Air India families claim cover-up as they ask one chilling question why plane crashed and killed 242 passengers
Air India flight AI171 had barely left the runway last month when it lost momentum and crashed in a densely populated area of India's western city of Ahmedabad, killing all but one of the 242 people on board and 19 others on the ground.
Now, a preliminary report by India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) has revealed that fuel supply to both engines was cut in the crucial minutes as the aircraft was ascending in the air.
The plane's black box data recorder showed the aircraft had reached an airspeed of 180 knots when the fuel switches of both engines were 'transitioned from RUN to CUTOFF position one', the report says.
The report says the switches were flipped within a second of each other, halting the flow of fuel to the engine.
In the audio, one pilot asks the other why he flipped the switches. The other pilot responds he did not do so.
Seconds later, the switches were flipped back on.
Both engines were able to relight, and one began to 'progress to recovery', the report said, but it was too late to stop the plane's gut-wrenching descent.
While the report identified the problem, it did not say whether the crash was caused by a crew error, mechanical malfunction, or electronic failure.
Speaking to the UK's Telegraph, Ameen Siddiqui, whose bother-in-law and niece died in the crash, argued it was a cover-up.
'It's a cover-up to protect Air India and the government,' he said.
'They want to blame dead pilots who can't defend themselves.
'How can the fuel switches end up turning off at a critical moment, either through pilot error or a mechanical fault?'
Appearing on Sunrise on Monday, former Qantas pilot Richard De Crespigny spoke about the fuel switches, saying if it was mechanical failure, it would be remarkable.
'The fuel control switches you turn them on at the start of the flight, turn them off at the end. You turn them on and off if you have to restart the engine or if there is a fire,' De Crespigny explained.
'You have to move them in flight. But to have two turn off within a second of each other is remarkable. If it's a switch failure, it is a really remote (chance of it happening).
'I suspect there is a human error in this (tragedy). But we just don't know.
'The investigators could release the voice transcript, so we know exactly what was said and correlate it to what happened.
'(But) they haven't done that.
'They have left a lot open.'
Is it a cover-up?
De Crespigny was asked on his thoughts of it being a cover-up.
'If it was a cover-up, and there was a mechanical fault, then we have had two switches that are faulty turning-off within one second of each other,' De Crespigny said.
'After 10 years of this 787's operations, this is highly (unlikely) ... Almost impossible.
'I don't think they want to cover it up.
'They're (just) not used to exposing all the facts and shutting down these rumours.'
Turning the fuel switches off?
De Crespigny said turning off the fuel switches would cause an aviation disaster.
'If you turned off the fuel switches, the engines would be running down within one second because you are turning off the main pumps and it's dramatic,' he said.
'It has to be because you have to stop fuel getting to the engine if there's a fire.
'The fuel switches were turned off and within 10 seconds they're both turned on.
'It suggests there was some interaction, somewhere in the cockpit.
'The switches didn't just float up or float down.'
What do the switches look like?
De Crespigny described the switches.
'They look like little mushrooms in the supermarket, button mushrooms you have to pull the switch out and move it up or down and then release it,' he said.
'It won't move by itself or by accident.'
De Crespigny explained he did hear of one incident where the switches were faulty.
'There was a report of these switches not having a lock to secure them,' he said.
'This would mean the switch might fall down in turbulence and turn off.
'To have two doing this (during) take-off ... This is very remote.'
- with CNN
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News AU
a day ago
- Sky News AU
Relatives of Air India disaster victim reveal they were sent the wrong remains by Indian authorities
The mother of a victim of last month's Air India disaster has spoken out after authorities in India sent her the wrong body. Fiongal Greenlaw-Meek, and his partner Jamie, were among the 261 people killed when Air India Flight AI171 crashed after take-off from Ahmedabad. The pair had travelled to India for a peaceful 10-day wellness retreat. Speaking to the Sunday Times, Amanda Donaghey said she was sent the remains of the wrong person by the Indian authorities. She said after arriving in India following the crash, the authorities asked her to present a blood sample to match the DNA for testing. 'Visiting the site and seeing it was something I felt like I had to do. I wanted to understand what had happened,' she told the newspaper. She went onto describe what she saw, saying the area in which the plane crashed resembled a warzone. 'I remember all these burnt trees. The trees were scorched black. But there were still birds and squirrels in those trees, which I found quite profound. It was like a bomb site.' 'You would think it was from a war scene, but there were still these small birds twittering,' she said. She was told the body of her son would be sent to England in a sealed casket. The paper reports that further DNA testing by a coroner in the UK revealed that the remains sent over were the wrong ones. 'It was heartbreaking,' she said. 'We don't know what poor person is in that casket. This is an appalling thing to have happened.' Ms Donaghey has joined others in demanding the UK government pressure the Indian government to do more to help, as more families across the UK revealed on Sunday that they had similar things happen to them. A total of 52 British citizens died in the catastrophe, which claimed the lives of all but one of the 242 people on board, as well as 19 people on the ground. Only a dozen UK victims' remains have been repatriated so far. In a statement posted to X, Air India said it continued to support the victims and their families.
