AgriSA and community leaders warn of economic fallout from tobacco legislation
In its parliamentary submission, AgriSA said the bill, in its current form, neglects to consider the broader implications on agricultural livelihoods. It said tobacco farming remained a vital income source for thousands of rural households, especially in provinces where alternative crops were not economically viable.
'We feel that good legislation is necessary to avoid harmful consequences that might not be foreseen in terms of the present bill. Our emphasis is on fixing what is wrong before we progress to further statutory requirements, the consequences of which have not been fully explored.
'We don't have a vested interest in smoking. We have a vested interest in a constructively regulated, purposeful, evidence-based bill that doesn't create the unforeseen consequence whereby we're supporting illegality through regulation, which is not appropriate to achieve the objective we all want to see achieved,' said AgriSA's Janse Rabie.
Rabie said tobacco production dropped by about 50% in five years.
'Why? Because illicit trade has eaten their market away. That's the bottom line and farmers ask the honest question to government: why has government allowed our market to be eaten away by illicit trade?
'If you want to really address the harm, you need to properly legislate the ability to enforce. We absolutely need to make sure that what is in place is properly enforced and that we don't carry on a system that is not working and is allowing for additional illegality to take place.'
Nedlac Community Trust CEO Nhlanhla Ndlovu said the issue of the Tobacco Bill was 'misguided from the point of view of not quantifying the impact to producers like farmers, with potential significant implications for the farmers, workers and communities they support'.
'It looks like there's an economic impact that will result in an inability, among affected farmers and communities, to make an income, but there's no viable replacement programme. You are taking away livelihoods in a context where crime stats are showing an increase across the board.'
ActionSA MP and harm reduction advocate Dr Kgosi Letlape added his voice, saying the bill seemed to condemn adult smokers to death while 'concentrating solely on issues of youth uptake, which are important, but the deaths don't come from the youth'.
He was also concerned about the impact on agriculture in SA. 'Should our agricultural sector be looking beyond our borders to progressive markets where their products could be used for less harmful sources of nicotine?
'My fear is not that the industry will die, it'll just be driven into the wrong hands.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Eyewitness News
6 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
National Dialogue to go ahead despite withdrawal of legacy foundations
JOHANNESBURG - President Cyril Ramaphosa said the National Dialogue will go ahead as planned despite the withdrawal of several legacy foundations. Foundations, including the Thabo Mbeki and Kgalema Motlanthe and Ahmed Kathrada, pulled out citing a rushed process, lack of an approved budget and concerns over government control. Action SA has also reacted, saying it is reconsidering its participation amid questions over the dialogue's credibility and impact. Speaking outside an engagement in Vereeniging, south of Johannesburg, Ramaphosa emphasised that logistical arrangements are in place - including released funds, a secure venue and an operations centre that's already functioning. ALSO READ: He said thousands of invites have been sent to a broad mix of stakeholders from community leaders, business, labour, to government representatives to ensure inclusive participation. Ramaphosa confirmed that the first part of the dialogue national convention will kick off next week, Friday, with him delivering the opening address to hundreds of attendees. "The dialogue will go ahead, the people of South Africa want the dialogue to go ahead. Of course, with an undertaking of this nature, there will be hiccups here and there." Ramaphosa said despite the criticism, the dialogue is a necessary platform to address South Africa's deepening socio-economic challenges. "The show is on the road, the caravan is moving."
IOL News
9 hours ago
- IOL News
Minister Macpherson faces backlash from ActionSA over alleged derogatory remarks
Minister Dean Macpherson is facing threats of being reported to the SAHRC for alleged racist remarks. Image: Independent Media Archives Public Works and Infrastructure Minister Dean Macpherson is standing his ground against pressure to retract utterances that were allegedly degrading ActionSA supporters to worthless people amid threats to report him to the South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC). The ActionSA held an online meeting on Thursday, discussing further steps to be taken against the DA's KwaZulu-Natal chairperson. The party, which had already referred Macpherson to the national Parliament's Joint Committee on Ethics and Members' Interests for disciplinary action, is furious that he, outside the Pietermaritzburg High Court late last month, referred to 'over 500 Black ActionSA members' as pharas. ActionSA was demanding that the issue of calling its supporters pharas be given the same condemnation as Open Chats Podcast hosts, who are now being probed by the SAHRC for making derogatory remarks about coloured people. During a TikTok livestream discussion, ActionSA MP Alan Beesley said the SAHRC was the next step to hold the minister accountable for his utterances. 'After we reported Macpherson to the ethics committee in Parliament, and since we were hoping that he was going to apologise after we gave him a week to do so, which he had not done; that is going to continue. 'And we are going to launch a formal complaint with the SAHRC as this was a violation of the human rights of people, who were predominantly black, in a racist manner,' said Beesley. Instead of bowing to pressure to apologise, Macpherson accused ActionSA of being an attention seeker that was hellbent on distracting him from the fight against corruption. 'It's interesting that every time I am fighting corruption or dealing with critical issues in the department, ActionSA is trying to divert attention away from that issue,' he told this reporter last week. When asked to comment on the threats to refer him to the SAHRC, Macpherson said: 'My comment still stands.' Beesley announced taking alleged racist remarks to the SAHRC, shortly after Macpherson was at the Cape Town Central Police Station to open a case against the Independent Development Trust (IDT) suspended chief executive officer, Tebogo Malaka, and the trust's spokesperson, Phasha Makgolane, for trying to bribe a journalist. Beesley said Macpherson violated the rights that were protected by the Bill of Rights. Macpherson was caught in a video that found its way to social media, addressing DA supporters and leaders, including its Francois Rodgers, about the presence of ActionSA supporters outside the court, saying: 'There is a smallanyana (little) party (referring to ActionSA); they just brought up some people, and we don't know who they are since they are pharas; they gave them some green T-shirts. 