Mother 'murdered her two young children then went to group therapy and JOKED about it'
Catherine Hoggle was arrested and charged on Friday with the 2014 murders of three-year-old Sarah and two-year-old Jacob.
Three years prior, a judge had dismissed an earlier indictment charging her with the same crimes, deeming her unfit to stand trial due to her mental health.
On Tuesday, the court heard prosecutors reveal they have new evidence implying she confessed to the murders.
Montgomery County State Attorney John McCarthy told the court she attended a group-therapy session with the father of the children, Troy Turney, hours after their deaths.
'At that point in time, she made a comment to a woman that was in those therapy sessions with her that she had strangled her children,' McCarthy said.
He alleged Hoggle made a 'strangling' motion with her hands before ultimately insisting she was joking.
He argued against her request to be released on bond, noting there was a third, surviving child she could attempt to harm if freed.
Police allege Hoggle was last seen with little Jacob on September 7, 2014, after driving off with him.
She returned home and allegedly told family members she had dropped him to a friend's house for a sleepover.
That night, police allege Hoggle secretly took Sarah from the home. Neither Sarah or Jacob have ever been seen again.
The new warrant states investigators met with a criminal profiler with the FBI who noted: 'It was their belief that the children were murdered, likely by strangulation and their bodies were disposed of via an outside trash container.'
Hoggle had allegedly intended to abduct the children's older brother, then five, from his school bus stop but the plan was foiled by the boy's father.
She was initially arrested and charged with neglect and abduction, both misdemeanors. She was sent to the state-run psychiatric hospital for treatment.
Then in 2017, she was indicted on murder charges. A judge ruled she was incompetent to stand trial and imposed continuing court-ordered treatment.
Under state law, authorities had five years to declare her competent to stand trial; otherwise, criminal charges would be dismissed.
Hoggle has long suffered from severe mental illness. She has a history of schizophrenia and was treated with antipsychotic medications after her arrest.
In 2022, a Montgomery County judge dropped the charges against her, citing the five-year time limit.
Hoggle was ordered to remain involuntarily committed for psychiatric treatment because she was still considered a danger to herself or others.
McCarthy vowed then that if she were ever deemed no longer a threat and released, he would charge her again with murder.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
13 minutes ago
- The Independent
‘Fixated' man who stalked Anna Friel for three years bailed ahead of sentencing
A man who was 'fixated' with actress Anna Friel and stalked her for nearly three years has been ordered by a judge not to contact her ahead of his sentencing next month. Phil Appleton, 71, sent numerous messages, visited the actress's home address on several occasions and left 'unwanted' gifts between January 1 2022 and December 11 2024, Reading Crown Court previously heard. Appleton, of Windsor in Berkshire, pleaded guilty to a stalking offence under Section 2A of the Protection from Harassment Act 1997 earlier this week. He was due to be sentenced on Thursday but judge Alan Blake adjourned the hearing until September 18 for a pre-sentence report to be carried out. The court heard that a psychiatrist had diagnosed Appleton with bipolar disorder and erotomania, where a person believes that someone else is in love with them. The psychiatrist said that Appleton had a 'fixation' with Friel and was trying to determine whether this was still the case, the court heard. The defendant, who the court heard has been in custody for six months and has spent time in a mental health facility, was granted conditional bail. Appleton must not contact Friel or enter the Royal Borough of Windsor and Maidenhead, and is to co-operate with those conducting the pre-sentence report. A website under his name appears to suggest that he is an actor and retired pilot. Friel, 49, rose to fame with her role as Beth Jordache in Channel 4 soap opera Brookside. She achieved international renown in 2007 starring as Charlotte 'Chuck' Charles in ABC comedy series Pushing Daisies. In 2017, she won the International Emmy for Best Actress for her role as the title character in the ITV and Netflix mystery drama series Marcella.
