Miscalculated grants: Overpayments amounted to $7m for most people, a shortage of $2m to others, says MOH
MOH said that the error had resulted in about $7 million in over-payments for about 90 per cent of the affected individuals.
SINGAPORE - The issue that caused a processing error in a government means-testing system which led to about 20,000 people getting the wrong subsidies and grants has been identified, said the Ministry of Health (MOH) on July 22.
MOH, which manages the Household Means Eligibility System (Homes), said that the error had resulted in about $7 million in over-payments for about 90 per cent of the affected individuals, and about $2 million in shortfalls for the remainder of those affected.
On July 21, MOH said that Homes had experienced a processing issue resulting in about 20,000 people receiving wrong subsidies and grants.
The ministry said then that those who received excess subsidy or grant amounts will not have to return them, while those who received less than they were entitled to will have the difference topped up by government agencies by November.
Homes uses income information from the Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore (IRAS) to means-test individuals with business income, such as self-employed people - for selected subsidy schemes across the Government.
What happened?
For the 2025 year of assessment, IRAS' tax filing notification process began later in mid-January, compared to the preceding December in previous years, said MOH.
This was to ensure CPF contributions for the full year were captured for more accurate income tax assessments.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Singapore S'poreans aged 21 to 59 can claim $600 SG60 vouchers from July 22
Singapore Changi Airport handles 17.5 million passengers in Q2 2025
Singapore 2 charged over alleged involvement in posting of bail for man who subsequently absconded
Singapore Teen charged after she allegedly sold vaporisers, put up WhatsApp ad showing e-cigarettes
Life Having a workout partner could be the secret to sticking to your fitness goals
Singapore 2,500 turtles seized in India and sent back to S'pore, put down humanely after salmonella detected
Singapore LTA seeks tailored solutions to improve Bukit Panjang LRT's maintenance inspections
Singapore Ports and planes: The 2 Singapore firms helping to keep the world moving
However, the 'system logic' at the time caused Homes to omit the business income of selected individuals. This led to inaccurate means-testing for individuals with business income and members of their households between Jan 1 and Jan 27, 2025.
MOH said that Homes was first alerted to the issue on Jan 13 through a member of public's query when applying for subsidies, which triggered an investigation leading to the identification of the issue.
The ministry added that it is currently enhancing the design of Homes for better integration and coordination with agencies.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
11 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Reporting advanced suspected cyber attacks will provide a defence framework: Shanmugam
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox (Seated, from left) Minister for Digital Development and Information Josephine Teo and Coordinating Minister for National Security K. Shanmugam touring the exhibits at the Exercise Cyber Star on Aug 1. SINGAPORE - Mandating that operators of critical systems, such as those that manage energy, water and transportation services, report suspected advanced attacks will provide the necessary framework for Singapore to defend itself, said Coordinating Minister for National Security K. Shanmugam on Aug 1. Declining to name the country behind the recent advanced persistent threat (APT) attack on Singapore, he urged organisations to have the mentality that there are and will be breaches. 'Accept that, and be prepared to defend,' he said, speaking on the sidelines of a biennial cybersecurity exercise, called Exercise Cyber Star, organised by the Cyber Security Agency of Singapore. 'Tell us immediately the moment you suspect (something). We work with you to try and deal with it,' he added. Mr Shanmugam's comments came after the authorities revealed in July that Singapore's critical information infrastructure (CII) came under attack from UNC3886, a state-linked advanced persistent threat actor. UNC3886 is one of several APT actors, whose activities have increased more than fourfold from 2021 to 2024, that target Singapore's CII. In light of increased threats, Singapore has also amended its Cybersecurity Act in 2024 to require CII operators to declare any cyber-security outage, and any attack on their premises or along their supply chain. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. World Trump modifies reciprocal tariffs ahead of deadline; rate on Singapore likely to remain at 10% Business Singapore's US tariff rate stays at 10%, but the Republic is not out of the woods yet Singapore NUS launches S'pore's first nursing practice doctorate to meet evolving healthcare needs Singapore Data breach involving 147,000 Cycle & Carriage Singapore customer records under probe Business CAD probing Tokenize Xchange operator; firm's director charged with fraudulent trading Singapore PM Wong to deliver National Day message on Aug 8 Singapore Man charged over kicking woman's face in Teck Whye Lane flat, leading to her death In particular, operators of critical systems must report suspected APT attacks to CSA, whose oversight will expand to include risks that come from suppliers and cloud services. The amendments are expected to kick in later in 2025. Declining to name the country behind UNC3886, Mr Shanmugum said: 'We release information that we assess is in the public a specific country is not in our interest at this point of time.' Experts have said that the group is linked to China. On naming the group, he added: 'In this case, we felt that the situation and the threat of the attack and compromise was serious enough, and we were confident enough to name UNC3886.' In a statement on July 19 responding to media reports about UNC3886 being linked to Beijing, a spokesperson for the Chinese Embassy in Singapore said: 'China expresses strong dissatisfaction with this, and we resolutely oppose any unwarranted smearing against China. 