
The McVulnerability Trap
In my psychology practice, when tears enter the room, they have a way of cutting through the noise—all of the defenses, all of the pretenses. A client's carefully constructed walls fall away, allowing something deep to emerge. I've seen this happen time and again, and it's why for years I saw crying as one of the purest forms of vulnerability—until I discovered crying TikTok.
The trend is exactly what you might expect: People post videos of themselves crying (or trying not to). Some of these videos are slickly produced; some feature moody music; many rack up hundreds of thousands of views. These displays of vulnerability are, of course, not restricted to TikTok (whose fate, under the new Trump administration, is uncertain). They can also be found on YouTube, Instagram, and other apps, part of a broader online aesthetic. Influencers and celebrities strip down to what can seem like the rawest version of themselves, selling the promise of 'real' emotional connection—and, not infrequently, products or their personal brand. In a post titled ' Reacting to My Sad and Lonely Videos,' the YouTube star Trisha Paytas watches old footage of herself sobbing and is moved to tears all over again; this sort of post shares space in her channel with clips in which she pitches her own merch. On Instagram, influencers toggle between montages of sadness and sponsored videos that show them cozily sipping fancy tea.
The weepy confessions are, ostensibly, gestures toward intimacy. They're meant to inspire empathy, to reassure viewers that influencers are just like them. But in fact, they're exercises in what I've come to call 'McVulnerability,' a synthetic version of vulnerability akin to fast food: mass-produced, easily accessible, sometimes tasty, but lacking in sustenance. True vulnerability can foster emotional closeness. McVulnerability offers only an illusion of it. And just as choosing fast food in favor of more nutritious options can, over time, result in harmful outcomes, consuming 'fast vulnerability' instead of engaging in bona fide human interaction can send people down an emotionally unhealthy path.
Not long ago in American culture, vulnerability was largely associated with weakness. To be vulnerable meant to be helpless or susceptible to harm. Then came Brené Brown, the social worker and research professor who, with her viral 2010 TED Talk, became one of the most prominent voices transforming the perception of vulnerability for a new audience. In her book Daring Greatly, Brown defined vulnerability as the 'birthplace of love, belonging, joy, courage, empathy, and creativity,' and as a crucial element in personal growth—a liberating message for people raised to suppress their feelings and show toughness.
This was well before the consumerist blending of therapy-speak and personal branding that has become commonplace on social media. It was four years before The Body Keeps the Score got the masses talking about trauma, and it was eight years before Nicole LePera launched the Holistic Psychologist on Instagram, today one of the platform's most popular therapy accounts. But in the past decade and a half, vulnerability's trajectory has come to mirror that of many psychological concepts—such as mindfulness, boundary-setting, and self-love—whose lines of insight have been tangled up with the attention economy and the free market.
McVulnerability is perhaps an inevitable outcome of what the sociologist Eva Illouz identifies as a modern-day landscape of 'emotional capitalism.' 'Never has the private self been so publicly performed and harnessed to the discourses and values of the economic and political spheres,' Illouz writes in her book Cold Intimacies. Emotional capitalism has 'realigned emotional cultures, making the economic self emotional and emotions more closely harnessed to instrumental action.' That is, not only does emotionality sell goods, but emotions themselves have also become commodities.
As people's vulnerability proxies—podcasters, celebrities, crying YouTubers—pour out their heart while shilling for their favorite cashmere brands, consumerism becomes unconsciously tethered to the viewing or listening experience. Studies have found that when people spend more time on social-media platforms, they are more likely to buy more things and to do so impulsively—especially when they feel emotionally connected to the content they watch. This is, perhaps, one of the more insidious effects of McVulnerability: It helps encourage a self-perpetuating cycle of materialism and loneliness, in which one inevitably spawns the other.
Yet McVulnerability's practitioners are also offering supply to satisfy a real emotional demand. As Derek Thompson wrote earlier this month in The Atlantic, more and more Americans are retreating from in-person social interactions, turning instead to smartphones and other devices in search of intimacy. Yes, they may be communicating with friends and family. But they are also spending a lot of time 'with' people they don't know at all.
