Tax-to-GDP ratio declines in FY2024–25, says think tank
ISLAMABAD: An economic thinktank has claimed that the tax-to-gross domestic product (GDP) ratio of the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has declined from 11.6 percent in 2019–20 to 10.4 percent in 2024–25.
According to a report - Decoding Pakistan's Budget Dynamics - issued by Economic Policy and Business Development on Monday, the 15–year period shows a significant increase in nominal GDP, with the most dramatic acceleration occurring in the 2019-20 to 2024–25 period.
The tax-to-GDP ratio shows a modest improvement through 2019–20 but declined by 2020–25, highlighting persistent challenges in revenue mobilisation despite repeated reform efforts.
In 2019–20, the tax-to-GDP ratio remained 13.2 percent, the report said.
The revenue composition shows differential growth rates across the 15-year period. Tax revenues grew steadily through fiscal year 2009–10 to 2019–20 and accelerated in the 2019–20 to 2024–25 period.
Direct taxes grew faster than indirect taxes over the full period, indicating a gradual shift toward income–based taxation. Non-tax revenue grew modestly from 2019–20 to 2024–25 but surged dramatically in the following five years, growing at an implied annual rate of over 40 per cent between2019–20 to 2024–25 period.
Tax component analysis revealed that all major tax heads grew significantly over the 15-year period. Customs duties saw particularly rapid growth from 2014–15 to 2019–20, growing from Rs281 billion to Rs1,000 billion.
The petroleum levy, while growing modestly in the earlier periods, accelerated extraordinarily in the 2019–20 to 2024–25 period, becoming a major revenue source by 2024–25. Income tax is the largest contributor to tax revenues, amounting to Rs5,454 billion in 2024–25.
Provincial share in federal revenues increased substantially over the 15-year period, growing at an average annual rate of 17.7 per cent, exceeding the growth rate of the overall budget.
As a percentage of gross revenue, provincial share increased from 32.6 per cent in 2009–10 to a peak of 48.5 per cent in 2019–20, before moderating to 41.8 per cent by 2024–25. The increase from 2009–10 to 2014–15 reflects the impact of the 7th NFC Award, which raised the provincial share of the divisible pool from 43.75 per cent to 57.5 per cent.
The report concluded that despite tax revenues growing by 768 percent, the tax-to-GDP ratio remained largely stagnant around 10–11 per cent. The increasing reliance on SBP profits (1,567 per cent growth) indicates dangerous dependence on central bank financing rather than sustainable tax measures, it added.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
34 minutes ago
- Business Recorder
Govt increases petrol price by Rs4.8 per litre for next fortnight
The federal government on Sunday increased the price of petrol by Rs4.80 per litre for the next 15 days, raising it to Rs262.59 from Rs254.64 per litre. In a notification, the Finance Division stated that the new prices will take effect from May 16, 2025. Israel's attacks on Iran: Pakistan govt may fall short of Rs1,161bn PL target In the last fortnightly review, the government had increased the petrol price by Rs1.00 per litre to Rs253.63, effective from June 1, 2025. However, the rate for high-speed diesel (HSD) will remain stable at Rs254.64 per litre for the next two weeks.
