MoD ‘dishonest' to call 1994 Chinook crash an accident, say families
All 25 passengers – made up of personnel from MI5, the Royal Ulster Constabulary and the British Army – were killed, along with the helicopter's four crew members.
The families of those who died said earlier this month that they were beginning legal action against the Ministry of Defence (MoD) for not ordering a public inquiry.
They want a High Court judge to be able to review information which they say was not included in previous investigations, and which they believe will shed new light on the airworthiness of the helicopter.
The families, who have coalesced into the Chinook Justice Campaign, said failing to order a public inquiry is a breach of the UK Government's human rights obligations.
An MoD spokesperson said: 'The Mull of Kintyre crash was a tragic accident, and our thoughts and sympathies remain with the families, friends and colleagues of all those who died.
'We have received a pre-action protocol letter from the Chinook Justice Campaign and are considering our response. Therefore, it would be inappropriate to comment further.'
Solicitor Mark Stephens, who is representing the families, said: 'The statements issued by the Ministry of Defence in recent days are so blatantly at odds with the facts as we now know them that they have caused immense upset to the families and cast a further cruel and disgraceful shadow on this ongoing travesty of justice.
'We know that the RAF helicopter carrying the 29 service personnel who were killed, serving their country, had been grounded because of fatal flaws in the software on board.
'For the MoD to claim that this was a 'tragic accident' flies in the face of the facts and is blatantly and disgracefully at odds with the truth.
'It is nothing short of dishonest, deceitful and disingenuous and we demand a retraction.'
The families have also called for the release of documents that were sealed at the time of the crash for 100 years, something revealed in a BBC documentary last year.
The MoD has said that records held in the National Archives contain personal information and early release of those documents would breach their data protection rights.
Mr Stephens said: 'For the Government to believe that data protection laws were designed to protect someone who is living – and who may have made a dreadful decision that night – rather than the truth emerging over 29 service personnel who were killed in an unairworthy aircraft, is a total abomination.
'This decision must be overturned, these files must be seen by a judge, and we will fight this in court if necessary.'
Niven Phoenix, a commercial pilot whose father Ian was one of the senior RUC officers killed in the crash, said: 'This was about as far from a tragic accident as you could get. Locking the files away until we are all dead proves there is a cover-up about something.
'The MoD's statement that these files have been sealed to protect third party interests is yet another disingenuous, distasteful and outright dishonest assertion designed to hide the truth using data protection laws which only came into force in the UK long after the crash.
'The Government would prefer for all the children of the Chinook victims to die like their parents rather than provide access, answers and take accountability for past mistakes. This is not the duty of candour promised by Keir Starmer in his election manifesto.'
Following the crash, the Chinook's pilots, Flight Lieutenants Richard Cook and Jonathan Tapper, were accused of gross negligence, but this verdict was overturned by the UK Government 17 years later, following a campaign by the families.
A subsequent review by Lord Philip set out 'numerous concerns' raised by those who worked on the Chinooks, with the MoD's testing centre at Boscombe Down in Wiltshire declaring the Chinook Mk2 helicopters 'unairworthy' prior to the crash.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Fish and chip shops 'could vanish' due to Nigel Farage's net zero opposition
Labour MP Bill Esterson, chair of the Energy Security and Net Zero Select Committee, accused Reform UK of ignoring the dangers of climate change and its impact on prices Fish and chips are at risk of vanishing from the high street if Nigel Farage has his way, a senior Labour figure has warned. British waters have seen record average temperatures over the first seven months of the year, leading to shifts in the species living in our waters, and creating challenges for fishing. Statistics also show the average price of fish and chips jumped from £6.64 in January 2020 to £10.09 in January 2025, despite industry attempts to ' cushion the blow ' for consumers. Labour MP Bill Esterson, chair of the Energy Security and Net Zero Select Committee, has now accused Reform of ignoring the dangers of climate change, and argued it was seeing prices soar in a blow to business. He told The Mirror: "While Nigel Farage wants us to ignore climate change, part of the British way of life is under threat. The seas around the UK are warming up. Cod and haddock are moving to colder waters." It comes after a Reform UK police chief's 'dark heart of wokeness' claim comes under fire. He continued: "The Labour government is taking climate action at home and abroad which will help limit the rise in sea temperatures. Reform needs to explain why they are happy for the British public to pay through the nose for our fish and chips, or possibly even lose our nation's favourite dish once and for all.' Mr Farage has previously described the UK's net zero target as 'complete and utter madness', while his fellow Reform MP Richard Tice recently 'declared war' on green energy projects. National Federation of Fish Friers President Andrew Crook told The Mirror climate change could be a factor in the price increases, and that the UK's chippies were doing their best to keep prices down for customers. He said: 'Most of the fish used in the nation's fish and chip shops comes from the Barents Sea and the waters around Iceland as the fish prefers deeper colder water than around the UK. We are currently feeling the effects of the quota for cod being reduced from 1m tonnes five years ago to 340,000 tonnes this year as scientists are trying to address a couple of poor year classes of fish. 'These could be caused by climate change, predation or another natural occurrence. In isolation we could handle it but we are seeing increases across the board and high tax burden which unfortunately has led to some increases but we are trying to cushion consumers as much as we can so they can continue to enjoy the nation's favourite dish.'
