logo
Dunphy's BBC debate a nostalgic reminder of English crisis never being far away

Dunphy's BBC debate a nostalgic reminder of English crisis never being far away

Irish Examiner14 hours ago
Nostalgia for the 1990s remains heavy. Just look at all those stadiums and parks the Gallaghers are filling. Football from the late 20th century has a similar cachet. No video assistant referees, no sportswashing; just good, hard, honest, simple fare, when men were men and pressing was what you did to your Burton suit. If the past is a foreign country then a recent BBC Archive release is a primary source of a time when the continental import remained exotic and not the dominant division of labour.
'Is English Football In Crisis?' asks an edition of On The Line in October 1993, broadcast the night before Graham Taylor's England played a key World Cup qualifier in Rotterdam. You know the match: Brian Moore correctly reading Ronald Koeman's free-kick – 'he's gonna flick one' – and the pathos of Taylor's hectoring of the linesman as England's hopes of qualifying for USA '94 sink into the briny.
Such is the soap opera of the English game – its warring factions, its unrelenting thirst for cash – that a crisis is often close, though now further down the food chain than the England team and the Premier League. A televised meeting of 2025's key actors is near unimaginable considering the secrecy many owners maintain, the global span from whence they come and many battles already being in camera through lawyers. The number of talking heads and influencers willing to step into the gaps is almost too grotesque to countenance. Snapshot to 1993 however, 14 months into the life of the Premier League, an entity barely mentioned over 40 minutes, and a room of football men are vehemently defending their corners. Just one woman is visible; the future sports minister Kate Hoey, and just one black face; that of Brendon Batson, deputy chief executive of the Professional Footballers' Association. He remains wordless.
Read More
Hallgrímsson facing Brady blow after calf injury rules veteran out of World Cup qualifiers
A raven-haired John Inverdale operates as a Robert Kilroy-Silk/Jerry Springer figure as various blokes in baggy suits – 'some of the most influential and thoughtful people in football' is Inverdale's billing – fight their corners. Here is a time before gym-buff execs, when male-pattern baldness is still legally allowed in boardrooms and exec boxes, when a moustache is anything but ironic.
'The whole game is directed towards winning rather than learning,' complains John Cartwright, recently resigned coach at the Lilleshall national academy, a less than gentle loosener. England's Football Association is swiftly under attack from Hoey over being 'out of touch'. Enter Jimmy Hill, a Zelig of football as player, manager, chair, the revolutionary behind the 1961 removal of the maximum wage, major figure – on and off screen – behind football's growth as a television sport. Few have filled the role of English football man so completely and his responses to Hoey are dismissive, truculent. 'You can only attack one question at a time and I find the attacks are so ignorant,' he rails, defending English coaching. Hill's stance has not travelled well. Within three years, Arsène Wenger, among others, would be upending the sanctity of English coaching exceptionalism.
A short film from the ever gloomy Graham Kelly follows. The then-Football Association chief executive dolefully advertises his body's youth development plan before David Pleat's description of English youngsters as merely 'reasonable' rather blows Kelly's cover. Former Manchester City manager Malcolm Allison, by 1993 a long-lost 1960s revolutionary, declares England's kids were behind Ajax's as early as the late-1950s. 'Big Mal', demeanour far more On The Buses than On The Line, cuts the dash of ageing rebel, an Arthur Seaton still restless in his dotage, cast to the fringes as Cassandra.
Next the programme's wild card; Eamon Dunphy, footballer turned bestselling writer. The irascible face of Irish punditry for many decades seizes the stage with typical barbed lyricism, hunting down the stuffed shirts who run the game, full j'accuse mode adopted from his opening words. 'English football has historically drawn its talent from the streets but unfortunately it has left its inspiration in the gutter,' he begins his own short film. Dunphy then lashes the 'merchant class' that 'have always wielded power', kicks against the 'subservient', celebrating football's 'free spirited' outsiders.
Read More
Adam Idah needs competition to thrive, says Celtic boss Brendan Rodgers
'Football's greatest men have usually been its saddest – ignored, betrayed or patronised,' says Dunphy, soon enough labelling English football media coverage as 'banal'. 'Where is football's Neville Cardus?' he asks, referencing the Guardian's legendary cricket writer, setting a slew of fellow journalists, including the late David Lacey, also of this parish, on defensive footings.
Cast in 1993 as rabble-rousing agent of chaos from across the water, Dunphy would declare himself an Anglophile in his 2013 autobiography, appreciative of the freedom found in 1960s Manchester compared to the illiberal Ireland he came from. Here he despairs for what made English football once so magical, bemoaning Allison's estrangement and that Hill's experience was also confined to the sidelines.
Arsenal vice-chairman David Dein, a prime Premier League's architect, is next for a Dunphy dagger. 'You seem exceedingly smug about the idea of kids having to pay more for their identity' is a laser-guided attack on replica shirts being replaced each summer. It proves a tinderbox moment. Hill and Professional Footballers' Association chair Gordon Taylor soon fly at each other. 'Get yer facts right, Jim,' hisses Taylor as the subject of player wages ignites a bonfire fanned further by agent Eric Hall's 'monster monster' smirks.
Inverdale calls for order and concludes with a round-robin from which Pleat's 'you need an impossible man, a democratic dictator right at the top of football' sounds positively frightening. Somewhere in Pleat's logic may lie the UK government's imminent imposition of an independent football regulator, a process that led today's power brokers into a sustained, bloody battle against such interference.
Fast-forward 32 years, through Premier League and Champions League dominance, international failures and successes, foreign talent and investment, profit and sustainability, splintering media landscapes, women's football embodying national pride, much has changed and yet self-interest remains the darkest heart of English football.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Cristiano proposes to Georgina... with ring the size of a golf ball
Cristiano proposes to Georgina... with ring the size of a golf ball