West Australian
a day ago
- West Australian
Fiongal Greenlaw-Meek: Air India crash victim's mother heartbroken after authorities sent wrong body to the UK
The mother of a wellness influencer who died in the Air India plane crash has been left distraught after authorities sent another victim's body back to the UK. Fiongal Greenlaw-Meek and his partner Jamie were among those on flight AI171, which plummeted to the ground shortly after taking off from Ahmedabad, India, in June. The couple had travelled to India for a 10-day wellness retreat. Mr Greenlaw-Meek's mother, Amanda Donaghey, flew to India shortly after she was told the devastating news about her son. 'Visiting the site and seeing it was something I felt like I had to do. I wanted to understand what had happened,' she told The Sunday Times . 'I remember all these burnt trees. The trees were scorched black. But there were still birds and squirrels in those trees, which I found quite profound. 'It was like a bomb site. You would think it was from a war scene, but there were still these small birds twittering.' Ms Donaghey, desperate to find her missing son's remains, gave a blood sample to help identify him through DNA. When local officials found his body, the 66-year-old mother was told that his body would be sent back to the UK in a casket. However, while in the throes of planning a funeral, she received a devastating call from police: A British coroner had determined from a more thorough DNA test that the remains inside the casket did not belong to her son. 'It was heartbreaking,' Ms Donaghey said. 'We don't know what poor person is in that casket. This is an appalling thing to have happened.' The grieving mother has called on the UK Government to do all it can to uncover what happened to her son's remains and 'bring Fiongal home.' Ms Donaghey is one of many heartbroken parents who have had to rearrange funeral plans due to the mix-up of bodies. Another family was given 'co-mingled' remnants of more than one person in their casket, so a process of separating the remains had to be undertaken before the funeral went ahead, according to the Daily Mail . In an eerie video posted just before boarding the doomed flight, the wellness influencer appeared in what would be his final video on social media. Mr Greenlaw-Meek and his partner Jamie can be seen preparing for their long-haul journey back to London, reflecting on their time in India. 'We are at the airport just boarding,' Mr Greenlaw-Meek said, before bidding farewell to India ahead of what his partner suggested would be a '10-hour flight back to England.' At the end of the heartbreaking video, Mr Greenlaw-Meek said, 'Going back happily, happily, happily calm.' It is believed that only Indian authorities performed DNA tests on victims, with no checks from international organisations.
Perth Now
a day ago
- Perth Now
Mum of Air India crash victim ‘appalled' after body mix up
The mother of a wellness influencer who died in the Air India plane crash has been left distraught after authorities sent another victim's body back to the UK. Fiongal Greenlaw-Meek and his partner Jamie were among those on flight AI171, which plummeted to the ground shortly after taking off from Ahmedabad, India, in June. The couple had travelled to India for a 10-day wellness retreat. Mr Greenlaw-Meek's mother, Amanda Donaghey, flew to India shortly after she was told the devastating news about her son. 'Visiting the site and seeing it was something I felt like I had to do. I wanted to understand what had happened,' she told The Sunday Times. 'I remember all these burnt trees. The trees were scorched black. But there were still birds and squirrels in those trees, which I found quite profound. 'It was like a bomb site. You would think it was from a war scene, but there were still these small birds twittering.' Ms Donaghey, desperate to find her missing son's remains, gave a blood sample to help identify him through DNA. When local officials found his body, the 66-year-old mother was told that his body would be sent back to the UK in a casket. However, while in the throes of planning a funeral, she received a devastating call from police: A British coroner had determined from a more thorough DNA test that the remains inside the casket did not belong to her son. 'It was heartbreaking,' Ms Donaghey said. 'We don't know what poor person is in that casket. This is an appalling thing to have happened.' The grieving mother has called on the UK Government to do all it can to uncover what happened to her son's remains and 'bring Fiongal home.' Ms Donaghey is one of many heartbroken parents who have had to rearrange funeral plans due to the mix-up of bodies. Another family was given 'co-mingled' remnants of more than one person in their casket, so a process of separating the remains had to be undertaken before the funeral went ahead, according to the Daily Mail. In an eerie video posted just before boarding the doomed flight, the wellness influencer appeared in what would be his final video on social media. Mr Greenlaw-Meek and his partner Jamie can be seen preparing for their long-haul journey back to London, reflecting on their time in India. Jamie Meek and partner Fiongal Greenlaw-Meek were among those on flight AI171, which plummeted to the ground shortly after taking off. Credit: Unknown / Instagram 'We are at the airport just boarding,' Mr Greenlaw-Meek said, before bidding farewell to India ahead of what his partner suggested would be a '10-hour flight back to England.' At the end of the heartbreaking video, Mr Greenlaw-Meek said, 'Going back happily, happily, happily calm.' If you'd like to view this content, please adjust your . To find out more about how we use cookies, please see our Cookie Guide. It is believed that only Indian authorities performed DNA tests on victims, with no checks from international organisations.
