Malaysia leads ASEAN in new direction on Myanmar
With Malaysia assuming the chairmanship of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations in 2025, Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim is poised to steer the regional bloc toward a more assertive stance on Myanmar's ongoing crisis. Unlike previous chairs, Malaysia aims to prioritize accountability for the Myanmar junta's atrocities and reject the legitimacy of its planned elections, widely criticized as a sham.
This approach, while ambitious, faces significant challenges given ASEAN's history of ineffectiveness on Myanmar. The implications for the Rohingya and other minorities are profound and Anwar's personal interest in the issue adds a unique dimension to Malaysia's leadership. However, the likelihood of this approach being successful remains uncertain, constrained as it is by ASEAN's structural limitations and regional dynamics.
Malaysia's chairmanship, themed 'Inclusivity and Sustainability,' comes at a critical juncture. Myanmar's junta, led by Senior Gen. Min Aung Hlaing, has plunged the country into chaos since the 2021 coup, displacing more than 3.3 million people and killing thousands, with ethnic and religious minorities bearing the brunt of the violence.
ASEAN's response, primarily through the Five-Point Consensus adopted in April 2021, has been widely criticized as toothless, failing to curb the junta's aggression or advance inclusive dialogue. Malaysia, under Anwar's leadership, seeks to break this cycle by rejecting engagement with the junta, advocating for accountability and dismissing the junta's election plans as a ploy to entrench power.
Anwar's strategy includes several key elements. First, Malaysia has appointed a special envoy, Tan Sri Othman Hashim, to facilitate dialogue with all stakeholders, including the national unity government and ethnic groups, signaling a shift toward recognizing Myanmar's legitimate democratic forces.
Second, Malaysia is pushing for increased humanitarian aid to affected communities, particularly the Rohingya, and stronger coordination with international bodies like the International Criminal Court to address human rights abuses.
Finally, Anwar has called for ASEAN to cease all economic and diplomatic ties with the junta, such as barring its representatives from ASEAN meetings and cutting off resources like aviation fuel that enable military operations.
While Malaysia's approach is principled, its success is far from assured. ASEAN's consensus-based decision-making model, which requires unanimity among its 10 member states, has historically paralyzed decisive action on Myanmar. Countries like Cambodia, Laos and Thailand, which maintain closer ties with the junta or prioritize economic relations with China, Myanmar's key ally, are likely to resist Malaysia's push for a hard-line stance. Previous chairs, such as Indonesia in 2023, attempted similar reforms but failed to overcome these divisions, resulting in the Five-Point Consensus' stagnation.
Anwar's vocal advocacy for the Rohingya stems from a combination of personal conviction and strategic positioning.
Dr. Azeem Ibrahim
Anwar's diplomatic efforts, including his controversial meetings with both the national unity government and Min Aung Hlaing in April, reflect a pragmatic attempt to engage all parties. However, the junta's track record of broken promises — such as its ceasefire of the same month, which was violated almost immediately — undermines the feasibility of negotiated progress. Moreover, Malaysia's ability to rally ASEAN members is complicated by its own foreign policy shifts, including closer ties with China and Russia, which may alienate Western partners that could support accountability measures.
The junta's planned elections, scheduled for either December 2025 or January 2026, further complicate Malaysia's strategy. Widely viewed as a sham to legitimize military rule, these elections exclude key stakeholders like the national unity government and ethnic minorities. Malaysia's call for inclusive polls is laudable but lacks enforcement mechanisms, as ASEAN's noninterference principle limits its ability to pressure the junta. Without unified regional support or external leverage from powers like the US or the EU, Malaysia's efforts risk being symbolic rather than transformative.
The Rohingya, a Muslim minority subjected to genocide in 2017, stand to gain significantly from a successful Malaysian-led ASEAN strategy. Malaysia hosts approximately 120,000 Rohingya refugees, a humanitarian burden that underscores the urgency of addressing Myanmar's crisis. Anwar's push for enhanced humanitarian aid and safe repatriation, in coordination with Bangladesh, which hosts nearly a million Rohingya, could alleviate immediate suffering. Furthermore, Malaysia's advocacy for International Criminal Court involvement may bring justice for atrocities, offering a semblance of accountability for the Rohingya and other persecuted groups like the Karen and Shan.