Extra.ie​

time10 minutes ago

  • Extra.ie​

Cristiano proposes to Georgina... with ring the size of a golf ball

Cristiano Ronaldo is officially set to tie the knot after proposing to his other half, Georgina Rodriguez, with a monstrosity of a ring. The couple have been dating since 2016 when they met at a Gucci store where Georgina worked as a sales assistant. The pair are raising six children together. In 2022, the pair tragically lost their baby boy as they were expecting twins with them saying at the time that 'only the birth of our baby girl gives us the strength to live this moment with some hope and happiness'. Ronaldo was reportedly looking at schools for his children in England. Pic: Instagram/georginagio Taking to social media on Monday, Georgina announced that her husband, arguably the most famous footballer in the world, had popped the question. Dropping a photo of a ring that is quite literally the size of a rock, Georgina wrote: 'Yes I do. In this and in all my lives.' Georgina and Cristiano have been dating since last year. Pic: Instagram/georginagio Georgina began her career as a professional dancer and model, and now also works as a social media influencer boasting almost 70 million Instagram followers. Cristiano recently signed a new contract with Al Nassr in Saudi Arabia and is seemingly set to continue playing beyond the World Cup next year.

‘Everything, I'm telling you' – Micah Richards convinced SNAPCHAT risks derailing Fulham's Premier League season
‘Everything, I'm telling you' – Micah Richards convinced SNAPCHAT risks derailing Fulham's Premier League season

The Irish Sun

timean hour ago

  • The Irish Sun

‘Everything, I'm telling you' – Micah Richards convinced SNAPCHAT risks derailing Fulham's Premier League season

Alan Shearer and Gary Lineker had plenty to say in response MICAH RICHARDS believes Fulham will struggle this season after the club banned players from using SNAPCHAT. Richards left Gary Lineker and Alan Shearer stunned as he predicted that the social media outlet could be the downfall of Marco Silva's side in the new campaign. 2 Micah Richards predicts a Snapchat ban could ruin Fulham's season Credit: Getty 2 Alex Iwobi and Co were stopped from sharing behind-the-scenes snips by club chiefs Credit: Snapchat Fulham stars regularly provided behind-the-scenes Snaps of their journey to last term's 11th place Premier League finish. Fans were left loving the brilliant banter between their Craven Cottage icons. The regular Snapchat posts also gave a glimpse into the players' lives at the London club's training ground and stadium. But Alex Iwobi revealed in July that he and his Fulham teammates had been banned from further Snapchat posts by a member of staff. He told followers: 'For those that are wondering why I haven't been snapping BTS (behind-the-scenes) in the changing room, one person in the media team has been saying I haven't been catching the right stuff. 'So, there's no more BTS. They also said I might get fined if I continue to do so, they're trying to ban snap in our changing room. 'That's why I ain't been snapping BTS, it's a shame, I know you guys enjoy seeing what my team-mates are like behind the scenes. But, I have to respect the rules.' Now, former Man City title winner Richards reckons that Fulham's Snapchat clampdown could come back to bite the club. BEST FREE BETS AND BETTING SIGN UP OFFERS Silva's side have only made one signing in back-up goalie Benjamin Lecomte, while two attackers have departed in Willian and Carlos Vinicius. But Richards believes the inability to post on social media will have a worse effect on morale than the lack of new arrivals. Fulham star Calvin Bassey shows Arsenal fans his bum at worst time possible Speaking on The Rest is Football podcast, Richards' fellow presenter Shearer first said: 'I don't see Fulham doing as well as they did last year. 'I've got them sixth-bottom, I think they'll have too much to have them in a relegation battle but just below last season.' Richards then noted: 'I agree. And their media person has stopped them using Snapchat, where you used to get all the insight, the videos and stuff. Great for chemistry.' This left Shearer amused as he responded: 'Excuse me, what the f**k has that got to do with the prediction, by the way?!' Richards continued: 'Everything, I'm telling you. You can't do the videos no more, you go in there, it's going to be silent, there's going to be no banter flying, so it could affect them. 'So I'm going to say they're going to be just below what they did last season.' Shearer gasped: 'No Snapchat, so they're going to be just below last season! That's the reason!' Host Lineker then summed up the conversation by adding: 'Too much c***chat, not enough Snapchat.'

