Gene Tech Bill Stalls Again. Support Hinges On Strong Health And Environmental Safeguards
'Rushed decisions lead to poor results,' said OANZ GE Spokesperson Brendan Hoare. 'This is a moment for good governance, for Parliament to listen to the overwhelming public opposition, weigh the evidence, and ensure Aotearoa New Zealand's primary sector is protected. Our environment and our global reputation depend on it.'
OANZ emphasised that despite repeated requests, no independent government analysis has been conducted on the economic, health, environmental or cultural impacts of deregulating gene technology; OANZ itself commissioned the only economic analysis through NZIER. Potential Costs of Regulatory Changes for Gene Tech, An Economic Assessment. The organisation says this lack of robust assessment leaves significant risks unaddressed.
A New Zealand First spokesperson said: 'The legislation itself is still in the consultation phase between government parties, including NZ First. There are clear provisions in the NZF–National Coalition Agreement that highlight that supporting, or otherwise, of any genetic modification liberalisation legislation is dependent on certain safeguards, protections, and risk mitigation to human health and the environment.'
OANZ reiterated its call for food and farming regulations that prioritise human health and environmental protection, the values and perspectives of Māori, and Aotearoa New Zealand's global reputation for integrity and sustainability.
'Kiwis deserve more than shortcuts,' Hoare said. 'This delay is a sign that concerns are being heard. Now we need leadership that ensures the outcome reflects the values that underpin Brand New Zealand and safeguard our future.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
5 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Marsden Point's past, present, and potential future
In recent weeks, a slew of ministers have visited. NZ First has floated the idea of introducing New Zealand's first Special Economic Zone (SEZ) to help pump investment into the site and life into the Northland economy. Ralph Sims, Massey University Professor Emeritus of Sustainable Energy and Climate Mitigation, told The Front Page that, for years, the International Air Transport Association, of which Air New Zealand is a member, has looked at sustainable aviation fuels. 'Marsden Point could be a world-leading centre for producing sustainable aviation fuels.' Channel Infrastructure chief executive Rob Buchanan told The Front Page that sustainable aviation fuel could flow through its infrastructure today. 'So, as that industry transitions from fossil jet to sustainable aviation fuel over the next 20 to 30 years, that product can come straight through the Marsden Point import terminal system like it can today. 'One of the unique features of our location at Marsden Point, and actually it's a function of our history, is we've got a very large landholding which is consented for at least the next 35 years for fuel manufacture. So, one of the significant opportunities that we're exploring is renewable fuels manufacturing on our site.' There was a range of decommissioned refinery assets and tanks available for fuel storage, he said. 'One of the projects we're working on with a consortium of international investors is indeed repurposing some of the old refinery assets for biofuels production in New Zealand.' Listen to the full episode to hear more about: The future for aviation decarbonisation Future renewable fuels manufacturing How a special economic zone could attract investors What to do with the remaining infrastructure? Prime Minister Keith Holyoake opening the Marsden Pt oil refinery on May 30, 1964. Photo / NZME Past In 1964, Prime Minister Keith Holyoake opened Marsden Point, heralding in a 'new energy era'. Its construction began two years earlier, with contractor Bechtel finishing it for £10 million. According to the Reserve Bank's inflation calculator, that's more than $556m today. Within just three years, expansion was on the horizon. But it wasn't until 1973 that a $160m project was approved. In the mid-1980s, the refinery expanded and upgraded to allow for increased production. Extra tanks, utility supplies, and environmental treatment units were added, along with a 170km pipeline between Marsden Point and Wiri, South Auckland. In 1988, the introduction of the Petroleum Sector Reform Act saw the energy industry deregulated. The company and its shareholders decided overwhelmingly to close the refining operation. Despite some community opposition, it ceased activity in 2022. The Cabinet noted that the closure of the refinery was expected to have 'little impact on fuel supply resilience under most disruption scenarios'. Channel Infrastructure is developing the former refinery with fuel storage and is looking at the likes of a bio-refinery, sustainable aviation fuel development and a bitumen import terminal. Photo / Denise Piper Present The privately owned Marsden Point was New Zealand's only fuel refinery until it was decommissioned in 2022. It would instead become an import-only fuel terminal under the name Channel Infrastructure, a publicly listed company. Some 3.4 billion litres of already-refined fuel pass through the facility each year – equal to 40% of New Zealand's total petrol and diesel demand and 80% of total jet fuel demand. The company has been earning more from its import-only operation, last year announcing a half-year profit of $16.6m, an increase on the previous year of 45%. Last year, Channel Infrastructure commissioned an independent assessment of the 'capital cost of recommissioning a refinery'. It was found that the cost would be in the range of NZ$4.9 billion to NZ$7.3b. Resources Minister Shane Jones admitted the figure was too steep, calling it a 'stupendous' amount of money. The Government's Fuel Security Study has noted that re-establishing the Marsden Point oil refinery or developing a new one would be inefficient, because of either its high costs and/or limited effectiveness. Channel Infrastructure has outlined its plans for Marsden Point. Future New Zealand First's Winston Peters and Shane Jones announced earlier this month that the Marsden Point Rail Link design would be open for discussions with investors and potential builders. The link, estimated to cost at least $300m, would provide rail to Marsden Point and Northport. It's all while Channel Infrastructure pushes ahead with its own development plans. A refurbished fuel tank collaboration with Z Energy, for example, is designed to store an additional 30 million litres of fuel. The company is investing up to $30m over two years for the tank and other developments planned for Marsden Point, including a bio-refinery. Dubbed the Marsden Point Energy Precinct Concept, it forecasts that an additional 2.5 billion litres of jet fuel would flow through over the next 26 years. 