Google loses appeal in antitrust battle with Fortnite maker
The unanimous ruling issued Thursday by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals delivers a double-barreled legal blow for Google, which has been waylaid in three separate antitrust trials that resulted in different pillars of its internet empire being declared as domineering scofflaws monopolies since late 2023.
The unsuccessful appeal represents a major victory for video game maker Epic Games, which launched a legal crusade targeting Google's Play Store for Android apps and Apple's iPhone app store nearly five years ago in an attempt to bypass exclusive payment processing systems that charged 15% to 30% commissions on in-app transactions.
The jury's December 2023 rebuke of Google's app store for Android-powered smartphones began a cascade of setbacks that includes monopoly judgements against the company's ubiquitous search engine last year and the technology underlying its digital ad network earlier this year.
Although not as lucrative as Google's search engine or ad system, the Play Store for Android apps has long been a gold mine that generated billions of dollars in annual revenue by taking a 15% to 30% cut from in-app transactions funneled through the company's own payment processing system.
Following a month-long trial, a nine-person jury determined that Google had rigged its system to thwart alternative app stores from offering better deals to consumers and software developers. That verdict resulted in U.S. District Judge James Donato ordering Google to tear down digital walls shielding the Play Store from competition, triggering the company's appeal to overturn the jury's finding and void the judge's mandated shakeup.
But a three-judge panel that heard Google's appeal in February rejected its lawyers' contention that Donato erred by allowing the case to be determined by a jury that deviated from the market definition outlined by another federal judge who mostly sided with Apple in Epic's case against the iPhone maker's app store.
Epic's lawsuit 'was replete with evidence that Google's anticompetitive conduct entrenched its dominance, causing the Play Store to benefit from network effects,' the judges wrote in the decision.
The ruling 'will significantly harm user safety, limit choice, and undermine the innovation that has always been central to the Android ecosystem,' Google's vice president of regulatory affairs Lee-Anne Mulholland said in a statement.
Unless Google can extend the enforcement delay placed on Donato's order issued last October, the company will have to begin an overhaul that includes making the Play Store's entire library of more than 2 million Android apps available to would-be rivals and also help distribute the alternative options. Google has argued that the required revisions will raise privacy and security risks by exposing consumers to scam artists and hackers masquerading as legitimate app stores.
But Epic's lawyers have ridiculed Google's warnings about the changes as scare tactics in a desperate attempt to protect the fortunes of its corporate parent Alphabet Inc.
Although Epic fell short in its attempt to have the iPhone's app store declared a monopoly, that case resulted in a judge issuing an order that required Apple to surrender exclusive control over the payment processing of in-app transactions and allow links to alternative systems without collecting a commission.
Besides being hit with Donato's order, Google still faces further trouble ahead that could leave an even bigger dent in its finances.
As part of the effort to address Google's illegal monopoly in search, a federal judge is weighing a proposal by the U.S. Justice Department that would require the sale of its Chrome web browser and ban the multibillion dollar deals that company has been making with Apple and others to lock-in its search engine as the main gateway to the internet.
Google is also facing a proposed breakup of its advertising technology as part of the countermeasures to its monopoly in that business. A trial on that proposal is scheduled to begin in September.