Read: 'Close Friends,' for a monthly fee
The rise of momfluencers serves as a perfect example. Many new mothers find themselves isolated and exhausted as they make the transition into parenthood. Maybe their families live across the country, or their friends are too busy to stop by. Starved for community, they might be struggling to find people with whom they can sit down and say, This sucks. On social media, they find influencers sharing tearful confessions about mom guilt or mom rage. But these posts aren't a substitute for actual community and support. Once the isolated moms put down their phone, they're just as alone as they were before.
Not all of the vulnerability shared online is devoid of authenticity. It can be genuinely helpful when someone describes their personal trials publicly, such as a survivor of abuse who shares their story, galvanizing others to seek safety. Vulnerability caught on video can also offer a powerful glimpse into the gravity of collective tragedy. An emotional clip about losing a home to wildfires can, for instance, bring to life the human cost of crisis in a way that headlines and statistics cannot. And of course, some parents who share their difficult experiences online do provide a valuable service, offering validation and practical insights (on, say, postpartum depression) that aren't always accessible elsewhere.
Next to those videos, it's not hard to see the ways in which McVulnerability, melodramatic and consumption-driven, merely masquerades as a chance to connect. McVulnerability offers a fleeting, convenient, and comfortable digital experience, allowing the people who consume it to skirt past the complications of being in a relationship with another person—although for some viewers, truth be told, that might be part of the appeal.
In my years as a therapist, I've seen a trend among some of my younger clients: They prefer the controlled environment of the internet—the polish of YouTube, the ephemeral nature of TikTok—to the tender awkwardness of making new friends. Instead of reaching out to a peer, they'll turn to the comfort of their phone and spend time with their preferred influencers. At a talk in 2023, the psychotherapist Esther Perel touched on this impulse while discussing what she calls 'artificial intimacy' —pseudo-experiences of emotional closeness that mimic connection but lack depth. These 'digitally facilitated connections,' she said, risk 'lowering our expectations of intimacy between humans' and leave us 'unprepared and unable to tolerate the inevitable unpredictabilities of human nature, love, and life.' I understand where my young clients are coming from: Putting yourself out there is uncomfortable. But for the reasons Perel articulated, I also worry that by relying mostly on social media to encounter other humans, they're forfeiting opportunities to develop the skills that could help them thrive in the flesh-and-blood world.
One of my psychology mentors has a point she repeats often: 'Vulnerability is generous.' It can be easier to project invulnerability, to pretend we don't believe strongly in an issue, to act as if we don't want. But being vulnerable—exposing ourselves via the unfiltered messiness of life—is one of the biggest emotional risks we can take, and one of the greatest gifts we can offer another person. When you choose to be vulnerable, you are essentially saying: I'm going to stand here as my full self, and I invite you to do the same.
McVulnerability, from whichever angle you look at it, is the opposite of generous. It doesn't require risk. It may pretend to give, but ultimately, it takes. And it leaves most of its consumers hungry for what they're craving: human connection—the real thing.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Elle
32 minutes ago
- Elle
Your Ultimate Summer Love Horoscope Is Here: What Jupiter In Cancer Means For Your Sign
Home is where the heat is in summer 2025. In June, Jupiter—the planet of growth, generosity, and faith—settles into cozy, intimate Cancer for the first time in more than 10 years. If you're hoping to cultivate true romance, you'll be more successful at the crib than the club. Straighten up your bedroom, and keep a few aphrodisiacs like chocolate, pistachios, and honey in the snack cupboard. You can read your daily horoscope here A sentimental water sign, Cancer is deeply private. During this 13-month transit, the magic happens in quiet moments. A safe space is a must, which means both finding and being a trustworthy person. (Read: Someone who doesn't spill the details of every erotic encounter across TikTok.) Nostalgia is big this summer with Jupiter in Cancer giving 'childhood