Review of Benyamin's The Second Book of Prophets
After reading interpretations of the Dead Sea Scrolls and the Nag Hammadi texts (both significant finds of the mid-20th century that offer insights into Judaism and Christian history), Benyamin was inspired to write this book that looks at the historical and spiritual figure of Jesus Christ through a new lens.
The author has explored Christian themes in his earlier works (Body and Blood, Yellow Lights of Death) and earned plaudits for other powerful stories as well (Goat Days, Jasmine Days).
This novel, translated by Ministhy S., is a brave, secularised retelling of the life and times of Jesus Christ, challenging some traditional Christian beliefs in an iconoclastic manner.
Conflicts and betrayals
Jesus makes his appearance at a crucial time when the Jews are struggling for freedom from centuries of Roman rule over territory that is broadly today's Israel. Many Jews believe Jesus could be their long-awaited 'messiah' who will liberate them, a matter in which Jesus shows no interest.
Besides, in Benyamin's retelling, the Tribe of Benjamin is opposed to someone like Jesus (from the rival House of David) coming as 'messiah', as well as his message of peace, love and equality. They conspire with the Romans to betray Jesus.
Yet, Jesus continues to lead a different freedom struggle, working with the various warring tribes to reconcile their differences, before sacrificing his life for the cause.
Internecine conflicts, treachery, distrust, disunity, betrayals — the leitmotifs of failed revolts throughout history — play out plainly among the Jews who fail to overpower the Romans.
Taking cues from history
Evidently, the author desires a different understanding of Jesus, not through the eyes of faith but by studying historical texts. In the novel, Jesus appears not as the son of god but as a social reformer and revolutionary, fighting evil and injustice.
The much-vaunted miracles performed by Jesus — turning water into wine, the healing of lepers and the resurrection of the dead — are interpreted in the book, not literally as miracles but as Jesus' spurning of prejudiced societal laws and customs of the time, or 'social miracles'.
Even Judas' betrayal of Jesus for 30 pieces of silver is attributed to tribal rivalries, not greed as the Bible narrates.
Undoubtedly, the Bible as well as the Dead Sea Scrolls and the Nag Hammadi texts allow different readings and perspectives of Jesus' life and that period in history. Clearly, Benyamin, with a passion for history, feels there is much to say about Jesus' life and times outside of the prevailing convictions, and has done so to also make the story relevant to our fractured times.
The novel, originally published in Malayalam in 2007, and read widely, drew flak from die-hard believers for Benyamin's secularisation of Jesus' life, upending conventional beliefs. Time will tell how readers of the English translation will respond.
The reviewer is a Bengaluru-based independent journalist.
The Second Book of Prophets Benyamin, trs Ministhy S. Simon & Schuster India ₹599
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
2 hours ago
- Indian Express
Mammootty's brother confirms actor's recovery, pens emotional note on the difficult period: ‘The whole world prayed for one person?'
All of a sudden, Malayalam cinema banded together on social media on Tuesday to share heartfelt posts regarding one person, highlighting the immense love and respect they hold for him. From superstar Mohanlal and Rajya Sabha MP John Brittas to hundreds of cinema lovers, the virtual space was flooded with notes celebrating his imminent return. That person was none other than Mammootty, who had been away from the limelight for the past few months due to an apparent health scare. While none explicitly mentioned what health crisis the Malayalam megastar had been dealing with, they confirmed that he has been declared free of it. Now, Mammootty's brother Ebrahimkutty has shared an emotional post, affirming that the Malayalam cinema icon is set for his much-awaited comeback. 'I am now revelling in a sense of relief one feels after crossing a vast sea of dark clouds and turmoil. All the suppressed anxieties have subsided. Now, it is time for a comeback,' he wrote on Facebook. He continued, 'For a long time, wherever I went, everyone's enquiry was only about Ichakka (Mammootty's nickname). During my travels for serial shoots, at railway stations, bus stands, on the streets, and at shooting locations, wherever I went, people would come and ask lovingly, 'Mammukka is okay, right?' The expression on their faces upon hearing my 'yes' showed the depth of their love for him. The whole world is praying for one person?! Yes. All the world I saw had been in prayer, wishing for Ichakka's health to be restored. Though the situation wasn't extremely grave, a lump remained in my heart. I prayed in every breath… along with crores and crores of people. Now that all the crises have been overcome, it is a relief like having swum across a sea.' Expressing sincere gratitude to all those who stood by them and prayed for Mammootty's speedy recovery, Ebrahimkutty concluded, 'Thank you, to those who carried unconditional love for Ichakka; to those who prayed; to those who ardently wished for his return… And to every human being and God.' A post shared by George Sebastian (@ On Tuesday, Mammootty's longtime associate George and close friend, producer Anto Joseph, shared similar posts on social media, indirectly announcing that the Malayalam megastar had overcome his purported health crisis and was ready to return to acting in full health after treatment and rest. 'With eyes brimming with joy, I stand before you with folded hands. To those who prayed for me, stood by me, and reassured me that nothing would go wrong-my dearest ones, thank you with endless love,' George wrote. While fellow superstar Mohanlal shared an old photo of him planting a warm kiss on Mammootty's cheek, along with a red heart emoji, MP John Brittas wrote on X, 'Dear Mammukka, your strength and resilience are truly inspiring! We're overjoyed to see you back, and we need your vibrant presence, charm and leadership for many years to come.' The megastar's longtime friend, actor VK Sreeraman, also shared a heartening post on Facebook, along with an old photo of them, recalling Mammootty's phone call to him after successfully passing the last medical 'test.'
