Two rights groups are first major Israeli voices to accuse Israel of genocide
Charlotte Greenfield
and
Emily Rose
, Reuters
People gather around an impact crater in the aftermath of overnight Israeli bombardment in Khan Yunis in the southern Gaza Strip on 28 July, 2025.
Photo:
AFP
Two Israeli human rights organisations say Israel is committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza, the first major voices in Israeli society to level the strongest possible accusation against the state, which vehemently denies it.
Rights group B'Tselem and Physicians for Human Rights Israel released their reports at a press conference in Jerusalem on Monday (local time), saying Israel was carrying out "coordinated, deliberate action to destroy Palestinian society in the Gaza strip".
"The report we are publishing today is one we never imagined we would have to write," said Yuli Novak, B'Tselem's executive director. "The people of Gaza have been displaced, bombed and starved, left completely stripped of their humanity and rights."
Physicians for Human Rights Israel focused on damage to Gaza's healthcare system, saying: "Israel's actions have destroyed Gaza's healthcare infrastructure in a manner that is both calculated and systematic".
Israel has fended off accusations of genocide since the early days of the Gaza war, including a case brought by South Africa at the International Court of Justice in the Hague that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu condemned as "outrageous".
A spokesperson for the Israeli government called the allegation made by the rights groups on Monday "baseless".
"There is no intent, (which is) key for the charge of genocide ... it simply doesn't make sense for a country to send in 1.9 million tons of aid most of that being food, if there is an intent of genocide," said spokesperson David Mencer.
A spokesperson for Israel's military did not immediately respond to request for comment.
Accusations of genocide have particular gravity in Israel because of the origins of the concept in the work of Jewish legal scholars in the wake of the Nazi Holocaust. Israeli officials have in the past said using the word against Israel was libellous and antisemitic.
When Amnesty International said in December that Israel had committed genocidal acts, Israel's foreign ministry called the global rights group a "deplorable and fanatical organisation".
The 1948 Genocide Convention, adopted globally after the mass murder of Jews by the Nazis, defines genocide as "acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group".
Israel launched its war in Gaza after Hamas-led fighters attacked Israeli communities across the border on 7 October 2023, killing 1200 people, mostly civilians, and taking 251 hostages back to Gaza. Israel has often described that attack, the deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust, as genocidal.
Since then, Israel's offensive has killed nearly 60,000 people in Gaza, mostly civilians, according to Gaza health officials, reduced much of the enclave to ruins, and displaced nearly the entire population of more than two million.
Israel has consistently said its actions are justified as self-defence, and Hamas is to blame for all harm to civilians, for refusing to release hostages and surrender, and for operating in civilian areas, which the group denies.
International attention to the plight of the Palestinians in Gaza has intensified in recent weeks, with UN agencies saying the territory is running out of food for its 2.2 million people.
Israel, which controls all supplies in and out of Gaza, says it has let enough food in, and blames the UN for failing to distribute it. Israel shut off all supplies into Gaza in March for nearly three months, reopening the territory in May but with new restrictions it says are needed to prevent aid from ending up in the hands of fighters. Since then, its forces have shot dead hundreds of Gazans trying to reach food distribution sites.
Israel has announced measures in recent days to increase aid supplies, including pausing fighting in some locations, allowing airlifts of food and safer corridors for aid.
Throughout the conflict, Israeli media have tended to focus mainly on the plight of Israeli hostages in Gaza, with less attention given to Palestinian civilians. Footage widely broadcast in other countries of destruction and casualties in Gaza is rarely shown on Israeli TV.
That has been changing, with recent images of starving children having a little more impact, said Oren Persico from The Seventh Eye, a group that tracks trends in Israeli media.
"It's very slowly evolving," he said. "You see cracks."
But he did not expect the genocide allegation would spark a major shift in attitudes: "The Israeli perception is: 'what do you want from us? It's Hamas' fault, if it would only put down its weapons and (release) the hostages this could all be over'."
