logo
The steamy, subversive rise of the summer novel

The steamy, subversive rise of the summer novel

Vox21-07-2025
is the host of Explain It to Me, your hotline for all your unanswered questions. She joined Vox in 2022 as a senior producer and then as host of The Weeds, Vox's policy podcast.
As a kid, one of the highlights of my summer vacation was sitting underneath a tree in my grandmother's backyard and getting lost in a book. I don't get a three-month summer break anymore, but tucking away with a juicy novel when it's hot outside is a ritual I still return to.
So what makes for a good summer read and how did this practice even emerge in the first place? That's what we set out to find out on this week's episode of Explain It to Me, Vox's weekly call-in podcast.
Next Page
Book recommendations — both old and new — that are worth your time, from senior correspondent and critic Constance Grady. Email (required)
Sign Up
By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
To find the answer we spoke with Donna Harrington-Lueker, author of Books for Idle Hours: Nineteenth-Century Publishing and the Rise of Summer Reading. Summer reading is a practice she knows well. 'As a teenager, let's just say I was a bit bookish,' she says. 'That meant that when my family went for its one-week vacation a year — which was a big treat — they were on the beach and I was in some kind of a bunk bed with Moby Dick or Siddhartha.'
Below is an excerpt of our conversation, edited for length and clarity. You can listen to the full episode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get podcasts. If you'd like to submit a question, send an email to askvox@vox.com or call 1-800-618-8545.
How did this idea of summer reading even start? Have we always grabbed books when it's hot out?
No, not really. My research focused on the 19th century, and I started looking at newspaper articles, advertisements from book publishers, and the like. And I divided it into two periods: before the Civil War and after the Civil War. Before the Civil War, summer reading was constructed as a masculine practice. The idea was that men would get away from the heat and the pressures of their lives, and they should read something cool. So the essays of Charles Lamb; poetry was mentioned often as well.
That all changes after the Civil War, when there's an increase in travel and tourism. The performance of summer leisure becomes an aspiration for a growing middle class, so you have many, many more people engaging in this practice. You have an increase in railroads as well. So you've got an easy way for people to get from point A to point B, and hotels begin to spring up. And as a result of that, publishers start really promoting summer reading. It takes a very specific form, and increasingly it becomes something that women do. It becomes a rather gendered space.
Can you talk about that idea of performing leisure a little bit? I think that's really interesting.
Publishers would advertise a variety of things as summer reading, but one of the central things was what I call the summer novel. It would be a novel that would be set in Saratoga Springs or Newport or Cape May, at a summer resort. Regardless of how wealthy or not people were, they always seemed to stay there for an entire summer as opposed to a week or a weekend. It would involve a courtship and over the course of the novel, two young people would meet, they would resolve their differences, they would visit various places, and at the end they would be married. By reading these, you'd get an idea of what these resorts were about, and you'd get an idea of how you performed leisure, what you did once you got there, and what the expectations were. So they were serving that purpose as well. There's also a good bit of fashion, so for the young woman, you'd get an idea of how you're supposed to dress.
That's so interesting. So it sounds like it's serving the purpose of a mixture of a Hallmark movie with your romance but the drama and intrigue of White Lotus.
Definitely the Hallmark characteristic of it. Absolutely.
Were these books purely escapist, or did they get at larger themes too?
One of the things that I found interesting was that yes, they are escapist in the sense of allowing you to experience another lifestyle, but they were very, very much kind of a liminal space, a space of betwixt in between. For young women especially, it's doing the cultural work of asking, 'What does it look like to have more freedoms as a young woman?' Because there was markedly more freedom — or at least as these books constructed it — during the summer and at summer resorts. You have women hiking and women going out on boats on their own and being unchaperoned, opening up vistas of freedom.
Now, admittedly, at the end of all these, order is reasserted. People go back to their normal lives. Marriage as the ultimate institution of tradition gets reasserted. But for the space of the novel there are more freedoms.
You have women hiking and women going out on boats on their own and being unchaperoned, opening up vistas of freedom.
The novels weren't spaces that were necessarily completely out of touch either. There would be references to a very violent Pullman strike that appeared in one of the summer novels. In the preface to one about Saratoga Springs, there's questions about American imperialism. There's questions about treatment of Native Americans. And so when you take the book as a whole, it's nation-building in a way as well, and it's questioning that in some of them.
What was the reaction to the rise of summer reading at the time? Was everyone just ecstatic that people were reading?
The publishing industry had a very serious marketing challenge on its hands. Post-Civil War especially, you have rising literacy rates – especially among young women – but you have a very solid and profound discourse that says novel reading is evil, that it is dangerous, especially for young women. The fear was that it would be sexually arousing, that the morals would be questionable. And so you get a lot of criticism, especially among clerics and also a real fear of French novels. They were considered the most problematic.
Do we still have a lot of these summer reading conventions in book publishing?
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

