FM criticises UK minister for saying she backs cuts
First Minister Eluned Morgan has criticised a UK cabinet minister and Welsh Labour colleague for saying she backed the chancellor's benefits cuts.
Welsh Secretary Jo Stevens told BBC Wales last week that the first minister had "welcomed" the reforms.
In a fiery session in the Senedd dominated by rows over changes to disability and sickness payments, Morgan said: "I had somebody else last week trying to speak for me. I speak for myself."
A source close to the first minister confirmed to the BBC that the comment referred to Stevens. The UK government has said it is not commenting on the matter.
In her strongest comments on the issue so far, Morgan said she lamented the reforms and that people were "suffering" and "worried".
But the first minister repeatedly declined to condemn the cuts outright as she came under sustained criticism from the opposition in first minister's questions (FMQs).
She had written to Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall asking for an assessment of the cuts' impact on Wales on 11 March.
A response was received at the weekend - over a fortnight later.
Facing criticism in the Senedd that she had declined to publish the response herself, Morgan said she hoped the UK government would release it on Tuesday afternoon.
At a committee meeting on Friday Morgan refused to support the welfare cuts until she knew what the impact would be.
She responded with silence when Stevens' claim of support for the changes was put to her.
Welsh ministers refuse to release benefits cuts letter
People 'terrified' by benefit reforms - Labour politician
Reeves criticised by Labour MP on benefits cuts
Welsh Conservative Senedd leader Darren Millar accused Morgan of a lack of transparency for not releasing the letter.
In her Spring Statement, Chancellor Rachel Reeves announced a number of benefit changes, including tightening qualification rules for Personal Independence Payments (Pips) - the main disability benefit - claimed by more than 250,000 working aged people in Wales.
In the Senedd Plaid Cymru's Rhun ap Iorwerth reminded the first minister of Stevens' comments, as he accused her of being fearful of upsetting the UK government.
In response Morgan said: "I've got a lot of people trying to put words into my mouth these days, haven't I?
"You summarized my position? I had somebody else last week trying to speak for me. I speak for myself. I speak for the Welsh government.
"The UK government can speak up for itself, and they can defend their positions. I will defend the position of the Welsh Labour government here in Wales."
Morgan came under pressure from a number of Plaid Cymru MSs, who called for her to condemn the reforms.
"What contempt Westminster shows us, leaving us in Wales to second-guess the effect that these benefit cuts will have because Westminster refuses to tell us," said Delyth Jewell, Plaid MS for South Wales East.
Morgan replied that she was "exercised about the proposal".
She said: "When we talk about changes, we have to understand that people are suffering here, and that we need to stand with them and listen to them and ensure that we speak for them.
"All over Wales today there are tens of thousands of people who are really worried about the impact that proposed reforms could have, but they don't know to what extent it will happen, they don't know when it will happen.
"I am determined to make sure that Welsh voices are heard when it comes to welfare reform," she added, promising to present concerns "plainly and unambiguously in the evidence that we will present in response to welfare reform".
While she argued there were some things in the plans that were positive, Morgan said: "One of the things that I lament is the fact that really, ideally, it should have been about putting people and the benefits system and the need to reform it first and then to worry about how that is organised afterwards."
The Welsh Conservatives' Darren Millar said in a statement: "The first minister promised accountability, but is delivering evasive answers and a complete lack of transparency.
"On a multitude of issues, Labour is hiding from scrutiny instead of giving the people of Wales the answers they deserve. On top of this, they're failing to stand up for Wales against Keir Starmer's wave of new taxes, hitting Welsh farmers and businesses."
By Gareth Lewis, BBC Wales political editor
Welfare reform is getting messier for Labour.
After some of the party's MPs and MSs spoke out against the plans, we now have the FM more explicitly taking issue with her Labour colleague at Westminster Jo Stevens.
Morgan's response last week to the claim that she welcomed the reforms was a silent, stony stare.
Some Labour MSs have been looking for the FM to assert herself on welfare, a tricky balance when the plans are being introduced by your own party.
Although she declined another opportunity to condemn the cuts, the language – "exercised", "lament" – is carefully chosen to go about as far as she feels comfortable without actually condemning them.
The problem for Morgan is that she is caught in a bind and risks pleasing no one.
One of her own MSs has already warned that his constituents are "terrified". Opposition parties are on the attack.