The Independent
13 minutes ago
- The Independent
Alligator Alcatraz is nothing more than ‘an oversized kennel' for migrants, ex-prison guard says
A former corrections officer who worked at the already-notorious 'Alligator Alcatraz' migrant detention center in Florida has come forward to warn about the 'inhumane' conditions in which detainees are being held at the facility. Identified only as Lindsey to protect herself and her family from harassment, NBC's Miami affiliate interviewed the officer and compared conditions at the camp to 'an oversized kennel,' describing its poor facilities and inmates, many of whom are not criminals, living in fear. She said that she had been hired by the security company GardaWorld Federal Services and agreed to be paid $26 an hour on a five days on, two days off basis, which required her to live in a shared trailer on site with other staff. Lindsey said she began working at the camp on July 6. Still, her employment lasted only a week because she contracted Covid-19, had to self-isolate, and was then fired after being accused of 'altering medical paperwork submitted to the company,' an allegation she denied. 'It's inhumane the way that they're keeping their residents,' she told NBC6 of her experiences. 'When I got there, it was overwhelming. I thought it would get better. But it just never did.' She said that each tent at the facility contained eight large cages, holding 35 to 38 inmates, meaning that each tent housed close to 300 people. Discussing the conditions in which the detainees were being held, she said: 'They have no sunlight. There's no clock in there. They don't even know what time of the day it is. 'They have no access to showers. They shower every other day or every four days. The bathrooms are backed up because you [have] got so many people using them.' Lindsey added that rainwater poured into the tents on stormy days and that everyone present found themselves in a 'constant battle' with mosquitoes due to the Everglades' close and humid climate. 'Not everybody there is a criminal,' she said. 'These people are still human. They pulled them from their livelihood. They're scared. They don't speak our language.' Lindsey said the harsh conditions were also rough on staff: 'We had to use the porta-johns. We didn't have hot water half the time. Our bathrooms were backed up.' Asked about her motivations for coming forward, she said: 'I was fired. And yeah, I'm p****d off. But more so than ever, like, they're doing wrong.' Responding to Lindsey's accusations, Assistant Homeland Security Secretary Tricia McLaughlin told The Independent: 'Any allegations of 'highly inhumane conditions' at Alligator Alcatraz are FALSE. This is yet another attempt to smear ICE law enforcement who is already facing an 830 percent increase in assaults against them. 'Additionally, the facility is managed by the State of Florida through the Division of Emergency Management. Under President Trump's leadership, we are working at turbo speed on cost-effective and innovative ways to deliver on the American people's mandate for mass deportations of criminal illegal aliens.' The Independent also contacted GardaWorld and the Florida Division of Emergency Management for comment. Supporters of President Donald Trump warmly greeted the Alligator Alcatraz project when it was announced in June, cheerily buying up merchandise and delighting at the idea that would-be escapees would not be able to get far due to the perilous swampland surrounding the disused airfield on which it was built. Many detainees at the site have previously complained about the dire conditions, decrying the scarcity of food, lack of water for washing, and constant bright light depriving them of sleep.
Times
14 minutes ago
- Times
Son of Briton arrested over ‘drowning' hit him with a car two years ago
The husband of a woman whose father-in-law allegedly tried to drown her was jailed for harassing her and hitting his father with a car, The Times can reveal. Alex Gibbon, 34, pleaded guilty last year to assaulting his father, Mark, and harassing the mother of his two children, Jasmine Wyld, 33. The Times understands he hit Mark while driving an £80,000 Porsche Cayenne in Beaconsfield, Buckinghamshire, in May 2023. Mark, 62, was arrested on suspicion of attempted murder on Sunday after he allegedly tried to drown his daughter-in-law, Wyld, in a row over his will. Wyld, a hairdresser, was left with a scratch on her chest and fearing for her life after the alleged attack in a swimming pool at a luxury resort near Walt Disney World, Florida. Mark, a lighting technician who has worked on music videos for musicians including Ed Sheeran, alleged that he and Wyld had been drinking when the row occurred. He has been charged with attempted second-degree murder and battery and will appear in court next month. Mark was staying with his family at the luxury Solterra Resort in Davenport, near Walt Disney World, when he got into an argument over the 'stipulations of his will'. Alex Gibbon and Jasmine Wyld It is claimed that during the disagreement, Mark repeatedly tried to push Wyld under the water. This allegedly prompted his nine-year-old granddaughter to jump into the pool and try to save her mother. Police officers at Polk county sheriff's office said Mark pushed her away. The police said: 'She [Wyld] advised that she could not breathe and believed that she was going to drown. [She] advised that she had to fight Mark in order to get away from him and from under the water but he kept pushing her back under.' Mark, from Beaconsfield, allegedly only stopped when two onlookers told him they had called the sheriff's office. He was taken into custody at about 5.20pm last Sunday. It is said that he admitted pushing his daughter-in-law under the water but denied trying to drown her. He is said to have claimed they were drinking when they got into a row. His son had previously worked with him at his film and television lighting firm Ultralight but resigned as director in April 2023. Mark has since renamed the company as MRG Lighting and he is listed as the sole director. Mark Gibbon's home in Beaconsfield, Bukinghamshire TOBY SHEPHEARD FOR THE TIMES Alex pleaded guilty in February last year to causing serious injury by dangerous driving and harassment without violence. He was sentenced at Aylesbury crown court to a total of 25 months' imprisonment, 36 months' disqualification from driving a five-year restraining order, and surcharge. The court was told that he had been subject to a community order at the time of the offences. Mark has worked on television and film sets as well as on music videos for performers such as Sam Smith and Paloma Faith. Grady Judd, the Polk county sheriff, said: 'It's great that Polk county draws visitors from all across the world but we expect vacationers to behave while they visit with us, just as we expect our lifelong residents to do the same. Because Mr Gibbon couldn't control his anger, he may find himself spending a lot more time in Florida than he had anticipated.'
