‘Repulsive'; ‘obscene'; ‘genocide': Dáil voices rise in unison over Israel's slaughter in Gaza
'Innocent children, they don't know what's going on, starving with the hunger ... This is reality, this is what's happening in front of our eyes and we can see that on the news every morning, noon and night, and worse and worse it's getting,' said Danny Healy-Rae.
Annihilation, as it happens.
'We are witnessing a genocide being live-streamed on our hand-held device,' said Labour's Eoghan Kenny.
READ MORE
The destruction is undeniable. We see it every day.
'One of the greatest crimes against humanity is playing out before our eyes in real time,' said Sinn Féin's Mairéad Farrell.
Speaker after speaker, making the same point during three hours of Dáil statements on the unfolding catastrophe in Gaza.
How can this be happening when the obscene reality is there for all to see?
How can the Israeli government escalate its eradication crusade in Gaza while the big western powers hang back and look on?
In angry, heartfelt contributions, TDs held out little hope that this week's harrowing scenes of children starving to death would deflect Israeli prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu from his remorseless campaign against the Palestinian people.
If the world's increasingly flaky bulwarks of democracy won't act, this doesn't mean that Ireland cannot make a stand.
There was understandable consensus when it came to condemning Israel for its campaign of genocide in Gaza. Nobody quibbled with the use of the word.
The differences came in the interpretation of what has been done and what should be done to force Netanyahu to end the war. The Government pointed to the lead it has taken internationally when most of its EU partners have been dragging their heels.
The Opposition, while acknowledging the actions taken by Taoiseach Micheál Martin and Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs Simon Harris, accused them of doing too little too late.
But given the sheer horror of what the suffering innocents are enduring in Gaza, the lengthy Dáil session didn't descend into the usual political tit-for-tat. Apart, that is, from an unnecessary swipe at the Taoiseach early on from Sinn Féin's Mary Lou McDonald, who talked about her party's Bill to end the sale of Israeli war bonds through the Central Bank.
It's an 'obscenity' completely at odds with Ireland's position on humanitarian standards and international law.
'And yet, when I raised this with the Taoiseach yesterday, his response was to call our legislation repulsive,' said Mary Lou. 'That's the word he used.'
Micheál Martin swiftly intervened to reject the assertion.
'What is truly repulsive is allowing the Irish Central Bank to oversee the sale of Israeli war bonds that are funding this genocide,' she replied.
Micheál wasn't letting this go.
'The Deputy is misleading the House. That's not right, now.'
Mary Lou moved on. If his Government is really sincere and serious about 'ending the clear barbarism we watch every day in Gaza', it will back their Bill.
Micheál repeated his objection.
'I said no such thing,' he said, in a quiet, level voice. Given the seriousness of the debate it was not good enough for her to 'falsely make that assertion. I did not say that and you know I did not say that. I would ask you to withdraw it.'
The Leas-Cheann Comhairle turned to Mary Lou. Well?
'I cannot withdraw it because the record of this House will reflect the fact that the word that was used across the Chamber to me was the word 'repulsive'.
Check back on it, persisted the Taoiseach.
'Because you said the Government was funding a genocide and I said that phrase was morally repugnant. At no stage did I say the tabling of legislation in respect of the Central Bank was repulsive,' he said, addressing Mary Lou slowly, asking her again to withdraw her words.
'You know that. Why did you conflate the two to make a false statement?'
She turned to the chair.
'Sorry. Why is the Taoiseach using our speaking time with this nonsense?'
Micheál wanted that withdrawal.
'I am not withdrawing it,' insisted the Sinn Féin leader.
'It was a smear, it was a smear against me.'
'I am not withdrawing a remark that you made.'
The Leas-Cheann Comhairle moved on. 'We'll leave it at that.'
'No sincerity,' murmured the Taoiseach.
So, what happened the previous day?
During Questions on Policy or Legislation, Mary Lou spoke about the slaughter in Gaza and her party's forthcoming legislation about Israeli war bonds.
'What people might not know is that the Irish Government has made Ireland complicit in funding this genocide,' because the Central Bank oversees the sale of these bonds which are directly used to fund Israel's war against Hamas.
'Taoiseach, work with us. Ireland cannot be complicit any longer in genocide.'
[
Air strikes kill dozens in Gaza as international criticism of Israel grows
]
He said what is happening to innocent civilians in Gaza 'is beyond any moral compass' and it was 'very regrettable' that she would say the Irish Government is funding genocide.
'I can't really comprehend why you say things like that. I would argue you do it for politics but it smacks of that only. It lacks sincerity ... But I think it's fundamentally wrong of you actually to take the tack that you're taking.
'I find it morally repulsive as well.'
Mary Lou was right in one thing – he did use the word 'repulsive'. But it was fairly clear that Micheál was angered by the suggestion his Government was facilitating genocide as opposed to Sinn Féin tabling a Bill.