The ‘Panama Playlists' leak claims to expose Spotify accounts of JD Vance, Pam Bondi and a slew of other pols and CEOs
The ‘Panama Playlists' leak claims to expose Spotify accounts of JD Vance, Pam Bondi and a slew of other pols and CEOs

New York Post

time3 hours ago

  • New York Post

The ‘Panama Playlists' leak claims to expose Spotify accounts of JD Vance, Pam Bondi and a slew of other pols and CEOs

Vice President JD Vance is a big fan of the Backstreet Boys' 'I Want It That Way.' White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt gets pumped up with Beyonce's 'Run the World (Girls)' — and there's one very prominent politician who loves Nelly's 'Hot In Herre.' That's all according to the Panama Playlists — a site that quietly went live Wednesday and claims to reveal the private music tastes of a slew of public figures. 'I found the real Spotify accounts of celebrities, politicians, and journalists. Many use their real names. With a little sleuthing, I could say with near-certainty: yep, this is them,' the anonymous eavesdropper wrote. 6 The Panama Playlists claims to expose the music taste and habits of some of the world elite and has no affiliation with the popular music app. REUTERS 'We've been scraping their accounts since summer 2024. Playlists, live listening feed, everything. I know what songs they played, when, and how many times,' they wrote, also stating the project has not affiliation with company 'Spotify.' The anonymous researcher told The Post that they became convinced in the authenticity of each account as the months of monitoring went on. 'I gained confidence in each person by looking at lots of signals. An example is Pam Bondi. Her longtime partner is John Wakefield, and her profile has an old playlist called 'john' and an old shared playlist with a user named 'John Wakefield,' so that gives me a lot of confidence it is her account.' 'Karoline Leavitt's profile has a playlist called 'Baby Shower,' and she had a baby a month after the playlist was made,' the owner of the website told The Post, emphasizing they only collected publicly available information. It all seems to be a bit of summer fun, that reveals the questionable, ironic and sometimes too-on-the-nose music choices of America's rich and powerful. 'Heard of the Panama Papers? That exposed offshore bank accounts. This is about onshore vibes,' the site says. Here is a sample of what 'Panama Playlists' found. JD Vance 6 The Panama Playlists included graphics of each person in a mock-up of Spotify's 'This Is…' playlist catrgory. Vice President JD Vance is a fan of the songs 'I Want It That Way' by the Backstreet Boys and 'One Time' by Justin Bieber, both of which appear on his oft-listened to 'Making Dinner' playlist. The millennial veep also appears to be a fan of pop-punk, with several songs from the early aughts favorite Death Cab for Cutie appearing on his playlist 'Gold On The Ceiling.' 6 Vice President JD Vance, the first millenial to hold executive office, is a fan of the band 'Death Cab for Cutie.' AP Sam Bankman-Freid FTX fraudster Sam Bankman-Fried has three public playlists — 'rap' 'soft' and 'loud' — which feature plenty of Eminem, also Death Cab for Cutie, and song 'Young Dumb, Broke' from Khalid. Karoline Leavitt Leavitt had the songs 'Run the World (Girls)' by Beyonce and 'Girls Just Want to Have Fun' from Cyndi Lauper on her 'Baby Shower' playlist. 6 Journo Taylor Lorenz has ears for early aughts classics and break-up tracks, according to her profile. WireImage Mike Johnson Republican Speaker of the House Mike Johnson's liked tracks on his Pandora account include 'Parachutes' from the movie 'Air Force One' and the 'Finding Nemo/Nemo Egg' theme performed by the City of Prague Philharmonic Orchestra. He's also into 'One Night Love Affair' by Bryan Adams and 'May It Be' by Enya. Taylor Lorenz Social media gadfly Taylor Lorenz's public playlists include 'Older Millenial College Rager TBT' and 'Breakup Songs' —- but her 'Favs' include tracks 'Romeo and Juliet' from Dire Straits and 'You Can Get It If You Really Want' from reggae legend Jimmy Cliff. 6 US Attorney General Pam Bondi opts for up-tempo songs on her playlist 'Pam.' AFP via Getty Images Pam Bondi Bondi prefers the more upbeat tracks on her playlist named 'Pam' — including Nelly's immortal jam 'Hot In Herre,' 'Hands to Myself' by Selena Gomez, and 'Fix My Eyes' from band For King & Country.' Sam Altman OpenAI CEO Sam Altman's 'My Shazam Tracks' — meaning songs he likely looked up — include the well-known 'Get Ur Freak On' by Missy Elliot, 'Make Me Feel Your Love,' by Adele, and 'Vivir Mi Vida' from Marc Anthony. Rashida Tlaib Rep. Rashida Tlaib (D-MI) included the song 'I'm a Mess' from Ed Sheeran on her 'In love' playlist on the account that bears her name. Brian Armstrong Coinsbase CEO Brian Armstrong has a playlist called 'Repeat' that is the song 'Long Way Home' by Gareth Emery saved 60 times. 6 Florida Governor Ron DeSantis has a 'hands off my classics' taste in rock and roll music. AP Ron DeSantis Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis is a major classic rock fan with his only public playlist featuring iconic songs 'Ring of Fire' by Johnny Cash, 'Southern Nights' from the rhinestone cowboy Glen Campbell, and The Charlie Daniels Band's 'The Devil Went Down To Georgia.'

