Texas Teacher Retirement System leader says Senate voucher proposal would not harm retirement funds
During a House Appropriations Committee meeting, lawmakers who help oversee the state budget questioned Brian Guthrie, executive director of the Teacher Retirement System of Texas, on how Senate Bill 2 could affect the stability of funds reserved for retired teachers.
Under SB 2, families could receive public tax dollars through state-managed education savings accounts to pay for their children's tuition at an accredited private school and other expenses like textbooks, transportation and therapy.
Texas budget experts recently concluded in their analysis of SB 2 that public schools, which receive money based on attendance, may experience a decrease in funding due to students leaving the public education system to participate in the voucher program.
The analysis, which relies on estimates provided by the Texas Education Agency, projects that roughly 24,500 students would leave public schools for private schools starting in the 2026-27 school year, increasing to 98,000 by 2030. Public school administrators and education advocates have long opposed the creation of a voucher program in Texas, saying it would deal a significant blow to public school funding.
But a different part of the bill analysis, based on information provided by the Teacher Retirement System, raised worries among public education advocates and state lawmakers in recent weeks. The analysis noted that a decrease in the number of teachers paying into the state's teacher retirement fund — which could happen if a voucher program leads students and teachers to exit public schools for private schools — could affect the fund's long-term stability. Lawmakers on Wednesday said they have received concerns from their constituents about the stability of the retirement funds.
Guthrie apologized to House lawmakers for the commotion the SB 2 analysis has caused. Based on the content of the bill and the education agency estimates his organization has reviewed, Guthrie clarified that he does not believe the legislation would harm Texas' teacher retirement fund. The Teacher Retirement System executive director said his agency intended to offer the scenario in the bill analysis as a hypothetical, adding that 'it would be very difficult for SB 2' as it currently exists and with current projections to hurt the fund's stability. The analysis also states that the retirement system can currently withstand 'some outflow of teacher employment from public schools to private schools.'
'That's just the bottom line,' Guthrie said.
That explanation did not appear to fully settle Rep. Mary E. González's concerns. The Clint Democrat noted that the SB 2 analysis does not account for changes to population growth, public school enrollment or birth rates, for example. She suggested those factors, combined with a voucher program, could also affect the number of students and teachers in public schools and the fund's stability.
'We can all have different opinions about SB 2,' González said. 'But I do want our retired teachers to have all the accurate information, and I think that's really critical.'
The SB 2 analysis noted that the number of teachers paying into the retirement fund in the future will 'ultimately depend on Texas' population growth.' The number of teachers contributing to the retirement fund has consistently gone up in recent years, the analysis shows.
During the Senate floor debate over the legislation earlier this month, Sen. Brandon Creighton, the Conroe Republican who authored the bill, sought to reassure his colleagues that the proposal would not affect the Teacher Retirement System, stating that 'we would never design a program that would put TRS at risk.'
He made those comments in response to questions from Sen. Joan Huffman, R-Houston, chair of the Senate Committee on Finance, who also said she has seen no evidence from other states that voucher programs harm teacher retirement funds. In a finance committee meeting last week, Huffman again attempted to dismiss those concerns.
'Of course we are committed to not doing anything to hurt our retired' teachers, she said. 'It would be stupid to do.'
We can't wait to welcome you to the 15th annual Texas Tribune Festival, Texas' breakout ideas and politics event happening Nov. 13–15 in downtown Austin. Step inside the conversations shaping the future of education, the economy, health care, energy, technology, public safety, culture, the arts and so much more.
Hear from our CEO, Sonal Shah, on TribFest 2025.
TribFest 2025 is presented by JPMorganChase.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
3 minutes ago
- The Hill
DOJ to begin turning over Epstein docs to Oversight panel Friday: Comer
The House Oversight Committee announced Monday it expects to begin receiving Epstein-related files from the Department of Justice (DOJ) by the end of the week. 'Officials with the Department of Justice have informed us that the Department will begin to provide Epstein-related records to the Oversight Committee this week on Friday. There are many records in DOJ's custody, and it will take the Department time to produce all the records and ensure the identification of victims and any child sexual abuse material are redacted,' Chair James Comer (R-Ky.) said in a statement. 'I appreciate the Trump Administration's commitment to transparency and efforts to provide the American people with information about this matter.' The plans spurred pushback from the panel's Democrats who said DOJ was failing to fully comply, failing to meet the original deadline and supply all documents. The panel, on a bipartisan basis, subpoenaed the Justice Department for files related to the deceased financier who was awaiting trial on sex trafficking charged when he died by suicide. The motion last month from Rep. Summer Lee (D-Pa.) called for the 'full, complete, unredacted Epstein files to be delivered concurrently to the majority and minority.' Comer's announcement Monday came the same day that former Attorney General Bill Barr was deposed by the Oversight panel on the Epstein matter, the first in a series of scheduled interviews. Rep. Robert Garcia (D-Calif.), the top Democrat on the panel, said after the deposition that Democrats would require all requested records from the DOJ. 'The most critical thing the House Oversight Committee needs for its investigation is the full, complete, and unredacted Epstein files, as well as any 'client list,'' he said. 'The bipartisan Oversight Committee subpoena requires these documents by tomorrow, and if the committee does not receive the files, it will be clear the Trump Epstein Coverup continues.' Republican Reps. Nancy Mace (S.C.), Scott Perry (Pa.) and Brian Jack (Ga.) joined Democrats in approving the request in July. The committee then also approved by voice vote a motion from Perry to 'expand the full committee's investigation' into the Epstein matter by also issuing subpoenas to a number of high-profile former Democratic officials: former President Bill Clinton, former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, former FBI Director James Comey, former Attorney General Loretta Lynch, former Attorney General Eric Holder, former Attorney General Merrick Garland and former FBI Director and special counsel Robert Mueller.
