Hypochlorous Acid Mists Are Touted as Cure-Alls. So We Tested Them.
Once we understood the science of hypochlorous acid, we put seven of the most popular, sought-after hypochlorous acid mists to the test. In many cases the ingredients lists look nearly identical (pretty much just water, salt, and hypochlorous acid). But the ratio of those ingredients and the formula's pH (or acidity level) are what made one product different from the next.
We compared their formulas, and for testing we selected mists with minimal ingredients and formulations that are considered safe to use on scrapes, makeup tools, and the face. This eliminated some mists that had hypochlorous acid as just one of several skin-care ingredients, including things like salicylic acid, peptides, fruit extracts, and added fragrance.
Our testing list included:
Our testing panel included six people with varying skin types, and they tested these products in Wirecutter's office. Testers evaluated each mist for its first-impression user experience, including the pump, the feel of the mist, how it performed over makeup, the packaging, and the smell.
Next, we considered price and formula, including acidity and concentration. Of the seven mists we tested, we were able to confirm that four had both ideal acidity and concentration.
The concentration of HOCl in products made for skin tends to fall between 0.01% to 0.02% hypochlorous acid (the rest of the spray is typically a mix of water and salt). Rambhia said this concentration is a 'sweet spot' in that it's strong enough to disrupt pathogens but mild enough for good bacteria to withstand. (This is one reason why you don't need to worry that hypochlorous acid sprays made for the skin will disrupt your skin's microbiome or kill off good bacteria.) Of the mists we tested, our two favorites fall within this range. Some brands, like Prequel, put the concentration of hypochlorous acid on the bottle. Hannah Frye/NYT Wirecutter
The next thing to consider is pH, or acidity. Some studies (including one from 2022 and another from 2023) suggest that for a hypochlorous acid product for use on skin, the ideal pH should fall roughly between 4 and 6 (similar to the pH of the skin's acidic mantle) to be the most effective for killing bacteria. And Tran and Bowles both agreed. That acidic mantle is a pH of about 4.5 to 5.5, so 'products in this acidic range better support skin's natural defenses,' Tran said.
However, if the formula is too acidic, and the pH falls below about 4, this may cause the hypochlorous acid solution to lose stability and convert to chlorine gas, Tran said. On the flip side, when pH surpasses about 6, some of the hypochlorous acid could convert to hypochlorite ion, a form research suggests is less effective at killing bacteria. Some brands list pH and concentration information on the bottle or online. For those that didn't, I reached out to the brands directly.
One spray stood out to our panel as a favorite in ideal formula, usability, and value: Personal Day Trust Me on This Hypochlorous Acid Spray. The mists that won over our testers. Marki Williams/NYT Wirecutter
Adored for its fine mist and beautiful packaging, this spray took the cake for our testers. We also liked that it didn't leave a potent chlorine-like smell.
Personal Day Trust Me on This Hypochlorous Acid Spray is a relative newcomer to the hypochlorous acid scene (it launched in March 2025), and it lands in the middle of the pack on price (at $6.75 an ounce, or $27 for a bottle, at time of writing). Our panel gave it high praise for its super-fine mist, which refreshed our testers' skin without making it feel too wet. I used the Personal Day mist over my makeup multiple times throughout testing, and it never displaced foundation or concealer, even with a generous amount of spritzing.
The dilution, as told to me by the company, is 0.02%, which falls into the acceptable range for use on the skin. The pH is between 5.3 and 5.7, falling into that expert-approved window.
The mist had little to no detectable scent, and all of the testers admired the packaging. Staff writer Caroline Mullen commented, 'It has a hefty weight, smooth rounded edges, and an almost flocked feeling that pleased me. Plus, I'm eternally into a bright green.'
This spray earned high praise for its gentle mist and pretty packaging. Some testers initially didn't love the light chlorine smell, but the scent faded quickly.
The Prequel Universal Skin Solution Dermal Spray was our next favorite. Like the Personal Day spray's mist, this one's fine mist hit the skin gently, not wetly. One tester remarked, 'The small packaging is so pretty, and it's easy to hold and spray.' However, some testers detected a stronger, pool-like scent from the Prequel spray in comparison with Personal Day's mist.
