logo
Sling and Botox Comparable for Mixed Urinary Incontinence

Sling and Botox Comparable for Mixed Urinary Incontinence

Medscape07-05-2025

OnabotulinumtoxinA (Botox) injection and midurethral sling surgery yielded comparable symptom improvement in women with mixed stress-urgency urinary incontinence (MUI) at 6 months, a multicenter randomized study found. Surgery led to insignificantly better outcomes in the Mid-urethral Sling vs Botox A (MUSA) trial conducted by Heidi Harvie, MD, MBA, MSCE, associate professor of obstetrics and gynecology at Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, and colleagues.
Heidi Harvie, MD, MBA, MSCE
'[Stress-urinary incontinence] SUI is most common, followed by MUI and [urgency urinary incontinence] UUI,' said Harvie. 'In the United States, MUI affects an estimated 30% of women by 60 years of age. Women with urinary incontinence typically report that UUI is more bothersome than SUI, and the combination of both is more bothersome than either UUI or SUI alone.' Of the two, MUI is the more challenging to treat.
Published online in JAMA , the MUSA trial recruited 150 women (age, 27-87 [mean, 59] years; about 55% White) from seven clinical centers in the Pelvic Floor Disorders Network, National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (NICHD). All had moderate to severe MUI with an average of seven leakage episodes per day and had not responded to conservative treatments, such as lifestyle changes and exercise, or oral medications.
From July 2020 to September 2022, participants were randomly assigned to receive either an intradetrusor injection of onabotulinumtoxinA 100 U (focusing on the urgency component) or midurethral sling (focusing on the stress urgency component). Of these, 137 received treatment, with last follow-up in December 2023.
OnabotulinumtoxinA recipients could receive an additional injection between 3 and 6 months, and all participants could receive additional treatment (including crossover to the alternative intervention) between 6 and 12 months.
The primary outcome was a change from baseline in Urogenital Distress Inventory (UDI) scores (range, 0-300) at 6 months. Secondary outcomes included a UDI change at 3 and 12 months, irritative and stress subscores of the UDI, urinary incontinence episodes, predictors of poor treatment response, quality of life, and global impression outcomes. In addition, adverse events, use of additional treatments, and cost-effectiveness were evaluated.
Both groups showed mean improvement in the UDI total score at 6 months with no significant difference in scores between groups.
OnabotulinumtoxinA: −66.8 (95% CI, −84.9 to −48).
Sling: −84.9 (95% CI, −100.5 to −69.3) for a mean difference of 18.1 points (95% CI, −4.6 to 40.7; P = .12).
= .12). In secondary outcomes, there was a greater improvement in the UDI stress incontinence score with the sling at −45.2 (95% CI, −53.7 to −36.8) vs with onabotulinumtoxinA at −25.1 (95% CI, −34.1 to −16.1; P < .001).
< .001). No significant difference emerged in the UDI irritative score with onabotulinumtoxinA at −32.9 (95% CI, −40.3 to −25.6) vs with the sling at −27.4 (95% CI, −34.6 to −20.3; P = .27).
= .27). In the medication group, 12.7% and 28.2% received a second injection by 6 or 12 months, respectively. By 12 months, 30.3% in the sling group received onabotulinumtoxinA, and 15.5% in the onabotulinumtoxinA group received a sling.
Overall adverse events did not differ between groups, but recurrent urinary tract infections were more common in the sling group at 17.6% vs in the onabotulinumtoxinA group at 6.9%.
Rates of surgical revision (1.5%), vaginal mesh exposure (2.9%), and short-term postprocedural urinary catheter use (11.8%) in the sling group were similar to those reported in other studies. In the onabotulinumtoxinA group, 2.8% required intermittent self-catheterization 2 weeks post-procedure.
'Midurethral sling surgery and onabotulinumtoxinA are both good options for improving MUI symptoms. However, these patients can be difficult to treat with one therapy,' Harvie told Medscape Medical News . She hopes the findings will potentially help inform treatment decisions and shared decision-making based on patient preference in partnership with clinician recommendations.
As for the economic side, her group is currently planning a cost-effectiveness analysis of the two approaches.
Brittany L. Roberts, MD
In an accompanying editorial on the study, obstetrician-gynecologist Brittany L. Roberts, MD, and colleagues at the Albany Medical Center in Albany, New York, agreed that shared decision-making should ultimately guide therapeutic strategy. 'Because 45% of patients had another therapy within a year, it underlines that mixed urinary incontinence is a chronic disease and may require new treatments over time,' they wrote. 'Future studies should explore this concept and examine the impact on the utilization of healthcare resources and patient satisfaction.'
Roberts' group pointed out that the 'clinical conundrum' of this mixed condition affects 1 in 4 women older than 65 years. 'The personal and societal costs of incontinence are significant,' they wrote. By age 80, 20% will undergo surgery for SUI or MUI.
While physical and behavioral therapies improve both types, medications are standard treatment for urgency. 'When conservative treatment fails, conventional guidance has been to treat the urgency before the stress component because anti-incontinence surgical procedures can worsen urgency incontinence and many urgency treatments are medical rather than surgical,' they wrote. Another strategy has been to treat whichever symptom is dominant.
Results from the Effects of Surgical Treatment Enhanced with Exercise for Mixed Urinary Incontinence (ESTEEM) trial revealed that both groups, surgery with or without behavioral and physical therapy, reported improved urgency symptoms, findings substantiated in prior cohort studies.
'While the original hypothesis of ESTEEM was that treating both components of mixed urinary incontinence with behavioral and physical therapy plus sling would result in better patient outcomes, ESTEEM revealed that urgency symptoms can improve with the midurethral sling alone, challenging previously held beliefs about the impact of anti-incontinence surgeries worsening the urgency component of mixed incontinence,' Roberts and associates wrote.
They further pointed out that combined findings from MUSA and ESTEEM revealed that the pathophysiology of stress and urge incontinence are likely intertwined. 'For example, both patients and clinicians have difficulty discerning which type of leakage patients have, particularly when the incontinence is severe.' With better diagnostic clarity on urgency and stress incontinence phenotypes, more specific advice maybe offered to individuals on what to treat first.
While the MUSA trial positioned both interventions in equipoise, they have significant differences. OnabotulinumtoxinA can be administered in the clinic or operating room and requires no incision but insertion of a cystoscope. Sling surgery is performed in the operating room and typically requires three small incisions. Slings are meant to be a permanent intervention, while onabotulinumtoxinA injection must be repeated as its effects wear off.
So why not perform a sling surgery and give onabotulinumtoxinA at the same time? A randomized trial of 78 patients posing this question found that compared with sling alone, combined therapy did not show greater symptom improvement at 3 months. Additionally, the combined therapy group engaged in more self-catheterization and had more urinary tract infections.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