Liedtke writes for the Associated Press.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Leaked images reveal Google's new budget earbuds
When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission. Quick Summary A new leaked render has appeared which shows off a new set of earbuds from Google. Those could be the Google Pixel Buds 2a, and may launch at the upcoming Google event. With the Google Pixel event now just a matter of weeks away, it should come as no surprise that the rumour mill has been spinning furiously. Fans are eager to understand what is coming, to try and get a feel for just how much of an upgrade is coming. We've already seen leaked renders of the Google Pixel 10 Pro, as well as those for the Google Pixel 10 Pro Fold. Those Android phones are likely to be among the most highly anticipated at the event, with the brand's offering growing substantially in recent years. Now, the same leaker has shared an image of a new set of earbuds. That is listed as the Google Pixel Buds 2a, which would make them a successor to the brand's current budget buds – the Google Pixel Buds a. The image was shared by Android Headlines, and shows the buds in a pale Lilac hue. The colour – which the report suggests is called 'Iris' – is seen in the innards of the case, which has a white outer casing. It looks like the case is designed to reveal a little sliver of that colour when closed, too. There appears to be a band which will be visible on the outside, ensuring your carefully chosen style can still be seen. You might have noticed I'm dwelling slightly here, dear reader, and that's because there isn't an awful lot more to tell you. While the leaked render gives us a good look at the device, there is no accompanying information to make any suggestions about the specs or pricing. With little else to go on, we'll just have to wait for the official launch to offer further comment. Still, with that set to take place in just a few short weeks, we shouldn't have long to wait.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Apple: Growth Despite Tariff Headwinds
Key Points Apple posted double-digit revenue and earnings growth, topping Wall Street's quarterly expectations. iPhone revenue continues to climb, and the company returned to growth in China. Expect Apple to continue to face questions about tariffs and AI, but its core franchises remain strong. 10 stocks we like better than Apple › Here's our initial take on Apple's (NASDAQ: AAPL) fiscal 2025 third-quarter financial report. Key Metrics Metric Q3 FY24 Q3 FY25 Change vs. Expectations Revenue $85.8 billion $94.0 billion 10% Beat Earnings per share $1.40 $1.57 12% Beat iPhone revenue $39.3 billion $44.6 billion 13% Beat Services revenue $24.2 billion $27.4 billion 13% Beat Apple Posts Strong Growth Despite Macro Headwinds Investors came into earnings season with questions about Apple's ability to weather the impact of tariffs, and the company answered by reporting robust growth. Apple said revenue grew by 10% and earnings per share by 12%, boosted by stronger-than-expected iPhone growth in the quarter. The sales growth, in a quarter marred by tariff talk, is a reminder of the enduring popularity of the iPhone and the success of a new, more affordable model released earlier this year. Apple has responded to the tariff concerns by shifting shipping patterns, with a majority of iPhones sold in the U.S. now reportedly assembled in India and not China. Apple had forecast low- to mid-single-digit growth in the quarter, predicting a $900 million headwind from tariffs in the period. Apple also returned to growth in China, posting sales of $15.4 billion for the quarter compared to $14.7 billion in the same three months of 2024. The company did not provide a Q4 forecast in the earnings report, but is likely to give some guidance about what it expects in the second half of calendar year 2025 during its call with investors. Immediate Market Reaction Investors were happy with the results. Apple stock was up 2% in aftermarket trading immediately following the release but ahead of the company's call with investors. What to Watch Apple's numbers were strong, but that was expected. The big question with Apple is not about the numbers, but about what comes next. Apple's AI efforts have floundered so far, and top execs have fled to rivals. There have been reports that Apple could find a partner to bring AI to its devices instead of continuing to develop in-house. Expect a lot of investor questions about AI on the call, as well as a focus on future devices that Apple can add to its offering along with phones, computers, iPads, and wearables. There is also still a looming uncertainty about tariffs, with tariff exemptions on smartphones expected to lapse and talk of new India tariffs that could further complicate supply chains. Apple is yet to answer the question about the "next big thing," be it AI or a new device, but the company's core franchises remain massively profitable and show no signs of sputtering from here. Helpful Resources Full earnings report Investor relations page Additional coverage Should you invest $1,000 in Apple right now? Before you buy stock in Apple, consider this: The Motley Fool Stock Advisor analyst team just identified what they believe are the for investors to buy now… and Apple wasn't one of them. The 10 stocks that made the cut could produce monster returns in the coming years. Consider when Netflix made this list on December 17, 2004... