logo
Martha Mills doctor's failings 'particularly grave'

Martha Mills doctor's failings 'particularly grave'

BBC News5 hours ago

The failings of a doctor responsible for Martha Mills' care, who died from sepsis, amounted to "gross negligence" and were "particularly grave", a medical tribunal says.Her death gave rise to Martha's Rule in hundreds of hospitals in England, giving parents the right to an urgent second opinion.The tribunal found consultant Prof Richard Thompson failed to appreciate how seriously ill 13-year-old Martha had become in the summer of 2021, following a bike accident.On the crucial afternoon, he did not examine her in person or send her to intensive care.The tribunal concluded Prof Thompson's fitness to practise is impaired, but whether he will be sanctioned is still to be decided.
Martha was transferred to King's College Hospital in London in 2021, one of three specialist treatment centres in the UK, after a holiday bike accident left her with serious injuries to her pancreas. Her parents, Merope Mills and Paul Laity, wrote about their pain and anger over their daughter's treatment following her death.During a family holiday, Martha had skidded on some sand and fell heavily on to the handlebars."It was a difficult, tricky injury, but it did not have to be a fatal one," Merope has said.But she stayed in the hospital for the next month.She developed an infection and then signs of sepsis - when the body's response to an infection is overwhelming and ends up injuring its own tissues and organs - but this was not managed properly.An inquest found that she could have survived her injuries if she'd been referred to the specialist children's intensive care in the hospital promptly, and received better care.Interviewed on BBC Radio 4's Today programme in 2023, Merope Mills said her family were not listened to by senior doctors on several occasions and were "not given the full picture" about Martha's deteriorating condition.
Over the past few weeks, the Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service has heard allegations from the doctors' regulator, the General Medical Council (GMC), that Prof Thompson failed on several counts over his care of Martha.He was the consultant on call on her ward on 29 August 2021 - two days before she died.The tribunal said it was "evident" that by around 17:00 that day Martha had "several high risk indicators" including her heart rate, blood pressure, breathing and a rising temperature, which "indicated a sudden and significant deterioration".It said Martha's condition, which included a new rash, justified her being moved to intensive care but "this opportunity was not taken".Later that evening, Prof Thompson was called at home by a colleague about Martha's continued fever. He had already seen her on his morning ward round, but did not return to the hospital to examine her in person.Prof Thompson has said one of the reasons he wanted to keep Martha on his ward was not to distress her parents, but the tribunal said this did not justify withholding or delaying her move to intensive care.The Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service has now decided that Prof Richard Thompson's fitness to practise had been impaired.The tribunal said this would reassure the public and send a message to doctors about the importance of following the fundamental principles of good care.
Martha's parents raised concerns about their daughter's care to the regulator, the General Medical Council, in 2022.Responding to the tribunal's findings Martha's parents said: "It is important to us that allegations denied have been found proved and the gravity of mistakes that led to our daughter's preventable death has been recognised. "We will always have in our minds the failures of culture, training and policy on Rays of Sunshine Ward at King's College Hospital, as well as the responsibility of individuals. "We'd like to thank all the thoughtful doctors who have helped us to understand what happened to Martha."The hospital that looked after Martha has admitted mistakes were made, and the trust said previously in a statement that it "remains deeply sorry that we failed Martha when she needed us most".

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Diabetes prevention scheme reduces risk of condition by quarter
Diabetes prevention scheme reduces risk of condition by quarter