The Prequel spray has the same dilution as the Personal Day spray: 0.02% hypochlorous acid, as stated on the bottle, and a pH of 5.5, as listed on the website. On the Prequel spray's ingredients list, you'll also find muriatic acid (aka hydrochloric acid), which Bowles said is used in diluted amounts to help lower the pH of the product. 'By doing so, it helps optimize the hypochlorous acid's effectiveness in killing bacteria and promoting healing,' she explained.
Prequel's mist also has a seal of acceptance from the National Rosacea Society; this indicates that a product has undergone testing and consideration specifically for those who struggle with rosacea, and that it should be free from ingredients commonly known to exacerbate rosacea symptoms. So if you have rosacea, you may consider this seal to be a plus.
Our testers considered the Prequel spray to be in a dead heat with the Hydrinity Hyacyn Active mist ($20 an ounce, or $60 a bottle, at the time of writing), which delivered a similar user experience. However, we couldn't justify the Hydrinity spray's price, so we dismissed it. The middle-ground mist we found to be slightly less satisfying than our winners. Marki Williams/NYT Wirecutter
This mist earned praise for its mild, chlorine-like smell and lightweight packaging (which makes it nice for traveling). Yet it lost points for having a messy mist and a cheap-feeling bottle (given the price).
We liked, but didn't love, the popular Tower28 SOS Rescue Spray. Although many testers enjoyed the look of the packaging, they said they found the mist to be a tad too damp. Editor Hannah Rimm said the Tower28 mist 'was very wet so I didn't want to put it on my face.' She added, however, that it felt refreshing on her body. Staff writer Maki Yazawa, who has used the Tower28 mist before, said, 'For $28, I'd expect a much finer mist, and the packaging feels cheaply made.' Some testers found the chlorine-like smell to be mild, but others disagreed.
Tower28's spray lists a pH of 4.5. We confirmed with the brand that its dilution falls within the ideal range of 0.01% to 0.02% hypochlorous acid, though Tower28 declined to disclose the exact percentage. This nondisclosure isn't necessarily a red flag, Tran explained, since some brands guard their formulations for competitive reasons. She added that Tower28 obtained some relevant certification seals (like the acceptance seals from the National Eczema Association and the National Rosacea Society), which are 'positive indicators of their product's safety and testing standards.' These are our testers' least favorite mists in terms of smell, feel, and packaging. Marki Williams/NYT Wirecutter
The mists our panel least liked using — E11ement Hypochlorous Acid Face and Skin Spray, SkinSmart Facial Cleanser for Acne, and Magic Molecule The Solution — coincidentally all have a pH of 7 or above, according to the brands, though their concentrations fall within the ideal range.
Hypochlorous acid mists with a pH of 7 or higher could still offer some benefits, but they might not be as effective at killing bacteria over time, Bowles said. She said this is especially true if you're hoping to use one of these sprays to help treat an inflammatory skin condition.
SkinSmart and Magic Molecules HOCl sprays are FDA-cleared, which is not required, and ultimately this may not be the most important factor to consider. 'What really matters is the formulation itself — particularly the pH,' Bowles said. 'A low-pH mist without FDA clearance can actually be more beneficial for skin care than a high-pH, FDA-cleared formula that isn't optimized for the skin's needs.'
Our least favorite mists had clumsier, wetter mists and strong (if fleeting) pool smells, and they were, unfortunately, also the most affordable options. If price is paramount, your skin may still see some benefits from these mists, but you could be compromising in other areas.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Times
5 days ago
- New York Times
This Portable Travel Essential Could Save Your Life. And It Costs Less Than $35.