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you'd have $638,629!* Or when Nvidia made this list on April 15, 2005... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you'd have $1,098,838!* Now, it's worth noting Stock Advisor's total average return is 1,049% — a market-crushing outperformance compared to 182% for the S&P 500. Don't miss out on the latest top 10 list, available when you join Stock Advisor. See the 10 stocks » *Stock Advisor returns as of July 29, 2025 Lou Whiteman has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Apple. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. Apple: Growth Despite Tariff Headwinds was originally published by The Motley Fool
Digital Trends
2 hours ago
- Digital Trends
7 moments from Samsung history that shaped the Galaxy Z Fold 7
The new Galaxy Z Fold 7 is the best foldable for most people — especially in the US — but it costs $2,000. Despite the high price, Samsung has recorded record-breaking sales for the Galaxy Z Fold 7 and Galaxy Z Flip 7, a fact made even more surprising considering Samsung's current market dominance is less than two decades old. Millions of Samsung foldables have been sold, but I recall a time when selling a Samsung phone priced under $100 was a challenge. I worked across all the carrier stores in the UK, and at this time, Samsung had such a poor reputation that it was a struggle to sell Samsung phones before the launch of Android and the subsequent Galaxy S lineup. Yet, within a few short years, Samsung became the dominant force in Android, playing a crucial role in halting the runaway success of the early iPhones. Samsung was everywhere and fast becoming the go-to alternative to those who wanted a credible alternative to the iPhone. Recommended Videos How did Samsung turn it around? Having used and reviewed Samsung phones before the first Galaxy S, I've experienced all the ups and downs as Samsung has established its dominance. Here are five key moments in Samsung's history that helped shape the new Galaxy Z Fold 7. May 2011: Galaxy S II — The Samsung Name Did you know that before the Galaxy S II, many Samsung phones didn't bear the company's name? Instead, they would often be released by carriers under custom names, running software that was preloaded with far too many useless apps, and handing software updates over to carriers to dictate the release schedule. The Galaxy S II changed this and is pivotal to Samsung's history. It was released on three of the four major carriers under the actual name, the only holdout being Sprint, which branded it the Samsung Epic 4G Touch. As a byproduct of the marketing around the product, Samsung began cementing its place in consumers' minds. Had Samsung continued custom names like it did with the original Galaxy S — T-Mobile had the Samsung Vibrant, AT&T had the Samsung Captivate, Verizon offered the Samsung Fascinate, and Sprint branded it as the Samsung Epic 4G — it would have been much harder for Samsung to build customer trust. In hindsight, this would be key over the following year. Sep 2011: Galaxy Note — The Big Phone Era Just months after the Galaxy S II, Samsung made one of its biggest contributions to smartphones with the launch of the Galaxy Note. Fourteen years later, it's clear that Samsung single-handedly launched the big-screen era that every phone has followed since. The original Galaxy Note was criticized for being too large with its 5.3-inch screen, but in hindsight, this would now be considered a mini phone by current smartphone expectations. Instead, the obsession with fitting as large a screen as possible in your pocket while keeping it portable has led companies to the best folding phones. However, even a great phone needs something else, and these two phones set up Samsung to cement its place in history just a year later. May 2012: Galaxy S III — The Olympics On 29 May 2012, Samsung launched the Galaxy S III. Two days later, it was launched in the UK, just two months before the Olympics came to London. All of this was synchronized, and for good reason: Samsung's sponsorship of the London Olympics directly contributed to its current success. Samsung's sponsorship revolved around making the Galaxy S III synonymous with the Olympics, and it worked extremely well. This sponsorship enabled Samsung to reach hundreds of millions of potential customers, and the Galaxy S3 London 2012 