Fending off coastal erosion: one Co Kerry community's story
Knowing that in a matter of minutes a storm surge could mean something close to obliteration of the place where you live makes people think differently about the best way to respond to an uncertain future.
This is the case in Maharees in west Kerry. Knowing the odds are stacked against you, what can you do? They have completed that soul-searching process and are acting upon it. It's a realisation that will soon confront hundreds of small communities around the Irish coastline, who will need to decide how they respond.
Rather than giving in to doomism, a remarkable form of collective action can emerge if the right approach to community engagement is adopted, says
Maharees Conservation Association
co-founder Martha Farrell. It's about being frank but not dictating, balancing self-education with expert input.
'We're giving it our best shot. We're not magicians. We can't turn back sea-level rise [but] we can make it as liveable for people as possible,' she says.
READ MORE
The Maharees is like a large 'Y' separating Brandon Bay and Tralee Bay. The 5km-long tombola – Ireland's largest – is described as a bar or finger-like spit. It is, in effect, the community's only protection, Farrell says, and yet its most fragile asset links offshore islands located at the top of the Y.
Marram grass, which they have planted extensively, stabilises the dune system and yet is fragile: 'It can be destroyed by just 10 footsteps'. It captures wind-driven sand. Chestnut fences meanwhile, stretching 800m to the west and in parts to the east, designate beach access routes and prevent grass from being trampled.
As if that is not challenging enough, Maharees has a unique ecosystem created and constantly changed by wind, rain and sea. It is home to Ireland's largest amphibian, the natterjack toad. It is at the heart of a special area of conservation. Tralee Bay is an important breeding site for critically-endangered species such as angel sharks and white skates and an-EU designated special protection area for birdlife. They are in 'a living lab', Farrell says.
But its vulnerability was becoming glaringly obvious, and the association emerged from this. The sea side was being lost and human activities – raves and parties in the dunes, 'wild parking' – were accelerating its demise. Over the winter of 2015-2016 the only road in and out of the Maharees peninsula was impassible on 17 occasions as raging seas threw up vast amounts of sand.
Visiting on a sunny June day, its beauty and fragility is evident with large numbers of holidaymakers, watersports enthusiasts and day-trippers. A survey in August 2019 recorded 23,040 cars travelling the narrow Maharees road in one week.
Group members are at Magherabeg Cut, having completed a beach clean. They stumbled across a nesting ringed plover and are concerned beach users will encroach.
Locals Janne Spillane and Zoe Rush at work on the sand dunes. Photograph: Domnick Walsh
Polite 'please keep off dunes' have given way to more blunt signage: 'Sand Dunes: They protect us! Let's protect them ... no wild camping.' Aerial photos show this has been successful.
Maintaining the dynamic of the dunes is critical, Farrell says. It requires wrestling with evolving processes of sand erosion and natural deposition. Seaward facing dunes are in constant battle with the sea. And yet Marram planting and fencing is now revealing growback to levels last seen before human influence.
The conversation began with two questions. 'We asked the people, 'what do you value about the place? What do you want the future Maharees to be?' There was no mention of climate change. Our vision came out of that,' she adds.
Through an alliance with Creative Ireland and local development agency the
Dingle Hub
, the
Neart Na Machairí
project has brought their efforts to the next level. It has embedded creativity 'to help rethink behaviours and take action to ensure the Maharees is well-adapted in the face of climate change and biodiversity loss', says project designer Zoë Rush – neart being Irish for strength.
Chestnut fences designate beach access routes and prevent Marram grass from being trampled. Photograph: Domnick Walsh
Three artists – 'creative practitioners' – Emer Fallon, Silke Michels and Zoë Uí Fhaoláin-Green – help facilitate a creative and collaborative exploration of the future of Maharees. This will inform a community adaptation plan that will benefit many others directly facing the prospect of 1m sea-level rise this century. It has got strong backing from State agencies (particularly the National Parks & Wildlife Service); Kerry Co Council, academics and NGOs.
'Coastal resilience requires an integrated approach, drawing from deep place-based knowledge of these habitats and the customs and traditions of people who live within them, [with] expert guidance and collaboration with State agencies to support and incorporate community visions of change within strategic and financial planning provided by Dingle Hub,' Rush says.
'This is far more than artists just listening to communities and then illustrating their needs,' she says. It is working closely with 'a conservation group who have such a good connection with the people'.
A steering group of four conservation group members was enhanced by locals from different sectors, going beyond the 50 people out of a population of 300 already active volunteers. Through intensive circulation of information and invites to events, 10 'community partners' were added; people ranging across tourism/hospitality; watersports, farming, fishing and long-term visitors.