Express Tribune
15 hours ago
- Express Tribune
CM outlines fiscal, development agenda
Sindh Chief Minister Murad Ali Shah outlined a fiscal and development agenda for the province while highlighting serious financial challenges and federal shortfalls. Addressing a post-budget press conference on Saturday, the CM criticised the federal government for failing to meet its financial commitments, revealing that Sindh was informed just one day before the budget presentation that Rs105 billion in expected funds would be withheld. Sindh has received Rs1,478.5 billion from the divisible pool since last year, but Rs422.3 billion remains outstanding. He expressed hope that the withheld amount would be disbursed by the end of June. Despite being under an IMF programme that demands strict fiscal discipline, the Sindh government will allocate Rs590 billion for development projects this year, with a total budget of Rs3.45 trillion, Rs1 trillion for development and Rs2.15 trillion for current expenditures. Notably, Rs1.1 trillion is earmarked for salaries and pensions, leading to salary increases of 12 per cent for lower-grade employees and 10 per cent for higher grades. Sectoral budget increases include an 18 per cent rise in education funding and an 11 per cent increase in health. Funding for agriculture, irrigation, and local government projects has also seen significant boosts. Furthermore, Rs236 billion has been allocated for infrastructure projects in Karachi, including public-private partnership initiatives. CM Shah highlighted Sindh's social welfare achievements, particularly in housing for flood victims, with 500,000 homes built and another 850,000 under construction, totalling 1.3 million. To enhance rural living standards, the CM announced a Rs600-billion-project for rural water and sanitation, benefiting 4.5 million villagers. Regarding taxation, Murad noted that no new taxes were introduced in the budget, with some taxes eliminated or reduced, including the abolition of the entertainment tax and cuts to restaurant taxes. The stamp duty on third-party vehicle insurance has been reduced to Rs50, with a drop in the insurance tax from 15 per cent to five per cent. To modernise governance, the Sindh government is digitising land records through block chain for easier access. The CM claimed that free laser levellers will be provided to small farmers, with subsidies for larger ones, alongside the implementation of cluster farming technology. The CM said that improvements in education and health include the establishment of 34,000 new caste centres and expanded support for persons with disabilities. Cognitive Remediation The CM outlined the K-4 water project structure, where the federal government is responsible for sourcing water from Keenjhar Lake, while the Sindh government manages distribution and has allocated necessary funds. A total of Rs20 billion is earmarked for the K-4 feeder, alongside plans for a costly five-million-gallon desalination plant. The CM also noted 20,000 to 25,000 job vacancies in grades I to IV, with plans for recruitment via IBA-administered tests for BPS-V to VII and filling higher Grade 16 positions. The CM mentioned Sindh's conditions for supporting the federal budget, emphasising equitable distribution of development schemes and the detrimental cut of university funding from Rs4 billion to Rs2 billion, which has sparked protests. On the critical Sukkur-Hyderabad Motorway, the CM expressed concern over the halving of federal funding from Rs30 billion to Rs15 billion. The CM emphasised that major projects are not included in the Federal Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP) and criticised the 18 per cent tax on solar panels as unjust. He warned that the Pakistan Peoples Party would not support the federal budget if unresolved.
Express Tribune
16 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Lawmakers demand tax relief for masses
On June 10, Finance Minister Miftah Ismail had announced an income tax relief of Rs47 billion for the salaried class. PHOTO: FILE Listen to article Lawmakers in the National Assembly on Saturday delivered a detailed and constructive review of the federal budget for FY2025-26 and called for providing more relief to the common man. While participating in the general discussion on the budget, Defence Minister Khawaja Asif said Pakistan suffered huge losses due to tax evasion, especially in sectors like tobacco, real estate, steel, and tyres. "We lose around Rs300 billion annually in tobacco taxes alone." He acknowledged that the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has made some improvements, but much more needs to be done. "If we can just improve our tax collection by 50%, we wouldn't need foreign loans," he noted. He demanded accountability and urged the finance ministry and the FBR to brief parliament on the large-scale tax evasion and the people behind it. "We need honesty in governance. Only then can we provide real relief to the people," he said. He gave the example of how public shops in Punjab are rented for very low rates, while private shops in the same area earn ten times more. "This has continued for decades without accountability," he pointed out. He called for a national campaign to end corruption, particularly in sectors dominated by a few corrupt families. Asif praised Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb, calling him a professional and experienced person. He credited him for bringing back international trust in Pakistan's economy. He shared encouraging economic data: GDP growth improved from -0.2% to +2.7%, inflation dropped to 4.6%, and the current account posted a $1.2 billion surplus. foreign investment rose by 20%. He admitted that the public may still be feeling economic pressure but said positive changes are happening. "The business community is showing more confidence, and the