The Conservatives argue she is not being transparent enough about her dealings with the UK government; Plaid Cymru and the Lib Dems that she is not fighting hard enough to stand up for Wales.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Rail challenger to take on Labour's nationalised trains
Private train operator Lumo is plotting a range of new services across Britain in a direct challenge to Labour's nationalised rail network. FirstGroup, which owns the low-cost rail company, is looking to expand operations after already announcing plans to triple Lumo's passenger count to 10m a year with the addition of five new routes. Graham Sutherland, the chief executive, said FirstGroup is now studying population growth and housebuilding plans to determine where is best to introduce new routes. However, he said the company is particularly keen to restore direct services to London from small towns across the UK, while it is also exploring the possibility of launching trains between poorly connected regional centres. He said: 'Obviously it gets harder the further you get through it, but we feel there are other opportunities still to come out over time. 'Anything we are looking at is commercially sensitive. But the basic criteria is do we think there are under-served areas in terms of rail and do we have an opportunity to drive modal shift and get people out of their cars.' It comes after Labour sent out mixed messages on the continuation of private rail services following the launch of its state-backed railway company, Great British Railways (GBR). Privatised 'open-access' operators, which are not paid by the Government to run services and make their money only from passenger fares, are due to remain in private hands, according to the blueprint for GBR. However, Heidi Alexander, the Transport Secretary, wrote to the industry regulator in January advising it to adopt a more rigorous stance on approving open-access applications. GBR is set to be fully operational by next year. Meanwhile, The Telegraph revealed last month that LNER, which is already government-run, is predicted to lose out on £1bn in ticket sales to private operators offering cheaper fares. Mr Sutherland said open access is no threat to the nationalised railway, claiming instead that competition helps to improve standards and attract new customers. Mr Sutherland added that further routes targeted by Lumo were likely to conform to its existing long-distance model. FirstGroup currently operates open-access services along the east coast main line from Kings Cross to Edinburgh and Hull via Lumo and sister brand Hull Trains, which it plans to extend to Glasgow and Sheffield respectively. A further two new routes are guaranteed, one from London Euston to Stirling, in Scotland, and the other from London Paddington to Carmarthen, in south Wales, after FirstGroup bought access rights from Arriva's Grand Union. FirstGroup has also lodged applications with the Office of Rail and Road to run trains from Euston to Rochdale via Manchester and from Paddington to Hereford and Paignton, Devon. Should the company succeed in expanding to all seven routes, its open-access revenue should jump from £106m to around £300m, Mr Sutherland said. FirstGroup's South Western Railway became the first to be seized by Labour last month and will be followed by its remaining Avanti West Coast and Great Western franchises. 擷取數據時發生錯誤 登入存取你的投資組合 擷取數據時發生錯誤 擷取數據時發生錯誤 擷取數據時發生錯誤 擷取數據時發生錯誤
Epoch Times
2 hours ago
- Epoch Times
Australia's Public Broadcaster Axes ‘Q+A' Show After 18 Years on Air
The ABC has confirmed it will not bring back its flagship panel program Q+ A, ending an 18-year run. The weekly show, which went on break last month, will not return to air, the national broadcaster announced on June 11. Hosted by Patricia Karvelas since 2023, Q+A earned a reputation as a high-profile forum for political and public debate. ABC News Director Justin Stevens acknowledged the program's legacy in shaping national dialogue. 'Discontinuing the program at this point is no reflection on anyone on the show. We always need to keep innovating and renewing, and in the two decades since Q+A began, the world has changed,' Stevens said. Stevens said the ABC would now focus on finding new ways to engage the public in political and national discussions. 'It's time to rethink how audiences want to interact and to evolve how we can engage with the public to include as many Australians as possible in national conversations,' he said. The announcement follows Network 10's decision to axe The Project after 16 years, with the final episode set to air on June 27. Karvelas to Expand ABC Reporting Role While Q+A ends, Karvelas will continue in her other ABC roles, including Afternoon Briefing, the Politics Now podcast, and her regular column on the ABC News site. 'Patricia (Karvelas) also recently reported for Four Corners, and we've now asked her to do more for Four Corners as time permits,' Stevens said. ABC staff were informed that the show's cancellation would involve some job losses. In place of Q+A, the ABC will expand its long-form current affairs content, including the creation of a new executive producer role for documentaries and specials. The public broadcaster will also permanently roll out Your Say, a public engagement initiative first launched during the last federal election. The project is aimed at including more community voices in ABC reporting. 'Your Say ensures we have a strong framework for putting the public's views, concerns, and questions at the heart of our journalism, complementing our daily commissioning and reporting,' Stevens said.
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
Key points announced ahead of Rachel Reeves' spending review
Rachel Reeves will set out her spending plans for the coming years on Wednesday as she unveils her spending review. The review, which will set out day-to-day spending plans for the next three years and capital spending plans for the next four, is expected to see boosts for the NHS, defence and schools. But it is also likely to involve squeezes for other departments as the Chancellor seeks to keep within the fiscal rules she has set for herself. Her room for manoeuvre has also been further constrained by the Government's U-turn on winter fuel payments, which will see the benefit paid to pensioners receiving up to £35,000 per year at a cost of around £1.25 billion to the Treasury. The full details will be revealed in the Commons on Wednesday, but several announcements have already been made. They include: – £15.6 billion for public transport projects in England's city regions; – £16.7 billion for nuclear power projects, including £14.2 billion for the new Sizewell C power plant in Suffolk; – £39 billion over the next 10 years to build affordable and social housing; – An extension of the £3 bus fare cap until March 2027; – £445 million for upgrades to Welsh railways. The Chancellor is also expected to announce changes to the Treasury's 'green book' rules that govern whether major projects are approved. The Government hopes that changing the green book will make it easier to invest in areas outside London and the South East.