Focusing too heavily on the symptoms of carbon monoxide poisoning may give people a false sense that they'll know if they're suffering from CO poisoning. That's because common symptoms of CO poisoning — such as headache, dizziness, fatigue, and nausea — resemble the signs of other illnesses, especially those that are easy to come down with while you're traveling. You might think you have food poisoning, the flu, COVID-19, or a migraine, or that you simply had too much to drink. 'If you have a headache, you're not going to call the fire department,' Hauschildt noted. On top of that, if you've ever gotten sick on vacation, you've probably done exactly what I've done: You've stayed in your room. If you have carbon monoxide poisoning however, this will only make you sicker, and the sicker you get, the less likely you are to get out, since another effect of CO poisoning is disorientation or confusion. And many carbon-monoxide related deaths happen while a person is sleeping, so some people might experience no symptoms at all. All of that is to say: A detector may be the only way for you to know if you have CO poisoning. Left: Our portable detector pick (left) is slightly smaller than a standard plug-in detector (right). Right: If you use plug-in detectors (pictured at top) at home, you can also bring them with you on vacation, an especially appealing option if you need to cover an entire rental. Maria Adelmann/NYT Wirecutter Luckily, CO devices are compact, readily available to buy, and relatively inexpensive. Unlike smoke alarms, carbon monoxide alarms don't need to be mounted because CO is about the same weight as air; as a result, many residential detectors for sale today are plug-in devices that also have a battery backup. These are totally suitable for travel as long as they conform to the UL 2034 standard, which reflects the latest safety regulations for such devices. Packing your home's plug-in alarms to take on vacation can be especially useful if you'd like to have several for coverage of a larger rental. But it may be worthwhile to get a dedicated, portable, battery-operated CO alarm that you can store with your travel supplies and that you won't have to remember to pack or return to its original location. Doug Mahoney, who writes Wirecutter's guide to smoke alarms, suggests the First Alert CO710 Carbon Monoxide Detector, a battery-operated detector that is about the width of two iPhones and weighs less than half a pound. It can slip into the front pocket of a carry-on. Although we haven't extensively tested CO detectors as their own category, we have tested combination fire alarms and CO detectors, and Doug is confident in this recommendation. Currently, only two well-established manufacturers of residential smoke alarms, First Alert and Kidde, undergo rigorous third-party testing to confirm that their products comply with UL standards, as indicated by a UL or Intertek mark on the back of the device. 'This certification is a pass/fail test for us,' Doug told me. 'If a company has it, we consider their products. If a company does not have it, we will not consider their products.' Unfortunately, Kidde's track record with its products is 'disturbing,' according to Doug, owing to a perpetual history of large-scale recalls. That makes First Alert the last one standing. Our portable pick is not much bigger than an iPhone and fits even in the smallest pockets of my travel bags, such as the side pocket of my Fjällräven Kånken and a pocket on my suitcase specifically designed for a phone and a power bank. Maria Adelmann/NYT Wirecutter We also think First Alert devices are nicely built and easy to use. For travel, the battery-operated CO detector has an advantage over a plug-in model: Not only is it smaller and able to work without occupying a precious outlet, but also, if you're vacationing internationally, you won't have to deal with a travel adapter for it. You can also place it at eye level so that you don't forget to pack it when you leave. Plus, the lithium ion battery should last about 10 years. Just note that because of that battery, you may want to slip the detector into your carry-on or personal item instead of your checked bag. The First Alert detector is blissfully simple (though we always recommend reading the manual). When the air is safe, the display shows the room temperature (left). Running a quick test demonstrates what the alarm sounds like and looks like when activated (right). Maria Adelmann/NYT Wirecutter Unless the detector is issuing an alert (or you're running a test), the display simply shows the temperature, a pleasant feature I like. It lets you forget about the risk of carbon monoxide poisoning while keeping you protected. If you're in a hotel room, you can just place the detector on a nightstand. If you're renting an entire house, the Environmental Protection Agency advises putting a detector on every floor. (Some sources go further, recommending detectors on every floor and in every bedroom.) Doug also suggests placing one in the basement, though not directly next to a furnace or any fuel-burning appliance, such as a hot water heater, which could cause a false alarm. If you have only one detector, the EPA suggests placing it near sleeping areas and confirming that it's loud enough to wake you. If your carbon monoxide detector merely chirps, it may be malfunctioning or in need of a new battery. But if it goes off continuously, get outside to fresh air as quickly as possible (or open windows if not) and then call 911.