'We've got the ability to store more fuel,' Buchanan said. 'We've got the ability to manufacture biofuels at Marsden Point, noting the feedstock for biofuels is domestic, so we aren't subject to the geopolitical risks that come with international shipping. 'We think it's a real opportunity for an energy security play for New Zealand in a world which is quickly becoming more geopolitically contested.' The Front Page is a daily news podcast from the New Zealand Herald, available to listen to every weekday from 5am. The podcast is presented by Chelsea Daniels, an Auckland-based journalist with a background in world news and crime/justice reporting, who joined NZME in 2016. You can follow the podcast at iHeartRadio, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Scoop
7 hours ago
- Scoop
Gene Tech Bill Stalls Again. Support Hinges On Strong Health And Environmental Safeguards
The Health Select Committee has again delayed the release of its report on the controversial Gene Technology Bill, this time pushing the deadline out to 10 October 2025. Organics Aotearoa New Zealand (OANZ) says the further delay underscores the complexity of the issues and the need for strong leadership and careful consideration before any decisions are made. 'Rushed decisions lead to poor results,' said OANZ GE Spokesperson Brendan Hoare. 'This is a moment for good governance, for Parliament to listen to the overwhelming public opposition, weigh the evidence, and ensure Aotearoa New Zealand's primary sector is protected. Our environment and our global reputation depend on it.' OANZ emphasised that despite repeated requests, no independent government analysis has been conducted on the economic, health, environmental or cultural impacts of deregulating gene technology; OANZ itself commissioned the only economic analysis through NZIER. Potential Costs of Regulatory Changes for Gene Tech, An Economic Assessment. The organisation says this lack of robust assessment leaves significant risks unaddressed. A New Zealand First spokesperson said: 'The legislation itself is still in the consultation phase between government parties, including NZ First. There are clear provisions in the NZF–National Coalition Agreement that highlight that supporting, or otherwise, of any genetic modification liberalisation legislation is dependent on certain safeguards, protections, and risk mitigation to human health and the environment.' OANZ reiterated its call for food and farming regulations that prioritise human health and environmental protection, the values and perspectives of Māori, and Aotearoa New Zealand's global reputation for integrity and sustainability. 'Kiwis deserve more than shortcuts,' Hoare said. 'This delay is a sign that concerns are being heard. Now we need leadership that ensures the outcome reflects the values that underpin Brand New Zealand and safeguard our future.'
1News
21 hours ago
- 1News
Ports of Auckland expansion first to get consent under new fast-track rules
An expansion at the Ports of Auckland is the first project to be granted consent under the new fast-track regime. The Fast-track Approvals Act, which was part of the coalition agreement between National and NZ First, was aimed at accelerating approvals for projects deemed to have regional or national significance. The approved works at the Port of Auckland included a new reinforced concrete-pillared wharf at the Bledisloe Terminal, an extension to the Fergusson North Berth, a cruise passenger terminal, and other upgrades. It would allow larger cruise ships to berth in Auckland and increase New Zealand's import and export capacity, Minister for Infrastructure Chris Bishop said. 'The project will deliver lasting economic benefits by boosting the efficiency of a critical part of Auckland's economy and supporting long-term growth." ADVERTISEMENT Construction was expected to begin next month. The project's application was assessed and approved with conditions by an independent expert panel. The consent was granted 66 working days after the panel was convened to consider the application. A total of 149 projects were on the fast-track list and were eligible to apply to the Environmental Protection Authority (EPA) for consideration by an expert panel. The panel considers each application and decides whether to approve it, with any conditions attached to those approvals. Regional Development Minister Shane Jones said he was looking forward to more projects reaching the approval stage - 10 were currently being considered by expert panels and a further three were in the pipeline. The Act has also faced criticism, with opponents being against some of the 149 projects, as well as the potential to override environmental protections and Te Tiriti. When the bill was passed in December, Labour said it was the most "radical and unbalanced" consenting regime in recent memory. ADVERTISEMENT Expert panels are currently considering: Delmore (residential) Maitahi Village (residential) Milldale (residential development) Tekapo Power Scheme (power scheme consent renewal) Waihi North (mining extension) Drury Metropolitan centre ADVERTISEMENT Sunfield (residential development) Rangitoopuni (residential and retirement units) Ryans Road (industrial subdivision). Drury Quarry Expert panels have been appointed for, and will shortly begin considering: Stella Passage (wharf extension and related work) Taranaki VTM (seabed mining) ADVERTISEMENT King's Quarry extension