The first year was 'a climate learning journey', bringing in different experts with knowledge on habitats, ecology and coastal erosion, explaining risks to the community and 'how they make those decisions that will then affect their long-term prospects', Rush says.
After a year 'all the community partners said, 'it's great listening and learning all this but we want action'.' Informed by workshops, the project was rejigged. Long-term visitor Mairead Kinsella wanted to share learning in a flyer for other visitors, Airbnbs and local businesses.
This is not a typical 'come and visit this lovely place' guide. It represents a creative response to the unique biodiversity of the region and its vulnerabilities to climate change. It encourages visitors to consider their role in preserving the natural beauty and ecological integrity of the places they enjoy; the essence of regenerative tourism.
Association chair Aidan O'Connor praised her contribution at a launch event in April: 'She listened to our story, learned about the challenges we face due to climate change, and created something that supports and uplifts us.'
The Maharees in Co Kerry separates Brandon Bay and Tralee Bay. Photograph: Domnick Walsh
Farrell says it's about sharing their identity: 'showing we are doing this already; you can go here, you can go there and learn about this place with us.' They want sustainable tourism as it is the lifeblood of the community, whether that's camper vans in the right place, people coming to their holiday homes or surfers in September – but not gentrification.
Striking the right balance is endlessly challenging, not to mention the vulnerability of local heritage to climate change and need for resilient local food supplies. Farrell highlights the precarious location of the graveyard where her father's remains are buried. It is on an exposed mini headland beside a 13th century church looking out to Oileán tSeanaigh with its ancient monastic settlement.
A total of 22 groups have visited their area seeking guidance. 'Some are looking for the magic wand but it's really about persistent graft, raising awareness and networking.'
Yes, there are fears about runaway climate change, but what is more immediately scary, Farrell says, is working out how they can buy a rundown schoolhouse so it becomes their 'community resilience hub'; a place for people to gather and a haven when extreme weather and power outages strike again. After all, this is a group of committed volunteers 'with just 21 binoculars and a fold-up tent' in their possession.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Tusla referrals set to breach 100,000 mark for first time
Tusla is set to receive more than 100,000 referrals this year for the first time, with calls for increased funding for the agency in the coming budget to cope with 'ever-increasing demand'. A Children's Rights Alliance (CRA) conference on child protection and the care system heard referrals have more than doubled since the agency's establishment in 2014, from about 46,000. Kate Duggan, Tusla chief executive, said each of the 100,000 referrals involve a 'real concern about a child or a young person.' The rise comes alongside a 500 per cent increase in the number of separated children seeking international protection who require support and accommodation from Tusla, she said. READ MORE The agency saw an increase of more than €145 million in funding last year, primarily in response to that rise in separated children. . However, 'significant investment' in child-protection and welfare frontline services, residential care facilities and the recruitment of social workers is required, Ms Duggan said. While 88 per cent of the 5,780 children in State care are currently accommodated in foster arrangements, the agency is about 200 residential care beds short, she said. That is alongside a deficit of between 250 and 300 social workers needed to meet demand. Andrea Reilly, who was in foster care from birth until the age of 18, said she 'felt like a file being passed around, rather than a human being' due to a 'constant turnover' of social workers. 'It wasn't that I had people who didn't care, but it's a system that's overloaded and a crisis-led approach has taken over. I remember from a young age that social workers were drowning from caseloads. If you weren't on fire, you weren't seen as a priority,' she said. 'If you're constantly having to start over with new people, it can really affect your self-esteem,' she said, adding that she felt like a 'passed-around file'. Alongside better working conditions for social workers, the 22-year-old from Co Tipperary called for stronger supports for foster carers. Hers, a woman named Geraldine, no longer fosters any more. 'She went through a lot over the years in terms of not feeling supported or really empowered by Tusla,' she said. The CRA has called for additional funding of €50 million for Tusla in Budget 2026, with chief executive Tanya Ward saying the agency never got the investment it needed in its early years. Asked after the conference about the request for additional funding, Minister for Children Norma Foley said there had been a 'significant uplift' for Tusla in the last two budgets, bringing its funding to €1.3 billion. 'We will seek, every year, to do more in that space,' she said. Separately, Ms Duggan said she was not aware of any children being wrongfully taken into care as a result of Tusla staff cloning information between siblings. The practice was flagged following a Health Information and Quality Authority ( Hiqa ) review of services in the midlands with Aontú leader Peadar Tóibín highlighting concerns that false information on some files could lead to children being 'wrongly or unnecessarily taken into care'. Ms Duggan said concerns around duplication of information have been dealt with by the agency. 'Certainly, I am not aware of any case where there has been a child inadvertently taken into care,' she said, adding that a review is ongoing. 'Where we receive a report from Hiqa and where there are any findings in relation to that, we identify it as an opportunity for either mitigating a risk or learning from it.'