stock market recently hit a historic 125,000-point high," he said. He criticized those who now attack the government's economic policy but had once urged the IMF not to support Pakistan. "These people tried to sabotage our economy," he said. "Pakistan is not about any one person. It is a mission, a belief, and a shared history," he added. He urged political leaders to rise above personal ambitions and serve the nation with sincerity. PPP senior leader Mirza Ikhtiar Baig emphasised the pivotal role of the industry, agriculture and services sector in driving long-term economic stability. Acknowledging the ongoing economic challenges, he said the government's push toward reforms, though modest GDP growth of 2.6% continues to be overshadowed by inflation, population pressure and mounting national debt. He raised concern over pension reforms, particularly the withdrawal of posthumous benefits for pensioners' children after 10 years, warning this could create financial distress for many families. The lawmaker also cautioned against harsh tax enforcement measures, such as granting arrest powers to income tax officers, which he said could dampen business confidence. However, he welcomed incentives in the construction and property sectors, including the reduction in withholding tax on property transactions from 4% to 2.5%, elimination of federal excise duty on commercial property transfers and reduction of stamp duty in Islamabad from 4% to 1% — measures expected to boost real estate activity. He also supported the increased defense budget, recognizing the valor and international standing of Pakistan's armed forces, particularly in light of recent hostilities. Mirza Ikhtiar praised the record-breaking $38 billion in remittances sent by overseas Pakistanis and called for an export-led growth model, especially through sectors like IT and rice. PTI legislator Asad Qaiser urged the government to revisit its decision to impose new taxes in the erstwhile FATA region, emphasising the area's sacrifices in the war on terror. Qaiser warned that further burdens could hinder socio-economic rehabilitation. He also highlighted issues of power outages and damage to household appliances in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa due to erratic electricity supply, urging greater PSDP allocations for the province. Qaiser raised alarms about the tobacco sector, noting the lack of a fixed minimum support price, which is driving companies out of K-P. He called for urgent government intervention to protect farmers. Senior MQM leader Dr. Farooq Sattar hailed the armed forces for their resilience during recent Pakistan-India tensions, crediting divine help and national unity under Field Marshal General Asim Munir. He appreciated relief measures for salaried classes in the budget but warned that the middle class continues to bear a disproportionate tax burden. Farooq Sattar urged reforms to reduce electricity and gas tariffs and proposed a national economic dialogue to adopt a unified "Charter of Economy." He stressed the importance of taxing agricultural income through provincial consensus under Article 177 to improve Pakistan's fiscal credibility with international lenders. Condemning Israeli aggression, he reaffirmed solidarity with Iran amid recent tensions. PPP stalwart Syed Naveed Qamar took a strategic view, asserting that the federal budget must not be limited to a balance sheet but should reflect a coherent economic vision. He stressed that budgetary allocations must align with policy goals rather than serve as mere political optics. Naveed Qamar criticized the neglect of agriculture, especially in terms of food security and misdirected subsidies that favor foreign producers over domestic farmers. He lamented that serious economic reformers are often sidelined while superficial narratives dominate policymaking. Naveed Qamar criticized Pakistan's reliance on international lenders and the failure to promote domestic exports, particularly in the cotton sector. The fertilizer subsidies and price controls, he argued, have hurt small farmers while benefiting powerful industrial lobbies. Naveed Qamar has called for the adoption of a clear, flexible, and consistent economic policy in anticipation of potential global oil price hikes, warning that the country cannot afford to remain tethered to outdated and reactive financial planning models. He cautioned that international oil price fluctuations pose direct risks to Pakistan's fiscal strategy, inflation targets, and energy affordability. He criticized the government for preparing budgets based on optimistic oil price assumptions without accounting for geopolitical volatility. "In recent years, our budgets were framed based on declining global oil prices. But if the situation in the Middle East worsens and prices suddenly spike, do we have an alternative strategy in place?" he asked, urging the finance ministry to explain whether price increases would be passed on to consumers or absorbed through subsidies. He stressed that such vital economic variables demand transparency and contingency planning. "There must be clarity. If the benchmark price increases by 20%, what is the fallback? Ad hocism will not take us forward." Naveed Qamar underlined the need for economic policies that transcend partisan agendas and prioritize institutional coherence. "We hear at the Prime Minister's level about the need for policy consistency. But if decisions continue to be made in silos, without coordination, instability will persist." He also urged serious consultation among political leadership, bureaucratic institutions, and the business community, warning against policy capture by a select few. "It's unacceptable that one individual travels abroad and makes decisions on the nation's behalf, while key institutions remain unaware. Responsible policymaking requires collective ownership." He