Investing: 'False economy' of lower fees amid US dominance
Last year, according to the London Stock Exchange, investors withdrew £15.13 billion from active UK strategies. In April 2003 UK investors held around 66% of their assets in equity funds. Today it is less than 50%.
Alternative assets have no doubt taken some share, but the biggest impact has been the use of ETFs (exchange-traded funds). These funds have, rightly, displaced many active funds that charged high fees for a portfolio very similar to that of the index. With annual costs of around 20 basis points for the most popular global equity ETFs, they have provided low cost and strong performance.
However, financial products are often undone by their own popularity, and they rarely provide a free lunch forever. The largest indices that passive funds follow are now heavily skewed towards a few countries, companies and sectors.
The US now dominates. The MSCI World Index, which should maybe be renamed, has over 74% exposure to the US, with the top 10 holdings being US companies, including all of the Magnificent 7 (Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, Alphabet, Meta, Nvidia, and Tesla). This is way beyond the US's share of global GDP which is closer to a third.
While share prices should follow earnings, not GDP, corporate valuations must still be anchored to something real for them to make sense. Accordingly, the US appears over-represented in this index and does not provide the diversification that some investors might expect.
These products may also have implications for investors seeking regular cash returns. US companies are well-known to prefer buybacks to those in other regions, and the dividend yield on the S&P 500 is now barely above 1%. Not only do buybacks increase the risk of market timing, but the lack of dividends hints at another potential unpleasant surprise – earnings per share can be far removed from cash per share.
Indices can also contain companies with a different problem – paying out too much cash. This is especially the case in high yielding sectors that often take on too much leverage and end up cutting their dividends. It might cost slightly more to ensure that an income-focused portfolio is prudently spread out, and with healthy growing dividends, but that is a price I consider well worth paying.
The most dangerous periods in financial markets are often preceded by a common condition: everyone crowded in the same room, and someone shouts fire. Lower expenses are in everyone's interests, as are more choice and competition. But not if it comes at the cost of patience, due diligence and common sense.
There are important and perhaps unintended consequences when investing in index ETFs. If they result in the wrong decision at the wrong times, they will almost always outweigh any minimal savings in annual fees.
Graham Campbell is co-manager of the RGI Global Income and Growth Fund
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Glasgow Times
6 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
The M&S hack that gives free cake every week and money off
One of the fastest growing 'baby clubs' in the UK the Parent Hood club is part of Marks and Spencer's Sparks loyalty scheme, and parents have been raving about the free cake 'hack', which offers a free slice every Tuesday, when purchasing a tea or coffee in the cafe. Olly and Amelia are parents to 16-month-old Madison and expecting the imminent arrival of their second child next month. Essex based Olly, who also jointly presents a popular Heart FM radio show with fellow M&S brand ambassador, Mark Wright, said that he and Amelia 'can't wait to get started on sharing their world as parents to two young babies, including the chaos and all that goes with it', adding that he first heard about the scheme from Amelia herself. What is the free cake offer at M&S Parent Hood club? The Parent Hood loyalty scheme turns One in August, and is now home to over 230,000 members – one of the fastest growing baby clubs in the UK - and has driven sales of over 1 million baby grows in its first year The Parent Hood 'welcome' offer – 10% off all baby grows for the first 12 months, drove sales of over one million of this baby mainstay, with 45,000 members redeeming this offer – and M&S have now extended this offer to 2 years As part of the Sparks loyalty programme there are discounts tailored to each member. For Mother's Day, every signed-up member received a luxury box of Chocolate biscuits as a special treat. As The Parent Hood turns One, members will receive a choice of a full-sized cake – options include a Red Velvet or a Victoria Sandwich – to help celebrate this special milestone. There's also Free Cake for All every Tuesday at Parent & Baby Coffee Mornings held in M&S Cafe's across the UK. More than 78,000 pieces of cake have been redeemed! 'I've been going to the Tuesday morning Parent Hood club at our local M&S café for the free cake offer to meet my friends and talk about all the joys of early parenting," says Amelia. "The sleepless nights, the times you are leaving the house when you must do a U-turn for a nappy change, all the joys.'. Recommended reading: Amelia adds: 'I really love the community at the cafes every Tuesday and of course the free cake. It gives you the chance to share your own experiences of parenting and sharing tips with each other. You come away feeling that you're not the only one finding it exhausting and sharing your views is so helpful for finding that peace of mind.' Olly is looking forward to spending more time with his young family as he admits that being on tour when Madi, as they call their daughter, was a very young baby, meant that he couldn't always be there to 'change the nappies at night-time and do the nightly feed'. 'I'm going to be around much more this time, and I can't wait for the challenges of having two under two. 'Amelia is such a calming presence and takes it all in her stride – I've learnt so much from her about being more patience and taking your time when it comes to having little ones.'
