I tested ChatGPT-4o vs Claude 4 Sonnet vs with 7 prompts — the results were surprising
To find out, I gave both models the same set of 7 prompts; covering everything from storytelling and productivity to emotional support and critical thinking.
The goal: to see which chatbot delivers the most useful, human-like and creative responses depending on the task. Choosing the right AI often comes down to how you use it, which is why this kind of test really matters.
Here's how Claude and ChatGPT performed side by side, and where each one shines.
Prompt: "I'm overwhelmed by work and personal tasks. Create a 3-day productivity plan that balances work, rest and small wins. Include AI tools I can use to stay on track."
ChatGPT-4o was concise with a visually engaging format that offered optional tasks and emotional check-ins (e.g., journaling). It focused on quick wins and low-pressure creativity to manage workloads. However, it lacked Claude's explicit emphasis on rest and energy management, and its AI tool suggestions were less systematically organized.Claude 4 Sonnet offered a clear plan, including time-blocked framework with features such as energy management, small wins and recovery that explicitly prioritize balance.
Winner: Claude wins for better addressing the root causes of getting overwhelmed by combining strategic structure, intentional recovery and AI-driven efficiency. It's ideal for users needing a clear roadmap to rebuild control while safeguarding well-being.
Prompt: "Write the opening paragraph of a sci-fi novel set in a future where memories are traded like currency. Keep it gripping and emotional."ChatGPT-4o leveraged first-person immediacy with a strong hook. However, it prioritized plot setup over emotional depth and the story lacks the heart-wrenching specificity of Claude's familial loss.
Claude 4 Sonnet zeroed in on a universally resonant loss. This specific, intimate memory evokes visceral empathy, anchoring the sci-fi concept in raw human emotion.Winner: Claude wins for balancing sci-fi concepts with emotional stakes, making the reader feel the horror of memory commodification. Its vivid imagery and tragic focus on parental love elevate it beyond ChatGPT's solid but less nuanced approach.
Prompt: "I have 3 apples, 2 bananas and a mango. If each fruit takes 5 minutes to cut and I can cut 2 fruits at once, how long will it take me to cut everything? Explain your reasoning."
ChatGPT-4o used concise bullet points and emphasized efficiency: "each session takes 5 minutes... adds up to 15 minutes."
Claude 4 Sonnet structured the answer with labeled steps (Reasoning, Calculation) and explicitly described the batches: "two fruits in the first session... final two in the third."Winner: tie. Both answers are mathematically sound and logically explained. Claude's response is slightly more detailed, while ChatGPT's is more streamlined. Neither is superior; they achieve the same result with equally valid reasoning.
Prompt: Rewrite this sentence in the tone of a Gen Z TikToker: 'I didn't like the movie, but the soundtrack was amazing.'
ChatGPT-4o used concise, widely recognized Gen Z terms, which are instantly relatable. The rhetorical question structure mirrors TikTok's punchy, attention-grabbing style.
Claude 4 Sonnet used a term that feels slightly off-tone for praising a soundtrack, and the longer sentence structure feels less native to TikTok captions.
Winner: ChatGPT wins for nailing Gen Z's casual, hyperbolic style while staying concise and platform appropriate. Claude's attempt is creative but less precise in slang usage and flow.
Prompt: "Give me 5 clever ideas for a blog post series about using AI tools to become a better parent."
ChatGPT-4o responded with viral, snackable content ideas that lack depth and risk feeling gimmicky over time.Claude 4 Sonnet prioritized meaningful AI integration into parenting, addressing both daily logistics and long-term skills.Winner: Claude wins for blog series ideas with a better balance of creativity, practicality and thoughtful AI integration for modern parenting.
Prompt: Pretend you're a friend comforting me. I just got rejected from a job I really wanted. What would you say to make me feel better?
ChatGPT-4o responds in an uplifting and concise way but lacks the nuanced and effectiveness for comfort in the scenario.Claude 4 Sonnet directly combated common post-rejection anxieties and the explicit permission to 'be disappointed' without rushing to fix things, which shows deep emotional intelligence.Winner: Claude wins for better mirroring how a close, thoughtful friend would console someone in this situation.
Prompt: "Explain the pros and cons of universal basic income in less than 150 words. Keep it balanced and easy to understand."
ChatGPT-4o delivered a clear response but it over-simplified the debate using slightly casual language that leans more persuasive than analytical.
Claude 4 Sonnet prioritized clarity and depth, making it more useful for someone seeking a quick, factual overview.
Winner: Claude wins a response that better fulfills the prompt's request for a structured, comprehensive breakdown while staying objective. ChatGPT's answer, while clear, simplifies the debate and uses slightly casual language that leans more persuasive than analytical.