But for the most part, this lengthy session was memorable for a strong show of unity from across the political spectrum against the reprehensible war crimes being perpetrated on defenceless babies in Gaza.
Yes, there were strong speeches from the Taoiseach and Tánaiste, but the depth of feeling from TDs of all stripes was compelling.
All of them, including Coalition TDs, called for more action from Ireland as they denounced the Israeli government – not the Israeli people. There were many passionate speeches.
Netanyahu 'has shown himself to be a monstrous leader and his government a monstrous authority', said the former ceann comhairle Seán Ó Fearghaíl.
Not only have they slaughtered women and children in Gaza, but they have done much damage to their own country.
'The State of Israel has a right to exist. I respect and love the Jewish people but I deplore, detest and reject Netanyahu and his people.'
Deputies condemned the Palestinian terrorist group Hamas for the unspeakable atrocities it committed on Jews in a raid on Israel two years ago which led to the war.
But, as Fine Gael TD Barry Walsh said, their 'barbaric and disgusting' action does not justify what is happening in Gaza now.
'It is murder, pure and simple,' said Independent TD Paul Gogarty, shouting the number 'fourteen thousand' at the top of his voice.
That awful figure, repeated time and again in the House. The number of babies who may die from malnutrition by the weekend.
'It appears that things have got so horrific that even the EU may be waking up,' he said.
It was late in the afternoon, a good two hours into the statements, when Galway-based Independent Catherine Connolly rose to speak.
'I've attended many, many protests, as all my colleagues have done, and there was a time when I was most uncomfortable with the chant that Israel is a terrorist state ... I have no such reluctance now, and I'm ashamed that I wasn't comfortable with that, because Israel is a terrorist state.
'It's out of control. It's a rogue state, and it's got that far because it has done everything with immunity from the big powers that be, including Europe, America and many, many other countries,' she said.
But what she heard in the chamber was heartening.
'You know, the speeches that were made today by the backbenchers were wonderful. They were absolutely wonderful. I was near to tears with the passion,' she said. 'I wish they had made those speeches earlier when we were appealing to you to stop Israel with getting away with impunity.
'And we're here today, now, and we're looking at 14,000 children about to die in the next 48 hours.'
Unimaginable.
'And words. What words will we now use? We have set the lowest bar for telling ourselves we're very good.'
She talked of troops allowed through Shannon. Of increased trading. Of the failure to enact the Occupied Territories Bill. 'And we learn now tomorrow, in the face of 14,000 children about to die, that a memo is going to go to Government.
'Shame comes to mind, embarrassment, but most of all, let's act and show leadership.'
During her speech, she held up a printed statement.
'And we're here today, and we've just learned that a delegation from 22 countries in the EU over looking at the refugee camp in West Bank has been shot at, and we're told that the delegation deviated from the route. The only deviant here is Israel. They have deviated from international law.'
Then word came that two of those delegates – the State's representative in Palestine Feilim McLaughlin and his deputy Sorcha Lowry – are Irish.
And the real time everyone was talking about came just that little bit closer.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Workers across public service receive latest pay increase
About 400,000 public servants will benefit from Friday from the latest instalment of the national pay deal agreed last year, with everyone covered receiving a 1 per cent increase. The increases will apply to groups including teachers, HSE -employed healthcare workers, An Garda Síochána , the Defence Forces , politicians and the State's roughly 50,000 civil servants. This will be the fifth of seven scheduled increases under the terms of the agreement, which provides for total pay rises of at least 9.25 per cent to all public servants over the course of its 30-month duration. In addition, there are provisions for lower paid staff to receive higher percentage increases and for local bargaining agreements. The bargaining agreements are intended to address outstanding issues in particular areas of the public and Civil Service to deliver a further 1 per cent over the course of this deal, with a further 2 per cent to follow in the next national agreement. READ MORE The bases for many of these local bargaining agreements are being finalised. The increase taking effect this week, however, is a flat 1 per cent that will be worth about €300 a year to the lowest paid grades in areas such as maintenance. It will be worth about €450 to teachers starting out, an increase that brings the starting pay for a newly qualified primary schoolteacher to €46,448. It will be worth some €2,500 per annum to higher paid public servants including government department secretary generals, many consultant doctors on the new public-only contracts, and members of the judiciary in the higher courts. Two more instalments are due under the terms of the deal, a further 1 per cent or €500, whichever is greater, on February 1st next year and a final flat 1 per cent on June 1st. The agreement formally expires on June 30th and talks are expected to start well in advance of that on a successor agreement. However, union sources said on Thursday that formal contacts are unlikely before the start of the new year.