However, failure to achieve meaningful progress could exacerbate the plight of these minorities. Continued violence and displacement in Myanmar, coupled with ASEAN's inability to act, may deepen regional instability, with Malaysia and neighboring countries facing increased refugee inflows and social tensions. The junta's elections, if held without reform, could further marginalize ethnic minorities, entrenching their exclusion from Myanmar's political process and perpetuating cycles of violence.
Anwar's vocal advocacy for the Rohingya stems from a combination of personal conviction and strategic positioning. As a long-time human rights advocate and a Muslim leader, Anwar has consistently championed the cause of Muslim minorities globally, including the Palestinians and the Rohingya. His condemnation of the 2017 Rohingya genocide and calls for international action reflect a moral commitment to addressing their suffering. This stance resonates with Malaysia's domestic audience, where the Rohingya issue is a significant social and political concern, given the country's large refugee population.
Strategically, Anwar's focus on the Rohingya enhances Malaysia's regional and global standing. By positioning Malaysia as a moral leader within ASEAN, Anwar seeks to restore the bloc's credibility and assert Malaysia's influence as a middle power. His engagement with both democratic and authoritarian actors in Myanmar reflects a pragmatic approach to diplomacy, balancing idealism with the realities of ASEAN's fractured dynamics.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al Arabiya
16 hours ago
- Al Arabiya
Inside Trump's ‘Alligator Alcatraz': Migrant detainees allege extreme abuse
At US President Donald Trump's new migrant detention center in the Florida Everglades, time has no discernible meaning. Prisoners are barely able to see sunlight in the windowless space, living under fluorescent lamps that are always on, with no clocks or anything else by which they might mark the days. Several detainees, their family members and lawyers have denounced appalling conditions at the facility, nicknamed 'Alligator Alcatraz' by an administration that has likened undocumented migrants to 'animals' and promised to deport millions. AFP spoke with several 'Alligator Alcatraz' detainees by phone and obtained further information about conditions there from relatives, lawyers and legal documents. Detainees spoke of facilities covered in filth, a lack of medical care, mistreatment, and the violation of their legal rights. 'They don't even treat animals like this. This is like torture,' said Luis Gonzalez, a 25-year-old Cuban who called AFP from inside the center. Florida authorities built the facilities in eight days -- opening the center on July 2 at an abandoned airfield in the Everglades wetlands. Governed by Republican Ron DeSantis, the southeastern state signed an agreement with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to detain undocumented foreigners, a power that until now had been reserved for federal authorities. Now, the Trump administration wants to make this a model for other detention centers across the country. Like 'murderers' Gonzalez arrived in the United States in 2022 and settled in Florida after authorities released him while his asylum application was being reviewed. Last month, when an immigration judge dismissed his case, ICE agents arrested him and took him to 'Alligator Alcatraz.' They kept him chained by his hands, waist, and feet on a bus with other detainees for more than a day before taking him to one of the large tents that house eight cells each, he said. 'I haven't seen sunlight in the 14 days I've been here,' he said. 'When they take us to the dining hall, they take us with our hands on our heads as if we were murderers.' He lives in a cell with about 30 people, a space enclosed by chain-linked fencing that he compares to a chicken coop. It is hardly ever cleaned, he says, not even the three toilets that everyone shares. At the time of the call, Gonzalez had not showered for a week. The days are hot, with swarms of mosquitoes in the cells, and the nights are not much better. Beatings, attempted suicide Gonzalez and other detainees have denounced the lack of medical care available at the site. Michael Borrego Fernandez, 35, complained of pain but was not treated until he began to bleed, according to his lawyers and legal documents. He underwent emergency surgery for hemorrhoids, only to have to be hospitalized again when he was not given antibiotics and his wounds became infected. Some prisoners, such as Marcos Puig, 31, have rebelled. Before a visit from officials, guards isolated him to prevent him from protesting, he said by phone from another Florida facility where he is now being held. Outraged, he broke a toilet in his new cell, prompting a dozen guards to enter, handcuff him, and punch and kick him all over his body. Afterward, he says, they left him kneeling for about 12 hours in a space without cameras or air conditioning before transferring him to another detention facility. 'I arrived here broken. I was covered in bruises,' he said. Another inmate, Gonzalo Almanza Valdes, reported seeing guards 'beat up' detainees, according to a recorded phone call with his wife. Desperation has pushed some to the limit. On Sunday, Sonia Bichara called her partner, detainee Rafael Collado. Through the speakerphone, the 63-year-old man said: 'I have tried to kill myself twice, I have cut my veins.' When contacted by AFP, Florida authorities denied allegations of abuse. 'Completely illegal' Activists and lawyers are demanding the closure of the facilities, which are facing two lawsuits. The first alleges that migrants' right to due process is not being respected. 'There are people who have been there since they arrived and have still not seen a judge. And that cannot be, it is completely illegal,' said Magdalena Cuprys, Gonzalez's lawyer. She said detainees were unable to request bail or a case review because the courts that should be hearing the cases are not doing so, claiming they have no jurisdiction over the state-operated center. The second lawsuit alleges that the facility threatens the Everglades ecosystem. Last week, a federal judge ordered a 14-day suspension of all new construction at the center while she reviews the case.
