived experiences that have accreted over multiple generations.
This is where the URA's identity corridors will play an important role in conserving and even enhancing the identity and heritage that already exist in many of our iconic spaces and neighbourhoods.
For instance, the Historic East corridor includes culturally rich and ethnically diverse neighbourhoods such as Geylang Serai, Joo Chiat and Katong. By linking up these neigbourhoods, the Historic East identity corridor provides a more cohesive and integrated experience of these neighbourhoods' heritage and identity. This can in turn generate greater interactions between visitors and residents and interest in the traditional crafts and food that continue to be found in these neighbourhoods.
Think you know all about Katong-Joo Chiat? There's so much more to discover! From old-school charm to modern experiences, go on an exciting adventure with Toufiq, our urban designer, and local heritage business owner Michael as they reveal the best-kept secrets of the Historic East Corridor. Have ideas to shape the future of our Identity Corridors? Sign up for our visioning workshops at: go.gov.sg/HEIdentityWorkshopFB #DMP2025 #SpaceForOurDreams #IdentityCorridors #Katong #JooChiat #ExploreSG
Posted by Urban Redevelopment Authority on Wednesday, November 13, 2024
Cities are much more than just buildings and infrastructure. They are living repositories of the shared memories, stories and traditions of the people who live in them.
The two need not be mutually exclusive. Through sensitive urban planning, our built environment can be planned and designed to highlight and enhance our rich cultural heritage and foster a sense of belonging among residents.
Even as Singapore continues to experience rapid economic and urban transformation, there remains a need to preserve and grow the Singaporean spirit or zeitgeist. This means ensuring a lived environment that both protects and expands on our rich cultural identity.
Dr Woo Jun Jie is Senior Lecturer at the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, National University of Singapore. He researches global cities in Asia, with a strong focus on urban governance, policy design and economic development. He is the author of several books on the emergence and development of global financial hubs in Asia.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNA
2 hours ago
- CNA
Digital literacy: About 250,000 people to benefit from S$3m boost to national fund, workshops
About 250,000 seniors, youths and individuals with special needs will benefit from a new S$3 million boost to a national fund promoting digital inclusion. Separately, there will be workshops on everyday banking and Generative AI to help people build practical digital skills. It is part of a renewed three-year tie-up between Singapore's largest bank and the Infocomm Media Development Authority. Karen Ngui, MD and Head at DBS Foundation, and Douglas Goh, Director, Digital Engagement and Adoption at the SG Digital Office at the Infocomm Media Development Authority, talk about why this initiative is important for Singapore and DBS. They also talk about how they will recruit participants for these workshops.
CNA
2 hours ago
- CNA
Local antique stores see boost in sales of Singapore-related items
Some local antique stores have seen sales of Singapore-related items increase by up to 40 per cent this year, compared with last year. This is as the nation celebrates its 60th birthday. Their customers are also younger, as a new generation, spurred by social media, unpacks the nation's history through vintage items. In this lead-up to National Day, Muhammad Bahajjaj finds out the appeal of these items.
Independent Singapore
2 hours ago
- Independent Singapore
Stuck in reception but dreams of banking: 'Should I quit now or power through to land my real career?'
SINGAPORE: Starting a new job can be exciting. You have a fresh environment, new coworkers, and the rewarding feeling of earning your own money, but what if that job feels completely wrong from the very beginning? That's the situation for one recent graduate who sought advice, information, and a different viewpoint on Reddit. After just one month as a receptionist at a large consulting firm, she was already doubting her choice. With a degree in banking and dreams of a career in finance, this current job felt more like a distraction than a step forward, even though it was secure. The big question is whether she should stay, quit, or leave this short experience off her resume as if it never happened. Experience vs. direction The Reddit post sparked a lively discussion among users. Many recognised the poster's situation as a common early-career crossroads. One user asked a blunt question: 'Why did you take the job in the first place?' It's a fair challenge. Was it just to pay the bills? To gain some workplace experience? Or was it a temporary choice until a better opportunity came along? Whatever the reason, the reality is clear: The longer someone stays in an unrelated role, the more it risks pulling them off course. 'You need to move ASAP to avoid getting stuck in your current role,' one commenter urged. Staying too long in a non-finance position could make it harder to convince future employers of your commitment to the industry. See also Revenge quitting is the new rage—but here's why it could backfire However, others warned against quitting without a plan. 'If you need the money, keep working while you search for a job. If you don't need the income, think about quitting and concentrating fully on landing a finance role,' another person advised. In short, it's not just about appearance; it's also about your financial situation. The resume debate: To list or not to list? Some people had mixed feelings about the idea of simply leaving out a job that lasted only one or two months from a resume. While it's true that you don't have to mention every short-term job, some wondered if hiding it would really help your long-term goals. 'If it doesn't relate to your field and doesn't add value, you might leave it off,' one commenter said. 'But it's still a valid job at a respected company, and if you present it well, it can show that you are adaptable and hardworking.' Ultimately, the choice depends on how well the experience fits your story. If you're applying for finance roles, a customer-facing position might not seem directly relevant, but it can highlight communication skills, professionalism, and reliability—all important in any field. See also 8 proven tips for successfully scaling an e-commerce business What employers in finance actually want Several users brought the talk back to the basics: What do employers in banking and finance look for? 'Relevant internships, good grades from a respected university, and connections who can recommend you,' one experienced user summarised. 'The closer the role is to the front office, the tougher the competition.' This means that a receptionist role, while respectable, might not add much to your resume. Instead, users encouraged the original poster to take action: Enrol in relevant courses, get certifications like CFA Level 1 or in financial modelling, and apply for internships aggressively—even unpaid ones if possible. Internships in finance aren't just stepping stones; they often lead to full-time jobs. So, what must be done? If you find yourself in a similar situation—stuck in a job that doesn't match your degree or goals—here's a summary of your options based on the advice given: Quit immediately (if you can afford it): Focus entirely on applying for finance jobs, take courses to improve your skills, and network actively. You might leave the receptionist job off your resume entirely. Stay (if finances require it): Continue job hunting in your free time. Present the current role as a transitional one on your resume, emphasising transferable skills. Upskill and intern : Whether you quit or stay, find time for courses and certifications. Seek internships—some users stressed that they can be more valuable than entry-level jobs when moving into finance. Final thoughts Starting in the 'wrong' job doesn't mean your career is doomed. However, staying there without a plan might be. Whether you include that short-term role on your resume or not is less important than what you do next. Focus on improving your skills, building connections, and aiming for roles that match your degree. Your true career hasn't started yet; it's just waiting for you to show up.