After putting Claude 4 Sonnet and ChatGPT-4o through a diverse set of prompts, Claude stands out as the winner. Yet, one thing remains clear: both are incredibly capable and excel in different ways.
Claude 4 Sonnet consistently delivered deeper emotional intelligence, stronger long-form reasoning and more thoughtful integration of ideas, making it the better choice for users looking for nuance, structure and empathy. Whether it offered comfort after rejection or crafting a sci-fi hook with emotional weight, Claude stood out for feeling more human.
Meanwhile, ChatGPT-4o shines in fast, punchy tasks that require tone-matching, formatting or surface-level creativity. It's snappy, accessible and excellent for casual use or social media-savvy content.
If you're looking for depth and balance, Claude is your go-to.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
32 minutes ago
- Yahoo
US tech stocks lose $1 trillion on AI bubble fears
The US stock market has seen $1 trillion wiped off in four days as a sell-off in tech companies deepened on Wednesday. The S&P 500 fell for the fourth consecutive day on Wednesday amid fears that an AI-powered stock market rally could be about to collapse. The tech-heavy Nasdaq fell by as much as 1.8pc in early trading on Wednesday, bringing the index down by as much 7pc so far this week in its worst sell-off since April. The Nasdaq has since pared back some of its losses but was still down by nearly 1pc by Wednesday afternoon. The drop-off has been fuelled by concerns that AI companies are overvalued, with some claiming they have little to show for the billions of pounds of investment that have been ploughed into companies such as OpenAI. Shares in Nvidia, the world's largest company with a $4 trillion valuation, fell by 3.3pc in early trading on Wednesday, before recovering slightly. The technology giant, which makes the chips that power vast AI data centres, was down 4.9pc since Monday. Shares in Palantir, the US data business and defence contractor, also sank by as much as 6pc on Wednesday before partially recovering. The value of its stock has tumbled by a fifth in six days. Shares in American chipmaker Intel plunged by more than 7pc while UK chipmaker Arm's share price was down by 3.6pc on Wednesday. It comes after a report from researchers at MIT suggested that 95pc of corporate AI projects are so far generating 'zero return' for businesses. Danni Hewson, head of financial analysis at AJ Bell, said: 'The MIT report into the AI boom has soured sentiment.' OpenAI chief executive Sam Altman also made public remarks last week that some investors had become 'overexcited' about AI. However, analysts cautioned against racing to sell tech stocks. Ulrike Hoffmann-Burchardi, Chief Investment Officer Americas at UBS, said in a client note: 'While some near-term tech volatility is not surprising given the run-up in valuations, we advise investors against becoming overly defensive for several reasons.' Tech earnings growth has been strong and companies are becoming better at monetising AI adoption, Ms Hoffmann-Burchardi said 09:16 PM BST Signing off... That's all from us on the blog today. You can follow all the latest business and economics news here. 09:15 PM BST Markets wrap US stocks fell on Wednesday, though by the end of the day the drops were not nearly as stark as during early trading. The S&P 500 closed down 0.26pc, at 6,394.97 while the Nasdaq Composite fell by 0.68pc to 21,170.19. Tech stocks Palantir, Nvidia and Intel fell by 1.1pc, 0.14pc and 8.86pc respectively. 07:46 PM BST Fears over government intervention US tech investors are also worried about Trump administration interference in the private sector. US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said on Tuesday that he is looking at taking a stake in chip firms including Intel in exchange for grants to spur factory building in the US. Intel's share price plunged by 8.86pc on Wednesday. Reuters also reported on Tuesday that Mr Lutnick is planning to expand this plan to other companies. 07:38 PM BST Global tech stock falls Shares in non-US technology companies have also slumped. The value of stocks in Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company (TSMC) fell by 4.2pc on Wednesday. German semiconductor manufacturer Infineon fell by 1.6pc while software company SAP dropped by 1.3pc. ASML, the Dutch multinational that makes the machines needed to make chips, also dipped by 0.64pc, while European chip design company STMicroelectronics was down by 0.85pc. 06:25 PM BST All eyes on the Fed Tech investors are watching closely for signals of a Federal Reserve interest rate cut. Phil Blancato, chief executive officer of Ladenburg Thalmann Asset Management, told Reuters: 'It's much more about profit-taking and temporary rebalance here. 'If you get a Federal Reserve cut or a mention of it on Friday, this will reverse pretty quickly, but this is a lot to do with names pushed up to really lofty levels.' Fed Chair Jay Powell will deliver a key speech at the Jackson Hole symposium on Friday, which will be closely watched for clues on the likelihood of a rate cut at the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC)'s next decision in September. 