Wales Online
3 hours ago
- Wales Online
Asda and Tesco pull pork from 'Red Tractor' supplier after allegations
Asda and Tesco pull pork from 'Red Tractor' supplier after allegations The supermarkets have suspended supply from a UK farm after claims of cruelty Pigs were said to have been abused Supermarkets have suspended supplies from a pig farm after an investigation detailed allegations of animal cruelty. Tesco and Asda said they had suspended supplies from Somerby Top Farm in Lincolnshire, which is run by British meat producer Cranswick. It comes after the Mail on Sunday reported that workers would routinely 'hit pigs with boards, paddles and their fists, deliberately targeting areas such as their snout and eyes'. The newspaper added that welfare checks often ignored 'visible injuries and suffering, with one inspection of 1,000 pigs lasting just 90 seconds', as well as 'multiple botched killings of lame piglets'. Covert filming at the farm, which houses thousands of pigs, was carried out over a 10-month period by animal rights group Animal Justice Project. It was reported that some of the 'most severe abuse' was inflicted on animals two weeks after the farm was audited by food chain assurance scheme Red Tractor. Red Tractor said Somerby Top Farm's certification had been suspended with immediate effect following the 'deeply distressing' footage. It added that it had referred the case to the Government's animal welfare regulator, the Animal and Plant Health Agency. A Tesco spokesperson said: 'We take animal welfare extremely seriously and expect all our suppliers to adhere to our high welfare standards. 'We were shocked by this footage, and we have immediately suspended the farm in question. 'Our specialist agriculture team is working with the supplier to carry out a full investigation.' Article continues below Asda said it had 'immediately suspended supply' from the farm after the supermarket was made aware of the claims. In a statement, Red Tractor said: 'This footage is deeply distressing. Red Tractor is taking this clear breach of animal welfare standards extremely seriously. 'The farm's Red Tractor certification has been suspended with immediate effect and a full investigation is underway. Red Tractor is conducting a thorough review of both current and historical footage, compliance and staffing on the farm. The farm will remain unassured if Red Tractor is not satisfied our standards are met. 'It's important to note that this footage was taken between May 2024 and January 2025, with evidence and allegations only being presented to Red Tractor in August 2025. This delay is concerning and suggests that these activists have prioritised ideology over protecting animal welfare. 'Red Tractor provides a free anonymous whistle-blowing service and we actively encourage anyone with concerns to raise these so that we can investigate immediately.' Cranswick's shares plummeted in May after UK supermarkets suspended supplies from another one of its farms that was linked to abuse against pigs. Covert footage appeared to show workers at Northmoor Farm in Lincolnshire abusing piglets. Workers were filmed holding piglets by their hind legs and slamming them to the ground, using a banned method of killing the animals known as 'piglet thumping'. Other footage showed the botched killing of a sow that left the animal screaming and writhing in pain. A sow was also shown being beaten with metal bars. The footage was filmed by Animal Justice Project and first reported by the Mail on Sunday newspaper. In an update on Northmoor Farm, Red Tractor said: 'Following the exposure of poor welfare practices in May, Red Tractor immediately suspended the farm's certificate. Following a full investigation, the farm's Red Tractor certificate was reinstated provided strict conditions are met. The farm is now subject to regular unannounced spot checks, was required to immediately retrain staff in animal welfare and must share regular regulatory reports with Red Tractor. 'The farm was also required to install CCTV, and that footage is regularly reviewed by independent welfare experts. These terms together with independent on-going scrutiny have been fully complied with since the reinstatement. Article continues below 'In addition, Red Tractor conducted an unannounced welfare spot check on Northmoor Farm on Wednesday 13th August 2025, which did not find any issues relating to Red Tractor standards.' Cranswick has been approached for comment.