New York Times
30-07-2025
- New York Times
You Don't Have to Wear Sunscreen...As Long As You Don't Mind Dressing Like Me
Before you come for me in the comments: Yes, I do know what I look like. But I also know that the sun is a killer. My Wirecutter colleagues have spent hundreds of hours testing sunscreens to protect your skin from the myriad risks it poses. Despite all of their work, and despite my trying all of those endless tubes and creams and aerosols, I've come to an unfortunate conclusion: I just don't like sunscreen. I don't like the greasy look of it. I don't like the sticky feeling of it. And I don't even like how it smells. I also have sensitive, burn-prone skin and absolutely no desire to incur sun damage. So what's a girl to do? Luckily, I've found a combination of clothing and other items that keep my skin safe, and they don't require me to smear globs of product I hate. When I'm wearing this getup, my sister won't walk next to me, my friends laugh at me regularly, and sometimes children even point and stare. Perhaps I look strange. But I am free. These opera-length UPF gloves provide coverage from your fingers to your upper arms. They're made from mesh, so they're extra breathable. And they have textured index-finger and thumb pads, so you can text on the move. To avoid using sunscreen, my solution is to wear UPF clothing. I specifically love having a hat and gloves that I can add to any outfit. UPF (ultraviolet protection factor) clothing is any type of clothing that offers protection from the sun. As Sarah Gannett wrote in our guide to UPF clothing, 'A garment isn't considered sun protective if it has a UPF rating lower than 15.' So any clothing you purchase for the sake of sun protection should have a UPF of at least 15 (my picks here both have a UPF rating of 50+). Many garments do this without having a UPF rating. But the rating lets you know exactly how much sun can penetrate the fabric, similar to the way SPF indicates how much sun can penetrate sunscreen. Unlike sunscreen, UPF clothing does not require 'reapplication'; you just pull on the item, and whatever it covers is protected until you pull it off. And there's a ton of UPF clothing to choose from (some items are recommended elsewhere on our site, including hats, shirts, and sun sleeves for gardening). My first line of defense is the Stevie Ultra Sun Hat. It may make me look like a beekeeper, but it's genius: On the underside of the hat, two snaps connect with the veil, so you can remove it or adjust its tightness, and it can be worn over the nose or under the chin. A flexible wire in the veil shapes around your nose (like a face mask) to create a snugger fit. Dorie Chevlen/NYT Wirecutter It also has a removable chin strap, which can be tightened on windy days to keep the hat secure. And the hat's 22-inch circumference can be tightened, so it's suitable for more head shapes (though not all — a few buyers on Coolibar's site said the 22-inch circumference was too snug for their heads). The brim extends 4 inches on the front half of the hat (the back half has a gator), keeping my face fully shaded and my neck fully covered even on the sunniest days. I have worn my Coolibar sun hat for two years, and it's holding up beautifully. From there, I add a pair of opera-length gloves. They allow me to skimp on sunscreen for the entire span of my arms, unless I'm wearing a sleeveless shirt, in which case I either rub sunscreen on my upper arms or tack a UPF umbrella onto my getup. Crucially, another thing that sets these gloves apart from winter pairs is their impressive breathability. Everyone asks me, 'Don't you get sweaty in there?' But I don't. The mesh is so breathable that I don't even feel it on my skin. Also, the touch-screen-compatible pads on the index fingers and thumbs allow me to wear the gloves daily without going batty. Since I am usually lost and swiping around Google Maps on any walk that I take, this is a must-have feature. Another nice detail is the silicon texturing on the palms; this material makes the gloves just a bit grippier, so if you're holding, say, a water bottle, it won't slip through your fingers. These gloves come in several colors and sizes, too (measured by the circumference of the biceps and the length of the fingers). In hindsight, I wish I'd bothered to measure; I lazily selected the medium-size gloves, but they're just a bit roomy; next time, I'd go with a small pair. There are many advantages to my sun-protective accessories, including that they're machine-washable. Every couple of weeks (or whenever I remember), I throw the hat and gloves into the washer on the delicate cycle, and then I air-dry them. (I put the gloves in a mesh bag so they don't tangle.) This getup is also a lot quicker to throw on than your classic rub-in sunscreen. On the few days that I use sunscreen instead of my UPF ensemble, I fume over how long it takes. Pulling on gloves and throwing on a hat takes maybe 15 seconds. But