What JD Vance, Pam Bondi, and Sam Altman Can't Stop Listening To, According to the ‘Panama Playlists'
What JD Vance, Pam Bondi, and Sam Altman Can't Stop Listening To, According to the ‘Panama Playlists'

WIRED

time3 hours ago

  • WIRED

What JD Vance, Pam Bondi, and Sam Altman Can't Stop Listening To, According to the ‘Panama Playlists'

Jul 30, 2025 6:34 PM A new website claims to know the Spotify listening habits of Trump officials, tech leaders—and even journalists. Attorney General Pam Bondi allegedly jams out to Nelly's 'Hot in Herre." Photograph: Soumyabrata/Getty Images From JD Vance's dinnertime Bieber to Sam Altman's Shazaming of incredibly popular hit songs, a website claiming to have published the Spotify listening habits of members of the Trump administration, tech leaders, and journalists is making the rounds. 'We've been scraping their accounts since summer 2024. Playlists, live listening feed, everything. We know what songs they played, when, and how many times,' the Panama Playlists site reads, alleging, 'With a little sleuthing, I could say with near-certainty: yep, this is them.' Are all of the accounts real? At this point, it's hard to tell. The accounts listed have not been independently verified by WIRED. Reporter Mike Isaac from the New York Times, tells WIRED that the songs listed on the website under his name matches his real Spotify listening history. Five of the Spotify listeners from the website confirmed to The Verge the accuracy of their posted data. So, I've spent all morning obsessively listening to every song on the 'Panama Playlists,' enjoying a voyeuristic look into the listening habits of powerful people. Representatives of the public figures whose playlists were featured did not respond to immediate requests for comment. Vance's potential cooking playlist, which which had been reported on before this drop, has Justin Bieber's 'One Time' and the Backstreet Boys's "I Want It That Way" in rotation. The 'Panama Playlists' also claim US Attorney General Pam Bondi jams out to Nelly's 'Hot in Herre' and Foreigner's 'Cold as Ice,' (the latter sounds like a mad lib for the administration's current immigration policy), Florida Governor Ron DeSantis allegedly streams Miley Cyrus's 'Party in the USA', and White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt appears to enjoy some Cyndi Lauper with 'Girls Just Want to Have Fun.' (I mean, some of them also want reproductive rights, too). Even gay Republicans couldn't resist the gravitational pull of Brat summer, it seems, with nominee for US Under Secretary of State for Economic Growth, Energy, and the Environment Jacob Helberg listening to Charli XCX's 'Apple' over 50 times in the past year. If the lists are accurate, Helberg could soon become the member of the Trump administration most on the gay-pop train. Chappell Roan's 'Femininomenon' and Addison Rae's 'Diet Pepsi' clock in as his next top two most listened songs, according to the 'Panama Playlists.' I wonder how Helberg's potential boss would feel about him being a Chappell-head, especially considering the artist said 'fuck Trump' last year. The songs Silicon Valley tech leaders allegedly have on repeat are especially unhinged. The public Spotify account seemingly linked to OpenAI CEO Sam Altman, which appears to follow playlists from one of Altman's longtime friends, contains multiple Shazam playlists of identified tracks, from Dixon Dallas's 'Good Lookin',' a gay parody of country music, to Missy Elliott's 'Get Ur Freak On.' Elliott's ubiquitous hit is mainly just the lyrics 'get ur freak on' repeated over and over, making it particularly ironic to Shazam. Additional songs that Altman appears to have Shazamed include: 'Pumped Up Kicks' by Foster the People, 'Liability' by Lorde, 'The A Team' by Ed Sheeran, 'Fly' by Nicki Minaj, and 'Make You Feel My Love' by Adele. Palmer Luckey, co-founder of defense company Anduril and controversial figure in Silicon Valley, confirmed on X that he curated a number of mid-2000s bangers for his 'Best Music Ever' list, created about a decade ago; Kelly Clarkson's 'Since U Been Gone,' Hilary Duff's 'So Yesterday,' and Avril Lavigne's 'Sk8er Boi' were all part of his Spotify listening habits. Hate to say it but these are, in fact, certified bops. What song did newly appointed Meta Chief AI Officer Alexandr Wang allegedly listen to after the deal with Scale AI, his startup, closed? The 'Panama Playlists' claim that it was 'Stubborn Love' by The Lumineers. Not necessarily the celebration song I would have picked. Venture Capitalist Marc Andreessen appears to have both 'Go The Fuck To Sleep' (probably where I would slot in The Lumineers) and 'Focus Alpha' playlists. San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie's alleged list of songs for working out on a Peloton bike include Donald Glover's 'This Is America,' about racism and gun violence, and The Rolling Stones's 'Gimme Shelter.' Is it crucial to know exactly what songs JD Vance might be listening to? Yes and no. While this is a seemingly trivial look into what's going on inside his headphones, the 'Panama Playlists' purport to be a stunning example of the porous nature of online data. The website serves as a critical reminder that your digital footprint could be more public and trackable than you typically realize. Similar to when Vance's Venmo account was left public, apps designed for consumers sweep up the data of everyone, even the most powerful people in the US. For Spotify users, any playlist you make is public by default, and this has to be manually turned off in the settings. And if you'll hold on for just a second, I have a couple default settings on my Spotify account that I need to change real quick—can't let my continued obsession with the Twilight movie soundtrack get out.

Spotify's terrible privacy settings just leaked Palmer Luckey's bops and bangers
Spotify's terrible privacy settings just leaked Palmer Luckey's bops and bangers