BBC News

time34 minutes ago

  • BBC News

Diabetes prevention scheme reduces risk of condition by quarter

A diabetes prevention programme in Wales could reduce the risk of developing the condition by nearly a quarter, research has the all-Wales programme "doesn't currently live up to its name" as it only operates in parts of Wales, a charity affects more than 220,000 people in Wales with projections it could rise by 22% over the next Burr, head of Diabetes UK Cymru, said NHS costs had also risen and called for money to be invested in patients before they start to live with the condition. The Welsh government said funding has been allocated this year to make further progress in embedding delivery in core activity and rolling it out across Wales. Following a pilot in two parts of Wales, in 2022 the gradual roll out began with 35 of the 60 primary care clusters in Wales, prioritising areas in each health board with a high prevalence of type 2 by the Welsh government but provided by health boards, it has now been offered to more than 10,000 people across Wales."So many people in Wales will not have access to this programme currently and that's an inequity – its not fair," said Ms Burr."We want everyone to have access to the same level of support and care because diabetes is such a serious condition. "It's actually at crisis levels in Wales and continuing to rise and we need to make sure we're getting people the help they need before they develop diabetes if possible." David Weekes from Swansea has been among those to benefit from the prevention programme. The 67-year-old only discovered he was pre-diabetic when he went to the GP about an unrelated rash on his knees, and was sent to see the prevention team in Penclawdd."We talked about my diet and exercise and I went back for a follow-up appointment this year," he said. "In that time I have lost 2st 1lb (13kg). I stopped eating as many biscuits and cakes and I now go to the gym every day."I feel a lot better in myself for doing it and my glucose levels have come right down."Ms Weekes said while he was not unfit before, it gave him the warning "I needed"."I now cycle seven days a week, for about 15-16 miles (25km), and I do weightlifting in the gym." The scheme uses a blood test, called an HbA1c test, to identify those at increased risk of developing type 2 diabetes by measuring their average blood sugar with levels between 42-47 millimoles per mole are classed as at increased risk and offered a 30-minute appointment with a healthcare support worker, where information and support is provided.A follow up appointment then takes place a year later. Dr Sarah Davies, a GP in Cardiff and primary care lead for diabetes in Wales, said blood tests would often identify someone is borderline for type 2 diabetes, but "until now we haven't had anywhere we can refer those individuals to get that support"."Primary care is on our knees and under-resourced across Wales. So sometimes those patients haven't received much in the way of information about pre diabetes."That's why I so welcome this program to enable us to refer these individuals into a community service."I'm hoping now that we've got this study that clearly demonstrates the benefits, this will support more widespread funding for this innovative program here in NHS Wales."She added that patients sometimes feel shame attached to being told they are pre-diabetic."There's a lot of blame associated with it, which is not the case. There's many reasons why people end up living with overweight, obesity and at risk of type two diabetes, many complex environmental, genetic reasons. "So sometimes people don't want to face up to it, but actually giving one to one support via this program is a lovely way to be able to give an individualized approach."Alisha Davies, head of research and evaluation at Public Health Wales, said results have shown the programme has been been effective in "stalling and reducing progression" to diabetic blood glucose levels. She said "robust monitoring and evaluation" will help to understand its impact over time on "an important preventable disease in Wales". Staff from one primary care cluster in Swansea have also taken the screening to a local mosque to identify those who are either pre-diabetic or have undiagnosed Wynn Burke said: "Our practice population includes a significant Asian community who are known to be at higher risk of diabetes from a much younger age."We do a lot of diabetes screening in high-risk individuals as part of our normal practice. "However, the percentage of our practice population with a diagnosis of type 2 diabetes remains below the expected ratio, therefore we sought to reach out and bridge potential health inequalities."Caroline Ashwood, an advanced nurse practitioner at SA1 Medical Centre, said around a fifth of the 140 people screened over three days so far had been identified as pre-diabetic, and three had diabetes."Swansea Mosque is based within our (cluster area), and it is one of the largest in the UK with around 10,000 members, so this was a great opportunity to bridge health inequalities," she said. "The team at Swansea Mosque were equally proactive in working together. They set up the online booking system and supported us on the screening days we have already carried out." The Welsh government said: "We know preventative support makes a real difference in reducing the risk of people with prediabetes developing type 2 diabetes, and funding from a variety of sources has been used to develop and extend the programme. "To ensure more people across Wales can benefit from early support, funding has also been allocated this year to make further progress in embedding delivery in core activity and rolling out across Wales." How many people have diabetes in Wales? There are more than 220,000 people in Wales with diabetes – predominantly with type 2 which is preventable – and the numbers have steadily risen in by Public Health Wales (PHW) suggest that without intervention, by 2035 there will be a 22% rise in those figures are higher among older people and men, though Diabetes UK Cymru said they were seeing more cases of people under 40 developing the research shows the cost and volume of medicines prescribed for diabetes has been steadily increasing over the last cost of medicine ingredients alone has risen 56% in the last five years and is now over £90m in Wales, partly because of the increase in the numbers of items were also 90,000 hospital admissions attributed to diabetes in Wales during 2021/2022. What is type 2 diabetes? Type 2 diabetes is where the body does not produce enough insulin, or the body's cells do not react to insulin eating, regular exercise and a healthy body weight reduce the risk of developing condition can cause excessive thirst, tiredness and the need to go for a wee a lot. It can also lead to complications like heart disease, stroke, kidney disease, retina damage and foot problems if not managed well.

