The Irish Times view on national economic planning: strategy must be recession-proof
So a key test of the revised National Development Plan due to be unveiled today will be its resilience. Inevitably a change in economic circumstances will mean that flexibility is needed in any plan, but are the broad goals of what will be outlined achievable, even if the economy is hit by some kind of slowdown, or even a downturn?
Some lessons have been learned in the management of the public finances, with cash being put aside in two funds for the future and the annual figures being kept in surplus. That said, decisions have been made much easier by a big surge in corporation tax. And this has allowed the Government to increase day-to-day, or current, spending rapidly, alongside higher capital investment.
To leave sufficent leeway,
further growth in State capital investment has to be married with tighter control of current spending. Hints on the strategy here may be contained in the Summer Economic Statement, also due for release today. And in the years ahead more tax revenues are also going to be needed. The Irish tax base is increasingly reliant on potentially transient corporate tax receipts and on income tax paid by middle and higher earners.
READ MORE
The key immediate uncertainty in national planning comes, of course, from the new US policies on trade. Significant financial buffers are needed to deal with the potential fall-out here and its implications for growth and tax revenue in the short term.
Ireland cannot go back to a situation where it is forced to slash State investment to balance the books, as happened after the financial crash. The State is still paying the cost of that today through massive deficiencies in housing and other infrastructure. Strong economic growth and high immigration have added to the pressures.
Delivery is also vital, of course . Ireland's slow progress on major investment projects has cast doubts over economic growth prospects, potentially hampering investment. Dealing with this is a key social, as well as economic, priority.
The outlook may be seriously affected by what happens between the EU and the US in trade talks over the coming weeks. Whatever transpires, it is fair to assume that significant uncertainty will remain for a prolonged period of time. And that this will raise questions about Ireland's economic model and how it needs to adjust.
More investment in key infrastructure is a vital part of the answer. As we consider how this is to be paid for, we can only hope that the impact of Trump's trade policies, while certain to be serious, does not become hugely disruptive.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
25 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Govt walks back plans to force companies to slap health warnings on booze amid rising cost pressure & Trump tariff fears
THE Government has canned plans to force booze companies to put health warnings on beer, wine and spirits. The measure has been slapped with a two-year delay due to concerns that it would hurt Irish 3 Frank Murray of Alcohol Action Ireland said there is a huge link between cancer and alcohol consumption 3 Tainiste Simon Harris brought the motion to cabinet Credit: PA The last The law was due to kick in next year but the Cabinet today agreed to put it on the long finger following backlash by the booze businesses. Industry figures had warned the Government that the introduction of the labels specifically for Ireland would create an added cost for businesses which could have an impact on prices for consumers. This increase in cost for companies was coming at a time when Trump is threatening tariffs of up to 30 per cent on all goods travelling from READ MORE IN IRISH NEWS Many Irish beer and whiskey companies rely on the US market for major sales, and tariffs run the risk of hurting their bottom line. In a bid to ease the pressure on these companies, the Cabinet today agreed to delay the introduction of the Tanaiste The Tanaiste told his Government colleagues that the delay will enable the Most read in Irish News However, one Minister told the Irish Sun that the alcohol labelling law will not see the light of day under the current Government. They said: 'That's that done. You won't be hearing about that again.' 'PEOPLE DON'T KNOW THOSE RISKS' Alcohol Action Ireland had previously slammed the Government's decision to delay the label law. Chairperson of Alcohol Action Ireland Professor Frank Murray told 'Unfortunately, the risk of alcohol consumption in terms of cancer, for instance, begins at very low levels of alcohol consumption, particularly breast cancer. 'Again, most people don't know that I'm afraid.' NEW PLAN The The proposal comes as part of a newly published ten-year NHS plan. There have also been similar initiatives in other countries — including 3 It was proposed that booze get slapped with a health warning Credit: Getty
The Irish Sun
25 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Major crackdown on migrants working illegally as firms will be given locations of asylum hotels to axe riders' accounts
MIGRANT hotel locations will be handed to delivery firm bosses to stop illegal riders using their apps. The Home Office has struck a deal with Deliveroo, Just Eat and Uber Eats in a major win for The Sun. 3 Hot-spots for delivery riders working illegally will be flagged up for raids to immigration enforcement officers Credit: Ray Collins 3 A masked rider challenges an immigration enforcement officer about his rights Credit: Chris Eades 3 Officers speak to a migrant delivery rider We revealed asylum seekers were They are not legally allowed to work but have used shared accounts to dodge checks. Last night PM Sir Keir Starmer said: 'The Sun has rightly put the spotlight on "And we're tackling the problem. If a rider is staying at this accommodation, the companies will know and can close down the rider's account. 'We will do what it takes to uphold the law and to ensure fairness for the British people.' Under the agreement, hot-spots for such riders will be flagged up for raids by to immigration enforcement officers. And delivery companies — who insist that they are already investing heavily in security systems to prevent abuse — will be hauled in again in the coming weeks to give updates on what progress they have made. Home Secretary Most read in The Sun 'By enhancing our data-sharing with delivery companies, we are taking decisive action to close loopholes and increase enforcement.' Last month we revealed how more than 20 cops in body armour Undercover delivery driver investigation But the migrants were allowed to return to their taxpayer-funded rooms after being questioned. Tory Shadow Home Secretary 'It is disgraceful that rampant illegal working has been taking place on an industrial scale at the very hotels 'This is all a consequence of the Government's complete failure to control our borders. 