Daily Record
an hour ago
- Daily Record
Argos and Very slash £100 off Apple Watch Series 10 line-up in rival deals
Argos and Very are cutting 100 off Apple's latest line of smartwatches that beat Amazon's own price cuts Argos and Very are battling it out with rival sales on their Apple Watch range. Both retailers have slashed £100 off select models of Apple's smartwatches, including the most recent release, the Apple Watch Series 10. Argos says its deals are the 'lowest price' ever offered, with a variety of Apple Watches available for the same price at Very. The main model is the Apple Watch Series 10 GPS 42mm with Jet Black Sport Band, which has seen a price drop from £399 to £299 at both Argos and Very. Apple touts this model as having the largest display on an Apple Watch, boasting more screen area and a slimmer, lighter design. It provides a host of 'advanced' health and fitness features such as heart rate monitoring, sleep tracking and workout tracking for activities like running, cycling and swimming. Google unveils new Pixel 10 - this older phone is hundreds cheaper on launch day Dog owner's healthy puppy suddenly has 'stomach problems' until they swap one thing The watch allows users to manage their personal and professional lives with real-time alerts for text messages, emails and social media, as well as the capability to make phone calls directly from the device. Other notable features include weather updates, music control, GPS and fall detection. It also boasts faster charging that achieves 80 percent battery in approximately 30 minutes. Also included in the sale is the Apple Watch Series 10 GPS 42mm Rose Gold Light Blush (£299), which both Argos and Very have flagged as an 'in demand' item, reports the Express. The final item at Argos is the Apple Watch Series 10 GPS 42mm with Jet Black Ink Sport Loop (£299), which features a robust nylon strap instead of the silicone band found on other models. Very also stocks this model, but provides customers with a broader selection of colours, including a Silver Aluminium Case with Blue Cloud Sport Loop and a Rose Gold Aluminium Case with Plum Sport Loop. Both Argos and Very beat Amazon 's own discounted price of £329, but for budget-conscious buyers, Sky Mobile provides the same devices through monthly payment plans. This allows customers to spread the cost with no upfront charge. These range from the £7 Apple Watch SE (GPS 40mm) to the £13 Apple Watch Series 10 (GPS 42mm). Daily Express Tech Editor Dave Snelling reviewed the Series 10 last year and awarded it five stars, describing it as a 'formidable upgrade' from earlier versions. He said: "The Series 10 is another impressive device from Apple. The bigger screen, improved charging, refreshed titanium design and bonus extras such as checking for sleep apnoea are all nice updates. "It's also thinner and lighter than before, gets that neat ticking seconds hand when in always-on mode and it's still able to check your fitness, transform into a digital wallet and even save your life should you fall. It's now so advanced there's very little it can't do and it's become a device we now struggle to live without. "If you have an older wearable on your wrist, it's definitely time for a change, and this device is super simple for us to recommend. Our only gripes are the lack of an Action Button and it still won't get through a weekend without needing a refill. "If you own a Series 9 there's also not a huge reason to upgrade this year especially as that device is getting the sleep apnoea upgrade via a software update."
Reuters
2 hours ago
- Reuters
India business activity fastest in at least two decades, price rises sharp, PMI shows
BENGALURU, Aug 21 (Reuters) - India private sector activity expanded at the fastest pace on record in August, fuelled by a robust surge in demand led by the dominant services sector, which allowed firms to hike prices at the fastest clip in over 12 years, a survey showed on Thursday. The latest results stand in contrast to expectations for a slowdown in economic growth in Asia's third-largest economy to average 6.4% this fiscal year after an unexpectedly strong 7.4% expansion during the first three months of 2025. HSBC's flash India Composite Purchasing Managers' Index (PMI), compiled by S&P Global, rose to 65.2 in August from 61.1, confounding expectations in a Reuters poll for a decline to 60.5. It was the highest reading since the survey began in December 2005 and remained above the 50-mark that separates growth from contraction for the 49th month. Record expansion was underpinned by the sharpest uptick in total new orders - a key gauge of demand - in nearly 18 years. The services sector led growth, with its activity index soaring to a survey high of 65.6. The manufacturing sector also showed significant strength - its preliminary PMI rose to 59.8, its highest reading since January 2008. While that boosted job creation, the survey also showed companies passing on increases in input costs to customers. The output price index increased to an over 12-year high of 55.8 from 53.5 in July. That also contradicts the recent trend of easing inflation in official data, which dropped to an eight-year low of 1.55% last month. The Reserve Bank of India, which targets inflation in a 2-6% range, started cutting interest rates early this year to stimulate the economy and paused at the latest meeting but is expected to cut again next quarter. Firms remained optimistic, with sentiment for the year ahead strengthening to its highest since March.