criticized the enduring influence of those who, he alleged, negotiated economically detrimental deals in past decades, leading to chronic dependence on external actors. "The same people who committed the country 30 years ago are still writing our policies. If we want sovereignty, we must abandon these recurring policy patterns." He stressed the need for a forward-looking, sovereign, and inclusive economic framework — one that replaces reaction with resilience. "We must move beyond fire-fighting. Only with vision, transparency, and consensus can we break the cycle of economic instability." Taking part in the debate, MNA Zartaj Gul stressed the need for increased budgetary allocations for women empowerment, calling it vital for the uplift of a key segment of society. She also warned of the grave threat posed by climate change and called for greater resources to mitigate its impact. Stressing the importance of regional equality, she urged a fair share of development funds for the Saraiki belt, noting its population is comparable to other provinces. Haji Jamal Shah Kakar lauded Prime Minister Muhammad Shehbaz Sharif for earmarking Rs 250 billion for Balochistan, terming it a long-overdue recognition of the province's importance. He welcomed allocations for infrastructure and highways but stressed the need for transparency and proposed the formation of a monitoring committee to ensure efficient fund utilization. PPP MNA Syeda Shehla Raza condemned the Israeli aggression against Iranian civilians, calling for global accountability. She criticized the federal budget for raising taxes and imposing a carbon levy while neglecting Karachithe country's economic hub. Opposing a new Danish university in Islamabad, she argued that existing institutions remain underfunded. She also highlighted the decline in oil and gas output, despite discoveries in Khairpur, and advocated urgent reforms. On a positive note, she welcomed the Reko Diq project, saying it could contribute 1% to Pakistan's GDP next year. Iqbal Afridi raised serious concerns regarding the rehabilitation of the merged districts (former FATA), urging the government to expedite the reconstruction of destroyed homes and ensure the return of displaced populations. He also demanded the withdrawal of newly imposed taxes in tribal areas and criticized delays in releasing development funds. Asia Naz Tanoli commended Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif for enhancing Pakistan's international image and improving the value of the green passport. She described the budget as balanced and people-centric, acknowledging the difficult decisions taken to pursue economic reform and national security. PPP's Sharmila Faruqui pointed out that nearly 70% of the national budget is consumed by debt servicing, leaving limited space for development. Citing Khawaja Asif's statement, she revealed that Rs 5.8 trillion was lost last year due to tax loopholes, subsidies, and concessions. She called for comprehensive tax reforms to ease the burden on the salaried and middle-income classes. MQM-P MNA Sofia Saeed Shah noted that although Rs 3.2 billion has been allocated for the KV-4 water project in Karachi, the amount falls short of the rising costs. She recalled MQM's earlier proposal of Rs 30 billion for the project and questioned the government's claims of reducing electricity prices while increasing levies on fuel. SIC lawmaker Shahzada Muhammad Gushtasap Khan stressed the need to increase allocations for education and health. He praised KP's 100% free healthcare program, attributing its success to effective provincial policy. Syed Ali Qasim Gillani demanded more investment in higher education in South Punjab to improve access. Emphasizing agriculture as the backbone of the economy, he urged greater support for crop production. He welcomed increases in the budgets for the Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP) and the information technology sector. MNA Muhammad Aslam Ghuman condemned Israel's aggression, calling it the "world's biggest terrorist," and reaffirmed Pakistan's solidarity with Muslim nations. He advocated for more support for farmers to ensure food security. Moin Aamer Pirzada called for widening the tax base by expanding the filer network. He also urged a review of the decision to end pensions for deceased government employees, stressing the need for humane policy revisions. PPP lawmaker Nawabzada Mir Jamal Raisani highlighted the federal budget's role in setting the country's economic direction. While welcoming the government's target of 4.2% economic growth and the allocation of special allowances for the armed forces, he expressed disappointment over the lack of substantial allocations for Balochistan. However, he appreciated the establishment of four Daanish Schools in the province and called for vocational training institutes to empower local youth. MNA Sajid Khan demanded the establishment of a Danish School in the merged tribal areas and emphasized coordinated efforts between federal and provincial governments to maintain peace in the region. SIC legislator Umair Khan Niazi criticized the budget and urged the inclusion of more high-net-worth individuals in the tax net. He called for increased allocations for agriculture and concrete support for farmers. PPP's Salahuddin Junejo raised the long-standing issue of the Hyderabad-Sukkur Motorway project and urged the Prime Minister to reconsider its funding. He advocated a structured agricultural policy to improve productivity. Highlighting injustices in his constituency, he said locals were not benefiting from natural gas extracted from the region and demanded job and resource rights for local residents. Junejo also thanked the Prime Minister for dispatching Bilawal Bhutto Zardari on diplomatic missions, praising his effective representation of Pakistan on the global stage.
