'Build baby build' to tackle housing crisis
Hundreds of millions of pounds could be invested in housing in Scotland if the Scottish government had clearer policies, a leading businessman has claimed.
Sir Tom Hunter said that he knew of developers who were choosing to take "build to rent" projects to Birmingham or Manchester because they were unsure of how rent caps would work in Scotland.
Social Justice Secretary Shirley Anne Somerville defended the principle of having rent controls during a cost of living crisis, but said legislation currently going through Holyrood would give developers the certainty they need about the policy.
And she said ministers were doing a "tremendous amount of work" with private firms to improve the planning process.
'We've been living in fear of eviction for four years'
What is a housing emergency?
Scottish government declares national housing emergency
In a wide-ranging interview Sir Tom also called for Scotland to be more like Singapore in bid to improve the education system and deliver a better health service.
And he said ministers should be paid more in a bid to attract the "best talent" into politics.
Last May the Scottish government declared a national housing emergency.
But Sir Tom told BBC Scotland's The Sunday Show the crisis could be solved "tomorrow morning".
He added: "It's very simple. Build baby build, to take a phrase from over the pond.
"To solve the housing crisis you need to build more houses. Really? That's it."
The entrepreneur said housing investors allocate their investment where they understand the policy.
He said: "I know of hundreds of millions of pounds that are sitting on the sidelines, not coming to Scotland because the investors go: 'We are not quite sure what the Scottish government's housing policy is. Rent cap? No rent cap? What is it?
"We will just go to Manchester. We will just go to Birmingham.
"And therefore sort the policy. Sort it tomorrow and hundreds of millions of pounds will flow into Scotland."
The businessman said a joined-up approach would also create opportunities for apprentices.
Ms Somerville, who also appeared on The Sunday Show, said she held talks with representatives of investors in the build to rent market last week.
She added: "While we have had a disagreement about whether rent controls should come to Scotland or not, the government's been very clear that it should.
"But we are very clear to do that in a way that will provide that certainty for private investors."
The minister said the housing bill that is currently going through parliament had a formula on rent caps and added the change was made after listening to private developers.
Meanwhile, Sir Tom also told the programme that ahead of the Holyrood election next year he wanted to look at "the big ideas, the bold ideas for Scotland."
He added: "If we look at where we are, a state of the union - not in a political sense - but our education standards are falling, our health service is struggling and we have a lacklustre economy.
"If this was a business, which is my background, I would be looking to see where my competitors were doing better than me."
Sir Tom commissioned a report on what lessons Scotland could learn from Singapore as he said it had one of the best GDPs of capita in the world.
He also highlighted the fact that the prime minister of Singapore earns $2.2m Singapore Dollars (£1.27m).
In comparison First Minister John Swinney earns £165,000.
Sir Tom said: "Countries with the best talent win.
"Do we have the best talent running our country?"
Asked to answer his own question, he replied: "I would say we could do better.
"We need to encourage better people into politics.
"The hardest job in this country is running the country."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Bloomberg
15 hours ago
- Bloomberg
Allegra Stratton: Can Restoration, not Revolution, Work for UK?
Today I'd love you to read this wonderful dispatch from our Irina Anghel. She's been to Lewis in the Outer Hebrides, the island where Donald Trump's mother was born, to see how they are braced for the effect of her son's tariffs. It's illustrated with a beautiful photo portrait by Emily Macinnes of fourth-generation Harris Tweed weaver Iain Martin, dressed in a handsome wool blazer, working on his loom at home.