carefully rubbing in sunscreen, making sure it's evenly distributed across your neck and face and on your ears, and then repeating that process every two hours? I've never measured, but I know it's a lot longer than a quarter of a minute. But even with this getup at my disposal, there will always be some occasions where sunscreen proves necessary — when I'm swimming, for example, or on really windy days (the veil can flap up in strong gusts, making its protection less dependable). And though my various UPF accessories are by no means cheap, the cost-per-wear is ultimately worth it. If anything, the biggest downside to this getup is the attention it brings. Even my friends laugh at me or call me a 'whack-ass beekeeper,' and while I have a very high threshold for embarrassment, it can still feel uncomfortable to walk around in public looking different from most people. And though wearing a face covering and gloves against the sun is common practice in many parts of the world, in the US and Canada, where I have worn my getup, people stare. That's usually fine by me, but sometimes I do choose the physical discomfort of sunscreen over the social discomfort of judgmental looks. More often than not, however, I throw caution to the wind and don my hat and gloves without a second thought. On a recent walk through Vancouver's Stanley Park with my boyfriend, he marveled at the response to my attire. 'People are giving you such nasty looks!' They were. They will again. But I'm holding my ground. No matter what others think, I have the smug satisfaction of taking care of my skin — my body — in my own way. I didn't invent this practice, and I won't be the last to employ it. So to all of my fellow sunscreen-averse, UPF-hat-wearing friends (past, present, and future), I will say it's an honor to be in your club. This article was edited by Hannah Rimm and Maxine Builder.
New York Times
17-07-2025
- New York Times
Ask Wirecutter: Help Me Find Actually-Cool Rx Sunglasses
My clay-sculpted mini-me is wearing the Galaxy Square Glasses from Zenni Optical with 1.67 high-index polarized progressive lenses tinted in blue mirror. They cost $222 total. Dana Davis/NYT Wirecutter and Connie Park/NYT Wirecutter Both of the companies we recommend in our guide to the best places to buy glasses online, Eyebuydirect and Zenni Optical, sell a large variety of frames that can be made into prescription sunglasses. All of them include UV protection and can be made with polarized lenses. Polarization, Reed explained, helps reduce glare in outdoor light, but it can make it hard to read digital displays like LCD screens. 'Polarization blocks light at a particular plane. If you are looking at a flat road or the hood of your car, light is going to come down and hit that and bounce up into your eyes,' he said. 'It can cause some glare, and so polarization purposely blocks that particular plane so that you can see better.' The main benefit to ordering prescription sunglasses online is cost. 'Usually online shops are much less expensive than local options,' says Nancy, the guide's author, who, like me, has a trifecta of nearsightedness, astigmatism, and a need for progressives. Most everyone can find frames they like and lenses that suit their prescription at this retailer. Prices are in the midrange, and the return period is shorter than most, but our testers consistently rated Eyebuydirect glasses as being better than the competition. It's possible to score a great pair of prescription eyeglasses from this retailer. And judging by customer reviews, as well as our own testing, many people do, sometimes at astonishingly affordable prices. But its return and refund options make it a slightly higher-risk choice. Keep in mind, though, that ordering prescription glasses online is not the best choice for everyone, especially if you have a strong or complicated prescription and need high-quality lenses. Your local optician — who can ensure the frames fit your face properly and precisely measure your pupillary distance, which is necessary for the best clarity of vision — may offer competitive pricing, especially if you have vision insurance. These are the Galaxy Square Glasses from Zenni, stored in my Croakies case. Annemarie Conte & Katie Quinn/NYT Wirecutter No matter where you buy prescription sunglasses, a good case to store them so they don't get lost or broken is essential. Some brands' cases are well designed and sturdy, while others feel like an afterthought. If you need a reliable, convenient case, the Croakies Sunglasses Case with Carabiner is a great choice. This hard-sided case zips closed to keep glasses protected. The convenient carabiner allows you to clip it to your bag for easy access. The Croakies case was recommended to me last year by a co-worker, and I love it because it's big enough to fit almost all frames, it has a zip closure, and you can clip it somewhere convenient so you're not rustling through your bag to find it.