In an editorial on the mainstream news site Ynet last Monday, journalist Sever Plotzker said images of Palestinians rejoicing over the 7 October attacks and abusing hostages had made Israelis "blind to Gaza". The Israeli public "now interprets the destruction and killing in Gaza as a deterrent retaliation and therefore also morally legitimate".
In a comment in the Jerusalem Post on Sunday, Dani Dayan, the chairman of Israel's Yad Vashem Holocaust memorial, said it was not accurate to accuse Israel of committing genocide.
"But that does not mean we should not acknowledge the suffering of civilians in Gaza. There are many men, women, and children with no connection to terrorism who are experiencing devastation, displacement, and loss," he wrote. "Their anguish is real, and our moral tradition obligates us not to turn away from it."
- Reuters
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Israeli hostage families hold emergency protest after Gaza militants release videos showing emaciated captives
By Billy Stockwell , Eugenia Yosef , Ibrahim Dahman , Mitchell McCluskey , Dana Karni , Catherine Nicholls and Lauren Izso , CNN Pictures of Israeli hostages held in Gaza during a demonstration outside the Kirya military headquarters in Tel Aviv. Photo: Abir Sultan/EPA/Shutterstock via CNN Newsource Protesters have gathered in Tel Aviv's 'Hostage Square' to stage an emergency protest, after the release of propaganda videos showing emaciated Israeli hostages still held in Gaza. Videos released by militant groups Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad this week showed Israeli hostages Evyatar David and Rom Braslavski in a visibly fragile state. In one video, the undated footage of David was juxtaposed with images of starving Palestinian children. A poster outside the Tel Aviv Museum of Art showing hostage Evyatar David. Photo: AFP / Getty Images via CNN Newsource They are among 50 hostages who remain in the territory, at least 20 of them are believed to be alive. The militant groups released the videos with ceasefire talks stalled and as Palestinians faced a mounting starvation crisis in the enclave. Steve Witkoff, the United States' special envoy to the Middle East, attended the public plaza on Saturday amid the protests, one day after he visited a controversial US-backed aid distribution site in the Gaza Strip. Witkoff later held a "very emotional meeting" that lasted nearly three hours with about 40 representatives of the hostage families, a source who was in attendance at the meeting told CNN. During the meeting, Witkoff said ceasefire negotiations between Israel and Hamas should be "all or nothing", with all 50 hostages in Gaza being returned to Israel in one go, the Hostages and Missing Families Forum cited him as saying. "The plan is not to expand the war, but to end it," Witkoff reportedly said. "We think the negotiations should be changed to all or nothing. "End the war and bring all 50 hostages home at the same time - that's the only way," "Someone will be to blame" if the remaining living hostages do not return to Israel still alive, Witkoff said, according to the forum. According to the forum, Witkoff said that the US would "get your children home and hold Hamas responsible for any bad acts on their part" and "do what's right for the Gazan people". "We have a plan to end the war and bring everyone home," he reportedly added. Reached for comment, Witkoff's team did not offer any further information on the special envoy's comments. The hostage families - who have frequently said that ongoing fighting in Gaza endangered their loved ones - on Saturday (local time) called for an end to the war in the territory and a "comprehensive deal" that would see the remaining hostages freed. Tens of thousands of people took to the streets to call for the release of the hostages. "Against the backdrop of horrifying footage and harsh reports about the hostages' condition - hostage families will cry out this morning in the heart of Tel Aviv," a statement from Israel's hostage families said. "We appeal to the Israeli government and the US administration - look our loved ones and us in the eyes." A poster outside the Tel Aviv Museum of Art showing hostage Rom Braslavski. Photo: AFP / Getty Images via CNN Newsource Ofir Braslavski, the father of Rom, said that he did not recognise his son, when he first saw him in the video. "My Rom is hungry for bread, thirsty for water, sick, physically broken and mentally shattered," he said. "My child is dying! "I address you, [Israeli] Prime Minister [Benjamin Netanyahu]: Enough! The phased approach to deals has failed. "Make the decision already - end the war and bring everyone here - the hostages, the fallen soldiers, the fighters, the reservists and those displaced from their homes. "We want to rehabilitate, to return to life, to breathe." David's brother, Ilay, said that