Meet the 32-strong Ireland squad heading to the Rugby World Cup
Meet the 32-strong Ireland squad heading to the Rugby World Cup

Irish Times

timean hour ago

  • Irish Times

Meet the 32-strong Ireland squad heading to the Rugby World Cup

Aoife Wafer Club: Blackrock/Leinster County: Wexford Age: 22 Position: Flanker READ MORE Wafer had been an injury concern after knee surgery, but is thankfully included in the World Cup squad. She won the 2025 Six Nations Player of the Tournament , was part of the 2024 World Rugby Dream Team, and was player of the match in the victory over New Zealand at the WXV1 tournament last year. Following the World Cup, she's set for a move to Harlequins. Ireland's Amee-Leigh Costigan in Cork for a warm-up match against Scotland. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Amee-Leigh Costigan Club: Railway Union/Munster County: Tipperary Age: 30 Position: Winger Perhaps best known for her Sevens antics, having been part of the Ireland team at the Paris Olympics, Costigan (formerly Murphy Crowe) is the Irish record-holder for most tries and was a try-scorer against England in this year's Six Nations. Ireland's Anna McGann scores her side's second try in Belfast despite McKinley Hunt of Canada. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Anna McGann Club: Railway Union County: Westmeath Age: 26 Position: Outside centre Another Sevens recruit, McGann was unlucky to miss out on the Olympics due to injury. She came back to the 15s to score a hat-trick of tries against Italy in the Six Nations and touched down twice in the warm-up game against Canada. Ireland's Aoibheann Reilly in Belfast. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Aoibheann Reilly Club: Blackrock/Connacht County: Roscommon Age: 24 Position: Scrumhalf Two ACL injuries within nine months haven't prevented Reilly from returning to full strength and earning a spot on the plane to England. The Roscommon native has been part of the Sevens system since 2021 and got her first 15s cap in 2022, amassing a further 16 since. Ireland's Aoife Dalton during a warm-up match with England in Cork. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Aoife Dalton Club: Old Belvedere/Leinster County: Offaly Age: 22 Position: Inside centre Named in the 2025 Six Nations Team of the Tournament, and player of the match in Ireland's win over Italy, Dalton finished last season with a Women's Player's Player of the Year at the Rugby Player Ireland Awards. One to watch. Ireland's Béibhinn Parsons tackled by Canada's Karen Paquin. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Beibhinn Parsons Club: Blackrock/Connacht County: Galway Age: 23 Position: Winger Despite her youth, Parsons is already a stalwart of the team, making history in 2016 as the youngest player to play a senior game for Ireland at 16. Back in form after injury, she scored two tries against Canada in the warm-up game. Ireland's Beth Buttimer in Belfast. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Beth Buttimer Club: UL Bohemian/Munster County: Tipperary Age: 19 Position: Hooker Buttimer, who turns 20 later this month, is the only uncapped player on the squad, having impressed in the recent u20 Summer Series. She has played with the Clovers in the Celtic Challenge and Munster at both underage and senior level. Ireland's Brittany Hogan during the warm-up match with Scotland. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Brittany Hogan Club: Old Belvedere/Ulster County: Down Age: 26 Position: Flanker Having missed out on the 2017 World Cup, Hogan has featured consistently Scott Bemand took the reins in 2023. Played in each of Ireland's Six Nations games this year and scored a try in the win over Italy. Ireland's Claire Boles training at the IRFU High Performance Centre in Dublin. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Claire Boles Club: Railway Union/Ulster County: Fermanagh Age: 27 Position: Flanker Boles travelled to the Olympics as a travelling reserve for the Sevens and was called on after Parsons and Lucy Mulhall were injured. She made her 15s debut in 2019, amassing four caps to date and was named in the squad for the game against Canada earlier this month. Ireland's Cliodhna Moloney-MacDonald training in Dublin. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Cliodhna Moloney MacDonald Club: Exeter Chiefs County: Galway Age: 32 Position: Hooker Almost three years exiled from the Irish team after a low point in the Irish women's team's relationship with the IRFU, she returned following Bemand's appointment. Playing her rugby full-time with Exeter Chiefs since 2022 after a move from Wasps, the Galway native has extended her contract for the 2025/2026 season. Ireland's Dannah O'Brien at a warm-up match in Dublin. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Dannah O'Brien Club: Old Belvedere/ Leinster County: Carlow Age: 21 Position: Outhalf Called into the senior squad for the inaugural women's summer tour in Japan aged 19, the former Tullow player has gone on to score 136 points in the Six Nations. She was the Celtic Challenge's top points-scorer in 2025 with 74. Ireland's Edel McMahon and France's Charlotte Escudero at a warm-up match in Belfast. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Edel McMahon Club: Exeter Chiefs County: Clare Age: 31 Position: Flanker Co-captaining the team, McMahon is one of the more senior players in the Irish squad and has played in the English Premiership since 2019, when she moved from Connacht to Wasps. Now plays with Exeter since a move in 2022. Ireland's Eimear Corri Fallon training at the IRFU High Performance Centre in Dublin. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Eimear Corri Fallon Club: Blackrock/Leinster County: Laois Age: 27 Position: Lock Balancing her burgeoning rugby career with studying medicine, the Laois woman was part of the Leinster team that defeated Munster in the 2024 Interpros and was Player of the Match in Leinster's victory over Ulster. Ireland's Emily Lane at the Affidea Stadium in Belfast. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Emily Lane Club: Blackrock/Munster County: Cork Age: 26 Position: Scrumhalf Lane made her Sevens debut in 2018, followed by her 15s debut in 2021. At the Paris Olympics, where Lane was the fifth most capped Irish player, she went viral when Erin King brought her safely to ground despite nearly tipping backwards over her team-mate's head during a lift. Ireland's Enya Breen at the IRFU High Performance Centre in Dublin. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Enya Breen Club: Blackrock/Munster County: Cork Age: 26 Position: Outhalf/centre A physiotherapist by trade, Breen has been a veteran of the 15s squad since her debut as a teenager in 2019 against France. She captained Ireland during their successful WXV1 campaign. Ireland's Eve Higgins at the IRFU High Performance Centre in Dublin. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Eve Higgins Club: Blackrock/Munster County: Kildare Age: 26 Position: Inside centre Higgins has been involved in Irish rugby for a decade now having been brought into the Sevens game at 16 before earning her first contract at 18, all while playing 15s for Railway Union. She's scored nine tries over her 27 caps at international 15s level and also featured at the Paris Olympics. Ireland's Fiona Tuite at the Affidea Stadium in Dublin. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Fiona Tuite Club: Old Belvedere/Leinster County: Dublin Age: 28 Position: Second row A former Dublin footballer, Tuite was introduced to rugby through the Sevens set up. She first took up 15s in college where she studied physiotherapy. Despite being unlucky with injuries, she has amassed 17 caps with the senior team. Ireland's Grace Moore at the warm-up match against Canada. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Grace Moore Club: Trailfinders Women County: IQ/London Age: 29 Position: Back row Scouted by the IQ Programme while playing for Richmond in the Premiership, Moore has played for Ireland in both Sevens and 15s. She played for Saracens before moving to Trailfinders for the 2024/2025 season. Moore has scored three tries in the Six Nations over her 20 appearances. Ireland's Ivana Kiripati during a warm-up match against Canada in Dublin. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Ivana Kiripati Club: Creggs/Connacht County: Westmeath Age: 23 Position: Number 8 Kiripati got her first two senior caps in the recent World Cup warm-up games. She played with Connacht at underage level before moving to the US for college, where she played both Sevens and 15s, and was part of the first Ireland under-20s panel. Ireland's Linda Djougang playing against Scotland in a warm-up game. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Linda Djougang County: Dublin Club: Old Belvedere/Leinster Age: 29 Position: Prop The most capped player on the squad with 48, Djougang has been a constant for Ireland since her first cap in 2019. She's scored 45 Six Nations points and was named Player of the Year at the 2025 Leinster Rugby awards. Ireland's Molly Scuffil McCabe training at the IRFU High Performance Centre. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Molly Scuffil McCabe County: Dublin Club: Manawatu RFC/ Leinster Age: 27 Position: Scrumhalf Encouraged to take up rugby by her then teacher, former Ireland player Fiona Coghlan, Scuffil McCabe has played both Sevens and 15s. She divides her time between Ireland and New Zealand, doing a pre-veterinary course in Massey University and playing with Manawatu Cyclones. Ireland's Neve Jones during a warm-up match against Canada. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Neve Jones County: Antrim Club: Gloucester Hartpury Age: 26 Position: Hooker Jones has been playing in the Premiership since 2022, having signed for Gloucester Hartpury. The 2020 Energia Women's AIL Rising Star, she captained Ireland in their warm-up defeat to Canada. Ireland's Eve Higgins and Niamh O'Dowd during a warm-up in Dublin. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Niamh O'Dowd Club: Old Belvedere/Leinster County: Wexford Age: 25 Position: Prop Set to shine brighter after consecutive, consistent appearances in last year's WXV1 tournament and this year's Six Nations, where only Aoife Wafer and Stacey Flood had more carries. Nominated for Women's 15s Players' Player of the Year at the Rugby Player Ireland Awards. Ireland's Nicole Fowley at the IRFU High Performance Centre. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Nicole Fowley Club: Galwegians/Connacht County: Galway Age: 32 Position: Outhalf Last year's Connacht Player of the Year, Fowley earned her first international cap in November 2016 against England. Absent from the international set up from 2019 to 2023, she returned in the WXV3 tournament, coming off the bench to make six conversions against Kazakhstan. Scored 52 points in this year's Celtic Challenge. Ireland's Ruth Campbell comes up against Claire Gallagher of Canada. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Ruth Campbell Club: Old Belvedere/Leinster County: Kildare Age: 22 Position: Second row In her first international game, Campbell started against Australia in September 2024, lasting the full 80 minutes. Her first Six Nations start came in March against France. Previously played for Naas before moving to Old Belvedere. Ireland's Sadhbh McGrath during a warm-up in Cork. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Sadhbh McGrath Club: Cooke RFC/Ulster County: Donegal Age: 21 Position: Prop McGrath has had a rapid rise to the senior international squad, having got into rugby when she was 14. Since then, she's played under-18s for Ulster and Ireland, and captained the Clovers against Byrthon Thunder. Ireland's Sam Monaghan breaks past Tyson Beukeboom of Canada. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Sam Monaghan Club: Gloucester Hartpury/Ulster County: Meath Age: 32 Position: Second row Former Meath footballer, Monaghan offers leadership and experience in this young side. In 2024, she co-captained the team for the Six Nations with Edel McMahon but was unlucky to miss out on this year's campaign due to injury. Ireland's Siobhán McCarthy at the IRFU High Performance Centre in Dublin. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Siobhán McCarthy Club: Railway Union/Munster County: Clare Age: 30 Position: Prop/second row McCarthy picked up rugby after Ireland's Grand Slam in 2013, joining Shannon RFC before eventually persuading her twin Kate to do the same, later playing together for Railway Union. Got her first international cap in 2024 in a 36-10 victory over Australia in Belfast. Ireland's Stacey Flood playing in Belfast. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Stacey Flood Club: Railway Union/ Leinster County: Dublin Age: 29 Position: Back/outhalf Flood has played Sevens rugby for more than a decade having started in 2013. Another Paris Olympian, she returned to the 15s set-up for the Six Nations after the Celtic Challenge Cup, in which she was one of the leading carriers and kickers for the Wolfhounds. Ireland's Meabh Deely at the IRFU High Performance Centre. Photograph: INPHO/ Laszlo Geczo Meabh Deely Club: Blackrock/Connacht County: Galway Age: 24 Position: Fullback Deeley was one of six Irish debutantes during the Japan Test Series in 2022. A college student at the time, she had a rugby scholarship from Trinity College Dublin and is a Geoscience graduate. Ireland's Nancy McGillivray with her first cap after the game against Scotland in Cork. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Nancy McGillivray Club: Exeter Chiefs RFC County: IQ Age: 22 Position: Centre Irish-qualified McGillivray first played rugby in Hong Kong at eight years old, where she went on to be involved in both the 15s and Sevens sides. She now plays for Exeter Chiefs in the English Premiership and was in the training camp for England for 2024/2025. Ireland's Ellena Perry applauds the fans after the game against Canada. Photograph: INPHO/ Ben Brady Ellena Perry Club: Gloucester Hartpury RFC County: IQ Age: 28 Position: Prop A late addition to the squad, Perry qualifies for Ireland through her maternal grandfather. She has 11 caps for England, the last earned in November 2020. Made her Ireland debut against Canada this month, replacing Niamh O'Dowd off the bench.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store