Senedd committee warns against making lying in Welsh parliament a criminal offence
It comes after the Welsh government committed to introduce legislation which would ban members of the Welsh parliament from deliberately deceiving.
But the Senedd 's standards committee, which the government asked to look into the matter, has concluded that members who lie on purpose should not be criminalised.
"We had some significant concerns about the risks outlined to the committee in the evidence it received of introducing a criminal offence," it said in its report.
The committee does, however, recommend broadening section 75 of the draft Senedd Cymru (Representation of the People) Order, which would make it an offence for election candidates to make any deliberately deceptive statements.
Former Plaid Cymru leader Adam Price put forward his party's motion in July last year, arguing that trust in politicians had "fallen to an all-time low".
But before it went to a vote, the Welsh government's then counsel general, Mick Antoniw, said the government was "committed to the principle" and said it would introduce legislation ahead of the next Senedd election in 2026.
Concerns had been raised by some members on the impact of such proposals on parliamentary privilege.
The report comes after the committee last month suggested introducing a mechanism to unseat members of the Senedd found to have breached its code of conduct.
In the report, published on Wednesday, the committee concludes it was "not convinced" that a new criminal offence would restore "trust in the system".
"Our view is that the risks and the unintended consequences currently outweigh the benefits," the committee added.
The committee said the perceived risks included the "considerable existing strain on the justice system", the right to freedom of expression under article 10 of the European Convention of Human Rights and the "difficulties of proving that a statement is false".
Instead, the committee recommends the Welsh government strengthen the existing standards procedures for members of the Senedd.
This includes a clear definition of deliberate deception and changing the code of conduct to explicitly state that members "must not make deliberately misleading statements".
A Welsh government spokesperson said the committee had "produced a detailed and thorough report into deliberate deception as part of its inquiry into member accountability".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
17 hours ago
- Wales Online
The staggering Whatsapp messages sent to the new Archbishop of Wales by her colleagues
The staggering Whatsapp messages sent to the new Archbishop of Wales by her colleagues When Cherry Vann was added to a Whatsapp chat, some of her more orthodox colleagues were 'dismayed and horrified' a gay bishop had been appointed to lead Church in Wales Cherry Vann has been chosen as the 15th Archbishop of Wales (Image: Church in Wales) One of the largest Anglican provinces in the world has severed its ties with its Welsh counterparts - all because the new Archbishop of Wales is gay. Cherry Vann, the Bishop of Monmouth for the past five years, was chosen as the 15th Archbishop of Wales at the end of July. Originally from Leicestershire, Archbishop Cherry Vann was elected as the the leader of the Church in Wales with a two-thirds majority and will be enthroned at Newport Cathedral in due course, she has pledged to bring "healing and reconciliation". Yet already, she has also come into conflict with colleagues from more orthodox countries. The day after she was elected, Vann was added to a WhatsApp group containing every Anglican chief in the an interview with The Sunday Times, she said two immediately criticised her appointment to their ranks. "They were dismayed and horrified," she says. For our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation, sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here . The Church of Nigeria, one of the largest Anglican provinces in the world, said it would sever ties with the Church in Wales. Henry Ndukuba, the Archbishop of Nigeria, said: "We do not recognise the so-called Archbishop of Wales and cannot share communion with a church that has departed from the teachings of the Bible." The chairman of Gafcon, an influential conservative group of archbishops and bishops, called her election an 'act of apostasy'. Other Christian groups and publications have also criticised her appointments. She told the journalist interviewing her that on the morning they were meeting she received a letter through the post calling her "an abomination". But she said it didn't impact her faith, although it was "hurtful". "I just rest in the fact that a lot of people are rejoicing, and I know where God wants me to be". In the interview, the new Archbishop of Wales criticised the institution she is part of, a "number of times", the author says with Bishop Vann saying the institution is "full of human beings who are flawed and failing" "I think the church can so often get in the way of God," the 66-year-old said. She was ordained into the Church of England in 1994, and was one of the first female priests, before spending 11 years as Archdeacon of Rochdale in Manchester. But she said she knew because she was gay, she knew her career wouldn't last in England. The Church in Wales has different rules to the Church of England, gay clergy in England are permitted to enter into civil partnerships only if they remain celibate. So, for almost 30 years, she had kept her relationship with Wendy Diamond, a retired council employee, secret with her partner "hiding upstairs" when visitors came to see them. "It was an appalling state of affairs," says Vann. "It felt as though I was being dishonest but I didn't feel at the time that I had any choice. I was living in fear." When she became Bishop of Monmouth, she said she finally felt comfortable enough to be open about her sexuality. "When we first came to Wales we had a party," the new archbishop of Wales told The Times. "We invited guests to my home and for the first time Wendy was able to come to the front door with me and welcome people as my partner. That, for her and for me, signalled what a massive change it meant being here." She has taken over after the resignation of Bishop Andy John, in the wake of two reports, commissioned by the Church in Wales over concerns about the culture surrounding the Bangor Diocese. Bishop Vann said: "I don't think there's something rotten in the clergy themselves,' says Vann, "but the church has a culture of wanting to protect its own. It's a shocking thing to say but perpetrators have been protected and the survivors have been left to flounder". Article continues below