Yahoo
31 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Democrat Colin Allred calls Texas redistricting destructive, criticizes Cornyn FBI request
U.S. Senate hopeful Colin Allred said Texas' latest redistricting maps undermine democracy and weaken minority communities' political power, calling them 'incredibly destructive' during a brief interview with the Globe-News. Allred, a former congressman and NFL player, is seeking the Democratic nomination for the seat currently held by Republican U.S. Sen. John Cornyn in the 2026 election. Cornyn, first elected in 2002, is running for a fifth term, and his campaign is already among the nation's most closely watched races—especially with Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton launching a GOP primary challenge in April as a staunch Trump ally. Allred previously faced U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz in 2024, losing 53.05% to 44.56%. Despite the defeat, he raised over $80 million and outperformed expectations in key Hispanic-dominant areas. His strong showing has cemented his status as a leading contender in 2026 and underscored the growing competitiveness of statewide Democratic campaigns. Against that backdrop, Allred said partisan redistricting has only deepened divisions and made congressional districts less accountable to voters. More: Cruz and Allred spar on abortion, immigration, economy: Summary of Texas debate for Senate 'This gerrymandering has broken Congress,' he said. 'It produces extreme representatives who aren't accountable. Some new districts are so bizarrely drawn, I don't know where members will even put their offices.' Allred pledged that, if elected, he would push for a national ban on gerrymandering by mandating independent redistricting commissions—a model used in states like California. 'We have to get away from politicians choosing their voters and return power to voters choosing their politicians,' he said. More: Cornyn touts legislative wins from 'One Big Beautiful Bill' in Amarillo He added that the new, proposed maps weaken majority-minority districts that have driven Texas' growth. 'Every district that's being targeted for removal was a majority-minority district,' Allred said. 'That means less voting power and less voice in Congress for Black and Brown communities… these are the areas growing the fastest in Texas, and they are the ones that need representation the most.' As an example, District 35—long majority-Hispanic—was redrawn to include more rural territory, diluting its urban voting power. Several federal lawsuits assert the maps violate the Voting Rights Act. The map fight triggered a 15-day Democratic walkout in the Texas House. On Monday, the holdout ended when those Democrats returned to the Capitol, restoring the two-thirds quorum Republicans needed to push through new congressional maps designed to produce five more GOP-leaning seats ahead of next year's midterms. Within this high-stakes moment, Cornyn drew controversy by asking the FBI to help locate the missing legislators. Allred sharply criticized that decision, viewing it as an alarming shift in democratic norms. 'Whether you agree with them or not, quorum breaks are a legitimate tactic that have been used for centuries,' he said. 'To suggest the FBI should be deployed against legislators is really dangerous.' Allred also highlighted that his campaign will center on lowering costs for health care, child care, and housing—issues he said resonate deeply in Amarillo, where rising home prices have strained local families. 'As somebody raised by a single mother who was a public school teacher in Dallas, I know how hardworking people are struggling,' he said. 'We're in an affordability crisis, and people feel like they're working harder for less.' Allred visited Amarillo in July to meet with residents, part of his effort to reach voters outside the state's major metropolitan areas. He said he plans to return again soon for his 'Unrig Texas' town hall series, aimed at challenging what he calls a rigged democracy and economy. Looking ahead to 2026, the stage is set for a politically charged contest. Cornyn retains strong establishment backing, while Paxton's primary challenge has exposed divisions within Republican ranks. For Democrats, Allred's 2024 campaign and shifting demographics suggest a potentially competitive race. The outcome will test whether Republicans can maintain their long-held dominance in Texas or if Democrats can gain ground in one of the nation's most reliably red states. This article originally appeared on Amarillo Globe-News: Democrat Senate candidate Colin Allred challenges Texas redistricting
The Hill
33 minutes ago
- The Hill
House Democrat: DC ‘not the safest place in the world'
Rep. Adam Smith (D-Wash.) said Sunday that Washington, D.C., is 'not the safest place in the world' amid President Trump's crackdown on crime in the District and pushback from Democrats over the president's actions. 'Both of my children live in Washington, D.C. You know it's not — it's not the safest place in the world,' Smith told NewsNation's Chris Stirewalt on 'The Hill Sunday.' 'And also some of the policies the Democrats advanced around crime over the course of the last 10 or 15 years very clearly did not work. There was not enough transparency and not enough accountability,' he added. Last week, Trump announced he was taking federal control of D.C.'s police department and deploying the National Guard in the city to combat crime. Since then, he has received heavy pushback on his law enforcement moves from Democrats and District residents. On Monday, Mississippi became the fourth Republican -led state to unveil plans to dispatch National Guard troops to D.C. to boost Trump's crackdown on crime in the District. 'I've approved the deployment of approximately 200 Mississippi National Guard Soldiers to Washington, D.C., to support President Trump's effort to return law and order to our nation's capital,' Mississippi Gov. Tate Reeves (R) said on the social platform X. Smith said last Tuesday it was 'pretty clear' Trump ''wants his own domestic police force.' 'Look, this president is trampling on basic freedoms of the American people to a degree we — I don't think we've ever seen,' Smith said on CNN. 'You see that with what the ICE [Immigration and Customs Enforcement] agents are doing, in terms of picking people up off the streets with no evidence, no due process, locking people up.' 'This is happening all across the country,' the Evergreen State Democrat added. 'Look, it's pretty clear the president wants his own domestic police force, and step by step, he's trying to create it, and we should be deeply alarmed by that, regardless of how you feel about crime in Washington, D.C., or any other city.'