06:18 PM BST Summer trading quirks August is typically a more volatile month for stock markets. Investors and traders often go on holiday before the end of the summer, meaning it is a time when there are often much lower trading volumes. August has historically been one of the worst-performing months for the S&P 500 06:06 PM BST 'We've been trimming our tech holdings' Firms are reducing their tech investments. Nancy Tengler, chief executive and chief investment officer of Laffer Tengler Investments told Bloomberg: 'We've been trimming our tech holdings some; we've trimmed Microsoft, Oracle, Broadcom, Nvidia, and have added to housing names in the past few months. 05:39 PM BST Small recovery There are signs the tech sell-off has begun to ease, with the Nasdaq Composite's drop easing from 1.8pc to 1pc by Wednesday lunchtime in the US. However, the tech-heavy index had still dropped by 2.2pc since the end of the day on Monday. Palantir's share price similarly erased some of its early losses on Wednesday but was still down by nearly 3pc. 05:32 PM BST Warning signs the bubble will burst The tech sell-off began on Tuesday after a report from Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) researchers warned that the vast majority of AI investments were yielding 'zero return' for businesses. 'Despite $30-40bn (£22-30bn) in enterprise investment into Gen[erative]AI, this report uncovers a surprising result in that 95pc of organisations are getting zero return,' MIT academics wrote. MIT's findings threaten to be the pin that pops the tech stock market bubble, which has added trillions of dollars to the value of US stocks. Since the launch of ChatGPT in 2022, Silicon Valley has been evangelical that AI chatbots will transform the economy. Executives have spent billions on tools for their staff as a result and predicted massive cost-savings. But the promised AI revolution has stalled, MIT's report suggested. After surveying 150 business leaders and 350 employees, MIT found that 'just 5pc of integrated AI pilots are extracting millions in value, while the vast majority remain stuck with no measurable P&L [profit and loss] impact'. Click here to continue reading... 05:22 PM BST US stocks 'in the early days' for a bubble American stocks are 'in the early days' for a bubble, according to the co-founder of Oaktree Capital Management. Howard Marks, who is co-chairman of the distressed debt investment manager, told Bloomberg: 'I'm certainly not ringing the alarm bells. The point is that things are expensive.' Mr Marks said that some tech stocks are 'quite highly valued' relative to history. He added: 'People get of the habit of thinking about market corrections … a reversion to the mean is very likely.' 04:57 PM BST Japanese stocks drop on AI sell-off Shares on Tokyo's Nikkei index fell by 1.5pc today after a major sell-off at a Japanese technology giant that has invested billions in AI technology. SoftBank, the Japanese investor that has backed businesses including OpenAI, fell by 7pc on reports that it intended to invest billions of dollars in US chip giant Intel. The Japanese business is also one of the biggest investors in OpenAI, having pledged to inject tens of billions of dollars into the Silicon Valley business. The latest investment is expected to value OpenAI at as much as $500bn, despite Sam Altman, its chief executive, warning over the weekend that investors stood to lose a 'phenomenal' amount of money from bad bets on the AI boom. 04:48 PM BST US tech stocks plunge on bubble worries Shares in some of the world's biggest technology companies plunged on Wednesday as market jitters about over-stretched technology stocks gathered pace. Nvidia, the US chip giant that supplies AI data centres, dropped by 1.6pc in early trading. The $4 trillion technology giant is down more than 4pc since Monday. Elsewhere, shares in Palantir were down as much as 6pc in earler trading on Wednesday. Shares in Arm, the UK chip designer, were down more than 4pc. Among the so-called 'Magnificent Seven' tech stocks, Meta had fallen by 1.4pc on reports it was again rejigging its AI Superintelligence team. Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
32 minutes ago
- Yahoo
AI and tech stocks slide as summer rally peters out
Tech stocks were under pressure this week as Wall Street's AI enthusiasm slowed and investors adjusted portfolios after a strong summer rally. The Nasdaq Composite fell 0.67% on Wednesday after sliding 1.46% on Tuesday. The tech-heavy index was on track to snap back-to-back weeks of gains. Meanwhile, the broader S&P 500 fell 0.24% and posted its fourth day of losses in a row. The Dow hovered around the flatline. Tech stocks had steadily rallied in recent months, lifting the S&P 500 and Nasdaq to a streak of record highs. Now Wall Street is taking a breather while optimism about the AI boom is facing some friction. Palantir (PLTR), a star of the AI trade, fell 1.1% on Wednesday after falling 9.35% on Tuesday. Meanwhile, Nvidia (NVDA) edged lower by 0.14% on Wednesday after sliding 3.5% on Tuesday. 'Investors rotated out of high-momentum tech stocks, reflecting renewed jitters over the sustainability of the AI trade,' Ulrike Hoffmann-Buchardi, head of global equities at UBS, said in a note. Investors are also in wait-and-see mode ahead of a critical day for markets on Friday when Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell is set to deliver remarks at the Jackson Hole Economic Symposium. 