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
State seems to be suggesting even people of means should apply for legal aid, barrister for Diarmuid Phelan tells court
The State appears to have suggested that even people of means should make legal aid applications, which a barrister for law professor Diarmuid Phelan has argued is 'entirely contrary' to the spirit of the scheme. A judge will give her ruling in September as to whether the State should pay the 'enormous' legal costs for Mr Phelan following a trial that ended last January. Mr Phelan was acquitted by a Central Criminal Court jury of murdering a trespasser on his farm. The costs issue was raised on Thursday evening, on the last day of the Trinity term, before Ms Justice Siobhan Lankford. Law lecturer Mr Phelan, who has assets valued in the millions, instructed two senior and two junior counsel at his trial and did not receive legal aid. He also called expert witnesses who gave evidence following the close of the prosecution case. READ MORE Mr Phelan (56) went on trial in October 2024 after he pleaded not guilty to murdering Keith 'Bono' Conlon (36), a father of four, at Hazelgrove Farm, Kiltalown Lane, Tallaght, Dublin 24 on February 24th, 2022. Mr Phelan is a barrister, law lecturer and farmer who owns Hazelgrove, formerly a golf course. Opening the application on Thursday evening, Sean Guerin SC, who was one of two senior counsel representing Mr Phelan at his trial, told Ms Justice Lankford that the starting point - and also expressly the most important consideration - in awarding costs was the verdict. Counsel submitted Mr Phelan was entitled to his costs and the onus was really on the prosecution to show why he shouldn't succeed in the application. Mr Guerin said one of the prosecution's submissions was that Mr Phelan had the option of applying for legal aid but had chosen not to do so. The barrister said the State appeared to be suggesting that even people of resources should make a legal aid application, which he suggested was a complete misunderstanding of what the scheme was. Opposing the application, John Byrne SC, for the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), argued there was no presumption in favour of costs and one cannot simply say they had been acquitted so were entitled to their costs. He said a more complex and nuanced inquiry was required by the trial judge. Ms Justice Lankford asked both parties to articulate their views if she decided to award Mr Phelan his costs but confined it to legal aid costs. She noted there was quite a wide discretion in case law, where 50 per cent of costs had been awarded to applicants. Mr Guerin told the judge there was no warrant for doing so as those weren't the costs his client had incurred. He said legal aid was not a guide or a measure as to what are the appropriate costs in a case. Mr Byrne said the discretion seemed to be very wide and awarding legal aid costs was not something the court couldn't do, provided it set out the basis for it. Ms Justice Lankford said she hoped to deliver the court's judgement in September.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
Dawn Meats eyes NZ co-op deal and what tariffs mean for the Border
Waterford-based Dawn Meats has emerged as the front-runner to take a controlling stake in New Zealand's Alliance Group, a farmer-owned co-operative that describes itself as the world's biggest exporter of sheep meat. Nigel Stirling has the details. Some Irish whiskey exporters may be forced 'to reorientate their focus away' from the US if a 15 per cent tariff rate applies as part of the recently agreed EU-US trade deal, the head of the Irish Whiskey Association has warned. Eoin Burke-Kennedy reports. Staying with tariffs, in Agenda, Paul Colgan assesses the fallout of the EU-US trade deal for Ireland and the impact of having a different tariff on either side of the Border. Did the EU bend the knee to Donald Trump in agreeing the bones of what appears to be a lopsided trade deal? In his column, Eoin Burke-Kennedy writes that Commission president Ursula von der Leyen may have taken a leaf out of Keir Starmer's book. READ MORE Former Sherry FitzGerald chief executive Steven McKenna has set up a consultancy to advise Irish SMEs on their digital strategies, mergers and acquisitions, and succession planning. Ciarán Hancock has more. Rising costs and a slow down in new business failed to halt manufacturing growth this month, figures published on Friday show. Irish factories boosted production for the seventh month in a row in July, according to AIB's Ireland Manufacturing Purchasing Managers' Index. Barry O'Halloran reports. Joe Brennan has details of a deal that sees Goldman Sachs acquire key economic interests to more than €1 billion of mortgages written by Finance Ireland before it exited the home loans market this year, according to sources. World of Work sees Margaret E Ward look at the changing role of fathers in the workplace and what that means for working life today. Inheritance tax is set to be reformed , but in Smart Money, Cliff Taylor warns that the changes inevitably won't please everyone. Irishman Mark Bourke wants to remain chief executive of Novo Banco after the Portuguese lender's acquisition by French banking group BPCE is completed next year. The Workplace Relations Commission has ordered Tesco to re-employ a worker it sacked last year for calling his manager 'useless' in a performance review meeting – after ruling the supermarket's management went over the top in dismissing him. Stephen Bourke has the story. Food prices in Ireland are rising at three times the rate of overall inflation, the latest data from the Central Statistics Office (CSO) show. Eoin has the details. If you'd like to read more about the issues that affect your finances try signing up to On the Money , the weekly newsletter from our personal finance team, which will be issued every Friday to Irish Times subscribers.