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Dozens of caravans parked on Curragh must leave, judge orders
The Minister for Defence has been granted High Court orders preventing dozens of caravans camping on lands in the Curragh, Co Kildare . Mr Justice Brian Cregan ordered that caravans, cars and other vehicles parked on the Department of Defence land, including areas used by horse trainers for gallops attached to the Curragh Racecourse, be removed by 1pm this Friday. Some of the caravans are also close to the Defence Forces firing ranges and have prevented the carrying out of training exercises. In an affidavit, department principal officer of property management, Eoin McDonnell, said 'mountains of rubbish' have been left behind by the transient and changing groups of caravan occupants, who the court heard are believed to be members of the Travelling community. There were caravans on the lands for nine months of last year and the bill for cleaning up the rubbish was nearly €186,000. Since the arrival of the first group of caravans in March, the bill has reached some €31,700, he said. READ MORE The dumped waste includes garden waste dumped as a result of transitory businesses along with household rubbish including clothing, bedding, mattresses, furniture, used nappies, sanitary towels and other such items. On one occasion, a young pup was found in rubbish dumped in a gully along the side of a road. The use of scramblers and quad bikes on the lands has caused damage to greens at Cill Dara Golf Club, while local residents have complained about noise and general nuisance from the encampments, Mr O'Donnell said. Fires have also been lit causing damage while on occasion illegally dumped material partially buried on the land create a serious trip hazard for horses galloping on the Curragh plain. Dogs are running around the horses and animals have been left to graze on the land by the caravan occupants. Some 200 horses are trained daily on the lands and the trainers based at the Curragh have said it is becoming very difficult to train due to the increased volume of caravans being parked close to a gallops known as Little Curragh, Mr O'Donnell said. Applying for the injunctions on a one-side only represented basis, Kelley Smith SC, for the Minister, said there has been quite a history over the decades of regular trespass on the lands by caravans, usually coming from England or France, during the months of May and August. Between 1992 and 2000, six court orders were obtained prohibiting the trespass. Despite those, since 2000, the unlawful caravan encampments have continued. Last year, counsel said, the number hit a record 75 at one point but this year that number was exceeded, with 89 counted. The caravan dwellers change as some move on and others arrive and they are located in a number of different areas around the Curragh. The Dublin-Cork rail line runs through the lands and a fire next to the line last March caused major disruption, counsel said. Bailiffs had been employed to serve notices to quit to the caravan occupants and only 21 people were identified, but because of the changing composition of those involved it has not been possible to identify everybody, counsel said. Mr Justice Cregan ordered that notices of the court order be pinned to the doors of each of the caravans, including the 21 named people, along with a 'plain English' notice explaining the order. He said anyone who wishes to contest the orders can turn up in court on Friday. He further ordered that the defendants and all people with notice of the orders be prohibited from returning once the Friday deadline has passed.
Irish Times
16 hours ago
- Irish Times
Fending off coastal erosion: one Co Kerry community's story
Knowing that in a matter of minutes a storm surge could mean something close to obliteration of the place where you live makes people think differently about the best way to respond to an uncertain future. This is the case in Maharees in west Kerry. Knowing the odds are stacked against you, what can you do? They have completed that soul-searching process and are acting upon it. It's a realisation that will soon confront hundreds of small communities around the Irish coastline, who will need to decide how they respond. Rather than giving in to doomism, a remarkable form of collective action can emerge if the right approach to community engagement is adopted, says Maharees Conservation Association co-founder Martha Farrell. It's about being frank but not dictating, balancing self-education with expert input. 'We're giving it our best shot. We're not magicians. We can't turn back sea-level rise [but] we can make it as liveable for people as possible,' she says. READ MORE The Maharees is like a large 'Y' separating Brandon Bay and Tralee Bay. The 5km-long tombola – Ireland's largest – is described as a bar or finger-like spit. It is, in effect, the community's only protection, Farrell says, and yet its most fragile asset links offshore islands located at the top of the Y. Marram grass, which they have planted extensively, stabilises the dune system and yet is fragile: 'It can be destroyed by just 10 footsteps'. It captures wind-driven sand. Chestnut fences meanwhile, stretching 800m to the west and in parts to the east, designate beach access routes and prevent grass from being trampled. As if that is not challenging enough, Maharees has a unique ecosystem created and constantly changed by wind, rain and sea. It is home to Ireland's largest amphibian, the natterjack toad. It is at the heart of a special area of conservation. Tralee Bay is an important breeding site for critically-endangered species such as angel sharks and white skates and an-EU designated special protection area for birdlife. They are in 'a living lab', Farrell says. But its vulnerability was becoming glaringly obvious, and the association emerged from this. The sea side was being lost and