the treatment of his sibling was "a brutal, barbaric assault on every shred of basic human decency. It's an act so vile, it scars the very soul of humanity". He called on the Israeli government and US President Donald Trump to do "everything in your power, by any means necessary" to save the hostages. Netanyahu spoke with the families of the hostages on Saturday evening, and expressed "profound shock" over the harrowing images released by Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad. "The cruelty of Hamas has no boundaries," he said. "While the State of Israel is allowing the entry of humanitarian aid to the residents of Gaza, the terrorists of Hamas are deliberately starving our hostages, and document them in a cynical and evil manner." Netanyahu told the families that the "efforts to return all our hostages are ongoing, and will continue constantly and relentlessly", according to the Israeli Prime Minister's Office. Israel Defense Forces (IDF) Chief of Staff Lt General Eyal Zamir said on Friday that fighting would continue "without rest" in Gaza, if there was no hostage deal. "I estimate that, in the coming days, we will know whether we will succeed in reaching a partial deal for the release of our captives," he said. "If not, the fighting will continue without rest." On Friday, the armed wing of Hamas released an undated video showing 24-year-old David - who was taken hostage at the Nova music festival on 7 October, 2023 - being held in a narrow cell. The Hostages and Missing Families Forum Headquarters initially cautioned against using imagery from the video, but later said that David's family had authorised the publication of a still image. On Saturday, Hamas released a new video featuring David, which appeared to be a longer version of the video released on Friday. A similar propaganda video was published by Palestinian Islamic Jihad on Thursday showing Braslavski also in a frail state. Islamic Jihad said it was the last video taken of the hostage, before the group lost contact in July, with the militants holding him. Earlier this week, a UN-backed food security agency warned that "the worst case scenario of famine " was unfolding in Gaza, its starkest alert yet, as Israel faces growing international pressure to allow more food into the territory. Hospitals across the Gaza Strip were overwhelmed, with bed occupancy reaching more than 200 percent at several facilities, according to the enclave's health ministry. Beds were being placed in corridors and on floors to accommodate increasing numbers of patients and casualties, it said. Seven people had died from malnutrition in the past 24 hours, the health ministry said Saturday, including one child, bringing the total death toll from starvation since the conflict began in 2023 to 169. In addition, at least 39 people were killed and more than 800 injured in the same period, while waiting for aid in different parts of the territory, the ministry added. - CNN
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Israeli hostage families protest after Gaza militants release videos of emaciated captives
By Billy Stockwell , Eugenia Yosef , Ibrahim Dahman , Mitchell McCluskey , Dana Karni , Catherine Nicholls and Lauren Izso , CNN Pictures of Israeli hostages held in Gaza during a demonstration outside the Kirya military headquarters in Tel Aviv. Photo: Abir Sultan/EPA/Shutterstock via CNN Newsource Protesters have gathered in Tel Aviv's 'Hostage Square' to stage an emergency protest, after the release of propaganda videos showing emaciated Israeli hostages still held in Gaza. Videos released by militant groups Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad this week showed Israeli hostages Evyatar David and Rom Braslavski in a visibly fragile state. In one video, the undated footage of David was juxtaposed with images of starving Palestinian children. A poster outside the Tel Aviv Museum of Art showing hostage Evyatar David. Photo: AFP / Getty Images via CNN Newsource They are among 50 hostages who remain in the territory, at least 20 of them are believed to be alive. The militant groups released the videos with ceasefire talks stalled and as Palestinians faced a mounting starvation crisis in the enclave. Steve Witkoff, the United States' special envoy to the Middle East, attended the public plaza on Saturday amid the protests, one day after he visited a controversial US-backed aid distribution site in the Gaza Strip. Witkoff later held a "very emotional meeting" that lasted nearly three hours with about 40 representatives of the hostage families, a source who was in attendance at the meeting told CNN. During the meeting, Witkoff said ceasefire negotiations between Israel and Hamas should be "all or nothing", with all 50 hostages in Gaza being returned to Israel in one go, the Hostages and Missing Families Forum cited him as saying. "The plan is