sweetheart' vibes. No, you don't have to dig up your eighth-grade crush on the socials. That said, it wouldn't be the worst idea. Jupiter is the zodiac's 'why not?' gambler, prone to peeking in places that make your heart skip a beat. If you have a 'one that got away,' consider following the above advice, too. Heartfelt reunions could lead to second chances this summer. Even if that ship has sailed, look around for someone who has your ex's best qualities. You could discover them in a new package. Selena Gomez, who has her sun sign in Cancer, basically set the template for us already. Opting for fiancé Benny Blanco's squishy brand of adoration, she made a sharp departure from her brooding bad-boy exes. While she's dated Pisces (Blanco's sign) in the past, only her current partner is devoted to prepping all her favorite meals for her to eat at a moment's notice. As Blanco told ELLE in a recent interview: 'I have a whole menu of things she likes, so whenever she's hungry, I have them in my back pocket. I prep a lot of stuff and freeze it. She loves coconut shrimp, so I'll prep a bunch of them, and then I just drop them in the deep fryer when she wants them. I make personal chicken pot pies for her, in little ramekins.' Some people may feel like taking a big step back from romance this summer, channeling Cancer Pamela Anderson's sovereign season of life. On her (decidedly un-Hollywood) coastal Canadian property, she spends her days writing, tending to the land, and thumbing her nose at ageist beauty standards by going makeup-free on red carpets. She has created a sacred space to revel in, a metaphoric crab shell, which is romantic in and of itself. So how can you navigate this summer's softer serving of love? Let's take it element by element. Feel free to read for either your sun sign or your rising sign here. Passion is your forté, but sentimentality isn't your usual territory. Yet this summer, it's where the magic happens. Jupiter in Cancer asks you to slow down and listen to your heart, instead of charging ahead. Vulnerability becomes your secret weapon, but it's not just about confessing before you ghost. Stick around for the 'awkward' afterglow—you'll bond in ways you never dreamed possible. You thrive in stability, and this transit offers just that—but with a sweetly emo twist. Jupiter in Cancer supports your desire to build something lasting, especially in love. You may find joy in curating a cozy home with a partner, but that's not the hard part. Your challenge now is to learn that strength can look like softness. In Cancer, Jupiter serves a masterclass in expressing your emotions in the moment rather than waiting for the 'right' time, which often never comes. You love connecting with people through laughter and fun. But feelings? That feels messy and complicated for the cool-headed air sign. Jupiter in Cancer invites you to go deeper in all your interactions. You'll also embrace a more practical approach to love. Rather than breezing through witty DM exchanges, you want face-to-face hangouts with people who you could see yourself building something real with. You're in your romantic, heartfelt element with abundant Jupiter amplifying all your emotions. Finally! You feel seen by the world; no more hiding your sensitivity. Now it's a superpower, and the rest of the world is operating on your wavelength. Get ready to deepen bonds as you insist on nothing short of emotional clarity. Ophira and Tali Edut (The AstroTwins) are among the most sought-after astrologers and intuitive advisors of our times. As the longtime resident astrologers for ELLE Magazine and the authors of over 20 books, they are the advisors to a roster of CEOs, celebrities, global leaders and successful entrepreneurs. They've read charts for celebrities the likes of Beyoncé, Dua Lipa, and Emma Roberts. Their new book, The Astrology Advantage (Simon & Schuster), introduces The AstroTwins' revolutionary I*AM System, which simplifies the birth chart into three archetypes: Innovator, Authority, and Maven. On television, The AstroTwins have appeared as guest experts for Bravo, MTV, 'Good Morning America,' and the 'Today' show, and created the first streaming reality TV dating show based on astrology, Cosmic Love (Amazon Prime Video, 2022). Their work on the subject of 'spiritual technology' as an essential tool for business success has been featured in Fast Company and at leadership conferences around the world. Ophira and Tali have taught thousands of people their methods through their online platform, and at their signature retreats. Graduates of The University of Michigan, Ophira and Tali grew up in Detroit and currently live in New York and Seattle.