'It's just a pause that may refresh as investors retrench and rethink how they want to position their tech dollars,' Rob Haworth, senior investment strategy director at US Bank Asset Management Group, told CNN. Powell's closely watched speech on Friday could provide signals about the Fed's potential rate-cutting path and comes at a key inflection points for markets after past months' ascent to record highs. AI jitters test Wall Street Excitement about AI propelled markets higher in recent months, boosted by robust corporate earnings and enormous spending by companies like Meta and Microsoft. But Wall Street's eagerness was tested this week after Sam Altman, chief executive at OpenAI, said he thinks the market might be in a bubble. 'Are we in a phase where investors as a whole are overexcited about AI? My opinion is yes,' Altman told reporters last week, according to The Verge. The OpenAI chief also said he thinks AI will provide value for the economy. 'Is AI the most important thing to happen in a very long time? My opinion is also yes,' he said. Also, researchers at MIT on Monday published a report detailing how the majority of companies testing new generative AI tools are seeing zero returns. While there was not an explicit catalyst for the decline of tech and AI stocks decline this week, investors said Altman's comments and the MIT report could be contributing to negative momentum. AI chip and semiconductor companies Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) and Marvell Technology (MRVL) were each down almost 7% this week. 'Altman's comments spooked some people when he talked about the AI bubble,' Dan Ives, head of global technology research at Wedbush Securities, told CNN. 'Tech stocks have had a massive run, so I think it's just typical that investors are starting to take some chips off the table going into Labor Day,' Ives said. 'But I believe it's going to be short lived.' Big Tech takes a breather Each of the Magnificent Seven tech stocks — Apple (AAPL), Alphabet (GOOGL), Amazon (AMZN), Meta (META), Microsoft (MSFT), Nvidia (NVDA) and Tesla (TSLA) — fell on both Tuesday and Wednesday, dragging down the broader market. As of Tuesday, they made up 33.5% of the S&P 500's total market value, according to S&P Dow Jones Indices, reflecting their outsized influence on the index's performance. 'Stocks have been on an absolute tear. Valuations have sprinted up,' said Ross Mayfield, an investment strategist at Baird. 'The fundamentals are good but not keeping pace with the price action.' 'I think along the way we'll see pockets of profit taking, even if it doesn't mark the end of the bull market in general,' Mayfield said. While tech dragged on the market, about 70% of stocks in the S&P 500 had closed higher on Tuesday, UBS' Hoffmann-Buchardi said. Sectors that outperformed included consumer staples, utilities and real estate. It's a sign that investors are shifting out of Big Tech and AI-related trades and toward more defensive stocks as they reassess the markets. Nvidia as of Monday had surged 93% since a low point in early April. 'We've been expecting this type of a pullback,' said Jay Hatfield, chief executive at Infrastructure Capital Advisors, who said he has taken down his exposure to tech in recent months. It's also the start of a historically weak season for stocks, Hatfield said. 'We're neutral on the market right now, but still really bullish for year end.' Palantir is still up 106% this year. But shares in Palantir are down six days in a row and had dropped as much as 9.8% on Wednesday before paring losses, reflecting the volatility in AI stocks. 'Now we're getting the downward momentum,' Hatfield said. 'Palantir is like the poster child for excessive valuation, and those investors are learning that the momentum works in both directions.' Sign in to access your portfolio
Yahoo
32 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Meta wants to speed its race to ‘superintelligence'—but investors will still want their billions in ad revenue
Meta is doubling down on its so-called race to 'superintelligence,' reshuffling its AI organization once more as its new Meta Superintelligence Labs (MSL) group takes shape. But analysts say investors are keeping their eye on the prize Meta has always promised: improved products that increase engagement and, in turn, sell more ads. Superintelligent AI models, if they arrive, are just a means to that end. This time it's former Scale AI CEO Alexandr Wang—brought on by Mark Zuckerberg in June as chief AI officer—leading the reorganization. Wang, who now oversees a sprawling operation of thousands of engineers, scientists, and product managers, is looking to rein it in, reportedly resulting in some expected executive departures and at least one team shutdown. Wang was hired to help recruit a small, high-priced cadre of researchers—some reportedly offered compensation packages exceeding $100 million, typically spread out over several years—now perched at the pinnacle of Meta's AI effort. But that group is only the tip of the spear: The new restructuring folds the entire AI organization into MSL, with four