Sligo bed and breakfast owner who raped guest fails in conviction appeal
'There is no reason to suppose that the jury did not faithfully apply the principles of law,' said Mr Justice Patrick McCarthy at the Court of Appeal on Monday, rejecting an appeal by Thomas Wymbs (68).
Advertisement
Wymbs was found guilty by a jury of one count of raping the woman between February 22nd and 23rd, 2020, following a Central Criminal Court trial in February 2024.
Wymbs was living at and was the proprietor of Atlantic Haven B&B, Moneygold, Mount Temple, Co Sligo at the time the offence took place.
Ms Justice Mary Ellen Ring sentenced him to seven and a half years with the final 18 months suspended on July 31st, 2024.
The sentencing court heard that the complainant in the case, a European woman in her 20s, had been staying at the B&B. At the time in question, she was the only guest.
Advertisement
On the night of February 22nd, 2020, Wymbs invited her to join him for a drink. Her last recollection was around midnight, before she woke in the middle of the night to find herself in Wymbs' bedroom and he was raping her.
Launching an appeal against his conviction earlier this month, Michael Bowman SC, for Wymbs, said the trial judge had made an error in refusing requests by the defence to address the jury on two issues.
He said the first related to comments made in the prosecution's closing speech and the second was linked to evidence given by an expert witness from Forensic Science Ireland in relation to alcohol consumption and its effects.
Mr Bowman said during the prosecution's closing speech, the jury were invited to consider why the injured party might have made the complaint. He said the question posed by the prosecution was why she would make up this story.
Advertisement
In delivering the court's judgement on Monday, Mr Justice McCarthy said that at the core of the case was the prosecution contention that the complainant was incapable of consenting because of the effect of alcohol, giving rise to sleep.
He said that a forensic scientist conducted analyses of the complainant's blood and urine, going on to say that the court did not think that the trial judge's failure or omission to summarise this expert evidence in his charge to the jury gave rise to a deficient charge.
He said that the trial was a short one, and the evidence of this witness could only have been fresh in the minds of the jurors since that evidence was given on the previous day.
Ireland
Family who turned down six emergency accommodation...
Read More
Mr Justice McCarthy said that there was no disagreement about the high level of intoxication of the victim and the statistical evidence merely bore that fact out.
Advertisement
Concerning the second ground of appeal, Mr Justice McCarthy said that the defence had the opportunity to respond to the prosecution's closing speech. He also said that the trial judge referred to the standard and burden of proof and told the jury not to speculate in any way when deciding the case.
'There is no reason to suppose that the jury did not faithfully apply the principles of law elaborated in the charge,' he said, adding that the court did not think the prosecuting counsel invited speculation in his closing speech.
In summary, the court rejected the appeal.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
23 minutes ago
- The Sun
Repair Shop host Jay Blades charged with two counts of rape and faces court next week a year after quitting hit BBC show
REPAIR Shop star Jay Blades has been charged with two counts of rape. Police confirmed the allegations against the 55-year-old dad of three from Shropshire. 4 4 Blades fronted the hit BBC show for seven years before stepping back last year. King Charles appeared alongside him on a special episode in 2022. West Mercia Police confirmed charges against the dad of three, with a magistrates' court date set for next Wednesday. A spokesperson said: 'Jason Blades, 55, of Claverley in Shropshire, has been charged with two counts of rape. "He is due to appear at Telford magistrates' court on 13 August 2025.' Blades was awarded an MBE in 2022 for services to craft while King Charles appeared on the Repair Shop the same year. The TV star is currently awaiting trial on a separate charge of controlling and coercive behaviour against estranged wife Lisa-Marie Zbozen, which he has denied. Blades was arrested in May 2024 - on the same day fitness instructor Lisa announced her decision to end their 18-month marriage. In September Blades was charged. His actions allegedly caused Lisa 'to fear, on at least two occasions, that violence will be used against her'. The presenter pleaded not guilty to the charge — which relates to the period between January 1, 2023 and September 12, 2024 — at a court hearing last October. He is due to attend Worcester crown court today for a pre-trial review regarding the charge. Blades, who married Lisa in an intimate ceremony in Barbados in November 2022, took a break from filming following his arrest. Sources said the decision was also linked to the death of his uncle Richard Braithwaite, 72, in North London in March. A neighbour has been charged with murder. Blades was also dropped from The Repair Shop's live show, Secrets From The Barn, and quietly removed from promotional material. His Repair Shop co-star, horologist Steve Fletcher, revealed in March he had visited Blades while on a break from the live tour. Steve shared a photograph of himself with Blades on Instagram with the caption: 'In a break from our 'Secrets From the Barn' Tour, I popped in to see Jay the other day for a cup of tea and a lovely chat. 'It was great to catch up. Hope to see him again soon.' The BBC later replaced Blades with Roman Kemp for the Christmas special of the popular series. Blades also resigned as chancellor of Buckinghamshire New University 'with immediate effect' following the initial charge. It said: 'We thank Jay for his loyal service to the university and will be making no further comment.' As well as fronting The Repair Shop since 2017, Blades also hosted BBC shows including Money For Nothing and Jay Blades' Home Fix. He also appeared as a contestant on the Strictly Come Dancing Christmas special and fronted a special BBC documentary, Jay Blades: Learning to Read at 51. 4 4