not to expand the war, but to end it," Witkoff reportedly said. "We think the negotiations should be changed to all or nothing. "End the war and bring all 50 hostages home at the same time - that's the only way," "Someone will be to blame" if the remaining living hostages do not return to Israel still alive, Witkoff said, according to the forum. According to the forum, Witkoff said that the US would "get your children home and hold Hamas responsible for any bad acts on their part" and "do what's right for the Gazan people". "We have a plan to end the war and bring everyone home," he reportedly added. Reached for comment, Witkoff's team did not offer any further information on the special envoy's comments. The hostage families - who have frequently said that ongoing fighting in Gaza endangered their loved ones - on Saturday (local time) called for an end to the war in the territory and a "comprehensive deal" that would see the remaining hostages freed. Tens of thousands of people took to the streets to call for the release of the hostages. "Against the backdrop of horrifying footage and harsh reports about the hostages' condition - hostage families will cry out this morning in the heart of Tel Aviv," a statement from Israel's hostage families said. "We appeal to the Israeli government and the US administration - look our loved ones and us in the eyes." A poster outside the Tel Aviv Museum of Art showing hostage Rom Braslavski. Photo: AFP / Getty Images via CNN Newsource Ofir Braslavski, the father of Rom, said that he did not recognise his son, when he first saw him in the video. "My Rom is hungry for bread, thirsty for water, sick, physically broken and mentally shattered," he said. "My child is dying! "I address you, [Israeli] Prime Minister [Benjamin Netanyahu]: Enough! The phased approach to deals has failed. "Make the decision already - end the war and bring everyone here - the hostages, the fallen soldiers, the fighters, the reservists and those displaced from their homes. "We want to rehabilitate, to return to life, to breathe." David's brother, Ilay, said that the treatment of his sibling was "a brutal, barbaric assault on every shred of basic human decency. It's an act so vile, it scars the very soul of humanity". He called on the Israeli government and US President Donald Trump to do "everything in your power, by any means necessary" to save the hostages. Netanyahu spoke with the families of the hostages on Saturday evening, and expressed "profound shock" over the harrowing images released by Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad. "The cruelty of Hamas has no boundaries," he said. "While the State of Israel is allowing the entry of humanitarian aid to the residents of Gaza, the terrorists of Hamas are deliberately starving our hostages, and document them in a cynical and evil manner." Netanyahu told the families that the "efforts to return all our hostages are ongoing, and will continue constantly and relentlessly", according to the Israeli Prime Minister's Office. Israel Defense Forces (IDF) Chief of Staff Lt General Eyal Zamir said on Friday that fighting would continue "without rest" in Gaza, if there was no hostage deal. "I estimate that, in the coming days, we will know whether we will succeed in reaching a partial deal for the release of our captives," he said. "If not, the fighting will continue without rest." On Friday, the armed wing of Hamas released an undated video showing 24-year-old David - who was taken hostage at the Nova music festival on 7 October, 2023 - being held in a narrow cell. The Hostages and Missing Families Forum Headquarters initially cautioned against using imagery from the video, but later said that David's family had authorised the publication of a still image. On Saturday, Hamas released a new video featuring David, which appeared to be a longer version of the video released on Friday. A similar propaganda video was published by Palestinian Islamic Jihad on Thursday showing Braslavski also in a frail state. Islamic Jihad said it was the last video taken of the hostage, before the group lost contact in July, with the militants holding him. Earlier this week, a UN-backed food security agency warned that "the worst case scenario of famine " was unfolding in Gaza, its starkest alert yet, as Israel faces growing international pressure to allow more food into the territory. Hospitals across the Gaza Strip were overwhelmed, with bed occupancy reaching more than 200 percent at several facilities, according to the enclave's health ministry. Beds were being placed in corridors and on floors to accommodate increasing numbers of patients and casualties, it said. Seven people had died from malnutrition in the past 24 hours, the health ministry said Saturday, including one child, bringing the total death toll from starvation since the conflict began in 2023 to 169. In addition, at least 39 people were killed and more than 800 injured in the same period, while waiting for aid in different parts of the territory, the ministry added. - CNN