'In fact, China is one of the main victims of cyber attacks. We reiterate that China resolutely opposes and combats any form of cyber attacks in accordance with the law, and will not encourage, support or condone hacker attacks.' On Aug 1, Mr Shanmugam also spoke about the need for cybersecurity exercises to be better prepared for attacks, which is why Exercise Cyber Star is important. The exercise is in its sixth edition, and is the largest to date. It was held over a period of 11 days and involved nearly 500 participants from CSA, owners from Singapore's 11 critical sectors, and the Singapore Armed Forces' Digital and Intelligence Service. At the event, CII operators were tested on their skills in countering simulated cyber attacks such as those from APT actors. CII operators were also tested on their ability to deal with spillover effects from the attacks that affect the larger business community and society. 'This exercise brings together the different sector leads, critical infrastructure exercise real-life scenarios,' said Mr Shanmugam. 'Imagine millions of people travelling on our subways, and something goes wrong... What's your approach on dealing with the attack? How do you recover from it?' he said, noting that the private sector also needs to have the know-how to better work with the government to contain the damages. Singapore's 11 CII sectors are aviation, healthcare, land transport, maritime, media, security and emergency services, water, banking and finance, energy, infocomm and government. UNC3886 is not the first APT attack on Singapore - there was a security breach in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs' technology systems back in 2014, and intrusions in the networks of two local universities in 2017 believed to be aimed at stealing government and research data. The Republic experienced its worst data breach in 2018, which involved the personal particulars of 1.5 million patients including former Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong. The attacker in this breach on SingHealth was said to have been persistent in its efforts to access the electronic medical records system, and is believed to have lurked in the healthcare group's network for at least nine months.
Straits Times
41 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Road Blog: With more Chinese EVs come fewer choices
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Chinese EV brands are increasing their share of Singapore's roads while others are fading away. SINGAPORE – If variety is the spice of life, then modern motoring life in Singapore is a bland diet of electric sport utility vehicles (SUVs), served by more and more Chinese carmakers. These vehicles are sleek, more affordable and better equipped than their European counterparts, and gaining ground fast.
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
More than $1.7 million lost in scams using fraudulent mobile apps
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox The police said that there were at least 32 cases of investment and job scams using fraudulent mobile apps reported since January 2025. SINGAPORE - Victims have lost about $1.72 million after falling prey to investment and job scams that involve fraudulent mobile apps on the Apple App Store and Google Play Store. At least 32 such cases have been reported since January 2025, police said in an advisory on Aug 1. In this scam variant, scammers would approach victims through social media platforms such as Facebook, as well as communications and dating apps, such as LinkedIn and Tinder. Scam victims were also approached using investment advertisements listed on social media. After building rapport with victims, the scammers then introduced fake investment or job opportunities to them. Victims were told to download and set up accounts on fraudulent mobile apps such as Dyreka, M Tree PE, Saftools and Tik StoreB2B on the app stores. Under the guise of investment or purchasing goods to set up a business, victims would be instructed to transfer money to the scammer's bank accounts or cryptocurrency wallets, police added. The police said that these transactions included the Singapore dollar, foreign fiat currencies and cryptocurrencies. Some victims would be given small profits to encourage them to deposit more money into these fraudulent investments or online businesses, police said. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. World Trump modifies reciprocal tariffs ahead of deadline; rate on Singapore likely to remain at 10% Singapore PM Wong to deliver National Day message on Aug 8 Singapore Data breach involving Cycle & Carriage Singapore customer details under probe Singapore Man charged over kicking woman's face in Teck Whye Lane flat, leading to her death Singapore 'For one last time, let's go home': Tears, laughs as last scheduled Jetstar Asia flight touches down Life The Projector leaves Cineleisure, returns to Golden Mile Tower Singapore 3 men charged over living on the earnings of prostitution Business OCBC Q2 profit drops 7% to $1.82b as interest rates fall, to pay lower interim dividend Victims would realise they had been scammed only when they could not withdraw their money, or when the scammers became uncontactable. Members of the public should be cautious when making investment decisions and adopt precautionary measures, the police advised. These include setting up security features, such as activating privacy functions on devices, to prevent unknown users from adding someone into chat groups. Suspicious messages, phone numbers and website links can be checked with the ScamShield app, by calling its hotline at 1799, or by visiting Before making investment decisions, ask the company as many questions as needed, the police advised. If the company cannot or avoid answering, check the company, its owners, directors, as well as management members to assess the authenticity of investment opportunities, the police said. The credentials of the company and its representatives can be checked using resources, including the Financial Institutions Directory, the Register of Representatives, and the Investor Alert List. These are available on the Monetary Authority of Singapore's website . Members of the public should download apps only from official app stores, and should also check for user reviews and ratings. They should also download anti-malware scanning apps.