The Verge

time5 hours ago

  • The Verge

Spotify's terrible privacy settings just leaked Palmer Luckey's bops and bangers

Have you ever wondered what bops powerful figures are listening to on Spotify? You'd be amazed what you can get with a profile search — but just in case you want them all in one place, there's the Panama Playlists, a newly published collection of data on the musical listening habits of politicians, journalists, and tech figures, as curated by an anonymous figure. The site appears to have data for a number of notables, including Open AI CEO Sam Altman, Speaker of the House Mike Johnson, US attorney general Pam Bondi, and Late Night host Seth Meyers. Five people featured on the website confirmed to The Verge that data for them is accurate; 'Thankfully mine isn't too embarrassing,' New York Times journalist Mike Isaac tweeted. Spotify's Laura Batey said Spotify would not have any comments before this story's publication. 'I'd be way more interested in is what podcasts people like JD Vance, Karoline Leavitt etc are listening to!!' Among the notables are Vice President JD Vance — whose 'Making Dinner' playlist features 'I Want it That Way' by the Backstreet Boys and 'One Time' by Justin Bieber, according to the site. Vance spokesperson Taylor Van Kirk did not respond to a request for comment. Taylor Lorenz, who is also featured on the site — 'Take a Bow' by Rihanna and 'Romeo and Juliet' by Dire Straits appear on her playlist, 'Favs' — confirmed her listing. 'I mostly use Spotify to listen to podcasts and what I'd be way more interested in is what podcasts people like JD Vance, Karoline Leavitt etc are listening to!!' she said in a text message. Former Verge staffer Joanna Stern, who is a personal tech columnist at The Wall Street Journal, confirmed her information is accurate and added, 'the maker of the Panama Papers Playlists seems to be anti-Third Eye Blind.' Another featured journalist, Kara Swisher, said that the playlist listed for her wasn't accurate. (It is called 'My Peloton Music' and features 'Savage,' by Megan Thee Stallion.) But Swisher also said that she shares a Peloton with her wife, so the site may have picked up her wife's Peloton music. Reached for comment, the editor Amanda Katz, Swisher's wife, said that playlist is 'definitely not mine.' Katz added, '[Swisher] doesn't even really use Spotify. In conclusion, trust no one.' Those songs might have played during a Peloton class, Katz said. If Katz is right, then judging people by the 'My Peloton Music' playlists is about as accurate as judging people by whatever's on at their gym. This website is possible because Spotify's design assumes everyone wants to share everything with the entire world and makes it difficult for users to protect their privacy. It defaults to making all playlists and profiles public. To change that, users need to go to the 'Privacy and social' menu and toggle the 'Public playlists' setting to private. However, that won't retroactively make playlists private; instead, you'll have to do all that by hand on each individual playlist. It's not clear who's behind the website, or how they got ahold of this data A lot of people use their name as their login — which may be because they signed up with their Facebook accounts. That makes searching for people particularly easy; I was able to find a Spotify profile for an Adam Mosseri that listed the 'Hang' playlist on the Panama Playlists website. Mosseri did not respond to an email asking if that account belonged to him. I found two Palmer Luckey accounts; one, 'Palmer Freeman Luckey,' contained the 'Best Music Ever' playlist that the Panama Playlists identified. 