'When you ask which party (they belong to), they said 'angazi' (I don't know), 'I am just here for one meal and one drink', and they were here for just singing and dancing.' Both the ActionSA and DA were in court attending a case they brought together against eThekwini Municipality for failing to fix sewage spillage around the city. Beesley said it was not premature to refer the matter to the SAHRC before being dealt with by Parliament, which is currently in recess. 'The SAHRC is here to protect human rights, while the ethics committee is here to protect the ethics of Parliament. We cannot divorce the fact that Macpherson is a member of Parliament and is a human being who is treating people differently. 'We should pursue him both as a member of Parliament and as an ordinary South African, because even if he made those comments as an ordinary South African, they would be out of line because you cannot mistreat people who are suffering the most, like that,' said Beesly. ActionSA provincial leader Zwakele Mncwango said Macpherson was refusing to apologise because 'he believed in what he said'. 'I think he does not see a reason why he must apologise as he stands by his words, and that is how he sees black people in South Africa. Unfortunately, he does not see anything wrong with what he said while he is a minister,' said Mncwango. He said Macpherson portrayed himself as a minister who was not prepared to use his ministerial position to help the homeless people out of their situation by building them houses. 'His arrogance will always show off, and even the DA has not said anything about this, and that tells you that it is in their DNA to stand with his views because if they also believed he is wrong, they should by now have spoken to him to apologise,' said Mncwango. ActionSA MP Mika Ngobeni, who was the livestream host, asked Mncwango to comment on parties in the Government of National Unity that were not criticising Macpherson in the same way they did against the podcast hosts who allegedly insulted coloured communities. Mncwango said this was because the legacy of apartheid was still hanging over. 'This requires all of us to work toward unity and to be true when it comes to reconciliation. If we ignore such matters or we look at them depending on who is saying what, we will never heal,' he said. [email protected]
The Star
11 hours ago
- The Star
‘Don't give us ridiculous conditions': EFF and MK party invited to join GNU
Jonisayi Maromo | Published 8 hours ago African National Congress (ANC) NEC member Mzwandile Masina said his party is moving ahead with plans to include more political parties in the Government of National Unity (GNU), and discussions are ongoing with political parties, including the Jacob-Zuma-led uMkontho weSizwe party. Earlier this week, IOL reported that as the ANC intensifies work to expand the size and reach of the GNU by adding more parties to the coalition currently governing South Africa, opposition party ActionSA insists it is not interested in joining the ruling arrangement. Leader of ActionSA, Herman Mashaba said so far, he has only heard from media reports that the ANC wants to approach ActionSA for negotiations around GNU inclusion, but his party has not heard a word from Luthuli House. One of the main political parties in the GNU, the Democratic Alliance (DA), strongly opposes expanding the ruling coalition. However, Masina said the ANC insists that, as the leader of the pact, the time has come to press the reset button. 'This GNU is led by ourselves. The DA will have to accept that we are resetting the button. We are bringing others who will be prepared to subscribe. What we will not accept are conditions, because previously we were given ridiculous conditions which we could not accept, which is why other parties are not necessarily part of the GNU,' the former mayor of Ekurhuleni spoke to broadcaster Newzroom Afrika. He said the ANC has directed the leadership led by President Cyril Ramaphosa to open discussions with other political parties represented in the National Assembly. Masina said the ANC is not expelling the DA from the Government of National Unity, but the decision to stay or leave the coalition lies with the blue party. 'We do not have a permanent relationship with them, because even ideologically we are two different parties, and it has been proven that we have to consolidate and ensure that this government remains stable,' he said. On the EFF and MK party, Masina said invitations have been extended to the opposition political parties and the ANC hopes they will not come with 'ridiculous conditions'. 'South Africa as a country is critical. We have spoken to those parties. We have spoken to EFF, we have spoken to MK, and MK is quite ridiculous. On one hand, they dispute the results (of the 2024 general elections) and on the other hand, they are in Parliament. There is a lot of confusion taking place there. 'With the EFF, there have been engagements, and I hope that this time around, they will not put demands that are ridiculous, that will make the ANC not consider. So I hope that throughout these engagements, they will allow us to ensure that we are firmer in terms of the statement and the principles that have been set up for this GNU, which is not permanent,' said Masina. On Tuesday, IOL reported that ANC veteran and National Executive Committee (NEC) member Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma has emphasised the need for the ANC to rebuild its structures on the ground and focus on local government to restore trust with the people. With the upcoming local government elections, Dlamini-Zuma stressed that the ANC should prioritise strengthening its branches and delivering services to communities. Service delivery remains a challenge in South Africa. This includes inadequate infrastructure, insufficient resources, and issues of maintenance and accountability. Dlamini-Zuma highlighted the importance of building strong branches. "Our branches must be built properly because the strength of the branch is what they do in the community… We are going to the local government elections, and we should be concentrating on that right now." In 2017, Dlamini-Zuma lost the battle to become the ANC president to Cyril Ramaphosa, who won with 2,440 votes. Dlamini-Zuma got 2,261. However, under Ramaphosa, the party lost its parliamentary majority in a historic election result that put South Africa on a new political path, in which the ANC was forced to form the Government of National Unity (GNU) with the DA and other small parties. [email protected] IOL News Get your news on the go, click here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel.