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
While Trump showed the world how to handle Brussels, Starmer waves the white flag on Brexit
PM's Brexit exit DONALD Trump showed the world how to force a deal with the EU. Terrify them with threats of the loss of billions in lost trade and tens of thousands of jobs … and watch Brussels beg for business. 1 Sadly, Sir Keir Starmer took the opposite approach with his sellout 'reset' deal. Now jubilant European leaders are bent on bullying the UK into accepting their tyranny all over again thanks to its terms. A total reversal of Brexit is closer than ever. The PM has repeatedly promised never to take the UK back into the EU's Customs Union and Single Market. Yet that is effectively what the EU Commission demands as the price of its agreement. Britain must take all EU regulations on food without any say in those rules — and pay penalties for not doing so. We couldn't even import food from outside the EU without its meddling. Technically, there is still time during last-minute negotiations for our dyed-in-the-wool Remainer PM to stop this gross betrayal of Brexit. But on current form he seems vanishingly unlikely to do so. Keir Starmer- hopes for reset with EU do not mean 'reversing Brexit' Boiling over VOTER rage at the immigration explosion is close to boiling point. And even the OBR says public services are seriously stretched because of Britain's over-reliance on migration. Yet tin-eared Labour ministers still lecture protesters outside asylum hotels by telling them 'anger doesn't get you anywhere'. They don't get that Nigel Farage's current success comes from speaking real people's language. Similarly, useless cops appear to have learned nothing from the handling of the identity of the Southport killer. — as Warwickshire police did in the case of an Afghan accused of raping a 12-year-old girl — are an affront to justice. The immigration status and nationality of all offenders should be published for each crime. It's the only way to restore trust. Cell out WHY is the Left's answer to prison overcrowding always to release prisoners or cut sentences? Ex-Chief Inspector of Prisons and human rights activist Dame Anne Owers says a near meltdown in the system means even mandatory life sentences for murder should be scrapped. How about, instead of letting thousands of dangerous criminals back on to the streets, Labour does what the Tories so abjectly failed to do.
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Man (70s) found dead in Waterford named as Waterford crystal worker
A man in his 70s found dead following an incident at a residential property in Waterford on Friday has been named locally as former Waterford crystal worker Pat Fitzgerald. Gardaí and the emergency services attended at the scene in St Catherine's Grange in the city shortly after 2pm on Friday. Advertisement Mr Fitzgerald, who was a widower, was found unresponsive at the property. He was transferred to University Hospital Waterford for treatment. He was pronounced dead at the hospital yesterday. A man in his 30s has appeared in court in connection with his death. Cllr Donal Barry of Waterford city south worked alongside Mr Fitzgerald for many years. The Independent councillor said that Pat was a trade union representative at the factory. 'Pat started his career in Waterford Crystal as a blower. He was then a full time union official in the plant," he said. Advertisement "There was 3,500 of us (employees) there at one stage and Pat was highly respected among all the workforce and even by and management. He did an awful lot of good work with the union then. "He was a fantastic union official and was well known throughout the country in the former ATGWU. He was (involved in the sit in) until the very end.' Mr Fitzgerald was also a former branch chairman of UNITE, formerly the ATGWU. He was the chair of the 364 branch of the UNITE trade union in 2009 when Waterford Crystal workers occupied the plant. Ireland Man (30s) charged after death of man (70s) in Wate... Read More The sit in began on January 30th, 2009, after the company's receiver shut down manufacturing after running out of cash. The sit in lasted close to two months and ended after workers agreed to split a payment of €10 million. Meanwhile, the Coroner and the Office of the State Pathologist have been notified and a post-mortem examination will be carried out. A technical and forensic examination at the scene has been completed. An incident room has been established at Waterford Garda Station. Investigating gardaí are appealing for witnesses. Anyone with information is asked to contact Waterford Garda Station 051 305 300 or the Garda Confidential Line 1800 666 111.