new groups focused on research, training, products, and infrastructure, all part of a bid for speed. The quartet of group leaders will all report to Wang, including well-known investor and former GitHub CEO Nat Friedman, who will lead product and applied research, and former OpenAI researcher Shengjia Zhao, who will lead the research team as chief scientist. In a recent email to employees, which detailed the restructuring, Wang acknowledged that reorganizations can be disruptive but insisted the new structure would 'allow us to reach superintelligence with more velocity over the long term.' (Meta did not respond to Fortune's request to confirm the contents of the email, which were published by Business Insider.) Investors, meanwhile, seem to have mixed feelings: Meta's stock slid more than 2% on the news today, but climbed most of the way back by market close. The share-price slide also reflects broader market jitters, as overheated AI and Big Tech names come off recent highs, said Daniel Newman, CEO of research firm the Futurum Group. He said he expects a 'modest correction' but noted that Meta has 'had an incredible run' and recently 'delivered a great quarter once again.' Still, analysts are eyeing Zuckerberg's nine-figure paydays for top AI researchers and his repeated reorganizing, and watching for signs that Meta will close the gap in the AI race. 'Of course there is some concern,' Newman said, pointing out that numerous frontier models from OpenAI, xAI, and Google continue to improve, while Meta's open-source Llama models have 'seemingly stalled.' 'We think the team at Meta, after Zuckerberg's hiring spree, will need a period of acclimation before it finds the velocity to develop more competitive solutions,' he said. Feeding Meta's product machine That need for speed, however, is best understood as an extension of Meta's product machine rather than a bid to solve humanity's greatest challenges. While Meta has dabbled in moonshot AI through its FAIR research lab (cofounded by chief scientist Yann LeCun), rivals like OpenAI and Anthropic and spinoffs such as Thinking Machines Lab and Safe Superintelligence have made the pursuit of artificial general intelligence (AI generally defined to be as smart as humans) and superintelligence (AI far smarter than humans) their central mission, by contrast, has remained the same as it was before 'superintelligence' became a buzzword: improving the products that power engagement on its massively profitable social-media platforms, including Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp. The advertising on those platforms is the source of nearly all of Meta's revenue, which reached $46.6 billion in the most recent quarter. Zuckerberg underscored this focus last month with an Instagram Reel and blog post in which he said AI is rapidly advancing and that we're beginning to see 'glimpses of AI systems improving themselves.' Superintelligence is now 'in sight,' he added—but while rival AI companies talk about scientific or economic breakthroughs, his vision is aimed squarely at the individual: a personalized AI that helps you 'achieve your goals, create what you want to see in the world, be a better friend, and grow to become the person that you aspire to be.' That framing neatly aligns with what Meta has always built—consumer-facing experiences designed to keep people engaged (and sell more ads). To Zuckerberg, superintelligence also means powering the future of AI-infused personal devices, specifically augmented-reality glasses that can 'see what we see, hear what we hear, and interact with us throughout the day.' Newman said he continues to like Meta's prospects because the company 'isn't as dependent on the research end of its business, as it is using AI to continue to create higher daily active user numbers—and of course, the coinciding revenue continues to rise as well.' But Forrester's Mike Proulx countered that there is no doubt Meta is laser-focused on building 'the best and most powerful AI models, period,' he told Fortune. 'The race is on, and Meta is lagging against competitors. A concerted focus on superintelligence gives Meta a North Star to rally around both strategically and operationally.' Zuckerberg echoed that sentiment on Meta's most recent earnings call, stressing that AI is at the center of each of Meta's five focus areas. But Proulx pointed out that it was AI glasses—not the company's family of apps—that Zuckerberg highlighted on that call as 'the main way' superintelligence will enter people's daily lives. Overall, Proulx said he is not concerned with the seemingly constant upheaval in Meta's AI organization. 'This space is moving at breakneck speed. As with any emerging tech race, there's inevitably going to be a lot of pivoting. It comes with the territory,' he said. For all the lofty talk of superintelligence, however, Meta's AI reshuffling shows its bets are mostly still the same: personalized products that keep billions scrolling, ads flowing—and soon, AI-powered glasses perched on every face. How the company fares will be closely watched: 'The question now is whether the team is effectively enabled to deliver, or not,' said Proulx. This story was originally featured on 擷取數據時發生錯誤 登入存取你的投資組合 擷取數據時發生錯誤 擷取數據時發生錯誤 擷取數據時發生錯誤 擷取數據時發生錯誤