News18
3 hours ago
- News18
Joe Jonas Recalls Getting Cozy In Private Plane Bathroom: 'I Joined The Mile High Club'
Joe Jonas revealed he joined the mile high club on a private plane. The 36-year-old singer has revealed he had sex with a partner in a plane bathroom 'a couple of years ago", but in a celebratory moment afterwards, Joe mistakenly high-fived the flight attendant instead of his drummer. In an interview with the NowThis series Are You Okay?, the Jonas Brothers star – who was married to 29-year-old actress Sophie Turner from 2019 until 2024 – told host Brianna Morales, 'I joined the mile high club a couple of years ago. I was wearing contacts [lenses], left the bathroom. I thought I was high-fiving my drummer. After the high five, I realised it was the flight attendant." Luckily for Joe, he was on a private flight, and he thinks if he had sex on a public plane, he would be 'banned" from flying. The Gotta Find You hitmaker quipped, 'It was a private plane. Or I would be banned from flying." Despite the situation turning awkward with his case of mistaken identity, Joe insisted it was worth it. Joe previously revealed how he and his brothers Kevin and Nick 'felt the pressure" to live up to their Christian values after talking publicly about their 'purity rings". After shooting to fame in the 2000s, the pop stars famously wore bands symbolising their desire to abstain from sex before marriage and Joe Jonas, 35, has admitted being open about their beliefs forced them to maintain the very high standards they set for themselves. During an appearance on Penn Badgley's Podcrushed podcast, Joe explained, 'Famously we were known for like purity rings, which were something in the community of a church where that was like what everybody else in our age were doing around 10, 11 years old, like, we're going to wait for the right person … One person on an interview when you're 15, 16 [years old] would ask you about it, and you're like: 'I don't want to talk about this,' and then they're like: 'Well, I'm going to write that you guys are in a cult'." Joe went on to say, 'Whether it was sex, or it was even religion or Christianity, [they'd be] questioning things like questioning if I believe in God, what is God? Is there even a God? And it's on the record. 'And you're like, uh … and so you felt the pressure,. I can definitely speak for all three of us here. [We] felt the pressure of being like: 'Well, we have to live these lives because we kind of said it in a paper once. And it's in print, so you [have] got to do it forever.' ' First Published: Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Loading comments...
Time of India
4 hours ago
- Time of India
TV stars Arya and Sibin Benjamin tie the knot in dreamy wedding, says 'A day full of love, a lifetime to go'
Arya and Sibin Benjamin, the popular Malayalam television personalities, celebrated their marriage in a traditional Kerala-style wedding. The couple, known from Bigg Boss Malayalam, shared heartwarming moments from their ceremony, including Arya's daughter, Roya, walking her down the aisle. Their union, a second chance at love for both, has garnered immense support and blessings from fans and industry colleagues. Malayalam television's beloved duo, Arya and Sibin Benjamin, have officially tied the knot in a heartwarming and intimate Kerala-style wedding today. The much-adored duo, who rose to fame through Bigg Boss Malayalam, took fans by surprise when they announced their engagement recently. Now, they've sealed their bond with a beautiful ceremony, surrounded by close friends and family. The couple shared stunning glimpses from their wedding on social media, just moments before, captioning the post: "A day full of love, a lifetime to go. 20/08/2025." Arya looked radiant in a custom-designed saree, exuding elegance and grace, while Sibin complimented her perfectly in a stylish designer kurta and traditional mundu. Their wedding photos have already begun making rounds on the internet, melting hearts with their sheer warmth and intimacy. But the most touching moment of the ceremony, and one that fans are raving about, is a picture of Arya's daughter, Roya, walking her mother down the aisle, holding her hand with pride and affection. Another memorable photo shows the teenager, standing between the couple during the traditional thali tying ritual, symbolizing the beautiful coming together of two families. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like One Luxe: A Statement of Prestige in Lokhandwala One Luxe by Veena Developers Undo The wedding marks a beautiful new beginning for Arya and Sibin, both of whom have found love for the second time in their lives. From being long-time friends and business partners to life partners, their journey has captured the imagination of fans across Kerala. The comment section of their post is brimming with love and blessings from industry colleagues and fans alike. Celebrities such as Jasmin Jaffar, Archana Suseelan, Shafna Nizam, and Priya Mani have sent heartfelt wishes to the couple.