South Wales Argus
a day ago
- South Wales Argus
Reform candidate wins Goetre Community Council by-election
The Conservatives had been looking for a fourth successive victory in by-elections to town and community councils in Monmouthshire after successes in Caerwent, Wyesham in Monmouth and Portskewett near Chepstow. But it was Reform that triumphed in the election to Goetre Community Council with candidate Martin John Stevens topping the poll in the Goytre Ward to become Monmouthshire's first Reform councillor in the village between Pontypool and Abergavenny. Though town and community councils are non-partisan, with decisions made by the full council and no division along party lines, candidates can stand for political parties and Reform considers the victory to be significant. Stuart Keyte, who is a Reform councillor on Torfaen Borough Council, and chair of its Torfaen and Monmouthshire branch, said contesting the community council elections has been preparation for next year's Welsh election when the constituencies will be combined to elect six Senedd Members using a proportional system. Referring to comments made by Richard John, the leader of the Conservative group on Monmouthshire council, Cllr Keyte said: 'So much for being a Reform-free zone. The Tories threw the full weight of of their campaign machine with dawn leaflet raids on the day of the election and big names knocking on doors.' The Torfaen councillor said former MP David Davies had been leafleting for the Conservatives and described the recent elections as 'preparation for when the Senedd elections start to kick off.' When the Conservatives won the Wyesham ward by-election in July, just days after Conservative Senedd Member Laura Anne Jones who had represented the ward on Monmouthshire County Council defected to Reform, Cllr John had hailed the Tory victory. He dismissed Reform as offering no more than 'soundbites' and said: 'Monmouthshire remains a Reform-free zone.' The victory in Goetre came on a night of celebration for Nigel Farage's party as it won the previously Labour held Llangennech seat on Carmarthenshire County Council. Cllr Keat said Reform is challenging across Wales: 'We are polling in the high twenties or projected to win in seats across Wales.' The Goytre Ward by-election was called due to a councillor automatically losing their seat due to failing attend meetings and the eight member council now has one councillor each from Reform, Labour and the Conservatives. Goetre Community Council, Goytre Ward result BUTLER Andrew Michael (Local Conservatives) 97 PARRY Neil James 115 STEVENS Martin John (Reform UK 150) Elected WILLCOX Maureen Catherine 48 Spoilt papers: 0 Turnout: 37 per cent
Wales Online
a day ago
- Wales Online
UK Government rules out giving something people in Wales want
UK Government rules out giving something people in Wales want The Welsh Government and all 22 councils want the Crown Estate to be devolved to Wales but the UK Government has said no The Crown Estate, the collection of marine and land assets and holdings that belong to the monarch, is a hot political topic The UK Government has said that the Crown Estate will not be devolved to Wales because it "would risk market fragmentation, complicate existing processes, and delay further development offshore". The Crown Estate is a collection of marine and land assets and holdings that belong to the monarch. It includes the seabed out to 12 nautical miles, which is around 65% of the Welsh foreshore and riverbed, and a number of ports and marinas. On land the Crown Estates owns 50,000 acres of common land in Wales. The value of the estate in Wales is more than £603m of land. It is a hot political topic, because since 2019 responsibility for management of the Crown Estate's assets in Scotland has been devolved but that is not the case in Wales. In 2024, the Independent Commission on the Constitutional Future of Wales – which you can read here – said that options for devolving the Crown Estate to Wales should be looked at. The Welsh Government want it too, with the First Minister making it clear Welsh Labour believe "the Crown Estate should be devolved". Plaid Cymru, which is doing better than Labour in polls ahead of a Senedd election in May 2026, is making it a central pledge of their election campaign. For our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation, sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here On top of that, all 22 councils in Wales have now backed a transfer of the Crown Estate from the UK to Welsh Government However, the UK Government has ruled it out. In response to a letter sent by campaigners Yes Cymru to Prime Minister Keir Starmer, Welsh secretary Jo Stevens has said that is not the position of her party colleagues in London. In it, she writes: "It is this government's view that devolving the Crown Estate and introducing a new entity would risk market fragmentation, complicate existing processes, and delay further development offshore. "Furthermore, devolution would mean Wales losing access to Crown Estate investment that comes from its revenues in England. It would also risk undermining investment in floating offshore wind, which is needed to provide lower bills, cleaner energy, and better jobs. This government is focussed on delivering these objectives and so does not support the devolution of the Crown Estate in Wales," the Cardiff East MP says. "Even if devolution could be done without risking the revenues the Crown Estate generates, this would not automatically lead to an increase in the funding available to the Welsh Government. This is because any revenues retained by the Welsh Government in a devolved system would likely be offset through reductions to their block grant as is currently the case in Scotland. "Creating an artificial border through the Celtic Sea would also complicate crucially important work to develop the floating offshore wind industry, particularly as floating offshore wind lease areas straddle the Wales/England border." YesCymru has pledged to intensify the campaign in response to Westminster's refusal, which started with a protest at the Eisteddfod. Chair Phyl Griffiths said: "The Crown Estate proves that the practice of extraction is still alive in 21st century Wales and has resulted in all 22 authorities speaking with one voice, underlining the fact we're a nation. "The London government's response to our call to transfer control of the Crown Estate to Wales, however, only proves that they see us as nothing more than a region of the UK." Article continues below