RNZ News
11 hours ago
- RNZ News
US envoy tells Israeli hostage families he is working on plan to end Gaza war
By Emily Rose , Reuters Families of Israelis held hostage in Tel Aviv square during US envoy Steve Witkoff's visit on 2 August 2025. Photo: Jack Guez / AFP US President Donald Trump's Middle East envoy told families of hostages being held by Palestinian militant group Hamas that he was working with the Israeli government on a plan that would effectively end the war in Gaza. Trump has made ending the conflict a major priority of his administration, though negotiations have faltered. Steve Witkoff is visiting Israel as its government faces mounting pressure over the deteriorating humanitarian conditions in the enclave. In a recording of the Saturday (local time) meeting, reviewed by Reuters , Witkoff is heard saying: "We have a very, very good plan that we're working on collectively with the Israeli government, with Prime Minister Netanyahu ... for the reconstruction of Gaza. That effectively means the end of the war." The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment on his remarks. Witkoff also said that Hamas was prepared to disarm in order to end the war, though the group has repeatedly said it will not lay down its weapons. Steve Witkoff arrives to meet families of Israelis held hostage as they demonstrate in Tel Aviv on 2 August 2025. Photo: AFP In response, Hamas, which has dominated Gaza since 2007 but has been militarily battered by Israel in the war, said it would not relinquish "armed resistance" unless an "independent, fully sovereign Palestinian state with Jerusalem as its capital" was established. Indirect negotiations between Hamas and Israel aimed at securing a 60-day ceasefire in the Gaza war and a deal for the release of half the hostages ended last week in deadlock. On Saturday, Hamas released its second video in two days of Israeli hostage Evyatar David. In it, David, skeletally thin, is shown digging a hole, which, he said in the video, is for his own grave. "They are on the absolute brink of death," David's brother Ilay said at a rally in support of the hostages in Tel Aviv, where thousands gathered holding posters of those in captivity and chanted for their immediate release. "In the current unimaginable condition, they may have only days left to live." Israeli Minister of Foreign Affairs Gideon Sa'ar said the "world cannot remain silent in the face of the difficult images that are the result of deliberate sadistic abuse of the hostages, which also includes starvation". Witkoff, who arrived in Israel with Benjamin Netanyahu's government facing a global outcry over the devastation in Gaza and the starvation growing among its 2.2 million people, met the prime minister on Thursday. Afterwards, a senior Israeli official said an understanding between Israel and Washington was emerging that there was a need to move from a plan to release some of the hostages to a plan to release all the hostages, disarm Hamas and demilitarise the Gaza Strip, echoing Israel's key demands for ending the war. On Tuesday, Qatar and Egypt, who are mediating ceasefire efforts, endorsed a declaration by France and Saudi Arabia outlining steps toward a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. As part of it, they said Hamas must hand over its arms to the Western-backed Palestinian Authority. The crisis in Gaza has also prompted a string of Western powers to announce they may recognise a Palestinian state. On Friday, Witkoff visited a US-backed aid operation in southern Gaza, which the United Nations has partly blamed for deadly conditions in the enclave, saying he sought to get food and other aid to people there. Dozens have died of malnutrition in recent weeks after Israel cut off all supplies to the enclave for nearly three months from March to May, according to Gaza's health ministry. It said on Saturday that it had recorded seven more fatalities, including a child, since Friday. Israel blames Hamas for the suffering in Gaza and said it is taking steps for more aid to reach its population, including pausing fighting for part of the day in some areas, air drops and announcing protected routes for aid convoys. UN agencies have said that airdrops of food are insufficient and that Israel must let in far more aid by land and quickly ease access to it. The Gaza war began when Hamas killed more than 1200 people and took 251 hostages in an attack on southern Israel on 7 October 2023, according to Israeli figures. Israel's offensive has since killed more than 60,000 Palestinians, according to Gaza health officials. According to Israeli officials, 50 hostages now remain in Gaza, only 20 of whom are believed to be alive. - Reuters