Arab News
2 days ago
- Arab News
US report says India acts minimally, Pakistan rarely acts against rights abuses
WASHINGTON: The US government noted abuses in India and Pakistan in a shortened human rights report released on Tuesday that said India 'took minimal credible steps' to combat the abuses while Pakistan 'rarely took credible steps.' The Trump administration scaled back the annual US government report on human rights worldwide, dramatically softening criticism of some allies and countries that have been President Donald Trump's partners. The State Department human rights documentation for India and Pakistan was also much shorter and scaled back this year. India has been an important US partner in recent years in Washington's effort to counter China's rise, although relations have been tense over Trump's imposition of a 50 percent tariff on goods from India. Pakistan is a non-NATO US ally. About India, the report said: 'The government took minimal credible steps or action to identify and punish officials who committed human rights abuses.' On Pakistan, it added: 'The government rarely took credible steps to identify and punish officials who committed human rights abuses.' Indian and Pakistani embassies in Washington had no immediate comment on the report released on Tuesday, which documented instances in 2024. Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch fault Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government for its treatment of minorities. They point to rising hate speeches, a religion-based citizenship law the UN calls 'fundamentally discriminatory,' anti-conversion legislation that challenges freedom of belief, the 2019 removal of Muslim-majority Kashmir's special status, and the demolition of properties owned by Muslims. Modi denies discrimination and says his policies, such as food subsidy programs and electrification drives, benefit everyone. In Pakistan, Amnesty International says government authorities fail to protect minorities, including Christians, and use 'excessive and unnecessary force' against civil society voices and protesters. In particular, rights groups, the UN, and Western governments raised concerns over the 2024 Pakistani elections. A UN working group said last year that former Prime Minister Imran Khan's detention violated international law. Khan remains in jail. Islamabad says its elections were fair and dismisses allegations of rigging and foul play. Washington and New Delhi have not reached a trade deal, while the United States has reached an agreement in recent weeks with Pakistan. Trump angered India by taking credit for an India-Pakistan ceasefire in May after hostilities between the neighbors following an April attack in India-administered Kashmir. India says New Delhi and Islamabad should resolve their ties directly without outside involvement.
Al Arabiya
2 days ago
- Al Arabiya
South Africa denounces ‘deeply flawed' US human rights report
South Africa has condemned what it called a 'deeply flawed' US report on its human rights record, issued just days after the Trump administration imposed 30 percent tariffs on many of the country's exports. In its annual human rights report released Tuesday, the US State Department accused South Africa of taking 'a substantially worrying step toward land expropriation of Afrikaners and further abuses against racial minorities.' Pretoria's foreign ministry expressed 'profound disappointment' over the findings, saying the report was 'an inaccurate and deeply flawed account' that failed to reflect the reality of its constitutional democracy. A law signed this year by President Cyril Ramaphosa — and criticized by Trump — allows land expropriation without compensation in rare cases. Land ownership remains a contentious issue, with most farmland still owned by white South Africans three decades after the end of apartheid. South Africa, Washington's third-largest trading partner in sub-Saharan Africa, is seeking a deal to preserve tens of thousands of jobs in its agricultural, automotive, and textile sectors that depend heavily on the US market.