'I can confirm the playlist is real,' Luckey posted on X. It's not clear who's behind the website, or how they got ahold of this data. Some of the profiles, such as that of NBC's Al Roker, include play counts for specific songs — which aren't part of the public profile. If Roker had his 'Listening activity' setting toggled to 'on,' it's possible whoever put this together followed Roker, then manually counted how many times he listened to Elton John's 'Philadelphia Freedom,' but I can't say for sure. When The Verge staffers were reviewing our own privacy settings, one of my editors was stunned to discover I was following her. She thought she'd set her own profile to maximum privacy — but when the two of us collaborated on a friend's playlist, I was able to follow her. She never received a notification. And when I checked in on my own profile, I was surprised to discover that I too had followers I had never been notified about. Spotify collects a lot more personal data than most users realize. Search queries, streaming history, browsing history, interaction with other users, location data, device IDs and even data about how you hold your devices are among the information for collection listed in the company's privacy policy. It is not possible to make a private profile; your profile name and photo are always available to any Spotify user you haven't blocked. The 'Panama Playlists' is pretty silly as private data goes — discovering people's favorite songs isn't nearly as scandalous as getting into their email, direct messages, or other sensitive data. But it does reflect a generalized move toward total surveillance. A similar and more serious version of this kind of Silicon Valley carelessness around user privacy has resulted in multiple stories about politicians' public Venmo transactions. Some of the data featured was more specific than playlists. According to this site, Alexandr Wang, Meta's chief AI officer, played The Lumineers' 'Stubborn Love' immediately after Meta's $14 billion investment in Scale AI. Wang didn't immediately respond to a request for comment. If your 'Listening Activity' toggle is not set to private, it's possible for anyone following your account to see what you're listening to. But it's not clear how the Panama Playlist site arrived at play counts for some of these songs, or from where it was pulling its data. Casey Newton, my former colleague who writes the Platformer newsletter, confirmed his information was accurate: his number 1 song last year was 'All You Children' by Jamie xx and the Avalanches. 'Here is my comment: 'All You Children' by Jamie [xx and the Avalanches] absolutely slaps,' he wrote. 'Highly recommended for your summer BBQ playlists.' With reporting by Nilay Patel and Sarah Jeong. Posts from this author will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All by Elizabeth Lopatto Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Culture Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Entertainment Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Features Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Internet Culture Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Music Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Privacy Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Report Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Spotify Posts from this topic will be added to your daily email digest and your homepage feed. See All Tech

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store