US judge blocks Trump religious exemption to birth control coverage
U.S. District Judge Wendy Beetlestone in Philadelphia said the 2018 rules were not justified, rejecting the Trump administration's claims that they were necessary to protect the rights of religious employers.
The ruling came in a lawsuit by Pennsylvania and New Jersey that reached the U.S. Supreme Court, which in 2020 upheld the rules on technical grounds but did not address their merits.
The U.S. Department of Justice did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Little Sisters of the Poor, a Roman Catholic order of nuns that intervened in the case to defend the rules, will appeal the ruling, according to the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, a nonprofit that represents the order.
The federal Affordable Care Act requires employers to provide insurance coverage for contraception but allows those with religious objections to seek exemptions.
The 2018 rules created a blanket exemption for employers with religious or moral objections to contraception. The Trump administration said that even requiring employers to apply for an exemption could burden their religious practice, in violation of federal law.
But Beetlestone on Wednesday said there was a mismatch between the vast scope of the exemption and the relatively small number of employers who may need it.
That "casts doubt on whether ... there is a rational connection between the problem the Agencies identified and the solution they had chosen," wrote Beetlestone, an appointee of President Barack Obama, a Democrat.
The administration of President Joe Biden, a Democrat, had proposed withdrawing the Trump administration rules in 2023 but that proposal was withdrawn weeks before Biden left office in January. — Reuters
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
GMA Network
a day ago
- GMA Network
PH in talks with US on Trump's 100% semiconductor tariff
Ambassador Jose Manuel Romualdez said at the US-ASEAN Business Council meeting in Manila that the imposition of the US tariff is very disturbing. (Photo by Michaela del Callar) The Philippines is in talks with the United States on the Trump administration's plan to impose a 100% tariff on semiconductors and computer chips, Manila top diplomat to Washington said Thursday, warning that the new US tax policy would hurt two of Manila's largest export industries. Ambassador Jose Manuel Romualdez expressed concern that the imposition of fresh steep tariffs, which he described as 'very disturbing' would affect the global semiconductor supply chain, impacting 'a lot of companies, not only here in the Philippines, but all over the Asia-Pacific region.' 'We are asking our friends also from other organizations that have been helping us…to be able to exempt this particular industry, especially those that have been established here in the Philippines for so many decades now,' Romualdez said at a moderated discussion with the media during the US-ASEAN Business Council meeting in Manila. Romualdez said the impact on the Philippines' semiconductor manufacturing industry would be 'substantial' if the new round of tariffs were to push through. The Philippines is the world's ninth-largest chip exporter and the semiconductor sector is the country's largest export industry. 'It's a very substantial amount. I can just tell you that it's very important for us to make sure that this industry is maintained here,' he told reporters in a separate interview. The envoy said American semiconductor manufacturer Texas Instruments, which has maintained decades-long presence in the Philippines, for example, recently made huge investments in the country, but remains 'in limbo' until details on the new chip tariff are finalized. Romualdez said consultations are ongoing with US trade officials, the US-ASEAN Business Council, US Chamber of Commerce and the Semiconductor Association in the United States and Washington D.C. Trump's latest announcement on global duties on electronics came more than three months after announcing sweeping reciprocal tariffs ranging from 10% to 100% on its global trading partners, including security allies, such as the Philippines and Japan. Trump, however, said American companies that will manufacture the crucial chips and semiconductors, which power automobiles, computers, mobile phones, gadgets, appliances and other essential tech equipment, in the US would be exempted from duties. Manila, on the other hand, is still in the process of finalizing details on the new 19% duties imposed by the Trump administration on Filipino products entering America, Romualdez said, adding that not all US imports are duty-free. The tariff on the Philippines is considered final, he said, but trade officials from Manila and Washington are 'still on the negotiating stage' on the specifics and exemptions contained in the trade deal. US agricultural products are likely not included in the list of duty-free American goods, Romualdez said. 'Of course, we have to consider the agricultural sector, which is very important for us,' he said. Foreign Secretary Theresa Lazaro said the Association of South East Asian Nations (ASEAN), of which the Philippines is a member along with nine other countries, is expected to ramp up and expand intra-ASEAN trade in response to the US tariffs. 'Discussions are evolving within ASEAN,' said Lazaro, who was also present at the forum with the media. Romualdez said President Ferdinand Marcos Jr.'s recent state visit to India, which pledged $446 million in investments, is 'a clear indication' of how the Philippines is looking for other markets outside of the United States and also in Europe as a result of the US tariffs. —LDF, GMA Integrated News