'All 'Then, the crossings would soon stop.' Labour is also planning to tighten the law, forcing gig economy firms to carry out full right-to-work checks on anyone using their platforms. And, from today, the Government is ramping up pressure on the criminals fuelling the migrant crisis. 'Plans in place to stop the gangs' By Sir Keir Starmer WE will stop at nothing to tackle illegal migration. So this week we have delivered a world first: a new sanctions regime to target the vile people-smuggling gangs. We will go after the gang leaders, those supplying boats and fake passports, and the moneymen. Their assets will be frozen. Their bank accounts will be closed. And they will be banned from the UK. We've already returned 35,000 people — way up on the year before. We're working with Germany to close a legal loophole there, allowing police to seize small boats being stored and transported in their country. By working with France, we have agreed to a totally unprecedented returns pilot. We're also taking a zero-tolerance approach to the illegal jobs which gangs promise. Under our nationwide crackdown, raids and arrests are already up 50 per cent. The Sun has rightly put the spotlight on migrants working illegally as food delivery riders. We will share asylum accommodation locations with Deliveroo, Just Eat and Uber Eats. If a rider is staying at this accommodation, the firms will know and can close down their account. We will do what it takes to uphold the law and to ensure fairness for the British people. Leaders of smuggling gangs, peddlers of fake passports and corrupt officials will be named and shamed. The first wave – expected to number around two dozen offenders – will include travel bans, asset freezes, and restrictions on access to the UK financial system. Meanwhile the Sun can reveal the Thistle City Hotel, one of the capital's biggest asylum accommodation locations, is When The Sun returned yesterday it appeared nothing had changed — as a steady stream of migrants came and went in full delivery rider gear from a fenced-off area put up to hide them from public view. We previously revealed that owners the Clermont Hotel Group, headed by CEO Gavin Taylor, had raked in £28million in revenue since taking on asylum seekers in November 2021. But at the same time residents of a block of apartments across the road fear the value of their homes has plummeted. One, who moved in 15 years ago, told The Sun: 'It is just constant noise, every day and every night. 'They all work. 'The police are here constantly. 'It's annoying a lot of residents in the block. 'I put my place on the market last year but nothing happened and I ended up taking it off the market because I had a newborn. Staff don't quiz 'kids' SMALL boat migrants who claim to be children are being given the benefit of the doubt by staff. A report by borders inspector David Bolt found that immigration workers show a 'lack of curiosity'. An Iranian with grey hairs and black stubble had his age claim of 17 accepted despite being assessed as 22. AI technology is set to be rolled out in 2026 which can accurately assess a person's age. Last year half of the 'children' were really adults. 'I'm not against people coming here for a better life. 'And obviously asylum seekers need to be somewhere. 'But if the hotel closed it would make the area a lot better. 'I'm sure the people who own the hotel are doing really well, funded by the Home Office while we pay our service charge and our taxes.' And a 27-year-old city finance worker said the problem had 'got a lot worse' since he moved in at the start of the year. He said: 'We went over there to try to get information on how long it would be a migrant hotel. 'We were pretty much kicked out straight away. 'They said they understand the problems but once the residents are on the street, they have no control.' The owner of a coffee shop said customers were staying away and his business had been broken into three times. Read more on the Irish Sun He added: 'I pay £8,000 every three months in taxes and business rates. 'If the hotel closed down I am sure business would improve.'
Irish Times
25 minutes ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on the State's new investment plans: the work is only starting
The Government's plan to invest more to address the infrastructure deficits in the Irish economy is a move in the right direction. Shortfalls in housing, water, energy and transport are not only crippling competitiveness but affecting people's daily lives. The Government is correct to push ahead with its planning, despite the international uncertainty. A growing economy and a rising population have left recent administrations running to catch up. International investors have been increasingly outspoken about Ireland's infrastructural shortfalls. All of this needs to be addressed. And Taoiseach Micheál Martin is correct when he says that State investment spending must be protected no matter what. However, the plans published yesterday raise of number of important questions. The lack of any detail of the projects to be included in the plan is somewhat puzzling. Everyone knew in the final period of the last government and the opening months of this one that the review was due. So why has no list of projects been completed? Because of this, as Prof Alan Barrett of the Economic and Social Research Institute pointed out, we do not have any of the essential detail on how the projects all fit together. READ MORE There are, of course, a significant number of projects which we do know about and which will be funded by the money now being put aside. The focus on vital areas such as water, wastewater and energy is important. But with last-minute rows over housing in particular, it is unclear that the Government yet has a convincing plan in this key area. An updated housing plan, due in the autumn, needs to give a clear view . The Government is also – belatedly – looking seriously at the blockages and delays to project planning. This is welcome but long overdue. These issues have been hiding in plain sight in recent years, leading to extraordinary delays and additional costs in projects large and small. Too much time was lost here by the last government. This one needs to get serious on the issue of the delivery. This will be uncomfortable politically and it remains to be seen if the Government has the stomach for the necessary fights. The scale of the investment commitments being made are significant. And paying for it will use a lot of the leeway in the national finances and also the cash put aside from the Apple tax payment and the sale of AIB shares. This means a higher level of risk. To create the required leeway in the national finances – and ensure yet more cash is not pumped into the economy – the increased investment spending must be combined with much tighter control of day-to-day spending. This is the trade off. If this does not happen, then the scale of the financial risks facing the State will increase yet further. And they are already high enough.