Olympic Edition marked the beginning of a tradition where Samsung creates custom Olympic-branded smartphones for each athlete at every Olympic Games. I remember working in retail on Oxford Street during the Olympics and in the months that followed. It should come as no surprise that just weeks later, when Apple launched the iPhone 5, Samsung's positioning and marketing strategy paid off even further. For the first time, customers who sought stock of the new iPhone 5 (to no avail) would then enquire about the Galaxy S III instead. Aug 2012: Galaxy Note II — The Multitasking Maestro A few short months after the Galaxy S III came another phone, and one that has directly impacted every Samsung phone made since. If you've used a Samsung flagship phone in the past decade, you'll know that it features an excellent multitasking feature. You may not know, however, that this feature first launched on the Galaxy Note II. Since then, every Samsung flagship has had multitasking features, and coupled with the S-Pen — a staple of the Galaxy Note — it introduced the concept of true multitasking on mobile devices. Over a decade later, Samsung remains the only company to invest in this, yet it is core to taking full advantage of the larger 8-inch main display on Samsung's new folding phones. Feb 2019: Galaxy S10 — Bye TouchWiz, hello One UI Between 2012 and 2019, Samsung grew to complete dominance in smartphones, having fought off the competition to capture the number one spot in global smartphone market share following the launch of the Galaxy S III. Each Samsung phone that launched in the years that followed continued to press the company's advantage, but in hindsight, many of these weren't as important as they seemed at the time. As we'll cover at the end, one particular moment continues to have an impact today. In February 2019, Samsung launched the Galaxy S10 and with it, One UI. A complete redesign of the software interface was the result of Samsung shedding its legacy software interface in favor of a new, more streamlined software experience. Aug 2022: Galaxy Z Fold 4 — Peak Folding Phone Before the Galaxy Z Fold 7, the Galaxy Z Fold 4 was the best Samsung folding phone, mostly as the Galaxy Z Fold 5 and Galaxy Z Fold 6 were notably iterative upgrades over previous generations. The Galaxy Z Fold 4 reduced the size of the hinge and the bezels around the display, while tweaking the screen's aspect ratios and implementing a new camera system from the Galaxy S22 line. The latter remains to this day: the Galaxy Z Fold 7 has the same 200MP camera as the Galaxy S25 Ultra — at least on paper — and previous versions since the Fold 4 have shared camera features with the flagship Galaxy S lineup. This was before the launch of thinner folding phones like the OnePlus Open (2023), Honor Magic V3 (2024), and Oppo Find N5 (2025), all of which are considerably thinner than Samsung's previous best. The Galaxy Z Fold 7 changes this considerably and continues a trend of Samsung making its phones thinner and lighter. Jan 2025: Galaxy S25 Ultra — The 200MP beast It would be remiss to think about all the Galaxy Z Fold 7 features without mentioning the Galaxy S25 Ultra, and specifically the 200MP main camera. Although the Galaxy Z Fold 7 also has a 200MP main camera, it's 18% smaller than the Galaxy S25 Ultra, yet as my testing showed, the Galaxy Z Fold 7 camera is just as capable as Samsung's imaging powerhouse. The Galaxy S25 Ultra isn't the first Samsung phone to use a 200MP camera, but several years of Samsung's marketing around this feature have piqued customer interest in the camera and the rest of the lineup. The fifth-generation Ultra delivers the best Samsung Ultra experience, and it's a key part of the marketing positioning for the Galaxy Z Fold 7. The Galaxy S25 Edge shows that Samsung is ready to bring better camera features to its flagship foldable, and the 200MP main camera solves a key complaint about previous versions. Plenty of other twists and turns These are just seven of the phones from Samsung's history that have shaped the Galaxy Z Fold 7. There's that phone, which explains why Samsung is cautious about its batteries, but as a result, the company's battery optimization is second-to-none. Samsung also deserves a lot of praise for how it handled that incident, and in my opinion, it's still a benchmark for other phone makers to meet. Then there's every foldable so far, with Samsung iterating and slimming the design and thickness of each version. The Galaxy Z Fold 7 bucks the trend of iterative changes, and instead, it delivers the biggest change to Samsung's foldable lineup so far. Hindsight is wonderful, but I have little doubt that fifteen years from now, the Galaxy Z Fold 7 will be one of the most impactful Samsung phones during this time. Having used every Samsung Galaxy flagship phone to date, I already know the Galaxy Z Fold 7 will be a phone I'll remember for a long time.