Yahoo
15 hours ago
- Yahoo
Cruise Scotland warns government against ‘damaging' levy proposal
The Scottish cruise industry has lashed out at the government's proposals to introduce a cruise ship levy over fears it would deter cruises from visiting its ports. The Scottish Government announced earlier this year that it is considering a proposal to allow local authorities to create a visitor levy on cruise ships docking at its ports. During the consultation, Cruise Scotland, a membership-based marketing organisation that represents key cruise industry players, issued a warning to the Scottish Government that the levy could damage the sector. The organisation expressed its concern in its formal submission to the government consultation on implementing a cruise ship levy, saying that cruises will become discouraged from visiting Scottish ports. 'Scotland must decide whether it wants to attract or deter a sector that delivers over £130m annually to the national economy and sustains jobs in some of the most remote and economically vulnerable communities,' Rob Mason, chair of Cruise Scotland, said. Mr Mason also claimed that if the levy was mishandled, it could result in job losses, cause a slump in local business growth and disrupt a tourism model that benefits communities. Cruise Scotland said that the government's plans are so far too ambiguous, stating that prolonged uncertainty regarding the levy is 'damaging' as cruise operators cannot plan accordingly. The group also warned against creating devolved powers for individual councils to implement the levy, as it claimed this would create competition between areas and would require port authorities to function as tax collectors. 'We must remember that this is a movable market that does not need to come to Scotland, despite all we have to offer, and neighbouring regions in the North Atlantic and Northern Europe are strongly positioned to benefit from any displacement,' Mr Mason added. While the chair said Cruise Scotland 'fully acknowledges' the need for targeted investment, he called upon the government to be more transparent in its decisions around the levy and asked for 'close collaboration' with the industry. The organisation said it remains engaged in discussions with policymakers. Cruise Scotland says that 1.1 million passengers visited Scottish ports in 2024, contributing over £130 million to local businesses and communities. Kirsty Hutchison, Cruise Scotland's market development manager, said that this number could see a drop if a levy were implemented. 'Introducing a levy could send the wrong signal to cruise operators at a time when Scotland is successfully growing its reputation as a responsible and attractive destination,' Ms Hutchinson said. 'The evidence from other markets suggests that a levy risks reducing visitor numbers, along with the significant revenue and opportunity they bring.' The levy has received support in other areas. The Scottish Greens are in favour of the potential to cut climate emissions, while the Orkney Islands Council said it would welcome the revenue it would generate for the communities. The consultation on the levy has now closed, and responses will be analysed over the summer to inform ministers the next steps they can take.
Yahoo
18 hours ago
- Yahoo
Up to £3bn may be needed to fix building cladding
Up to £3bn of public money may have to be spent assessing and removing potentially flammable cladding from buildings in Scotland. New estimates from the Scottish government suggest up to 1,450 residential buildings may need remediation work, including about 250 high-rises. It was previously estimated about 900 buildings were affected. However, full surveys will be needed to establish what needs to be done on a case-by-case basis, with 107 buildings being examined as part of a pilot phase. It is now estimated that the Cladding Remediation Programme could cost £1.7bn to £3.1bn over a 15-year period. If new legislation is passed by the Scottish Parliament, additional funding could be unlocked to fix building safety issues. Ministers making 'painfully slow' cladding progress Scottish ministers given new powers to tackle cladding The Building Safety Levy (Scotland) Bill will see a tax charged on the construction of certain new residential properties, in line with equivalent legislation in England. The bill seeks to raise about £30m a year to help fund work to fix residential buildings with unsafe cladding which have no linked developer. Public Finance Minister Ivan McKee said: "The Scottish government is committed to doing what is right and necessary to address the challenge of fixing buildings affected by unsafe cladding. "That includes putting the appropriate funding arrangements in place to ensure that the associated costs of cladding remediation do not fall directly onto affected homeowners. "I know that developers share our determination to keep people safe and this levy will ensure they make a fair contribution to these costs, just as they will be doing in England." He added: "I also welcome the continued co-operation of developers who have accepted responsibility for the assessments and any required mitigation and remediation of their buildings." Trade body Homes for Scotland, whose members deliver the vast majority of all new homes in Scotland, said they were committed to remedial action on buildings they had built. But a spokesperson raised concerns about the impact of a building safety levy. "In addition to the proposed Building Safety Levy, Scotland's largest home builders are already contributing to the remediation of other impacted buildings through their payment of the Residential Property Development Tax (RPDT)," they said. The spokesperson said the proposed levy would mean an additional layer of taxation which "will add thousands of pounds to the cost of new homes, pushing families, first-time buyers and future generations further away from home ownership". They added: "At a time when Scotland is facing a housing emergency and 693,000 Scottish households are living in some form of housing need, this is simply unacceptable." The UK government agreed in principle to devolve the powers needed for a Scottish Building Safety Levy last year. Last month ministers announced plans to speed up efforts to inspect and repair buildings in response to the 2017 Grenfell Tower fire in London that killed 72 people. The 23-storey tower's cladding is believed to have contributed to the rapid spread of the fire. It broke out in the kitchen of a fourth-floor flat at the tower block in North Kensington, just before 01:00 on 14 June 2017. Within minutes, the fire had rapidly spread up the exterior of the building and moved across all four sides. By 03:00, most of the upper floors were well alight. As well as those killed, more than 70 people were injured. The Cladding Remediation Programme was set up in the aftermath of the disaster but Scottish ministers have been criticised for its slow progress. How are the laws on cladding changing in Scotland? 'No warning' over cladding evacuation, couple say