‘Women' targeted in prostate cancer campaign by major charity
‘Women' targeted in prostate cancer campaign by major charity

Telegraph

timean hour ago

  • Telegraph

‘Women' targeted in prostate cancer campaign by major charity

A leading prostate cancer charity has been promoting the stories of 'women with a trans history' above men on its website. Prostate Cancer UK has a webpage dedicated to the 'real-life stories' of men who have undergone prostate treatment. But the first stories that readers see underneath a sub-heading of 'here, men share their experiences' are those of Suzanna and Alice. The charity moved the two stories to the bottom of its website after being approached by The Telegraph. The trans women make up two of the 20 stories published by the charity – which has been accused of causing confusion among men seeking advice and guidance – despite one of them never being diagnosed with prostate cancer. Campaigners said Prostate Cancer UK risked 'harming its target audience' with the 'unclear activist language'. 'Trans history' The first story describes Suzanna as a '72-year-old woman with a trans history' who was treated for 'an enlarged prostate' and did not have cancer. She had her genitals removed in 2013 and later developed incontinence issues. The story says: 'I went to the GP. I had no qualms about doing this, unlike some women with a trans history, as had been at the practice for years and the GP knows about my trans history.' The protein-specific antigen test revealed nothing but an MRI scan suggested that the prostate was twice the size it should be. Suzanna was given drugs to 'calm an 'overexcited' bladder' and another 'to relax my urethra so that I could pass urine more easily'. The story concludes: 'I know that some health professionals don't understand the issues with regards to trans women and that education is needed, but my consultant was very thorough and professional. There were no issues like, 'Why are you here, you are a woman?'' Of the 20 stories included, it was one of just two in which the person was not diagnosed with cancer. The other was a story of a young man living with prostatitis, which is inflammation of the prostate. The other trans woman's story describes how 'Alice was diagnosed with an enlarged prostate and prostate cancer before she transitioned'. The story says: 'When I was diagnosed, I thought, 'Great, take the lot away', until I quickly learnt that the prostate remains after genital reconstructive surgery. At this time, no one treating me for prostate cancer was aware of my gender dysphoria. 'Overall, my experience is that no one who has spoken with me – urologists, GPs or gender specialists at the gender identity clinic – have indicated that they are aware of any specific issues required for a trans woman with prostate cancer. 'In the end, I had to suggest that my urologist was contacted by the gender identity clinic staff as the urologists were treating me as a male, not as a trans woman.' 'Wrong way to go about it' Fiona McAnena, the director of campaigns at human rights charity Sex Matters, said it was 'helpful that Prostate Cancer UK reminds all men about this male-specific cancer, and that identifying as a woman doesn't mean a man is no longer at risk'. She said: 'But describing these men as 'women with a trans history', as the charity does, is completely the wrong way to go about this.' Ms McAnena said that 'confused young trans-identifying women who've been taught a nonsense version of science based on gender ideology at school in recent years may think this refers to them', while 'some trans-identifying men claim they have become biologically female'. She said that 'no responsible charity should leave room for such disinformation' and warned that it risked losing the importance of biological sex, such as in the case of cervical campaigns, which she said 'have all but abandoned clear words like 'woman' and 'female' and instead talk confusingly about 'people with a cervix''. 'Prostate Cancer UK risks harming its target audience – that is, all men, however they identify – by embracing unclear activist language,' she added. 'Must be based on biological reality' Dr Alice Hodkinson, a GP and co-founder of Biology in Medicine, said that 'prostate cancer care must be based on biological reality, not gender identity, to ensure patient safety'. She said: 'Most men who identify as trans women have not undergone surgery, are not on cross-sex hormones, and all retain their prostates, so they remain at risk of prostate cancer. 'Trans women who have had genital surgery or are taking hormones, may face additional risks.' A Prostate Cancer UK spokesman said: 'We're here to stop people dying from prostate cancer, and to support all those affected by it. That includes men, trans women, non-binary and intersex people, and their family and friends. 'As part of our mission to raise awareness of prostate cancer and its impact, we tell the stories of a diverse range of hundreds of people each year in the press, across our social media, and on other channels including on our website, emails to supporters, and many more.'

Job losses at Totally as urgent NHS call firm collapses
Job losses at Totally as urgent NHS call firm collapses

BBC News

time2 hours ago

  • BBC News

Job losses at Totally as urgent NHS call firm collapses

A healthcare firm, which provided urgent care services in NHS 111 call centres, has gone into administration with the loss of 100 which employed 1,400 people across several sites in the UK, including Stockton-on-Tees and Newcastle, said workers had lost their jobs across the group but did not confirm how many had been affected at each company has been sold to PHL Group, another healthcare provider to the NHS - with the immediate transfer of 600 of its Vance, joint administrator at EY-Parthenon, said he was pleased that hundreds of jobs and "critical frontline NHS services" had been safeguarded by the sale. Derby-based Totally had been struggling since losing the NHS 111 support contract in February. Mr Vance said: "We are pleased to have agreed the sale of Totally plc which safeguards critical frontline NHS services and includes the retention of over 600 jobs." Follow BBC North East on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store