SLEEP 2025
SLEEP 2025

Medscape

timean hour ago

  • Medscape

SLEEP 2025

Narcolepsy an Independent Cardiovascular Disease Risk Factor Narcolepsy is associated with an increased risk for CVD, independent of common comorbid conditions and medications used to treat the disorder, new research showed. Medscape Medical News , Jun 07, 2024 Narcolepsy an Independent Cardiovascular Disease Risk Factor Better Sleep Tied to Less Loneliness Good quality sleep may have a role in driving down rates of loneliness, especially among younger adults. Medscape Medical News , Jun 21, 2024 Better Sleep Tied to Less Loneliness Couples-Based Tx for Sleep Apnea Nurtures Happier Relationships Couples-based therapy called WePAP boosted treatment adherence for sleep apnea, leading to higher relationship satisfaction and lower levels of conflict, a study suggested. Medscape Medical News, xx-Date-Here-xx

If You Do One Move For Strong, Sculpted Shoulders, Please Let It Be This One
If You Do One Move For Strong, Sculpted Shoulders, Please Let It Be This One

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

If You Do One Move For Strong, Sculpted Shoulders, Please Let It Be This One

Lateral raises may not look like they're doing much for your body, but trust me—they do. They're an essential shoulder exercise that will amp up your strength and stability in a big way. The move targets mainly your deltoids (the triangular muscles on top of your shoulders) and will create visible shoulder definition if that's your thing. But you won't reap the benefits of this move unless it's done correctly. Too often, I see people just swaying and swinging their dumbbells around, without any sort of structure or form. Not only is that not going to get you the results you want—it's also putting at risk for injury. That's why as a certified personal trainer and founder of KKSWEAT, I'm going to teach you everything you need to know about lateral raises, including how to do them, technique, variations, and more. Stand with a dumbbell in each hand with arms by sides, palms facing down and inward. Without bending arms, raise them up and straight out to sides until they're shoulder-level, still in your periphery. Lower the dumbbells back to starting position. That's 1 rep. Form cue: When you raise your arms, keep them at shoulder-level—and no higher. Do not lift them up to your ears. Make sure to keep your head above your tailbone, too, with no movement in your upper torso. Reps/sets for best results: I recommend using 5- to 8-pound weights for three sets of 8 to 12 reps. Make sure to take a 30- to 45-second rest in between sets. I can't say this enough, but lateral raises are a prime shoulder move. It's an isolation exercise, meaning that it's extremely focused on a particular joint and group of muscles. In this case, it's your shoulder joints and your deltoid muscles. Strengthening these can protect you from future injuries when you're lifting—and score you toned shoulders at the same time. Do them with your thumbs up. Standard form for a lateral raise is with your palms facing down (as demonstrated above). But if you're struggling with this form, try doing the move with your thumbs up. With this modification, you'll find it's easier to keep your shoulders down and focus on that stability. Play with tempo. Try sneaking a three-second hold into your lateral raise before bringing your arms back down. This will build up your resistance and strength. Try a front raise instead. This is basically the same thing as a lateral raise, except you'll be bringing your arms up in front of you, rather than out to your sides. By doing so, you'll target slightly different muscles to mix it up. Add it to your shoulder circuit. Dumbbell lateral raises aren't meant to be a warm up and should only be done after you've substantially worked out the other parts of your upper body. This helps ensure you'll have the shoulder mobility to do the move correctly. Plus, lateral raises target smaller muscles, and I generally recommend starting with chest and back movements (since those are bigger muscles) to warm up first. Personally, I usually put my lateral raises about three quarters of the way into my shoulder circuit. You'll find that by warming up larger muscles first, it's easier to focus on form, avoid injury, and reap all the benefits the lateral raise has to offer. You Might Also Like Jennifer Garner Swears By This Retinol Eye Cream These New Kicks Will Help You Smash Your Cross-Training Goals

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store