Section 4 crisis to be resolved soon; will appeal to Centre, SC: Khandre
Presiding over a meeting held with Chikkamagaluru district MLAs and forest and revenue department officials at Vikas Soudha, he said that a request will be submit-ted to the Supreme Court and the Centre to give an alternative to the designated forest with residential areas, patta land, etc. and the land allocated after the Section 4 notification, and to abandon this land from the forest area.
In many cases, even though Section 4 has been notified for 60-70 years, Section 17 is still not in effect. After the implementation of the Forest Conservation Act of 1980, it has become difficult to abandon such forests. Therefore, it is imperative to appeal to the Center and the Supreme Court.
Chikkamagaluru district is in the Western Ghats and there is a rich forest area here. There is 300-400 acres of land in a single survey number, and there is confusion because there is no joint survey. In this context, he told the officials to conduct a joint survey of forest and revenue land and try to resolve the problem quickly.
The survey number in the certificate submitted to the Supreme Court as a deemed forest also includes houses, government schools, government buildings, and land plots.
Now that we have finally got the opportunity to submit a report to the Supreme Court, we can submit a petition to the Supreme Court by conducting a proper survey and determining the amount of land eligible for abandonment, and by providing revenue land elsewhere as an alternative and cultivating a forest there, Ishwar Khandre said.The Forest Minister also instructed that the deemed forest certificate, which was al-ready submitted to the Supreme Court in 2022, be uploaded on the department's of-ficial website to make it available to the public.
Responding to the request of the MLAs that the current 10 km buffer zone around the bear sanctuary in Arsikere limits of Hassan district is also causing hardship to the farmers of Chikkamagaluru in the border area, the Minister said that a proposal has been submitted to reduce this limit to 1 km. He assured that this problem will be resolved soon.
Forest, Ecology and Environment Minister Eshwar B Khandre, who convened a meeting to discuss the problems being faced by the common people due to Section 4 of the Forest Act and the affected forest notification in Chikkamagaluru district, was thanked by MLAs Rajegowda, Thammanna, Nayana Motamma, Srinivas and Anand who participated in the meeting.
Forest Force Chief Meenakshi Negi, Chief Wildlife Warden Subhash Malkade, PCCF BP Ravi, Biswajit Mishra, Chikkamagaluru District Commissioner Meena Na-garaj and others participated in the meeting.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Indian Express
28 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
Markers and proofs of citizenship
NEW DELHI: The genesis of the present controversy over the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of voter lists in poll-bound Bihar lies in the Election Commission of India (ECI) changing a parameter for the enrollment exercise for the first time. For the longest time, any one could get into the poll rolls through self-declaration of citizenship. Deletion would kick in only if someone challenged the bona fides and produced material to establish it. The poll body has now shifted the burden of proof of citizenship to the applicant. Rebutting challenges, the ECI in its counter affidavit in the Supreme Court said, it is "vested with the power to scrutinize whether a proposed elector fulfils the criteria for being registered as a voter in the electoral roll, which includes, inter alia, an assessment of citizenship as per Article 326 of the COI. Such scrutiny is constitutionally mandated and crystallized by virtue of RP Act 1950. This power flows directly from the provisions of Article 324 (superintendence, direction and control of the preparation of the electoral rolls) read with 326 (adult suffrage), and sections 16 (disqualification if a person is not a citizen) and 19 (ordinarily a resident in a constituency entitled to be registered in the electoral roll) of the RP Act 1950.' Supreme Court judge Surya Kant concurred. 'Law regarding conferment of citizenship or taking away of citizenship will have to be enacted by the Parliament. No debate is required on that. But once that law has been made and in terms of that if somebody has been acknowledged or recognised as citizen, inclusion of that person in the voters list and a person who has not been recognised as citizen and who is not a citizen, exclusion of that person, that has to be undertaken by the commission only,' he said. He agreed that self-declaration of citizenship may lead to legal complications, adding the ECI can verify their authenticity.