Newsweek
36 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Woman Finds Puppy With No Front Paws at Shelter, She Knows What To Do
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. A chihuahua born without front legs has left the internet teary-eyed as she adapts to life on wheels. Hannah Sanders (@hannah_sand24), 26, from Seminole, Florida, shared footage of her adopted 5-month-old pup Belly, who was originally a foster from Rags to Riches Animal Rescue in Tampa, Florida. Sanders had only planned to foster Belly for a few days—but quickly fell in love and decided to adopt her. The video footage documenting Belly's journey through various sets of wheels has garnered 1.1 million likes and 7.6 million views on TikTok. "She was rescued from a dog hoarder house. I was only supposed to foster her for three days but after the first day I fell in love with her and knew I wanted to adopt her. I first created her two sets of wheels out of Legos hoping it would work for her. After posting that video online a man named Jeff reached out to the rescue offering to help 3D print her wheels," Sanders told Newsweek. A split image of Belly the chihuahua. A split image of Belly the chihuahua. @hannah_sand24/@hannah_sand24 The heartwarming clips show Belly's progression from makeshift Lego wheels to a custom 3D-printed pair of blue wheels, specially designed to support her mobility. "Every set of wheels we got helped us figured out how to make the next set better. Watching her grown and become so strong has made me so incredibly proud of her. She amazes me everyday with her strength. She sleeps with me every night in bed and cuddles up to me. I am so blessed to have her," Sanders added. According to Walkin' Pets, adopting a disabled pet can be a life-changing experience. Caring for animals with special needs often deepens compassion, fosters patience, and teaches valuable lessons about perseverance and empathy. Even simple milestones can become sources of immense joy for both the pet and their caregiver. TikTokers flooded the comments with support and emotion. "Her trying to use her arms," said Amber. "Pls give her anything she ever wants," said another user. "I am very proud of you for taking the time out of your life to make this little babies life even better. You and her deserve the world," another viewer wrote. "I love when people invent things or make things to help others out of love and kindness," one user added. Do you have funny and adorable videos or pictures of your pet you want to share? Send them to life@ with some details about your best friend and they could appear in our Pet of the Week lineup.


Newsweek
36 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Prince William's Reaction to Alcohol-Free Drink Goes Viral
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Prince William's reaction to being offered an alcohol-free cider during a royal visit has gone viral on TikTok. Why It Matters A TikTok video of the moment, which showed the prince enjoying himself at the event, received more than 715,000 views and 34,000 likes. Commenters praised the prince for responding in the same way many of his generation would, describing him as being in touch with ordinary people. Prince William and Sophie, the Duchess of Edinburgh, drinking cider at the Royal Cornwall Show in Wadebridge, England, on June 6. Prince William and Sophie, the Duchess of Edinburgh, drinking cider at the Royal Cornwall Show in Wadebridge, England, on June To Know The Prince of Wales was at the Royal Cornwall Show with his aunt Sophie, the Duchess of Edinburgh, when they tried a Rattler, a brand of Cornish hard cider that also sells a zero percent alcohol alternative. On being told he had been offered the zero percent version, William replied: "Oh no, no, no, no. I need an original," referring to the brand's signature drink, which contains 5.5 percent alcohol by volume. As he stood by the Rattler stall, William had said earlier, "Everyone remembers where they were when they had their first Rattler." He added: "You remember the first one. You don't remember the last." "We've got [something] a little bit different for you today," his host replied. "What's the Rattler? Zero?" William said. "Oh no, no, no, no. I need an original." The royal continued: "You bring out the big guns. Can't do the zero stuff." What People Are Saying One user commented on the TikTok video: "He's a great example for other Royals he's in touch with the everyday man loves football and loves a drink long live the future king." Another wrote: "Is 0% cider not just apple juice." A commenter added: "Future king has great banter." Prince William Speaks Out About Oceans Since the Royal Cornwall Show, William has helped to promote a new nature documentary, David Attenborough: Ocean. He also gave a speech about protecting the world's oceans in Monaco on Sunday: "The truth is that healthy oceans are essential to all life on earth. They generate half of the world's oxygen, regulate our climate and provide food for more than 3 billion people. "And today, they need our help. Rising sea temperatures, plastic pollution and overfishing are putting pressure on these fragile ecosystems … and on the people and communities who depend most upon them. "What once seemed an abundant resource is diminishing before our eyes. We all stand to be impacted. And we are all responsible for change—both negative and positive." Jack Royston is chief royal correspondent for Newsweek, based in London. You can find him on X, formerly Twitter, at @jack_royston and read his stories on Newsweek's The Royals Facebook page. Do you have a question about Charles and Queen Camilla, Prince William and Princess Kate, Meghan Markle and Prince Harry, or their family that you would like our experienced royal correspondents to answer? Email royals@ We'd love to hear from you.