human activities – raves and parties in the dunes, 'wild parking' – were accelerating its demise. Over the winter of 2015-2016 the only road in and out of the Maharees peninsula was impassible on 17 occasions as raging seas threw up vast amounts of sand. Visiting on a sunny June day, its beauty and fragility is evident with large numbers of holidaymakers, watersports enthusiasts and day-trippers. A survey in August 2019 recorded 23,040 cars travelling the narrow Maharees road in one week. Group members are at Magherabeg Cut, having completed a beach clean. They stumbled across a nesting ringed plover and are concerned beach users will encroach. Locals Janne Spillane and Zoe Rush at work on the sand dunes. Photograph: Domnick Walsh Polite 'please keep off dunes' have given way to more blunt signage: 'Sand Dunes: They protect us! Let's protect them ... no wild camping.' Aerial photos show this has been successful. Maintaining the dynamic of the dunes is critical, Farrell says. It requires wrestling with evolving processes of sand erosion and natural deposition. Seaward facing dunes are in constant battle with the sea. And yet Marram planting and fencing is now revealing growback to levels last seen before human influence. The conversation began with two questions. 'We asked the people, 'what do you value about the place? What do you want the future Maharees to be?' There was no mention of climate change. Our vision came out of that,' she adds. Through an alliance with Creative Ireland and local development agency the Dingle Hub , the Neart Na Machairí project has brought their efforts to the next level. It has embedded creativity 'to help rethink behaviours and take action to ensure the Maharees is well-adapted in the face of climate change and biodiversity loss', says project designer Zoë Rush – neart being Irish for strength. Chestnut fences designate beach access routes and prevent Marram grass from being trampled. Photograph: Domnick Walsh Three artists – 'creative practitioners' – Emer Fallon, Silke Michels and Zoë Uí Fhaoláin-Green – help facilitate a creative and collaborative exploration of the future of Maharees. This will inform a community adaptation plan that will benefit many others directly facing the prospect of 1m sea-level rise this century. It has got strong backing from State agencies (particularly the National Parks & Wildlife Service); Kerry Co Council, academics and NGOs. 'Coastal resilience requires an integrated approach, drawing from deep place-based knowledge of these habitats and the customs and traditions of people who live within them, [with] expert guidance and collaboration with State agencies to support and incorporate community visions of change within strategic and financial planning provided by Dingle Hub,' Rush says. 'This is far more than artists just listening to communities and then illustrating their needs,' she says. It is working closely with 'a conservation group who have such a good connection with the people'. A steering group of four conservation group members was enhanced by locals from different sectors, going beyond the 50 people out of a population of 300 already active volunteers. Through intensive circulation of information and invites to events, 10 'community partners' were added; people ranging across tourism/hospitality; watersports, farming, fishing and long-term visitors. The first year was 'a climate learning journey', bringing in different experts with knowledge on habitats, ecology and coastal erosion, explaining risks to the community and 'how they make those decisions that will then affect their long-term prospects', Rush says. After a year 'all the community partners said, 'it's great listening and learning all this but we want action'.' Informed by workshops, the project was rejigged. Long-term visitor Mairead Kinsella wanted to share learning in a flyer for other visitors, Airbnbs and local businesses. This is not a typical 'come and visit this lovely place' guide. It represents a creative response to the unique biodiversity of the region and its vulnerabilities to climate change. It encourages visitors to consider their role in preserving the natural beauty and ecological integrity of the places they enjoy; the essence of regenerative tourism. Association chair Aidan O'Connor praised her contribution at a launch event in April: 'She listened to our story, learned about the challenges we face due to climate change, and created something that supports and uplifts us.' The Maharees in Co Kerry separates Brandon Bay and Tralee Bay. Photograph: Domnick Walsh Farrell says it's about sharing their identity: 'showing we are doing this already; you can go here, you can go there and learn about this place with us.' They want sustainable tourism as it is the lifeblood of the community, whether that's camper vans in the right place, people coming to their holiday homes or surfers in September – but not gentrification. Striking the right balance is endlessly challenging, not to mention the vulnerability of local heritage to climate change and need for resilient local food supplies. Farrell highlights the precarious location of the graveyard where her father's remains are buried. It is on an exposed mini headland beside a 13th century church looking out to Oileán tSeanaigh with its ancient monastic settlement. A total of 22 groups have visited their area seeking guidance. 'Some are looking for the magic wand but it's really about persistent graft, raising awareness and networking.' Yes, there are fears about runaway climate change, but what is more immediately scary, Farrell says, is working out how they can buy a rundown schoolhouse so it becomes their 'community resilience hub'; a place for people to gather and a haven when extreme weather and power outages strike again. After all, this is a group of committed volunteers 'with just 21 binoculars and a fold-up tent' in their possession.