New Indian Express
41 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
Timelines for Prez, Guvs will lead to constitutional disorder, Centre tells SC
NEW DELHI: The Centre on Saturday cautioned the Supreme Court that fixing timelines on governors and the president to act on bills passed by a state Assembly would lead to a 'constitutional disorder'. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta has said this in a written submissions filed in the Presidential Reference raising constitutional issues on whether timelines could be imposed for dealing with bills passed by a state Assembly. 'The alleged failure, inaction or error of one organ does not and cannot authorise another organ to assume powers that the Constitution has not vested in it. If any organ is permitted to arrogate to itself the functions of another on a plea of public interest or institutional dissatisfaction or even on the justification derived from the Constitution ideals, the consequence would be a constitutional disorder not envisaged by its framers,' he said. A note filed by Solicitor Mehta has argued that the apex court imposing fixed timelines would dissolve the delicate equilibrium that the Constitution has established and negate the rule of law. 'The perceived lapses, if any, are to be addressed through constitutionally-sanctioned mechanisms, such as electoral accountability, legislative oversight, executive responsibility, reference procedures or consultative process amongst democratic organs etc. Thus, Article 142 does not empower the court to create a concept of 'deemed assent', turning the constitutional and legislative process on its head,' it reads. The positions of the governor and president are 'politically plenary' and represent 'high ideals of democratic governance'. Any perceived lapses, the note says, must be addressed through political and constitutional mechanisms, and not necessarily through 'judicial' interventions. Mehta has contended that Articles 200 and 201, which deal with the governors' and president's alternatives after receiving a state bill, deliberately contain no timelines. 'When the Constitution seeks to impose time limits for taking certain decisions, it specifically mentions such time limits. Where it has consciously kept the exercise of powers flexible, it does not impose any fixed time limit,' Mehta has said.
Hans India
an hour ago
- Hans India
Disappearing water bodies leave citizens at mercy of monsoon
Tirupati: Aspell of heavy rain is enough to throw life out of gear across the undivided Chittoor district. From Tirupati and Chittoor city to Puttur, Palamaner, Punganur, Kuppam and Srikalahasti, clogged drains, vanished lakes and encroached waterways trigger flooding year after year, leaving residents in low-lying areas anxious every monsoon. Despite crores of rupees spent on storm water management, the results are meagre on the ground. People are often unable to sleep when it rains as within hours, water enters their homes in the low-lying areas. The temple city, lying at the foothills of Seshachalam, is particularly vulnerable as nearly 20 waterfalls feed local lakes before draining into the Swarnamukhi River. But unchecked urbanisation has destroyed the natural channels. Pedda Cheruvu has been taken over for government offices, Peruru tank was built over, and Thummalagunta pond gave way to a cricket stadium. Avilala Cheruvu, once spread over 200 acres, was damaged during political events in 1992 and 2008 despite Supreme Court protection. It is learnt that Tirupati once had 44 water bodies, of which six disappeared between 1975 and 1990, another ten between 1990 and 2004, and several more in the years that followed. An inlet channel that was originally 30 to 40 feet wide has now narrowed to barely 15 feet due to encroachments, a factor that contributed to the severe flooding witnessed in 2021. Several colonies including Madhura Nagar, Railway Colony, Satyanarayana Puram, Sivajyothi Nagar and Bairagipatteda face routine inundation. A drainage canal project launched in 2015 on the Tirupati–Karakambadi stretch remains incomplete, while a Rs 189 crore package sanctioned in 2023 for canal restoration is stuck due to land issues and political hurdles. Other towns show a similar pattern. In Puttur, the outlet canal of SR Cheruvu was blocked, flooding Jendamaanu Veedhi and Bhavani Nagar. In Palamaner, choked feeder channels to Eddula Cheruvu forced evacuations during heavy rain. In Chittoor, proposals for an underground drainage system remain unimplemented while silt-choked drains cause regular overflow. The Tirupati Municipal Corporation, however, has initiated daily desilting of drains. Commissioner N Mourya directed officials to ensure free flow of rainwater while acknowledging complaints about leaking sewage lines and stagnation. Experts warn that climate change is likely to bring more intense rainfall and say restoring natural waterways, clearing encroachments and building modern storm water systems are essential. They also stress that desilting drains before the monsoon could avert much of the flooding. Until then, residents across the district will continue to dread every passing cloud.