GMA Network
2 days ago
- GMA Network
US judge blocks Trump religious exemption to birth control coverage
A U.S. judge on Wednesday struck down rules adopted during President Donald Trump's first term that exempt employers with religious or moral objections from having to provide workers with insurance coverage for birth control. U.S. District Judge Wendy Beetlestone in Philadelphia said the 2018 rules were not justified, rejecting the Trump administration's claims that they were necessary to protect the rights of religious employers. The ruling came in a lawsuit by Pennsylvania and New Jersey that reached the U.S. Supreme Court, which in 2020 upheld the rules on technical grounds but did not address their merits. The U.S. Department of Justice did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Little Sisters of the Poor, a Roman Catholic order of nuns that intervened in the case to defend the rules, will appeal the ruling, according to the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, a nonprofit that represents the order. The federal Affordable Care Act requires employers to provide insurance coverage for contraception but allows those with religious objections to seek exemptions. The 2018 rules created a blanket exemption for employers with religious or moral objections to contraception. The Trump administration said that even requiring employers to apply for an exemption could burden their religious practice, in violation of federal law. But Beetlestone on Wednesday said there was a mismatch between the vast scope of the exemption and the relatively small number of employers who may need it. That "casts doubt on whether ... there is a rational connection between the problem the Agencies identified and the solution they had chosen," wrote Beetlestone, an appointee of President Barack Obama, a Democrat. The administration of President Joe Biden, a Democrat, had proposed withdrawing the Trump administration rules in 2023 but that proposal was withdrawn weeks before Biden left office in January. — Reuters
GMA Network
2 days ago
- GMA Network
Trump names Stallone, Strait among Kennedy Center honorees
Sylvester Stallone is unveiled by U.S. President Donald Trump as the Kennedy Center Honoree, during Donald Trump's visit to the Kennedy Center in Washington, D.C., U.S., August 13, 2025. REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque WASHINGTON - US President Donald Trump on Wednesday named "Rocky" star Sylvester Stallone and country music great George Strait among the recipients of the Kennedy Center Honors, as he pursues a controversial overhaul of the storied arts institution. Disco diva Gloria Gaynor, rock band KISS and British theater star Michael Crawford, known for his indelible turn in the lead role of Broadway staple "Phantom of the Opera," will also receive the Honors, one of the nation's highest arts awards. Trump announced he himself would host the Honors gala, which usually takes place in early December and is later broadcast on CBS. "I did not insist, but I think it will be quite successful," he told reporters at the stately white marble complex overlooking the Potomac River. He also joked that he wanted an honor himself but was "never able to get one." Stallone, who at 79 is the same age as Trump, is a three-time Oscar nominee: for best actor and screenplay for the 1976 classic boxing flick "Rocky," and for best supporting actor, again in the Rocky Balboa role, in the 2015 follow-up "Creed." He is also a major Trump supporter and one of the president's "Hollywood ambassadors" along with Jon Voight and Mel Gibson. Strait, 73, is one of the best-selling musicians of all time, known for huge hits like "All My Exes Live in Texas" and "Amarillo by Morning." Gaynor, 81, is the singer behind the monster disco anthem "I Will Survive." KISS, formed in the 1970s in Trump's hometown New York City, gained fame with its shock rock performances and outlandish black and white face paint. Crawford, 83, made his mark on British television in the 1970s before achieving international success by originating the title role in Andrew Lloyd Webber's musical "Phantom of the Opera," thrilling audiences with his powerful tenor voice. 'Not going to be woke' The Kennedy Center, one of the nation's top performing arts venues, is a living monument to the late John F. Kennedy. Opened in 1971, it has long enjoyed bipartisan support. But in February, shortly after returning to the Oval Office, Trump ousted the center's leadership and installed himself as board chairman, vowing to purge any programming he deems objectionable. "A few short months ago, I became chairman of the Kennedy Center," Trump said Wednesday. "We ended the programming." In his first term, from 2017 to 2021, the Republican president skipped the Kennedy Center Honors gala, the biggest fundraiser of the year, because some of the artists receiving awards criticized him or said they would not attend in his presence. The Kennedy Center is home to the National Symphony Orchestra and also offers theater, opera, comedy and other productions. Many artists associated with the center, including opera singer Renee Fleming and musician Ben Folds, have cut ties with the institution. Others including comedian Issa Rae canceled performances. The producers of smash hit historical musical "Hamilton" opted to cancel a scheduled 2026 run timed to coincide with the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, citing the end of "neutrality" at the center. — Agence France-Presse