Daily Mirror
3 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
KEVIN MAGUIRE: 'Brextremists and Trumpists have proved their unfitness to govern Britain'
The Mirror's Kevin Maguire argues that Brextremists and Trumpists have proved they are unfit to ever govern Britain again, saying "they must never be trusted" They must never be trusted again, inviting infamy as the British fools who sold out heroic Volodymyr Zelensky and assaulted Ukraine by supporting Putin's puppet Donald Trump 's bid for the US Presidency. Lickspittle Nigel Farage campaigned for his 'good friend' Trump at rallies and fawned over America's tinpot tyrant. Chancer Boris Johnson undid the signature achievement that was backing Ukraine in an otherwise sleazy, incompetent and corrupt Premiership by ignoring alarm bells to endorse his fellow great deceiver. Deranged Liz Truss cemented her descent into idiocy after that short-lived disastrous No 10 spell in falsely asserting the world would be safer with Trump in the Oval Office. Naive Kemi Badenoch bought a Trump stunt in McDonald's as proof he understood ordinary Americans' lives because she once temporarily worked in one of the corporation's burger bars. Shape-shifting Farage tribute act Robert Jenrick, currently plotting to seize Badenoch's Tory tarnished crown, actually boasted in August last year, he would vote for Trump if he could. Foot-in-mouther Suella Braverman was similarly gushing, the twice sacked Conservative former Home Secretary and onetime Reform potential recruit publicly declaring too she wanted Trump to be President. Tory posh disciple Jacob Rees-Mogg was so besotted he gushed he'd love to emulate Trump and - seriously! - 'build a wall in the middle of the English Channel' before Somerset gave the prat the boot. And then there is 30p Lee Anderson, another Reform pickup from the Tories, who strutted as the England's shouty Midlands version of the US Fat Cat tycoon. As we shudder at a Trump putty in Putin's hands, let us remember Desperate Donald's British acolytes also missold the expensive tragedy that is Brexit with special mention for generic Jenryk, an opportunist vocal convert since the 2016 referendum. Yanking Britain out of the European Union, the economy diving and migration jumping alongside longer passport queues, should be enough on its own for the above to never be gifted power in future. The fate of Ukraine, US President demanding Kyiv surrender when America would rightly never, for example, sign away Alaska or California if Putin occupied its territory, seals the ill-judgement of Britain's Trumpists. Labour PM Keir Starmer playing a difficult diplomatic hand is stomach-churning whenever he lauds Trump to sustain a bromance in the hope the UK can be a minor restraint. But send any of the true believers into Downing Street and regrets we'd quickly have a plenty, reduced to a 51st state. The Brextremists and Trumpists have proved their unfitness to govern Britain. Don't get me started on feather-bedded £3m landowners Wealthfare beneficiaries are loudly bemoaning again they may no longer be able to pocket nice fortunes without paying their fair dues to our country, a rich something-for-nothing brigade upset this time over speculation Rachel Reeves might shut a £2.1billion inheritance tax loophole. The cash slipped to dodge the duty by giving it away at least seven years before the owner shuffles off this mortal coil has soared 40% over five years. That's lost tax that could improve health and education, enforce law and order or fill potholes instead of cascading inequality and privilege through generations. Life's lottery winners who pay inheritance tax are fortunate when a couple can leave a fat million before it starts applying and don't get me started on feather-bedded £3m landowners and farmers. The Chancellor of the Exchequer may do nothing, intimidated by a self-serving backlash. That would be a pity. Jaundiced Jenkyns all over the place There's nothing like a dame when it's clueless Reform reactionary Dame Andrea Jenkyns, the former Boris Johnson Tory fan woman now the ultra-Conservative party's Greater Lincolnshire Mayor. Surely playing herself in an adults-only pantomime in the Grimsby Auditorium is next after frightening shallowness was exposed in a horror performance on Channel 4 News with Krishnan Guru Murthy. Jaundiced Jenkyns was all over the place when challenged how she'd deal practically with asylum seekers then collapsed completely when her interlocutor factually pointed out the vast majority of sexual crimes are committed by British-born people. Right-whingers like Jenkyns want to single out the ethnicity of suspects to fuel fires, not douse flames. As a grandfather of Southport victim Bebe King observed, mental health issues and poor educational attainment correlate with criminal convictions. Releasing school records might be more relevant. You got to be squidding us They say that if you lie down with dogs you catch fleas but holy carp when poor David Lammy's on the hook after fishing with bottom feeding American extremist JD Vance before buying a legally required rod licence. I bet he's let off with a slap on the wrist with a shop-bought dead old carp rather than netting the max £2,500 fine yet for heaven's hake the hapless Foreign Secretary's organisational skills are plankton level. Next time he needs to mussel up and tell a US Vice President who ain't no fintastic catch you got to be squidding us. Going up Now Labour's conscience, former leader Neil Kinnock reminding voters what the UK Government should do by proposing the end of a poverty-creating vile Tory two-child benefit cap after earlier championing a wealth tax is top trolling. Starmer must hate him. Going down UK trade envoys are political Mickey Mouse jobs but Manchester Rusholme MP Afzal Khan is more Goofy, forced to quit his Turkey sinecure after visiting the Turkish occupied northern Cyprus pariah state. Talk about failing to use his noggin. Speaker's corner 'I was never really one for posters because why would you ruin the wallpaper?' And I'm never really one to knock the young yet £400million Warwickshire council's 19-year-old student Reform leader George Finch - still living with his mam - never putting up a footballer, pop star or even a map in his bedroom is a taste of Hard Right weirdos who'd fill Parliament should Farage win an election.
