WTO reverses parts of previous decision in EU-China intellectual property dispute
Advertisement
In April, a
WTO panel rejected the
EU's complaint, lodged in 2022, that
China had violated the global watchdog's IP rules over patents for 3G, 4G and 5G mobile technology. However, it did say that China had failed to comply with all WTO transparency obligations.
The
EU appealed the case at the Multi-Party Appeal Arbitration Arrangement, a surrogate for the WTO's Appellate Body which was closed in 2019 after the
United States repeatedly blocked judge appointments.
On Monday, the arbitrators reversed part of the previous panel decision and found that the Chinese courts' prohibition of patent holders to enforce their patent rights in countries outside China, through the use of anti-suit injunctions, was not consistent with Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights rules concerning patent rights.
The arbitrators upheld the previous findings on four issues but reversed the panel's findings on three issues. It has given China 90 days to remedy its measures to comply with WTO rules.
Advertisement
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
38 minutes ago
- South China Morning Post
What are rare earths, and why is China's dominance facing global pushback
Read more about rare earths: Rare earth elements are the cornerstone of producing electronics and technological applications, from defence equipment to automobiles. China dominates the global supply of rare earths, controlling more than 90 per cent of all processing. Amid widening trade wars and growing economic instability, companies have sought to diversify their supply chains to lower their reliance on Chinese supplies. But industry analysts suggest that from funding to production, such change could take upwards of 20 years because of major challenges including time, cost and human capital.
South China Morning Post
2 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Europe and Ukraine press US ahead of Trump-Putin meeting
European officials presented their own Ukraine peace proposals to the United States on Saturday as US President Donald Trump prepared for talks with Russian President Vladimir Putin on ending the war. Trump announced on Friday that he would meet Putin in Alaska on August 15, saying the parties, including Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, were close to a deal that could resolve the 3½-year conflict. Details of the potential deal have yet to be announced, but Trump said it would involve 'some swapping of territories to the betterment of both'. It could require Ukraine to surrender significant parts of its territory – an outcome Kyiv and its European allies say would only encourage Russian aggression. US Vice-President J.D. Vance met Ukrainian and European allies in Britain on Saturday to discuss Trump's push for peace. The Wall Street Journal said European officials had presented a counterproposal, including demands that a ceasefire must take place before any other steps are taken and that any territory exchange must be reciprocal, with firm security guarantees. 'You can't start a process by ceding territory in the middle of fighting,' it quoted one European negotiator as saying.
South China Morning Post
8 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Trump's overhaul of State Department may play into Beijing's hands for decades
During nearly three decades as a US diplomat in China, Southeast Asia and Africa, Matt Ingeneri watched his Chinese counterparts dispense prestigious scholarships, hold lavish banquets and conduct expensive national day celebrations. 'They are very good hosts and can be really charming when they want to be,' Ingeneri, now in the private sector, said, adding that the US State Department budgets were far smaller and corruption concerns greater. 'We had a hot dog on a Ritz cracker.' But Chinese officials also mixed their soft power with unbending deportment when espousing Beijing's red lines, he added. 'It's all fun and games – until you want to keep your claim to the South China Sea.' The US effort to counter China's growing global footprint is difficult enough. President Donald Trump's radical State Department overhaul is not making it any easier and could play into Beijing's hands for decades, according to lawmakers and past and current department officials. 'Our competition with China requires all hands on deck. It's global in nature. It affects virtually every issue, every topic that crosses borders,' said Mark Lambert, a 35-year State Department veteran and former head of its China House overseeing Beijing-focused diplomacy. 'We just gutted [development programmes] ourselves, a huge win for China.'
